Lincoln

I just wonder whether there was some way to save the union and free the slaves without getting 700,000 men killed. Also, is saving the union worth the death of 700,000 men? What would Canada do if a couple of provinces wanted to secede?

Did the movie mentioned that Arlington Cemetery is on land appropriated from the Lee estate?

Lincoln was a smart President. If there was a way to prevent it before it started, I'm sure he would've thought of it, but then again, it's not just up to him. Sometimes before a settlement can be reached, reason to settle will only be considered after many are killed. Example: Why didn't Japan surrender after the 1st atomic bombing?

I didn't pick up on any discussion of Arlington Cemetery. Who cares anyways but the appropriation might be karma.
 
I've read accounts that characterized George Washington as one who treated
slaves humanely. At least Washington had the decency to pay his slaves whose
teeth he took away for his denture.

Good things might have been said about Thomas Jefferson as a slave owner.
The founding father who wrote all men are created equal couldn't be a bad guy.
 
I've read accounts that characterized George Washington as one who treated
slaves humanely. At least Washington had the decency to pay his slaves whose
teeth he took away for his denture.

Good things might have been said about Thomas Jefferson as a slave owner.
The founding father who wrote all men are created equal couldn't be a bad guy.

I understand there was a grandfathering provision for existing slave owners after the 13th Amendment was enacted.
 
I've read accounts that characterized George Washington as one who treated
slaves humanely. At least Washington had the decency to pay his slaves whose
teeth he took away for his denture.

Good things might have been said about Thomas Jefferson as a slave owner.
The founding father who wrote all men are created equal couldn't be a bad guy.

Except that some 'men' were worth less than others, 3/5th's.
 
I understand there was a grandfathering provision for existing slave owners after the 13th Amendment was enacted.

Not sure at all what you mean by the above

AMENDMENT XIII

SECTION 1.

Neither slavery nor involuntary servitude, except as a punishment for crime whereof the party shall have been duly convicted, shall exist within the United States, or any place subject to their jurisdiction.

SECTION 2.

Congress shall have power to enforce this article by appropriate legislation.



Except that some 'men' were worth less than others, 3/5th's.
One often sees people writing or saying this, but what does it really mean? It does seem to read a lot into the original language of Article 1, Section 2, Paragraph 3 of the United States Constitution that isn't there in print:

Representatives and direct Taxes shall be apportioned among the several States which may be included within this Union, according to their respective Numbers, which shall be determined by adding to the whole Number of free Persons, including those bound to Service for a Term of Years, and excluding Indians not taxed, three fifths of all other Persons.
 
I didn't pick up on any discussion of Arlington Cemetery. Who cares anyways but the appropriation might be karma.
So Edwin Stanton (Secretary of War) thought. The U.S. Supreme Court, however, disagreed in 1882.


Good things might have been said about Thomas Jefferson as a slave owner.
The founding father who wrote all men are created equal couldn't be a bad guy.
From what I've read Jefferson was a rather typical Virginia slave owner, not particularly sadistic, but certainly not particularly benevolent.
 
Good things might have been said about Thomas Jefferson as a slave owner.
The founding father who wrote all men are created equal couldn't be a bad guy.

Thomas Jefferson would be thrown in jail today for rape and being a child molestor, registered on a known sexual predator's list and they would throw away the key.
 
I've reasd about lincoln, but not 5000 books so take my opinion with a grain of salt. As i understand it, his main goal was to preserve the union and only well into the war did he take a firm position against slaver. So if he was a saint it came late in life. Had there not been a civil war and the south had suseeded there would not have been a dominant U.S. in the world in the early 20th century. Perhaps without a dominant U.S. WW1 would not have been a victory for the allies thus no crushing reparations on Germany. No huge wall street crash in 1929. Not as great a depresion = no adolf hittler and no ww2 . Just a thought, but the U.S. has brought as much hardship as success to the world since 1900 so it would be interesting to see how we all turned out without one dominat USA.
 
As i understand it, his main goal was to preserve the union and only well into the war did he take a firm position against slaver.
That is my understanding as well. Here is the question for Canadians. Would you wage a bloody war to keep confederation togethre if say a couple of provinces want to secede?
Without a dominant U.S., you might not have the iPhone. Just kidding. As for alternative history, without the U.S. all of Asia would be speaking Japanese right now and working as slaves for Toyota.
 
