Light rapid transit vs subway

LRT vs subway

  • more LRT

    Votes: 6 7.0%
  • more Subway

    Votes: 60 69.8%
  • combination

    Votes: 20 23.3%
  • other

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    86

Yoga Face

New member
Jun 30, 2009
6,307
19
0
light raid transit (LRT) are streetcars on tracks that cars cannot go on


this makes the streetcars go faster and maintain schedule


while this is good for passengers and will encourage more city drivers to leave their cars home it eliminates traffic lanes

how will this eliminate congestion ? as cars will still come from outside of toronto and now have less traffic lanes


this is the big debate in council and Ford wants more subways not LRT


while subways are more expensive in the long run they are not as they last longer ( LRT need to be replaced evey 40 years) and they will be demanded in the future as toronto gets more populated
 
Subways.

But with the catch that we need to find a way to pay for them.
 
I would further add that the process of creating more subway stations (which can take years to build) will of course disrupt traffic. That being said, I believe that more subways will be needed in the future, but that there is also a place for LRT as well where it makes sense.

I would like to add that part of the goal of expanding public transit (be they LRT, subways, even expanded bus lanes) ultimately is to reduce the number of people using cars to travel within the city, and thus reduce congestion.
 
They should be building subways costantly in city like ours should be no need to take cars to work anywhere
 
This is silly: Subways and LRT are not directly comparable any more than bikes and SUVs are. Where's your poll asking why everyone doesn't commute by bike and have huge bucks left over to buy college tuitions for their kids? Houses closer to where they work? Or maybe to build subways with? A subway you can't afford (that'd be a Ford Dream Subway*) is no subway at all.

As for the nonsense about LRTs causing gridlock by 'taking away' a traffic lane, open your eyes. What causes gridlock, and robs us of a place to put bike lanes, or even 'takes away' traffic lanes is cheap drivers parking their cars on our roads. let them buy their parking at market rates and keep the traffic moving on roads that non-car owners and drivers paid for to keep the city moving. Meantime, open your eyes, where we now have LRTs cars move faster than before, because they no longer have to stop whenever streetcars open their doors

*Ford Dream Subway: An Eglinton LRT line buried at huge extra cost so he wouldn't have to look at it. Ford has never had anything useful to offer on the subject of actual subways, which are actual trains running underground at high speed, carrying high volumes of passengers between distantly spaced stations.
 
that's the point ... reduce cars in the city and make local transit more reliable, accessible and quicker for transportation. Happens every in Europe cities. Thought you'd realize that by now when everyone around the world is talking about sustainability.
 
I would suggest MONORAIL is the way to go.

Much much cheaper. Greener.

the track is raised on concrete pillars like the Airport.

you run these strategically, into current subway terminals.

cheap, easy and could be up in no time!

hide the concrete pillars with greenery in the green belts.

so easy.....yet ignored!
 
Unfortunately, there is no shortage of coruption and pocket lining with tax payers money in the infrastructure industry.

Take the housing Industry for example.

It took them 15 years to figure this out.

http://www.thestar.com/news/crime/2013/01/31/alleged_pricefixing_at_gta_construction_companies.html

It's somewhat late in the game compared to other major cities who did it when money was not as scarce as it is today.

Subways are better for moving people faster without hindering traffic.

It's a bigger investment and more intensive with tunnel digging but a long lasting infrastructure.

If we want efficiency in building subways, might be best to contract the Spaniards.

LRT is more suited to areas that don't have the ridership numbers to support a subway plus cost effectiveness.

If we want efficiency in running transit we could contract a number of those outside Canada including the very efficient Asians.

If it's all done by Canadians, don't expect to see much in your lifetime plus non stop corruption.
 
I would suggest MONORAIL is the way to go.

