Lincoln

the shelf life of slavery would have been relatively short. Did 700,000 humans have to die to speed up abolition by maybe 10-20 years?
You make some huge assumptions, further as pointed out by now several times the principal war aim of the United States was to preserve the Union.
 
Canada is a very different place, we tend to work through things, not shoot first and ask questions later. That's why we didn't have the same amount of difficulties and confrontations with the native and the wild west was an american phenomenon. The closest thing we got to the 'Wild West' was the Yukon gold rush of '98 and it was gone in four years.
A good history of the Northwest Mounted Police will show that matters were rather more complex, for instance that the principle warlike plains tribes were in the U.S.
 
Now you have me even more confused. Post Constitutional Period?

Excuse the quote from Wiki-Pedia. I don't pretend to be knowledgeable on U.S. History. Just vaguely recalling what I've read.

Constitution of the United States

The Constitution of the United States was drafted in 1787, and included several provisions regarding slavery. Section 9 of Article I allowed the continued "importation" of slaves. By prohibiting changes for two decades to regulation of the slave trade, Article V effectively protected the trade until 1808, giving the States then existing 20 years to resolve this issue. During that time, planters in states of the Lower South imported tens of thousands of slaves, more than during any previous two decades in colonial/US history.[28]

As further protection for slavery, the delegates approved Section 2 of Article IV, which prohibited citizens from providing assistance to escaping slaves and required the return of chattel property to owners.

In a section negotiated by James Madison of Virginia, Section 2 of Article I designated "other persons" (slaves) to be added to the total of the state's free population, at the rate of three-fifths of their total number, to establish the state's official population for the purposes of apportionment of Congressional representation and federal taxation.[29] This increased the power of southern states in Congress for decades, affecting national policies and legislation. They were represented primarily by men of their planter elite, who also dominated the presidency for nearly 50 years.
 
You make some huge assumptions, further as pointed out by now several times the principal war aim of the United States was to preserve the Union.


Agreed. The Confederacy was disruptive to the Union in more ways than one. As Aardvark154 pointed out in that Lincoln letter, the war wasn't just about slavery.
 
The only thing I worry about is Spielberg pulling a Spielberg and making the characters out to be much more than they ever were.

For example, the "Mrs Bixby Letter" scene from "Saving Private Ryan"

No way it ever happened, no way any General in the US army thought of Mrs. Bixby, no way he just happened to have the book there, no way he knew the words by heart, etc. Typical Spielberg getting all misty-eyed romantic on the audience.

in the invasion soldiers are killed by bullets travelling through water

impossible
 
Germany didn't need reparations as a reason to be involved in WWI. Hitler would've found another excuse other than revenge for reparations. Thank God that a democracy like the U.S.A. was dominant back then. Who would stifle the tyrannical Soviets if not Nazi Germany or Imperialist Japan?

Pre-WWI Germany was no more or less evil than Britain and France. It was
actually the least imperial world power by comparison. Woodrow Wilson's decision
to enter the war to safeguard democracy was pointless given that Germany was about
as democratic as it could be. Without U.S. intervention Germany might have defeated
France but nothing like the pursuit of the domination of the whole world by a mad dictator
would have transpired. Since the era of Napoleon European nations had their way to resolve
even the most devastating conflicts. For instance Germany defeated France in the
Franco-Prussian war. And yet the reparations Germany demanded of France actually
benefited the economies of both nations.

A lunatic like Hitler would never have been voted into power had it not been
for the extreme humiliation and harshness brought on the people of Germany.
What the U.S. accomplished in WWI was to upset the balance of powers in
Europe and paved the way to the rise of the third reich.
 
in the invasion soldiers are killed by bullets travelling through water

impossible
Most, however, agree that it is one of the most accurate, horrific depictions of the D Day landings in film.

I know of several Word War II veterans who refuse to watch more than the first two minutes, even on televison because it brings everything right back.
 
What the U.S. accomplished in WWI was to upset the balance of powers in Europe and paved the way to the rise of the third reich.
Ask what the Governments of G.B. or Canada would have said about that. Further the Imperial German Government deliberately decided to pursue unrestricted submarine warfare despite repeated U.S. warnings. Germany took a look at U.S. preparedness at the time (which was abysmal) and decided to roll the dice.

Now Wilson's asking for a Declaration of War against the Austro-Hungarian Empire and his self-determination of peoples on the other hand I will entirely agree with you were stupid and have caused problems for much of the almost a century that has now passed.
 
The cost of the Civil War to the U.S. in blood and treasure was immense. I still like to think there could have been solutions short of all out war. For example, could they not have negotiated a deal where the Feds buy land and slaves from the slaveowners and then lease the land to the freed slaves? Or, is that just wishful thinking?
 
The cost of the Civil War to the U.S. in blood and treasure was immense. I still like to think there could have been solutions short of all out war. For example, could they not have negotiated a deal where the Feds buy land and slaves from the slaveowners and then lease the land to the freed slaves? Or, is that just wishful thinking?
It is in the land of Harry Turtledove.

Were such things in someway possibilities - yes. Where such things ever given real consideration by any of the factions - NO.

Further, you have asked this and been answered several times now!
 
The author Eric Foner said the movie is "inadequate" in its portrayal of Lincoln but he also said you can't do Lincoln justice in just 2 hours. Maybe that Ken Burns guy can do an 8 hour documentary on Lincoln like he did with the Civil War and Baseball.

I'm finding that I have more and more difficulty with this as it relates to all movies. 2 hours just isn't enough to tell a proper story. Not to mention that real life does not have an introduction, a middle and an ending. Life is an evolving, constantly changing organism. To try to compact that into a movie is about as good as compacting luncheon meat into a can and calling it fresh meat.

This is why lately I've been more attracted to TV series...they're not limited to any particular time limit. TV shows can spin an entire world to life, characters, places, events, even history. An entire universe if you will. I haven't been able to sit through a full movie in years...I just find the very concept ludicrous.
 
Agreed. The Confederacy was disruptive to the Union in more ways than one. As Aardvark154 pointed out in that Lincoln letter, the war wasn't just about slavery.

I think that Slavery was the heart of the issue. The south tries to white wash it saying it was about "state's rights" and nonsense like that, but I firmly believe that the Civil War was all about slavery, specifically, the expansion of slavery in the newly added states.

Abraham Lincoln in his inaugural address said it best, "One section of our country believes slavery is right and ought to be extended, while the other believes it is wrong and ought not to be extended. This is the only substantial dispute."
 
I think that Slavery was the heart of the issue. The south tries to white wash it saying it was about "state's rights" and nonsense like that, but I firmly believe that the Civil War was all about slavery, specifically, the expansion of slavery in the newly added states.

Abraham Lincoln in his inaugural address said it best, "One section of our country believes slavery is right and ought to be extended, while the other believes it is wrong and ought not to be extended. This is the only substantial dispute."

Just try saying this out loud in any bar in Dallas or Atlanta. Go on. I dare you.
 
I think that Slavery was the heart of the issue. The south tries to white wash it saying it was about "state's rights" and nonsense like that, but I firmly believe that the Civil War was all about slavery, specifically, the expansion of slavery in the newly added states.

Abraham Lincoln in his inaugural address said it best, "One section of our country believes slavery is right and ought to be extended, while the other believes it is wrong and ought not to be extended. This is the only substantial dispute."
The actual issue in 1860 was the highlighted extended.

The South believed Lincoln had ulterior motives, but Lincoln himself had campaigned solely upon prohibiting the expansion of slavery into new western territories