Outplaying vs. Winning

Re: Aha!

The Doctor said:
I think it's fair to say that not everyone places the same emphasis on goaltending as you do. If you are looking at the team as a whole, you can't then breakdown the components and have a weighted distribution of values. Personally I believe scoring is more important than goaltending becasue if you can't score, you're going to loose eventually. Unless of course you are planning on the lucky bounce off someone's ass that you already stated you can't plan for.

If you're looking at the team as a whole, that whole is comprised of a bunch of values with relative importance - you can break it down how you like - skaters and goaltending; offense and defense; whatever. The sum of those weighted values must equal the whole, the reality. If you don't come to the conclusion that the Leafs outplayed the Senators, there's something wrong with your analysis *of the whole*.

I agree that scoring is more important than goaltending - I've already stated this - see earlier in the thread. The two most important things on a team are team offense and team defense. It may be that goaltending is the single most important aspect of team defense - this is debatable. But the fact that the goalie's the most important player on a team is not debatable. I place "emphasis" on a goaltender because THAT'S REALITY. Even a casual inspection of the game should tell you that.

But, tell me - how important do YOU think that goaltending was in the series we're talking about? Do you think it was important? Do you think Ed Belfour's play was the most important factor in the decision? ... Don't be scared. We all know the answer. Of course it was.

(Oh, by the way, if you truly believe that scoring is more important than goaltending - the Leafs outscored the Senators in the series overall. One more reason why they outplayed them.)

The Doctor said:
Unfortunately you are not in any more of a position to interpret what they say than I am and if I do the same thing you've done, I take them at face value and believe they mean *including goaltending*

I choose to believe that they know what they're talking about.
So, you say when they said that the Leafs were outplayed, they were including the performance of Ed Belfour? Hmm, that's interesting, because almost every time they'd say that, they'd say that Ed Belfour saved their asses. Meaning that Belfour's play WASN'T meant to be included in the previous statement.
Are you for real?!?

The Doctor said:
That is your opinion and unfortunately that does not make your pojnt correct and Goober's wrong.

No, it doesn't. But, my point is correct, and Goober's IS wrong.

Don't just say "you could be wrong", or "that's just your opinion". State something that disproves what I'm saying!

The Doctor said:
Note:Please read my comments carefully and notice that they are statements of my opinion and therefore do not imply any interest or intention to argue "outplaying vs. winning". This board is about freely expressing your opinions and although you have a differing opinion and are willing to argue it ad nauseum does not make it any more correct. That's just my opion of course.

Look, if I say "it's my opinion that the sky is blue", and someone else says "it's my opinion that it's yellow", we most certainly CAN talk about one opinion being correct or not.

This is no longer a semantic argument. Goober refuses to believe what *even others who claim I'm giving them a headache* are willing to concede.
It just proves that he's either stubborn, not that smart, or that he hasn't thought it through enough.
Not my fault, in any case .....

Any objective analysis of the playoff match between the Senators and the Leafs will lead you to the conclusion that the Leafs outplayed the Senators because of the play of Ed Belfour. That the Leafs outplayed the Senators is a fact. In fact, it's the starting point of the analysis of WHY the Leafs won.

Argument A: The Senators outplayed the Leafs because they outhit, outskated, and outshot them.
Argument B: The Leafs outplayed the Senators because they won four games in a seven game series.

Which statement reflects reality and which reflects supposition?

Please.
 
The object of the game is NOT to outplay but to outscore your opponent. However, outplaying your opponent increases your chances of outscoring them. This is not, however, a one to one relationship. A team can outplay it's opponent but still loose on the score sheet where it matters most.
 
Look, I've about said all that I'm going to say.

*wild, massive applause in the background*

1. If you don't understand that the Leafs outplayed the Senators, you just don't understand anything about hockey, sports, or life.

