Light rapid transit vs subway

LRT vs subway

  • more LRT

    Votes: 6 7.0%
  • more Subway

    Votes: 60 69.8%
  • combination

    Votes: 20 23.3%
  • other

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    86
Here is my opinion: Prioritize "coverage" (# of kilometers) over excessive capacity. Subway will give you a lot of capacity but lower coverage per dollar. Subway would also take a LONG time to build. Subways are VERY expensive to build and operate. Main advantage of subway is that it provides you with a lot of capacity. Enough to serve not only today's needs but also projected capacity 35 years from now.

On the other hand, LRT can be built much faster and much cheaper and can be made operational in 1/4th the amount of time and cost.

See, we are at the cusp of technology-breakthroughs in transportation. In < decade, autonomous/self-driving cars will start getting mass produced. So, the capacity that Subway is supposed to provide is unlikely to get fully utilized. We will have all kinds of breakthroughs by then. Self-driving/cheap taxis or self-driving buses or something.

Building LRT today will provide enough capacity to serve today's needs and needs of next decade or so. And after a decade or so, advances in self-driving and other technologies may significantly reduce the # of passengers that will need to take Subway or LRT.

So, do self driving cars take up less space on the highways? If not, and as the population increases, your theory would call for more highways? The roadways are not working very well at the moment. I plan 90% of my travel to avoid the rush hours. That includes leaving very early for the commute from Durham to Toronto, or working from home until mid morning then driving in. I also use the 407 during rush hour as it almost always moves above the speed limit. I am not a fan of public transportation, but cars are not the answer to our future needs. Even if the invisible man is driving them.
 
Yep, a good portion of the Spadina streetcar track only lasted 15 years.
On the other hand railway tracks seem to last a lot longer, where cheap-ass pols don't think they gotta use salt to make roads safe for cars without having to plow them clean. You might also check out what's corroding the rebar in the Gardiner.

TANSTAAFL folks. That less expensive house out in the burbs, that you could only get to by constantly buying new cars (salt again) and can't afford to pay taxes on is costing everybody big time.
 
Subways should be kept in the downtown core where the population density supports the need. The downtown relief line is needed and should be subway. In more sparse densities LRT is the way to go. The Sheppard line is overkill. I wish our planners dug a tunnel for an express train so we can have 2 trains going at the same time. Guess no one had the vision while we had cheap irish and chinese labour.
 
Subways should be kept in the downtown core where the population density supports the need. The downtown relief line is needed and should be subway. In more sparse densities LRT is the way to go. The Sheppard line is overkill. I wish our planners dug a tunnel for an express train so we can have 2 trains going at the same time. Guess no one had the vision while we had cheap irish and chinese labour.
I'm sure they did have the vision. It comes free and even guys like our Mayor can have visions.

What they didn't have was the money, or a guy like R.C. Harris pushing them to damn well come up with it, because he wasn't gonna build something half-assed (like a buried trolley line). That's why today's subway runs on a bridge over the Don that he built a half-century before.
 
Subways should be kept in the downtown core where the population density supports the need. The downtown relief line is needed and should be subway. In more sparse densities LRT is the way to go. The Sheppard line is overkill. I wish our planners dug a tunnel for an express train so we can have 2 trains going at the same time. Guess no one had the vision while we had cheap irish and chinese labour.

That's the logical argument, and correct.
Sadly Ford and his followers are on some ideological bent based on this imaginary 'war on the car' and don't want anything they perceive as slowing down their god given right to drive.

If you want the land and space of the 'burbs, then you should accept the fact that subways don't make sense there.
 
What is so hard to understand about monorails. They do NOT run on same plane as subways. They run elevated..above ground..on pillars. Easy peasy and much cheaper to build. They can run strategically thru industrial spaces, green belts, over roadways, adjacent to roadways, generally perpendicular to subway, but they intersect near the subway stations.

you dismount into a cheap, glassed in monorail station, which allows you to transverse over, and down an escalator into a subway station.

it so easy.

so for instance you could have a loop on say Islington and Kipling. A huge circle from lakeshore up to Steeles. Two tracks, each monorail running opposite directions. Then you do Royal York, and design strategic routes, up and Down, hitting the Bloor west subway.
 
So given that every World's Fair has a monorail and there are some monorails actually in daily service in various parts of the world, what do you think accounts for the continuing unpopularity of this superior form of transit?

I'm no engineer, but I'd bet that it's far cheaper and safer to build a roadbed for heavy trains carrying masses of people at high speed if you're doing it on subsoil in a tunnel. Building a bridge up in the air to carry all that weight and moving mass without a horde of supports is no small challenge, never mind what the people below might say. Has anyone actually built one that operates at subway-standard loads and speeds? How would we know the monorail would last longer than the Gardiner?
 
