Motorcycle Death Arrest

You have done a fine job to clearly illustrate that several other possible circumstances contributed to her death.
So, if the passenger in a pick-up-truck which is traveling over twice the speed limit, and the operator of which is intoxicated isn't wearing their seat belt and is thrown from the vehicle and killed. . . This is going to affect the driver being convicted of Manslaughter or aggravated DUI/OUI/OWI in what way?

You seem to be stuck living in a world of contributory negligence (not that this ever applied to Criminal Law).

Your negligence arguments might have some bearing on a Civil Suit, but since we are in an age of comparative or non-absolute contributory negligence the estate is very likely still going to recover since there is frankly no way a judge or jury is going to find that her negligence was greater than his.
 
You have done a fine job to clearly illustrate that several other possible circumstances contributed to her death.
The onus is not on the Crown to prove that she died before the cars hit her and that she didn't have an exceptionally weak grip.
Asshole is at fault regardless.

There are potential extenuating circumstances that may help mitigate his charge(s) and sentence.
Nobody is suggesting that he will receive the maximum sentence for manslaughter.
But that does not mean that some blame must be attributed to the victim.

The deceased may have been negligent in her responsibilities but the fault and blame for the criminal actions that directly lead to her death are all his.
 
The onus is not on the Crown to prove that she died before the cars hit her and that she didn't have an exceptionally weak grip.
Asshole is at fault regardless.

There are potential extenuating circumstances that may help mitigate his charge(s) and sentence.
Nobody is suggesting that he will receive the maximum sentence for manslaughter.
But that does not mean that some blame must be attributed to the victim.

The deceased may have been negligent in her responsibilities but the fault and blame for the criminal actions that directly lead to her death are all his.

Well firstly they need to prove there WERE criminal actions that led to her death. They don't seem to have laid any charges yet that would build this foundation. That could change. As I have said if the defence can creat any doubt around these criminal acts, then her death can very quickly become a misadventure scenario.
 
So, if the passenger in a pick-up-truck which is traveling over twice the speed limit, and the operator of which is intoxicated isn't wearing their seat belt and is thrown from the vehicle and killed. . . This is going to affect the driver being convicted of Manslaughter or aggravated DUI/OUI/OWI in what way?

You seem to be stuck living in a world of contributory negligence (not that this ever applied to Criminal Law).

Your negligence arguments might have some bearing on a Civil Suit, but since we are in an age of comparative or non-absolute contributory negligence the estate is very likely still going to recover since there is frankly no way a judge or jury is going to find that her negligence was greater than his.

If you can prove all those things, sure. But CAN YOU in this case?
 
Well firstly they need to prove there WERE criminal actions that led to her death. They don't seem to have laid any charges yet that would build this foundation. That could change. As I have said if the defence can creat any doubt around these criminal acts, then her death can very quickly become a misadventure scenario.
If his defence is going to be that he had no idea that the police were after him and that he didn't realize that his passenger had fallen off, he had better hope that it is possible to have a jury of 12 people who think like you.
 
If his defence is going to be that he had no idea that the police were after him and that he didn't realize that his passenger had fallen off, he had better hope that it is possible to have a jury of 12 people who think like you.

He does not have to explain ANYTHING, all he has to do is attack any proof the prosecution has. (which is very little). They might not even be able to place him at the scene of the crime.
 
He does not have to explain ANYTHING, all he has to do is attack any proof the prosecution has. (which is very little). They might not even be able to place him at the scene of the crime.
So you have inside information on the prosecution's weak case and you are divulging this fact here on TERB?

Placing him at the scene of the crime would be a slam dunk smoking gun and pretty much cook his goose.
Even just connecting her helmet to him and having witnesses that saw them together shortly before the incident could be enough to fry him.

Maybe they have the wrong guy.
Let's see how it plays out.
 
50106_579770486_4176_n.jpg


I wonder if his guns are registered?

I know somebody who knows this idiot. And yes this is his picture. Goes by the name of Richie.
 
So you have inside information on the prosecution's weak case and you are divulging this fact here on TERB?

Placing him at the scene of the crime would be a slam dunk smoking gun and pretty much cook his goose.
Even just connecting her helmet to him and having witnesses that saw them together shortly before the incident could be enough to fry him.

