Goober Mcfly said:
Why did I start this again?
Simple. They ran into a hot goaltender. They didn't run into a hot defence, or a hot checking team, or a hot hustling team, or a hot passing team. They ran into a hot goaltender. That's all.
I'm not sure why you started this again, but don't blame me.
But, anyway, my question was *FACTORING IN GOALTENDING*. You've essentially said that, when you DON'T factor in goaltending, they were outplayed. "Because of goaltending" doesn't answer the question of how a team can be outplayed and still win FACTORING IN GOALTENDING.
Goober Mcfly said:
Now, for the last time, the Senators outplayed the Leafs in all facets of the game except goaltending. If you choose any 100 facets of the game, including goaltending, the Senators outplayed the Leafs in 99 of them. THEREFORE they outplayed the Leafs, on the whole, but still lost.
I'm not sure I agree about "99 out of 100", but whatever. It's still a steaming pile of turd.
So, whoever played better in MORE areas of the game outplayed the other team, as a whole? Is that what you're really saying??
So, all those things count the same: shots, goals, hits, faceoffs, takeaways, giveaways, GOALTENDING (which, apparently, is only *one* category in your list), dekes, point shots, can-openers, breakouts, offensive zone faceoffs, defensive zone faceoffs, breakaways, penalty killing, power plays ... all those things are measured equally. Who chooses what those categories are?? Who decides that spitting, or intimidating the officials isn't a part of the game? How do you determine who did that better?
Don't you think that's a bit silly??
Don't you think that's a flawed interpretation of the game? I certainly don't think it reflects reality.
'Cause in my reality, in the series we're now talking about, goaltending was clearly the most important factor. In your *analysis* of the game, goaltending counts the same as, say, one-time shots. In that case, that someone "outplayed" someone else is a pretty useless statement.
Goober Mcfly said:
I don't understand your reasoning, therefore, that if a team has better statistics in all facets of the game except one, that one trumps them all and makes the latter team outplay the other.
Hey, if your definition of "outplay" is what I've outlined above, we can stop this discussion.
I think it's utterly useless to any meaningful analysis of the game, but whatever.
IF, on the other hand, you propose that "outplay" includes all facets of the game *outside of goaltending*, and *in proper proportions*, we might be able to wrap this up. That would be fine. The statement would have some meaning, and I'd agree with it, insofar as as agrees with your definition of "outplay".
Just admit that when you say "outplay" you mean everything but goaltending. Fine. I've said this before. This is what you really mean. Because, when you factor in goaltending in its proper proportion, you're then taking EVERYTHING into account, and obviously, taking EVERYTHING into account, the Leafs outplayed the Senators - the Senators lost. (Or, are you back to the argument that everything counts the same - all hundred (thousand?) things that guys can do to win games all count for the same in the end?)