Much much cheaper. Greener.

the track is raised on concrete pillars like the Airport.

you run these strategically, into current subway terminals.

cheap, easy and could be up in no time!

hide the concrete pillars with greenery in the green belts.

so easy.....yet ignored!
How the heck are you gonna run a monorail into a subway?? :confused:
 
I would further add that the process of creating more subway stations (which can take years to build) will of course disrupt traffic. That being said, I believe that more subways will be needed in the future, but that there is also a place for LRT as well where it makes sense.

I would like to add that part of the goal of expanding public transit (be they LRT, subways, even expanded bus lanes) ultimately is to reduce the number of people using cars to travel within the city, and thus reduce congestion.

the subway stations are the really expensive part. i would dig the tunnels with minimal stations as a start. then add more stations later.
 
You cross a monorail over a subway...usually the subway stations are underground.


You bring a monorail to ITS OWN station at the subway. Passengers just take escalator down to subway platform.

This is not difficult! No need to build complicated subway platforms. Just glassed in structures that feed the subway platform.

So for instance you could have a north south monorail on Islington. Feed it into the subway station.

Do that all along the Bloor line. Eliminates a lot of buses too!

So, throw a few pilings in the ground....throw some track on top. Voila. Done!!!
 
You cross a monorail over a subway...usually the subway stations are underground.


You bring a monorail to ITS OWN station at the subway. Passengers just take escalator down to subway platform.

This is not difficult! No need to build complicated subway platforms. Just glassed in structures that feed the subway platform.

So for instance you could have a north south monorail on Islington. Feed it into the subway station.

Do that all along the Bloor line. Eliminates a lot of buses too!

So, throw a few pilings in the ground....throw some track on top. Voila. Done!!!
Yes, but the subways run underneath houses and office buildings.

Unless you mean run the monorail on top of a subway and still underground. But is there enough space for that??
 
Unfortunately, there is no shortage of coruption and pocket lining with tax payers money in the infrastructure industry.

Take the housing Industry for example.

It took them 15 years to figure this out.

http://www.thestar.com/news/crime/2013/01/31/alleged_pricefixing_at_gta_construction_companies.html

It's somewhat late in the game compared to other major cities who did it when money was not as scarce as it is today.

Subways are better for moving people faster without hindering traffic.

It's a bigger investment and more intensive with tunnel digging but a long lasting infrastructure.

If we want efficiency in building subways, might be best to contract the Spaniards.

LRT is more suited to areas that don't have the ridership numbers to support a subway plus cost effectiveness.

If we want efficiency in running transit we could contract a number of those outside Canada including the very efficient Asians.

If it's all done by Canadians, don't expect to see much in your lifetime plus non stop corruption.

You're kidding right.

The residential construction industry and the infrastructure industry are not the same thing. Not even by a million miles.

You think Dufferin Construction can call up AECON, or Miller, or Brennan or Grascan, or Dagmar, or Ellis Don, or Kenaidian, or any number of other infrastructure contractors and tell them to collude? Never in a million years could it happen.

And I for one don't want my tax dollars going to Asians or Spaniards. We are more than capable of building our own infrastructure right here in Canada. (You wanna talk about corruption, the Europeans wrote the book and the Asians mastered it.)
 
Subways.

But with the catch that we need to find a way to pay for them.

it seems to me they pay for themselves


partialy with fares because there are more riders and by increased productivity in the economy because everything moves faster and increased land value which increases taxes


so borrow the money
 
I've often wondered why they don't build an express line down the DVP. Up on top straight downtown, then turn underground straigt to queen. Would eliminate at of traffic and revieve the yonge line. Most of it would be cheap. It could even be covered with a shell for weather at a very cheap price. Downtown in 15 minutes straight to the financial district.
 
I've often wondered why they don't build an express line down the DVP. Up on top straight downtown, then turn underground straigt to queen. Would eliminate at of traffic and revieve the yonge line. Most of it would be cheap. It could even be covered with a shell for weather at a very cheap price. Downtown in 15 minutes straight to the financial district.

you dont think an express lane would not plug up ?????????? isnt that where most are going ? you would need at least two lanes i would think

sounds very expensive to build an elevated lane all that way how do you get cheap out of that idea?