A murder in a home lowers the value of the home. It doesn't matter that it's irrational (which it is). By not informing the buyer of that event, the seller committed fraud against the buyer.
Trickier is whether that disclosure would have to be made to tenants of a rental. Generally not. Properties like this are prime candidates for real estate investors to buy and then rent out for a long period of time. After a few decades, the fact that someone was murdered in the house will matter much less to potential buyers and the owner can then turn a tidy profit based on the lowered property value for his initial purchase.
Trickier is whether that disclosure would have to be made to tenants of a rental. Generally not. Properties like this are prime candidates for real estate investors to buy and then rent out for a long period of time. After a few decades, the fact that someone was murdered in the house will matter much less to potential buyers and the owner can then turn a tidy profit based on the lowered property value for his initial purchase.