Had there not been a civil war and the south had suseeded there would not have been a dominant U.S. in the world in the early 20th century. Perhaps without a dominant U.S. WW1 would not have been a victory for the allies thus no crushing reparations on Germany. No huge wall street crash in 1929. Not as great a depresion = no adolf hittler and no ww2 . Just a thought, but the U.S. has brought as much hardship as success to the world since 1900.
Crushing reparations on France and the U.K instead perhaps, Canada a very different place, the one thing one can say with any certainly is that the world would be different.
 
That is my understanding as well. Here is the question for Canadians. Would you wage a bloody war to keep confederation togethre if say a couple of provinces want to secede?
Without a dominant U.S., you might not have the iPhone. Just kidding. As for alternative history, without the U.S. all of Asia would be speaking Japanese right now and working as slaves for Toyota.

It's been recently tried twice in Canada and twice been defeated by the ballot box. It seems we came to our senses long before bayonets are drawn. In the past, not so much. Ever heard of the NorthWest rebellion?

Canada is a very different place, we tend to work through things, not shoot first and ask questions later. That's why we didn't have the same amount of difficulties and confrontations with the native and the wild west was an american phenomenon. The closest thing we got to the 'Wild West' was the Yukon gold rush of '98 and it was gone in four years.
 
As i understand it, his main goal was to preserve the union and only well into the war did he take a firm position against slaver. So if he was a saint it came late in life.
Much depends upon how you define a firm position against slavery. Certainly most people in 1860 would have said that he took a firm position against the expansion of slavery.

Lincoln's views are famously summarized in his letter to Horace Greeley the editor of the New York Tribune in August 1862

"I would save the Union. I would save it the shortest way under the Constitution. The sooner the national authority can be restored; the nearer the Union will be "the Union as it was." If there be those who would not save the Union, unless they could at the same time save slavery, I do not agree with them. If there be those who would not save the Union unless they could at the same time destroy slavery, I do not agree with them. My paramount object in this struggle is to save the Union, and is not either to save or to destroy slavery. If I could save the Union without freeing any slave I would do it, and if I could save it by freeing all the slaves I would do it; and if I could save it by freeing some and leaving others alone I would also do that. What I do about slavery, and the colored race, I do because I believe it helps to save the Union; and what I forbear, I forbear because I do not believe it would help to save the Union. I shall do less whenever I shall believe what I am doing hurts the cause, and I shall do more whenever I shall believe doing more will help the cause. I shall try to correct errors when shown to be errors; and I shall adopt new views so fast as they shall appear to be true views."
 
Imagine if Lincoln never freed the slaves.

How long would slavery have continued (if the US let the south have its way)

10 years?

20 years?

50 years?

To this very day?
 
Imagine if Lincoln never freed the slaves.

How long would slavery have continued (if the US let the south have its way)

10 years?

20 years?

50 years?

To this very day?

Slavery was abolished in certain northern states. I can think of various reasons that would've prevented it's rise, like attrition, migration, and international protest on importation.
 
I've reasd about lincoln, but not 5000 books so take my opinion with a grain of salt. As i understand it, his main goal was to preserve the union and only well into the war did he take a firm position against slaver. So if he was a saint it came late in life. Had there not been a civil war and the south had suseeded there would not have been a dominant U.S. in the world in the early 20th century. Perhaps without a dominant U.S. WW1 would not have been a victory for the allies thus no crushing reparations on Germany. No huge wall street crash in 1929. Not as great a depresion = no adolf hittler and no ww2 . Just a thought, but the U.S. has brought as much hardship as success to the world since 1900 so it would be interesting to see how we all turned out without one dominat USA.

Germany didn't need reparations as a reason to be involved in WWI. Hitler would've found another excuse other than revenge for reparations. Thank God that a democracy like the U.S.A. was dominant back then. Who would stifle the tyrannical Soviets if not Nazi Germany or Imperialist Japan?
 
Slavery was abolished in certain northern states.
By 1860, also abolished in the U.K. and its colonies and much of Latin and South America as well. So, the shelf life of slavery would have been relatively short. Did 700,000 humans have to die to speed up abolition by maybe 10-20 years? The other problem is that the war devastated the South and the 4 million freed slaves had no homes and no visible means of support.