2. If, when you say that the Sens outplayed the Leafs, what you *mean* is that their skaters outplayed the Leafs' skaters, fine. I can live with that. It's what commentators and coaches mean. But, if you then fail to comprehend the difference between those two statements and maintain that the Sens outplayed the Leafs, as a whole, please see point 1.

Here's two websites for further information on the fascinating topic of statistical analysis in hockey:

www.puckerings.com

www.hockeyresearch.com

Enjoy. :)

Further dispute of *factual statement* in other threads will result in a rehashing of this argument. That is all.
 
Goober Mcfly said:
So the goalies don't wear skates?

I'll assume you were being facetious.

Besides, under the new rules they're going to wear 6' bungee cords attached to the crossbar and thus won't need skates.
 
Well, I obviously don't understand anything about hockey, so teach me oh hockey master god!
 
Shocking. You know, after all this, Goob, I really have no idea how much you know about hockey.
 
Goober - You forgot to add life as well ;)
 
Hey, you *could* choose to peruse those websites and see what you think - expand your mind.
Then we might be able to have a more intelligent discussion of the topic.
Or not.
 
Ranger: Thank you for the websites. Interesting reading.

Maybe somebody can come up with a scoring system that would discount the increasing dominance of the goalie in hockey. Similar to the weighted goal hypothesis.

Just thinking aloud so don't slam me. Just a thought.

SQ
 
I'm glad you found them interesting. There's TONS in all of the links - lots of different analyses and hypotheses.

Most of these systems are normalized for league-wide scoring on a year-to-year basis. So, in a year like this year, a guy who scores 40 goals is worth far more to his team than a guy who did it twenty years ago. Same for goalies - a 2.50 GAA just isn't worth what it once was. It's all based on league and team averages.
 
Unfortunately, as is still painfully apparent, not everyone in here has bothered to check out the links.

Not really surprising.

But, it'll just cause me to resurface this thread every once in a while, so people can try, once again, to get points through their thick skulls.
 
:rolleyes:

So let me see if I've got this...you're going to keep bumping this thread until we see things your way and agree that you are right and that we've been wrong all along?



*rolls on the floor in laughter pointing at Ranger68*
 
No, I'll bump this thread when people question the obvious.

Or is that somehow unclear?

In the words of Foghorn Leghorn, "Go away, son, you bother me."
 
Out-Posting vs. Winning

Ranger68 said:
No, I'll bump this thread when people question the obvious.
What is obvious is that you're the only one here who even remotely cares at this point. Please do not mistake any references to winning vs. outplaying anywhere else as interest in debating the topic...it's just no so. Have you ever heard the phrase..."they're laughing with you not at you"? That's not the case here.
Or is that somehow unclear?
Apparaently to everyone other than yourself.
In the words of Foghorn Leghorn, "Go away, son, you bother me."
Ummmm, yeah. That has been your indirect response to everyone who has been able to see the wisdom in your posts.

BTW- When debating in these threads, you can out-post everyone on the topic but still not win over any converts. :D
 
Hey, I can't help if it those people who post against me (not everyone, mind you) can't follow simple logic.

:D

And, actually, my response has practically always been to ask for a dialogue - the interchange of ideas. It's Goober who's the one who usually takes his ball and goes home. Not my fault.

If you keep posting regarding this idiot notion that a team can be outplayed and still win, I'll keep responding. Again, not my fault.

Have a nice day.

Oh, and I'm laughing AT you, not with you. Just so we're clear.
 
Ranger68 said:
...And, actually, my response has practically always been to ask for a dialogue - the interchange of ideas.

But Ranger you can't have a dialogue if you continue to insult the intelligence of other's ideas. No one will have a meaningful debate with someone who thinks and says he knows more than other. It becomes a pointless exercise. That's when they pick their ball up and go home.

Just trying to help. :)

SQ
 
Cnd-Guy said:
it's not idiotic, look at the Leafs vs Ottawa :D

You're not taking into account goaltending. Factoring in goaltending, did the Senators outplay the Leafs??