Th

It would be great to have a third track for express running from King or from St. Andrew up to the bloor line with no stop, but the original planners did not have the foresight to build a wide enough tunnel unfortunately.

It's not that the original planners didn't have the foresight.

The city just didn't want to spend the money.
 
What is so hard to understand about monorails. They do NOT run on same plane as subways. They run elevated..above ground..on pillars. Easy peasy and much cheaper to build. They can run strategically thru industrial spaces, green belts, over roadways, adjacent to roadways, generally perpendicular to subway, but they intersect near the subway stations.

you dismount into a cheap, glassed in monorail station, which allows you to transverse over, and down an escalator into a subway station.

it so easy.

so for instance you could have a loop on say Islington and Kipling. A huge circle from lakeshore up to Steeles. Two tracks, each monorail running opposite directions. Then you do Royal York, and design strategic routes, up and Down, hitting the Bloor west subway.

Monorails are a joke.

FYI, Toronto started to build a monorail in the 60's on Lakeshore Blvd down by the Ex. Even started to build the foundations for the piers. Finally somebody put a stop to it. The foundations are still buried there under the road.
 
I would prefer more subways but I hope we get LRT, just so that Rob Ford can't get what he wants and to piss him off. If that makes any sense.
 
Raising property taxes somewhat?

I read somewhere Toronto's taxes are some of the lowest in Ontario. I dunno though, just an idea

The Mil rate is lower, however, since the property values are higher, Torontonians pay as much as anyone else in dollars.

You cannot compare a $400,000.00 house in Toronto (a very small house to a condo) to a $400,000.00 house in Smithville, or Niagara Falls, or Hamilton (say)
 
The Mil rate is lower, however, since the property values are higher, Torontonians pay as much as anyone else in dollars.

You cannot compare a $400,000.00 house in Toronto (a very small house to a condo) to a $400,000.00 house in Smithville, or Niagara Falls, or Hamilton (say)
Okay, fair enough.

So how would you pay for a new subway then?? You cant raise fares because then students and average working people (who represent most subway users) cant afford to ride TTC
 
Okay, fair enough.

So how would you pay for a new subway then?? You cant raise fares because then students and average working people (who represent most subway users) cant afford to ride TTC

As far as I can see, Toronto does not have the taxing power or capacity to raise further revenue to build a new subway or subways at all, and thus only way for the city to build more subways is to receive direct funding or subsidies from the provincial or federal governments. Since neither the current Liberal minority government in Ontario nor the Conservative majority government in Parliament are likely to provide such funding, building new subways is an idea that is simply impossible/unfeasible.

However, the Rapid Transit LRT does have funding lined up from the province, so if Toronto's City Council goes ahead with this, then at least there is something that can be built and made available (unless if the Ontario government -- whether the current Liberal government or, say, a Conservative or NDP government decides to pull funding midway).

My fear (and perhaps likely outcome) is that the current intransigence from Ford vis-a-vis LRT will cause the province to reconsider funding for Rapid Transit (especially given Ontario's fiscal situation as it is), and thus nothing ends up being built.
 
I would be pretty sure the folks standing at bus stops in the suburbs would be happy if the number of buses was increased. more frequent pickup would satisfy most needs. rather than wait for subways which will most likely NEVER come. make a couple of east-west routed bus express, add an express route instead of that bypass subway line and by the summer, the transit woes are solved. or try to find popular support for spending billions we don't have.
 
Monorails carry masses of people up and down the Las Vegas Strip.

Efficient, Green, quiet, dependable...running off electricity..not fossil fuel.

Las Vegas had TONS of cash....any option they wanted.....they chose monorails!
 
Monorails carry masses of people up and down the Las Vegas Strip.

Efficient, Green, quiet, dependable...running off electricity..not fossil fuel.

Las Vegas had TONS of cash....any option they wanted.....they chose monorails!
Masses? Are you sure? They look a tad smaller than our subway trains, and up and down the Strip sounds much like the typical world's fair operation. Who's gonna be first with with actual maximum passenger load numbers?

What subways cannot easily do is provide for short trips and close together stops. Surface or above surface transit like LRTs and monorails (or buses and streetcars, if we get really granular) do that better. But as GO, and our jammed thruways show us, we're still facing a longstanding backlog of demand for whole train-loads of capacity coming into the City or leaving it. As an inner city resident I'd be quite happy to shop around and go to the theatre by monorail, but I can't see them as 'solving' the DVP or the 401 Problem.