NFL Playoffs

OK. So tell me how many QBs who have run throughout their careers have been consistently among the best? How many in the HOF? Fran Tarkenton? Who else?

Now tell me how many have had careers even remotely close to Manning and Brady?

I agree Wilson and Newton are dynamic but the only reason I'd take them is because they are younger, not because they can run.
 
I am a huge NFL fan and have been watching football for a very long time and think anyone who watches the NFL and doesn't think that Joe Montana or Tom Brady are the best overall QB (Super Bowl era) to ever play the game have no clue what they are talking about or is a super fan of another QB which is leading them to be biased on the subject.
Tom Brady has never played with the calibre of offensive superstars that Peyton Manning has played with and has always had fill in players in many positions but even with that he has managed great success. Even with Edelman and Gronkowski out for quite a few games they still managed a lot of success this year. They are the greatest franchise in the NFL currently and have set a standard for other teams to follow and have been for the last 15 years dominating the NFL.

Peyton Manning as great as he is in the regular season he simply sucks in the playoffs he is a dismall 13-13 in W-L with 1 ring where Brady is 22-9 in W-L with 4 rings.
By the time both of these guys retire their regular season stats will be very similar other than their INT's, Peyton has 251 INT and Brady only has 150 INT in the regular season and Peyton has 539 TD to Brady 428 TD although Peyton came into the league 3 years before Brady.

For Peyton Manning to be in the same category as Joe Montana or Tom Brady he would need to have a playoff season where he dominates every game and wins the Super Bowl. Even if he wins this year he should not be considered as he hasn't done anything in the playoffs and he is still a dismall 13-13 in W-L.

To be even considered the best you would have to be dominating in the regular season, in the playoffs, have multiple championships and have great abilities at your position between Brady and Manning only Brady has all of those qualities.
 
In that case, you have to acknowledge that Manning had real crappy defenses giving him next to no propping all those years in Indy yet he still had great results.

I would if that were true, it isn't. The Indy defense was pretty decent with Antoine Bethea, Dwight Freeney, Marlon Jackson, Robert Mathis, Gary Brackett. If you want to go there then Manning had some terrific offensive weapons when Brady didn't including Reggie Wayne (6 pro bowls), Dallas Clark (1 pro bowl), Marvin Harrison (8 pro bowls).

Sticking to yesterday, Belichick called an awful game. No hurry up offense like they did all year to keep the Broncos D off balance. Going for it on 4th and 2 late when a field goal would have won the game. Failing to get Edelman involved in any consistent way.

The real story was Gary Kubiak out coached Belichick. Kubiak and Wade Philips manhandled the Patriots exploiting the Patriots band-aid offensive line with devastating effect keeping Brady off balance with 18 knockdowns. They did an amazing job handling the game. With that Manning was only 17 of 32 with 176 yards. 3 points the whole second half.

Take a solid O-line like Carolina has and a big quarterback who can move fast and shake off hits. I think almost all that advantage for Denver goes away.

Carolina by 13.
 
Although I enjoyed watching the Patriots lose I feel for Boston native Katie Nolan. Not only does she have to prop up those two TSN rejects, she also won't be getting a Gronking to remember.

 
I am a huge NFL fan and have been watching football for a very long time and think anyone who watches the NFL and doesn't think that Joe Montana or Tom Brady are the best overall QB (Super Bowl era) to ever play the game have no clue what they are talking about or is a super fan of another QB which is leading them to be biased on the subject.
Tom Brady has never played with the calibre of offensive superstars that Peyton Manning has played with and has always had fill in players in many positions but even with that he has managed great success. Even with Edelman and Gronkowski out for quite a few games they still managed a lot of success this year. They are the greatest franchise in the NFL currently and have set a standard for other teams to follow and have been for the last 15 years dominating the NFL.

Peyton Manning as great as he is in the regular season he simply sucks in the playoffs he is a dismall 13-13 in W-L with 1 ring where Brady is 22-9 in W-L with 4 rings.
So Manning had good regular season stats because he had talent around him but when the Colts lost in the playoffs it was all on Manning.

