NFL Playoffs

Again as I said earlier their regular season stats are very similar and by the time they both retire their numbers will be very similar, and Brady will actually lead in some categories. Peyton Manning started playing 3 years earlier than Tom Brady and has 539 TD and 251 INT 71940 YDS VS Tom Brady who has 428 TD 150 INT 58028 in 3 fewer seasons, and their win and losses are 186-79 for Manning VS 172-51 for Brady.

Manning is not only struggling in SB rings but also in playoffs in general and only has a 13-13 record in the playoffs where Brady is 22-9.

If you think all of these numbers are subjective because they don't play head to head and can't be compared then that's your own biased opinion.

And I didn't even start with all the fill in receivers that Tom Brady has been playing with and the future HOF that Peyton Manning has been playing with.
I am sorry that you have your head stuck so far up your biased, Brady craving ass (or is it your biased head up your ass) that you cannot at least acknowledge that there is even a possibility that Peyton's career rivalled Brady or Montana. As I said, I never declared Manning was better but that it is at least open to debate.

I have no time to try to reason with somebody who is completely biased and unreasonable.
 
Again as I said earlier their regular season stats are very similar and by the time they both retire their numbers will be very similar, and Brady will actually lead in some categories. Peyton Manning started playing 3 years earlier than Tom Brady and has 539 TD and 251 INT 71940 YDS VS Tom Brady who has 428 TD 150 INT 58028 in 3 fewer seasons, and their win and losses are 186-79 for Manning VS 172-51 for Brady.

Manning is not only struggling in SB rings but also in playoffs in general and only has a 13-13 record in the playoffs where Brady is 22-9.

If you think all of these numbers are subjective because they don't play head to head and can't be compared then that's your own biased opinion.

And I didn't even start with all the fill in receivers that Tom Brady has been playing with and the future HOF that Peyton Manning has been playing with.
Below is the most important deciding factor when considering why certain comparable great quarterbacks have fared better against their rivals at the time during the playoffs and Super Bowls and why comparing quarterbacks head-to-head during post season games is a media driven event:

1) DEFENCES!

Staubach vs The Steel Curtain. Bradshaw vs, The Doomsday Defence Part II. I am sure there is no doubt in anyone's mind which quarterback had the more difficult task. Had you reversed the quarterbacks with the teams, I believe most would agree that Bradshaw would have zero Super Bowls.

Marino vs Montano. Those SF defenses of the 80's were damn great and didn't receive the acclaim they deserve because of the more glamorous accomplishments of the offence which was spearheaded by Montano and Rice, supplemented by Taylor, Craig and a great, versatile offensive line. All of whom would not have 4 SBs if not for the genius of Bill Walsh. Marino basically had a very poor defence through his whole career.

Brady vs Manning. No doubt that the Patriot defenses were much, much better than the Colt defenses and posed a much greater challenge to Manning than the Colts defenses could ever hope to pose against Brady, especially 2001-2006. When faced with a defense that pressured him and could provide more than adequate coverage of his receivers, Brady was not The Brady of Legend, but a mere mortal. The 1st SB vs. the 17 point underdog Giants a. nd their swarming, harassing front four. The 2nd SB vs. the Giants. The Patriots/Seahawks SB, where had it not been for Malcolm Butler's last second goal line interception, the Patriots and Bradichek would have been known as 3 time SB losers. The just completed NFC championship game vs. The Broncos.

Football is at it's core is a Team and Organizational Game, more so than any other sport. And to equate success almost solely to QB success vs. their QB counterpart such as: Bradshaw 4SBs vs. Staubach 2SBs; Montano 4 SBs vs. Marino 0 SBs or Brady 4 SBs vs. Manning 1 SB is a media driven invention lapped up not by objective, purists of the game but by media driven lap puppies.

Bart Starr would not have been Bart Starr had it not been for his great teams and their organization during the 60's. Same goes for Bradshaw, Montana and Brady.

Heck head-to-head, Eli Manning far outplayed Tom Brady in 2 SBs.

The thing folks., is that QBs don't play against each other as the media would like us to believe, they're not even on the field at the same time opposing each other.

What they do is 1) play against the opposing defense 2) and the whole team and organization surrounding that defence.
 
Last edited:
Below is the most important deciding factor when considering why certain comparable great quarterbacks have fared better against their rivals at the time during the playoffs and Super Bowls and why comparing quarterbacks head-to-head during post season games is a media driven event:

1) DEFENCES!

Staubach vs The Steel Curtain. Bradshaw vs, The Doomsday Defence Part II. I am sure there is no doubt in anyone's mind which quarterback had the more difficult task. Had you reversed the quarterbacks with the teams, I believe most would agree that Bradshaw would have zero Super Bowls.

Marino vs Montano. Those SF defenses of the 80's were damn great and didn't receive the acclaim they deserve because of the more glamorous accomplishments of the offence which was spearheaded by Montano and Rice, supplemented by Taylor, Craig and a great, versatile offensive line. All of whom would not have 4 SBs if not for the genius of Bill Walsh. Marino basically had a very poor defence through his whole career.

Brady vs Manning. No doubt that the Patriot defenses were much, much better than the Colt defenses and posed a much greater challenge to Manning than the Colts defenses could ever hope to pose against Brady, especially 2001-2006. When faced with a defense that pressured him and could provide more than adequate coverage of his receivers, Brady was not The Brady of Legend, but a mere mortal. The 1st SB vs. the 17 point underdog Giants a. nd their swarming, harassing front four. The 2nd SB vs. the Giants. The Patriots/Seahawks SB, where had it not been for Malcolm Butler's last second goal line interception, the Patriots and Bradichek would have been known as 3 time SB losers. The just completed NFC championship game vs. The Broncos.

Football is at it's core is a Team and Organizational Game, more so than any other sport. And to equate success almost solely to QB success vs. their QB counterpart such as: Bradshaw 4SBs vs. Staubach 2SBs; Montano 4 SBs vs. Marino 0 SBs or Brady 4 SBs vs. Manning 1 SB is a media driven invention lapped up not by objective, purists of the game but by media driven lap puppies.

Bart Starr would not have been Bart Starr had it not been for his great teams and their organization during the 60's. Same goes for Bradshaw, Montana and Brady.

Heck head-to-head, Eli Manning far outplayed Tom Brady in 2 SBs.

The thing folks., is that QBs don't play against each other as the media would like us to believe, they're not even on the field at the same time opposing each other.

What they do is 1) play against the opposing defense 2) and the whole team and organization surrounding that defence.
Nice to see some rational, objective observations.

I suspect certain individuals may refuse to accept it as such.
 
I still prefer my QB's to be mobile.

The 3 best QB's of the past 20 years - Brady, Manning and Rodgers. Only 1 of them is mobile. However I see your point. When your QB can run, break tackles and dodge defenders it adds another dimension to the offence. No question without Cam Newton's mobility, Carolina would not be where they are today.