Real Estate Agent Worth Their Commissions?

MrPrezident

A Big Man For a Big Job
May 30, 2002
1,160
479
83
Red House over yonder.
Are real estate agents worth their commissions? What is a fair commission? I recently made a bid on a house. Somehow this agent expected me to also sign on with her as a buyer's agent so she could also work two sides of the deal. Somehow this strikes me as wanting to be paid twice. She also disclosed she had an interest in the title agency we would use. Triple dipping?

Between the agents who try to bump up middleman costs and the abusive real estate transfer fees, is it any wonder that home buyers are having affordability problems?
 
The last time I bought it was a family sale. So we used one lawyer, flat rate who did all the paper work. You don't need one if you already know what you are looking for and have a specialized lawyer to do the due diligence.

Selling I would use one as they would be able to get best price. But double dipping? I'm not even sure that's legal.
 
“Double ending” in real estate deals in Ontario is legal, but requires both parties’ consent. It’s often advised against due to the obvious conflict of interest, and the fact that you are agreeing to be unrepresented. You have the right to ask that another agent be involved. Even without double ended deals, in our system, the buyer’s agent is always in an COI, because they are rewarded more if you get a worse deal. Instead of “double ending” I think we should start calling the practice “spit roasting” or “double penetration” to deter it. 😂
 
Using the listing agent does give you a bit of leverage in the deal where you can tell the agent you want a break in the commission. If they are listing it at 2% on each side of the deal, tell them to give you 1.5% cash back after closing, they still make their 2% plus an additional .5%. Otherwise you are going and grabbing the agent working the open house down the street.

The obvious downside to buying through the listing agent is the lack of ability to negotiate. They work for the seller, they can't push them to accept the lower offer you would naturally be putting in. Yes, a buyer agent benefitting from a higher sale price can be seen as a conflict as well, but the buyer agent doesn't have as much invested in this and is more interested in you closing the deal to your satisfaction and getting a pay check.
 
I used one agent to sell and another to buy because I was moving from one area of town to another and I wanted agents familiar with their neighbourhoods.

Both were disappointed that I didn't use them for both transactions, but they got over it. This was when housing sales were good. My selling agent didn't give me a break on commission, but I didn't have to pay for staging.
 
Correct me please, I thought only the seller pays a commission .
Does she want to sell your current property and get that commission?
 
Are real estate agents worth their commissions? What is a fair commission? I recently made a bid on a house. Somehow this agent expected me to also sign on with her as a buyer's agent so she could also work two sides of the deal. Somehow this strikes me as wanting to be paid twice. She also disclosed she had an interest in the title agency we would use. Triple dipping?

Between the agents who try to bump up middleman costs and the abusive real estate transfer fees, is it any wonder that home buyers are having affordability problems?

I'm friends with the one of the best agents in the city. She makes $600,000 a year from what amounts to a weekend's worth of work on each house.

Is she worth it? Not really. When she sold my Mother's house, I negotiated her down on the commission, as houses sell themselves in Toronto for the most part.

They have access to more buyers PERHAPS but mostly they're just ridiculously paid "valets".

And yes most agents want to work both sides of your transaction obviously.
 
  • Like
Reactions: zbla and xix
Correct me please, I thought only the seller pays a commission .
Does she want to sell your current property and get that commission?
Yes, essentially the seller pays the commission, as it's deemed to be from the proceeds of the sale. As a buyer, you can put anything in the offer regarding commissions if you want to, it's up the other side to agree (and the agents obviously). Or you sign a side deal with the agent about reducing or kicking back part of the commission after closing. When we bought out current house a few years ago, we used a local agent in this city than the agent we used to sell our house in the other city, mainly because it was more convenient to get her to show us houses. We found her at an open house that we were interested in but it sold before we were ready to make an offer. But we kept in touch with her and she said for buyers, she gives back 1% of her commission, which was a nice little bonus to get a couple weeks after the closing when bills were high. Of course, our agent who had our house listed was trying to convince us to use him to buy the new house in the other city, but we were happy with this other agent. I doubt ours would have done all that driving and then also agreed to a rebate either, although we didn't ask.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Spunky1