Maybe they have the wrong guy.
Let's see how it plays out.

No I have inside info, just the list of charges (esp. lack thereoff) seems puzzling.
 
If his defence is going to be that he had no idea that the police were after him and that he didn't realize that his passenger had fallen off, he had better hope that it is possible to have a jury of 12 people who think like you.
Indeed I have seen juries that were less than brilliant. However, a jury such as that would have to give a whole new meaning to the phrase.

Further, although it isn't always the case, I've seen plenty of juries that even when you have used all your challenges, you look at them and say "oh Lord," cut straight through the nonsense and deliver eminently sensible verdicts.


As to the "lack of charges": a) don't believe everything you read in the newspapers b) it may well be that the Crown feels strongly enough about the defendant's conduct that it doesn't want to give the jury the "out" of convicting on a lesser offense
 
He does not have to explain ANYTHING, all he has to do is attack any proof the prosecution has. (which is very little). They might not even be able to place him at the scene of the crime.

You have NO IDEA what you're talking about. None. Zero. Zip. Nada. Zilch. Really, nothing.

The prosecution is going to show up with, at a minimum:

1. Evidence from the police and from witnesses that he fled from the police

2. Evidence of his speed

I mean even if he didn't know the police were there the speed he sped away at was criminally negligent in and of itself, and on top of that, he was fleeing from the police!

That part of their case is a slam dunk. There is really not much to argue about there.

Where they are going to have to work hard is to prove that he was the guy on the motor cycle. His best defense is going to be "sure it looked like me, and it looked like my bike, and I knew that girl pretty well, but it wasn't really me".

If the prosecution can persuade a jury that he was the guy on the bike, travelling at that speed, fleeing from the police, when she died--it's game over.
 
One of your basic errors nottyboi is that you are confused as to what counts as a reasonable doubt. You think ANY doubt gets him off, that the prosecution has to prove their case scientifically or mathematically and that any doubt = innocent.

That is not true, only REASONABLE doubts get you off the hook. Not far fetched possibilities, reasonable possibilities. The defense has to show that there is an alternative explanation which, while not necessarily proven, is at least plausible.

"Even though he hit the gas when the lights and sirens went up, and even though people inside cars heard the siren, and even though the lights would be clearly visible in his rear view, he didn't really see the cops" <-- not a REASONABLE doubt, that is far fetched, and no jury is going to believe that.
 
Either I will or neither of us will....this video shows it is possible although the bike is being ridden only at about 8/10th in the corners since the rider cannot hang off the bike:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vh0rkr6Hb2w


and even better one where they actually pass other people:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s4Ov7botYUQ&feature=related


the defence will use videos like this to show opinions like yours are rubbish.

Yeah, those videos will do a great job for the defence. Highly skilled riders, with passengers that KNEW what is coming up, on a closed course. I'm sure videos like that would really win points with the judge/jury.
 
Yeah, those videos will do a great job for the defence. Highly skilled riders, with passengers that KNEW what is coming up, on a closed course. I'm sure videos like that would really win points with the judge/jury.

What if it is shown she had a lot of experience with bikes???
 
Interesting little rumour from another site:

"Rumours abound locally that the cop was the first car to run the lady over, and he booked it for the station to write his report. He is apparently refusing to co-operate with internal investigations at this point. "


Now what happens if it turns out the cop actually HIT the bike knocking the passenger off.. hmmmmm
 
Do you really expect one? Or at least a credible one?

Well, I know that he's an attention whore who needs to overule everyone no matter how ludicrous his opinions are; but, I'm sure he wouldn't create a website and then plant his own rumour.:)
 
Interesting little rumour from another site:

"Rumours abound locally that the cop was the first car to run the lady over, and he booked it for the station to write his report. He is apparently refusing to co-operate with internal investigations at this point. "


Now what happens if it turns out the cop actually HIT the bike knocking the passenger off.. hmmmmm
Is there a logical reason why you would think that this is the case or that it is even quite likely?
Even if this was true, there was no intent and it was still the asshole's fault.

Evidence to convict does not have to be absolute and I can't imagine why you would be motivated to presume that every conceivable remote possibility is probable and highly likely.

At least you have brought together several people, who often disagree, to agree that you are seriously fucked up. :p