Brady did well with no talent around him, yet they are still the greatest franchise.

You did mention biased didn't you.
 
So Manning had good regular season stats because he had talent around him but when the Colts lost in the playoffs it was all on Manning.

Brady did well with no talent around him, yet they are still the greatest franchise.

You did mention biased didn't you.

The success of any football team is solely on the shoulders of the QB, when QB's struggle their team struggle, if someone can't understand that there is a lack of football knowledge and trying to explain why Montana and Brady are in another category than other superstar QB's is pointless.
 
The success of any football team is solely on the shoulders of the QB
You lose right there. Blatantly wrong.

As I earlier said, these guys were both great and there is no objective way to determine how much weight each parameter of their career stats carries. Anybody who thinks that one is clearly above the other have no clue what they are talking about or is a super fan of another QB which is leading them to be biased on the subject.

I will ask again, do you think Eli is greater than Marino was?
 
I always laugh when I see
Brady..vs..Manning
Montana..vs..Marino
Griese..vs..Tarkenton
Bradshaw..vs..Staubach
They NEVER squared off against eachother!!
And neither did Brady/Manning. They were never on the field at the same time. They never faced the same defenses. They never played with the same supporting cast. They never had the same coaches. It's not like boxing or tennis. It is a team sport which seemingly is a concept elusive to some.
 
In AFC Championship games I think Manning is now ahead 4-1 or 3-1 vs. Brady. Brady's legacy should be "Couldn't beat Manning to get to the SB". Between this and regular season stats Manning had a greater career. (Doubt I will get any disagreement there.)

You lose right there. Blatantly wrong.

As I earlier said, these guys were both great and there is no objective way to determine how much weight each parameter of their career stats carries. Anybody who thinks that one is clearly above the other have no clue what they are talking about or is a super fan of another QB which is leading them to be biased on the subject.

I will ask again, do you think Eli is greater than Marino was?

Are you saying that Peyton Manning is better than Joe Montana and Tom Brady?
 
Again to be considered the best at any position you would need to have natural talent at your position, dominate in regular season, dominate in playoffs, and have multiple championships.
This notion that players who are not on the field at the same time should not be compared to one another is just stupid. Going with that ideology no football player, and no baseball player at the same position should ever be compared to one another. This idea is just a way for people not wanting to say one is better than the other.

The most naturally talented player to ever play the game is Dan Marino but that doesn't make him the best, just like how Montana, Brady, Bradshaw winning the most number of super bowls alone does not make them the best to ever play the game but it is the overall achievements they have in regular season, playoffs, natural QB talents, and super bowl wins that would make them better than others.
 
Are you saying that Peyton Manning is better than Joe Montana and Tom Brady?
Not in the least. There are compelling arguments to be made for all 3.

I am saying that it is impossible to have an unequivocal answer. To repeat, there are too many parameters. They were/are all amazing but there are too many factors and eras and teammates and opponents and coaches to declare a definitive winner. As somebody else said, you can't compare players from different eras. As I said QB's do not compete head to head like in individual sports where the task is clearly easier yet still open to interpretation.

We should accept and appreciate what we've been able to see and it is fun to debate and speculate, but unless some QB wins 15 SBs with 2,000 TD's and a consistent dramatic turnover of teammates and coaches (maybe a slight exaggeration LOL), it comes down to a subjective opinion to which we are all entitled to believe but not entitled to force others to believe.
 
Again to be considered the best at any position you would need to have natural talent at your position, dominate in regular season, dominate in playoffs, and have multiple championships.
This notion that players who are not on the field at the same time should not be compared to one another is just stupid.
I didn't say that they can't be compared. I said it is much more difficult to do so in a team sport than it is in a head to head individual sport because there are so many other factors than just those particular players' talents.

The most naturally talented player to ever play the game is Dan Marino but that doesn't make him the best, just like how Montana, Brady, Bradshaw winning the most number of super bowls alone does not make them the best to ever play the game but it is the overall achievements they have in regular season, playoffs, natural QB talents, and super bowl wins that would make them better than others.
Agree. However so many people are putting so much weight on the SB wins that I was playing devil's advocate by asking if Eli's 2 SBs make him better than Marino with zero.

