Lincoln

Prior to 1860, some other countries abolished slavery. The U.K. and its colonies abolished slavery in 1833 and I suspect it was done with little if any bloodshed.

You ignore the fact that there was not a significant section of the population in the UK that not only opposed the abolition of slavery, but threatened to separate/secede from the country if there was an attempt to do so at a national level (as had occurred in the US).

As for the abolition in the colonies, the slave trade itself was abolished in the UK and its colonies in 1807 under the Slave Trade Act, followed by the abolition of slavery itself in 1833 under the Slavery Abolition Act, prompted by a rebellion in Jamaica led by slave Sam Sharpe in 1831.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Samuel_Sharpe

It's also worth noting that slavery itself was officially abolished in 1833, but the actual freeing of slaves took another 5 years under a forced apprenticeship system.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abolition_of_slavery#Slavery_Abolition_Act_1833
 
So, life was pretty hard in the north as well which should answer Red's "inane" post.

Not really, as 'life was pretty hard in the North as well' wasn't your initial claim. Love to watch your tap dance your way around your posts. Life as a slave was much harder starting from their room&board on the west coast of Africa and their travel accommodations onboard the luxurious slave ships. i doubt the residence of NY spent much, if any, time in shackles. I suggested the videos as it's clear you don't read well or the right stuff.
 
their travel accommodations onboard the luxurious slave ships.
Are you suggesting that Irish immigrants came to America in luxury liners? Maybe conditions were slightly better than slave ships but not much better and life was hard in the north as well (which is what I said in an earlier post).
 
there was not a significant section of the population in the UK that not only opposed the abolition of slavery, but threatened to separate/secede from the country if there was an attempt to do so at a national level (as had occurred in the US).
Yes, but was there a bloody war that ensued?
 
I World War 1, 60,000 Canadians were killed. Not wounded, killed.
Would you by chance know the population of Canada in 1914?

Here is another statistic from the Civil War. The population of the South in 1860 (excluding slaves) was approximately 5 million. Over 300,000 were killed in the Civil War and virtually the entire economy was destroyed.
 
Here is another question. Were all Southern slaveowners bastards or was there such a thing as a "benevolent" slaveowner?
 
Are you suggesting that Irish immigrants came to America in luxury liners? Maybe conditions were slightly better than slave ships but not much better and life was hard in the north as well (which is what I said in an earlier post).

Not at all. Slightly better? The irish were also expecting a better life in the new world, getting away from starvation and oppression, unlike the slaves who knew what hey were in for and it wasn't a better life.

No, what you actually said was;

Conditions in the northern factories and slums were probably no better or only slightly better than slavery.

Keep up the tap dance, I hear it's good cardio.
 
Last edited:
I don't envy President Lincoln and he appears to be a very decent human being. Very difficult position to be in. More Americans died in the Civil War than in all other wars combined. Was war the only solution? Was there no other way, perhaps over a longer timeframe?

Lincoln was truly a great man and probably the greatest President that ever lived. His courage, intellect and spiritual side were inspiring. He also had a personality. Daniel Day-Lewis was terrific. Tommy Lee Jones and Hal Holbrook were superb to name a few of the other great actors.

The audience was mostly older.

Generals Grant and Lee were cast well.
 
Here is another question. Were all Southern slaveowners bastards or was there such a thing as a "benevolent" slaveowner?

To quote Roy Batty, "Quite an experience to live in fear, isn't it? That's what it is to be a slave"
 
Was war the only solution? Was there no other way, perhaps over a longer timeframe?
Of course there were others ways. The problem is that no one wanted to accept those other ways - such as governmental compensation for emancipated slaves.


Here is another question. Were all Southern slaveowners bastards or was there such a thing as a "benevolent" slaveowner?
That rather depends upon through what lens one is looking. From the viewpoint of someone held in bondage slavery was not "benevolent" period! Through other lenses one can say that chattel slavery was harsher in the Mississippi Delta than in other parts of the U.S. (hence the expression being sold down the river), it generally was harsher on very large plantations in the cotton belt than it was among those who owned only a few slaves in other parts of the U.S.
 
To quote Roy Batty, "Quite an experience to live in fear, isn't it? That's what it is to be a slave"
Absolutely true. I would think that the sweatshop workers in the north and the coal miners in Pennsylvania also lived in some degree of fear. Irish Catholic tenant farmers on land stolen by the Orangemen also lived in fear and 2 million were left to starve to death.
 
Lincoln was truly a great man and probably the greatest President that ever lived.
I just wonder whether there was some way to save the union and free the slaves without getting 700,000 men killed. Also, is saving the union worth the death of 700,000 men? What would Canada do if a couple of provinces wanted to secede?

Generals Grant and Lee were cast well.
Did the movie mentioned that Arlington Cemetery is on land appropriated from the Lee estate?
 
Of course there were others ways. The problem is that no one wanted to accept those other ways - such as governmental compensation for emancipated slaves.
Apparently, the U.K. government compensated slaveowners for emancipated slaves. Is it really true that "no one" wanted to accept other options?
 
I just wonder whether there was some way to save the union and free the slaves without getting 700,000 men killed. Also, is saving the union worth the death of 700,000 men? What would Canada do if a couple of provinces wanted to secede?

I hope the U.S. gets to find this out again real soon.
 
Apparently, the U.K. government compensated slaveowners for emancipated slaves. Is it really true that "no one" wanted to accept other options?
The question is of course not did one or two or even a thousand or two agree, rather was it widely accepted by the various political/regonal factions the answer to that is no.

You also have to remember that in some ways there were two Union Armies as far as enlistments and Commissions were concerned: the 1860-1863 Union Army which almost entirely was about the need to save the Union. And the 1864-1865 Union Army which while not leaving behind the struggle to save the Union was equally if not more about freeing the slaves.