Murder House

A murder in a home lowers the value of the home. It doesn't matter that it's irrational (which it is). By not informing the buyer of that event, the seller committed fraud against the buyer.

Trickier is whether that disclosure would have to be made to tenants of a rental. Generally not. Properties like this are prime candidates for real estate investors to buy and then rent out for a long period of time. After a few decades, the fact that someone was murdered in the house will matter much less to potential buyers and the owner can then turn a tidy profit based on the lowered property value for his initial purchase.
 
By way of reply to Aardvark the liability of the vendor's agent will very much depend upon how the allegations against him/her are styled.

For example, there was a case from Saskatchewan that dealt with a house that had been moved. In the process of being moved the structural integrity of the house was compromised. Everyone (the vendor, the vendor's agent and the purchasor's agent) except the purchasor knew the house had been moved (and none of them told the purchasor).

The trial judge heard expert evidence that the vendor's agent had a duty to disclose all known latent defects to the propsective purchasor and this duty trumped any duty the agent had to the vendor. However, the judge did not decide liability against the vendor's agent on this ground becuase the judge decided that, irrespective of any such duty, the fact was that the purchasor was not relying on the vendor's agent in this regard, she was relying on her own agent. However, the judge did find the vendor's agent liable for negligent misrepresentation for saying to the purchasor that the house was of "quality construction".

My sense is that the courts will find there is a duty on a realtor (acting for a vendor) to disclose material facts/latenttt defects irrespective of their duty to the vendor. To be more precise the court will likely impose a strict duty to disclose on the vendors and will not accept that a vendor's realtor (as a legal agent for the vendor) could point to his/her duty to the vendor as a legal excuse for not fulfilling an unequivocal duty that the vendor had.
Certainly in a case where there is a physical defect that the purchaser wouldn't have been able to ascertain by observation. Particularly so when their Buyer's Agent knew of the problem and failed to inform them. As you can tell, to me this seems different from this case where there is no physical defect.

Now I will mention that having taken a few minutes today to dig a bit further, this is an area of law that seems to have very recently gone into flux in the U.S. For instance see the Pennsylvania case Milliken v. Jacono which is currently pending rehearing on the Appellate level. Under fairly recently enacted California law, a seller must disclose only if a murder was committed within the past three years. Florida on the other hand in 2003 codified that there was no duty of a seller or a licensee to disclose homicide, suicide, or death.

A murder in a home lowers the value of the home. It doesn't matter that it's irrational (which it is). By not informing the buyer of that event, the seller committed fraud against the buyer.
If this is established case law in Canada, it is different from the U.S. where this is an area very definitely in flux and is state specific.
 
Certainly in a case where there is a physical defect that the purchaser wouldn't have been able to ascertain by observation. Particularly so when their Buyer's Agent knew of the problem and failed to inform them. As you can tell, to me this seems different from this case where there is no physical defect..

I don't know if it has ever been held by a Canadian court that a history of murder in a house will absolutely lower the property value of a house and must therefore be disclosed by a seller and their agent. I think it is fair to say however that the duty to disclose is broader than physical or latent defects - which is why it is phrased as "any material fact". I think it is also fair to say that the duty applies irrespective of whether the prospective purchaser could independently acquire the information (e.g., a zoning restriction, covenant or right of way registered on title that, with some digging on the purchaser's part coud be discovered).

Given that over 90% of civil cases settle I think it is unlikely that this one will ever see the dim lighting of a courtroom but it would be interesting to see how far a Canadian court would go in expanding what a "material fact" is. The cases you cite from Pennsylvania and Florida illustrate the difficulty with the issue - why is 3 years the arbitrary cut off? Is murder the threshold crime? What about a really violent attempted murder? What about a history of brutal child abuse? What about a history of being used as a brothel? What about a history of being a clubhouse for an outlaw MC? I would hope the Court would insist on cogent evidence that the history of a home as the scene of a murder will unequivocally lower its property value before it would impose a duty to disclose on the vendor.