Of all those factors you mentioned the only place Manning is lacking is in SBs. For the most part he has better regular season stats than Brady. So what is the weighting factor there? Is it 80% SBs and 20% regular or is it 60/40 or something else? Nobody can answer. There is no formula. This is where it becomes subjective, i.e. it is simply opinion/conjecture, not irrefutable fact.
 
If Manning had Belichick for his entire career he too would likely have 4 SBs. Pats without Brady still go 11-5 in '08. Colts without Manning turn into steaming pile of crap that ensures they then get Andrew Luck in the '12 Draft. I'd say the horseshoe on their helmet is appropriate
 
If Manning had Belichick for his entire career he too would likely have 4 SBs. Pats without Brady still go 11-5 in '08. Colts without Manning turn into steaming pile of crap that ensures they then get Andrew Luck in the '12 Draft. I'd say the horseshoe on their helmet is appropriate
As I said, compelling arguments can be made for all parties. However, no matter how much fun it is, it is all speculation and nobody should be too dogmatic regardless of who their choice is.
 
Ok. Here's a question.

Does anybody's opinion of rankings change if Peyton gets his 2nd in two weeks?
 
Not in the least. There are compelling arguments to be made for all 3.

I am saying that it is impossible to have an unequivocal answer. To repeat, there are too many parameters. They were/are all amazing but there are too many factors and eras and teammates and opponents and coaches to declare a definitive winner. As somebody else said, you can't compare players from different eras. As I said QB's do not compete head to head like in individual sports where the task is clearly easier yet still open to interpretation.

We should accept and appreciate what we've been able to see and it is fun to debate and speculate, but unless some QB wins 15 SBs with 2,000 TD's and a consistent dramatic turnover of teammates and coaches (maybe a slight exaggeration LOL), it comes down to a subjective opinion to which we are all entitled to believe but not entitled to force others to believe.

Neither do RB, neither do WR, neither do LB and every other position in Football as well as baseball. So you are saying no player in baseball or football should ever be compared to one another because they don't compete against one another.
 
I didn't say that they can't be compared. I said it is much more difficult to do so in a team sport than it is in a head to head individual sport because there are so many other factors than just those particular players' talents.


Agree. However so many people are putting so much weight on the SB wins that I was playing devil's advocate by asking if Eli's 2 SBs make him better than Marino with zero.

Of all those factors you mentioned the only place Manning is lacking is in SBs. For the most part he has better regular season stats than Brady. So what is the weighting factor there? Is it 80% SBs and 20% regular or is it 60/40 or something else? Nobody can answer. There is no formula. This is where it becomes subjective, i.e. it is simply opinion/conjecture, not irrefutable fact.

Again as I said earlier their regular season stats are very similar and by the time they both retire their numbers will be very similar, and Brady will actually lead in some categories. Peyton Manning started playing 3 years earlier than Tom Brady and has 539 TD and 251 INT 71940 YDS VS Tom Brady who has 428 TD 150 INT 58028 in 3 fewer seasons, and their win and losses are 186-79 for Manning VS 172-51 for Brady.

Manning is not only struggling in SB rings but also in playoffs in general and only has a 13-13 record in the playoffs where Brady is 22-9.

If you think all of these numbers are subjective because they don't play head to head and can't be compared then that's your own biased opinion.

And I didn't even start with all the fill in receivers that Tom Brady has been playing with and the future HOF that Peyton Manning has been playing with.
 
Neither do RB, neither do WR, neither do LB and every other position in Football as well as baseball. So you are saying no player in baseball or football should ever be compared to one another because they don't compete against one another.
You are having problems comprehending.

For at least the 3rd time I have said that they can be compared and it is a fun debate, but in many cases there is no definitive answer. That is, unless somebody is so far ahead of the other that there is no question at all to anybody. In the case of Manning vs. Brady vs. Montana the only issue is Manning's SBs.