too soon........With the release of the movie "Lincoln", would anyone be interested in having a calm, rational, polite, unemotional and unbiased discussion of the man, his times and his legacy?
too soon........With the release of the movie "Lincoln", would anyone be interested in having a calm, rational, polite, unemotional and unbiased discussion of the man, his times and his legacy?
As it was they cut it down to cover but the final four months of Lincoln's life.The author Eric Foner said the movie is "inadequate" in its portrayal of Lincoln but he also said you can't do Lincoln justice in just 2 hours. Maybe that Ken Burns guy can do an 8 hour documentary on Lincoln like he did with the Civil War and Baseball.
Conditions in the northern factories and slums were probably no better or only slightly better than slavery.But it never once mentions white slavery!)
The only thing I worry about is Spielberg pulling a Spielberg and making the characters out to be much more than they ever were.
For example, the "Mrs Bixby Letter" scene from "Saving Private Ryan"
No way it ever happened, no way any General in the US army thought of Mrs. Bixby, no way he just happened to have the book there, no way he knew the words by heart, etc. Typical Spielberg getting all misty-eyed romantic on the audience.
Conditions in the northern factories and slums were probably no better or only slightly better than slavery.
I just saw the movie, not sure what I was expecting but I didn't really enjoy it that much.
Spoiler Alert !!
Lincoln is assassinated at the end of the movie.
So, how was life in the sweatshops of New York and the coal mines of west Virginia? What were the living conditions of the Lower East Side like in the 1860's?why do you say such inane things?
So, how was life in the sweatshops of New York and the coal mines of west Virginia? What were the living conditions of the Lower East Side like in the 1860's?
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/art...oln-tried-deport-slaves-British-colonies.htmlDid President Lincoln have a transitional plan for the freed slaves?
I didn't see the movie but I am somewhat familiar with the subject. It is about the malicious discrimination against Irish Catholics in NYC circa 1845 to 1865. It is also about the Irish Catholics resistance to being drafted against their will to fight and die in "Lincoln's War".Watch Gangs of NY,
Frankly, more about resentment of Black competition in the labour market. Further, that the Democratic Tammany Hall political machine which attempted to get Irish immigrants to become U.S. Citizens so that they could vote in local elections, was quite "Copperhead" in its sympathies.*It is also about the Irish Catholics resistance to being drafted against their will to fight and die in "Lincoln's War".
I didn't see the movie but I am somewhat familiar with the subject. It is about the malicious discrimination against Irish Catholics in NYC circa 1845 to 1865. It is also about the Irish Catholics resistance to being drafted against their will to fight and die in "Lincoln's War".
(As an aside Daniel Day Lewis starred in both Gangs of New York and Lincoln.)
how dare he make a sentimental movie.
So, life was pretty hard in the north as well which should answer Red's "inane" post.The average life expectancy of a slave was 30 years while the average age for someone in NY was 38 in 1850.
I don't envy President Lincoln and he appears to be a very decent human being. Very difficult position to be in. More Americans died in the Civil War than in all other wars combined. Was war the only solution? Was there no other way, perhaps over a longer timeframe?Saw it last night. I had tears in the wells of my eyes at the very end. Great movie but if you're not keen on history and politics, it might be a little long.
I don't envy President Lincoln and he appears to be a very decent human being. Very difficult position to be in. More Americans died in the Civil War than in all other wars combined. Was war the only solution? Was there no other way, perhaps over a longer timeframe?