Murder House

Rockslinger

Banned
Apr 24, 2005
32,764
0
0
Here is an interesting court case as reported by the Saturday Star and Global TV News. A couple is suing the previous owner and the real estate agent who sold them a house that is the scene of a brutal double murder a few years ago. The real estate agent has already been disciplined by her association.
 
that would suck if they bought the housed at a marked up price too xP
 
i don't understand why that would matter. i wouldn't give a fuck if someone was murdered in my house. they clean the hell out of them after and there would be no trace left.
 
it is very likely that souls of the departed hang around because of an untimely death.
 
Would your wife live in a house knowing that the son killed his mother and sister?

i really don't understand why that matters ? it happened before i lived there and it was cleaned up, who cares. do you kiss your girlfriend knowing she had a dick there before ? shit was cleaned up and no trace. i really don't understand why it matters. should we tear down or vacate everything that had a murder committed there ?
 
i really don't understand why that matters ? it happened before i lived there and it was cleaned up, who cares. do you kiss your girlfriend knowing she had a dick there before ? shit was cleaned up and no trace. i really don't understand why it matters. should we tear down or vacate everything that had a murder committed there ?

Lots of people are superstitious.
Personally it wouldn't bother me one bit. But what WOULD bother me is the lack of disclosure. Of course it doesn't affect the structure of the house, etc... but a double-murder is a significant event in this society (and a child was involved making it even more shocking), so I agree that it was unfair to keep that piece of information (that I'm sure most people would consider important) from the buyers.
 
couple is suing the previous owner and the real estate agent who sold them a house that is the scene of a brutal double murder a few years ago. The real estate agent has already been disciplined by her association.
So why was the Real Estate Agent disciplined?

Is there much case law on this in Canada? There isn't much in the U.S. and it generally has gone badly for those attempting to get out of the contract.
 
So why was the Real Estate Agent disciplined?

Is there much case law on this in Canada? There isn't much in the U.S. and it generally has gone badly for those attempting to get out of the contract.

i just asked this at another forum. florida law says that they don't have to tell you shit.
 
i just asked this at another forum. florida law says that they don't have to tell you shit.
If it concerns you take the time to do a newspaper search, directly ask the question etc. . . when it comes to haunted houses caveat emptor most definately is the word of the day.

I will say that the few people I've known who have felt that they lived in haunted houses had strange rather than frightening experiences.
 
If it concerns you take the time to do a newspaper search, directly ask the question etc. . . when it comes to haunted houses caveat emptor most definately is the word of the day.

I will say that the few people I've known who have felt that they lived in haunted houses had strange rather than frightening experiences.

i would be so busy asking questions about the taxes and structure of the house that i wouldn't have time to think of whether someone was killed there. as for haunting, i welcome that stuff i really enjoy and like it and would get used to it easily.
 
When I bought my house, I jokingly asked the real estate agent about stuff like this, she said the agent has to tell you if anything like this happens. Personally, my concern wouldn't be ghosts, but if it were sufficiently notorious, people could be coming around to gawk at all hours of the day & night, possibly trespassing or even chipping pieces off. Think about the Bernardo house in St. Catharines, it was torn down rather than sold.
 
Personally, my concern wouldn't be ghosts, but if it were sufficiently notorious, people could be coming around to gawk at all hours of the day & night, possibly trespassing or even chipping pieces off.
You might also have problems reselling the house.
 
Both the SELLER and the AGENT are being sued.
Presumably they told the Real Estate Agent, however, if they did not and she just knew it on her own. . . the agent's fiduciary duty is normally to the seller.

I await comment from Ogare, RLD et al, but it looks like this may be a groundbreaking case in Ontario. If the courts hold as have U.S. courts, caveat emptor is going to be the word - see #8.

The Real Estate Board Code of Ethics states that a real estate agent has an obligation to disclose any fact that could affect a person's decision to buy a property*, the price that ought to be paid, and the ability to sell the property at a future time. *The stigma of a murder is seemingly one such thing, but how in Ontario is the obvious conflict with the agent's fiduciary duty to the seller handled? Does the Code of Ethics have the force of law?


By the way a link to an article on this http://www.thestar.com/news/gta/art...er-sale-of-house-where-double-murder-occurred
 
By way of reply to Aardvark the liability of the vendor's agent will very much depend upon how the allegations against him/her are styled.

For example, there was a case from Saskatchewan that dealt with a house that had been moved. In the process of being moved the structural integrity of the house was compromised. Everyone (the vendor, the vendor's agent and the purchasor's agent) except the purchasor knew the house had been moved (and none of them told the purchasor).

The trial judge heard expert evidence that the vendor's agent had a duty to disclose all known latent defects to the propsective purchasor and this duty trumped any duty the agent had to the vendor. However, the judge did not decide liability against the vendor's agent on this ground becuase the judge decided that, irrespective of any such duty, the fact was that the purchasor was not relying on the vendor's agent in this regard, she was relying on her own agent. However, the judge did find the vendor's agent liable for negligent misrepresentation for saying to the purchasor that the house was of "quality construction".

My sense is that the courts will find there is a duty on a realtor (acting for a vendor) to disclose material facts/latent defects irrespective of their duty to the vendor. To be more precise the court will likely impose a strict duty to disclose on the vendors and will not accept that a vendor's realtor (as a legal agent for the vendor) could point to his/her duty to the vendor as a legal excuse for not fulfilling an unequivocal duty that the vendor had.