Motorcycle Death Arrest

If you are someone who gets scared easily by speed, sure.

You are thinking of speed in absolute terms as if this guy and his girl were isolated at Mosport racetrack with the track all to themselves.

The larger issue here, since we are talking about a 400 series highway, is relative speed. When the motorcyclist is on a 400 highway, whether he likes it or not, he's in a relationship with every other vehicle on the road.
And, when you're travelling at double the speed of everyone else on a busy highway you are deliberately creating an absolutely insane pinball game where anything can happen in the blinking of an eyelash.

I will concede that if the girl in question was a complete psychopath, she probably wasn't afraid of what was going on.
 
What is wrong with that. Out in the real world Rashid Soujah would be well advised to make such an offer.

If the charge fails to stick, I don't see many climb downs from this one. I am also surprised they did not go for criminal negligence causing death... and I suspect it's because it would be hard to prove the negligence was purely his. What I do know, is if he was a the dickhead former attorny general he would be walking.. for sure.. but in this case I suspect he will plead to a lesser charge because he cannot afford a lawyer that can get him off completely.
 
What are you trying to say?.. the guy is a moron dickhead? SURE... I AGREE... but that does not mean the victim was blameless? If you associate with pond scum.. you are gonna get dirty.. WTF is wrong with you people.

Now you're just going all over the place. You were trying to justify his speeding up for fun and maybe it wasn't because of the police asking him to pull over.
Now suddenly because the guy (you're admitting is scum) it's partially her fault for riding with him in the first place?

You made your stance earlier on putting partial blame on her and really it's ALL on the rider and you refuse to admit you were wrong in putting some blame on the passenger.
She did her part I'm sure (holding onto him) but he did his part by throwing her off, we'll see how this plays out.
 
but that does not mean the victim was blameless
Ok, so please inform us how much or how little "blame" does the victim in a case such as this need to have to be exculpatory for the Defendant? Seemingly you are saying that merely agreeing to go on a motorcyle ride is enough.
 
What is wrong with that. Out in the real world Rashid Soujah would be well advised to make such an offer.

If the charge fails to stick, I don't see many climb downs from this one. I am also surprised they did not go for criminal negligence causing death... and I suspect it's because it would be hard to prove the negligence was purely his. What I do know, is if he was a the dickhead former attorny general he would be walking.. for sure.. but in this case I suspect he will plead to a lesser charge because he cannot afford a lawyer that can get him off completely.
 
Ok, so please inform us how much or how little "blame" does the victim in a case such as this need to have to be exculpatory for the Defendant? Seemingly you are saying that merely agreeing to go on a motorcyle ride is enough.

Not possible to say without knowing all the facts. How well did she know the defendant. Had she ridden with him before. Was she drunk. Did she have any motorcycle experience, did people she know warn her this guy was a dick head? What was her mental state. Was she being treated for depression and a suicide risk and therefore maybe not holding on to tempt fate? WHO KNOWS!!! But I can say for sure her responsibility >0.
 
I am also surprised they did not go for criminal negligence causing death...
I don't know the procedure in Ontario, but it is quite common for someone to be arrested on one charge, and for additional charges to be subsequently added by the prosecution, so this charge might well be on the table at trial.

but in this case I suspect he will plead to a lesser charge because he cannot afford a lawyer that can get him off completely.
So having described Soujah as a "moron dickhead" you now want us to feel sorry that he doesn't walk.
 
You are thinking of speed in absolute terms as if this guy and his girl were isolated at Mosport racetrack with the track all to themselves.

The larger issue here, since we are talking about a 400 series highway, is relative speed. When the motorcyclist is on a 400 highway, whether he likes it or not, he's in a relationship with every other vehicle on the road.
And, when you're travelling at double the speed of everyone else on a busy highway you are deliberately creating an absolutely insane pinball game where anything can happen in the blinking of an eyelash.

I will concede that if the girl in question was a complete psychopath, she probably wasn't afraid of what was going on.

Do you honestly think people do not intentionally tempt fate on the 400 series highways for the adreneline rush? I'm not saying its right, but I have seen many times people do wheelies on the 400 series hwy.. I have not done so myself, but I have ridden and driven quite fast on them. To me it was quite fast, some people would probably say I have a deathwish.. but when you have three lanes open and can see for miles.. as you can in some spots.. personally I don't think it is very risky.
 
Do you really think the law works like that? A good judge will go based on the evidence. All the defence really has to do is attack the evidence. If the guy knows what is good for him he will not testify. Just attack the evidence and show that nothing can be proven. If he was already riding like an idiot (which presumably attracted the attention of the cops) then how can you conclude he was attempting to evade rather then just continuing to ride like an idiot...for example. Intent is a LARGE part of any trial.

You aren't giving the judge and the jury enough credit for being able to tell the difference between bullshit and a plausible doubt.
 
I don't know the procedure in Ontario, but it is quite common for someone to be arrested on one charge, and for additional charges to be subsequently added by the prosecution, so this charge might well be on the table at trial.

So having described Soujah as a "moron dickhead" you now want us to feel sorry that he doesn't walk.

No, no need to feel sorry for that guy, just be aware that justice is for sale in Ontario if one has the means.
 
With that responsibilty of riding a bike you also have to be a responsible bike rider, much like a driver in a car.
A driver can be speed as insanely fast as he wants but he has a responsibility for the safety of his passengers as well.

I agree. I'm just saying that if they had been in a car and he sped off the same way, the outcome would probably be different. Something for anybody getting on to a bike to think about.
 
You aren't giving the judge and the jury enough credit for being able to tell the difference between bullshit and a plausible doubt.

It is pretty easy to attack the evidence when it is all based on speculation.. we shall see. One has to PROVE these things. It is possible he lawyered up and turned himself in.. who knows. One will not even need to say those things. Just ask the cop if he was able to prove he was evading arrest...WHICH need I remind you he is NOT CHARGED WITH yet. (could be a little hint there for you).

Cop: he was trying to escape apprehension
Schister: Then why did you not charge him with fail to stop?
Cop: uhh uhhh DOOH!!!
 
Not possible to say without knowing all the facts.
Gee really?

Further of all the points you raise the only one that really has any exculpatory effect is was she suicidal. That she was intoxicated the driver bears the responsibility (and if she had so little to drink he couldn't tell, unlikely that is why she fell), so she knew he was a jackass driver - that somehow eliminates his responsibility to operate safely?
 
Gee really?

Further of all the points you raise the only one that really has any exculpatory effect is was she suicidal. That she was intoxicated the driver bears the responsibility (and if she had so little to drink he couldn't tell, unlikely that is why she fell), so she knew he was a jackass driver - that somehow eliminates his responsibility to operate safely?

Not it does not, but he is not being charged with unsafe operation of a vehicle.. he is being charged with MANSLAUGHTER.
 
surprised they did not go for criminal negligence causing death

You may want to review the Criminal Code of Canada.

222 (5) A person commits culpable homicide when he causes the death of a human being,
(a) by means of an unlawful act;
(b) by criminal negligence;
(c) by causing that human being, by threats or fear of violence or by deception, to do anything that causes his death; or
(d) by wilfully frightening that human being, in the case of a child or sick person.


They've got him on either part (a) or part (b) of that. Once you have determined that there is a culpable homicide you go on to decide what kind of culpable homicide it is: Murder, manslaughter, or infanticide. The difference between murder and manslaughter is whether there was intent to kill.

Presumably he had no intent to kill anyone so they're going for manslaughter.

But sure they could probably get him for dangerous operation of a vehicle causing death for which the punishment is also life in prison.
 
Gee really?

Further of all the points you raise the only one that really has any exculpatory effect is was she suicidal. That she was intoxicated the driver bears the responsibility (and if she had so little to drink he couldn't tell, unlikely that is why she fell), so she knew he was a jackass driver - that somehow eliminates his responsibility to operate safely?

Not it does not, but he is not being charged with unsafe operation of a vehicle.. he is being charged with MANSLAUGHTER.
 
You may want to review the Criminal Code of Canada.

[(5) A person commits culpable homicide when he causes the death of a human being,
(a) by means of an unlawful act;
(b) by criminal negligence;
(c) by causing that human being, by threats or fear of violence or by deception, to do anything that causes his death; or
(d) by wilfully frightening that human being, in the case of a child or sick person.


They've got him on either part (a) or part (b) of that. Once you have determined that there is a culpable homicide you go on to decide what kind of culpable homicide it is: Murder, manslaughter, or infanticide. The difference between murder and infanticide is whether there was intent.

Presumably he had no intent to kill anyone so they're going for manslaughter.

you think they have him on a and b, I don't. And the stark fact is, they have not chosen to charge him with any other unlawful acts yet, which alone raises all kinds of doubts.