Light rapid transit vs subway

LRT vs subway

  • more LRT

    Votes: 6 7.0%
  • more Subway

    Votes: 60 69.8%
  • combination

    Votes: 20 23.3%
  • other

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    86
Whats hilarious aboot all this is Toronto's traffic problems are peanuts compared to Latin America and some Asian cities. I heard in Bangladesh you're lucky if you move 10 feet in one hour during rush hour. Imagine that in Toronto, they would have Rob Ford's head on a platter
 
Not raised. Ground level for most of the run. Laying track and a concrete covering would be cheap. Plenty of space not on the highway but beside it. Only when you get to the core do you put it underground. For now 2 stops at yonge and university. Run it say 7am to 11 pm. Would move a lot of people including the gta. Add enough parking at the station. Good for events too.
 

Love it!! Excellent idea :thumb:


need more such creativity


how about local transport off of roads during rush hour


this means they would run before morning rush


more four and three day workweeks
 
I've often wondered why they don't build an express line down the DVP. Up on top straight downtown, then turn underground straigt to queen. Would eliminate at of traffic and revieve the yonge line. Most of it would be cheap. It could even be covered with a shell for weather at a very cheap price. Downtown in 15 minutes straight to the financial district.
Almost like the Allen Expressway and the Spadina subway line running through Spadina Valley?
 
Deciphering Butler's poor writing, I think he is actually proposing running a subway line alongside the DVP, not an express way for cars, as he mentioned a "station".

Basically he's suggesting we build the downtown relief line. It does make more sense than putting a subway into scarborough. LRT's out into the 'burbs and more subways into downtown--that would actually be economically viable.

I read one critique that pointed out that the population of Scarborough would have to *double* to make a subway there economic. On the other hand the lines into the downtown core are just rammed and having a 3rd way to get from the core to the bloor line would take a lot of the load off yonge and university.
 
How the heck are you gonna run a monorail into a subway?? :confused:

I am guessing he means something similar to Kennedy subway station that runs the Scarborough RT into the station upstairs then you can go downstairs to the subway tracks. Run an monorail to where subway stations are then connect them with stairs/ elevator to tracks below.

To answer the original question....definitely SUBWAY. Right now there is debate about running rapid transit street car style right down the middle of the street I live on and nobody here wants it. Everyone wants it underground and out of the way. But when people that don't live in my neighborhood (on opposite side of the city that already have a subway) cry and want RT because they don't have to deal with the inconvience it brings then it looks like we will have to suffer with an street car in the middle of our road. And before people begin to get upset that they are "crying about cost" my suggestion is to stop building subways into Vaughin and Markham (no offence to people that live there but hey you chose to live there) and use the money in the city where it was taxed out of and give the people that are paying for it what they want.
 
( LRT need to be replaced evey 40 years)


Not a chance in Canada. Bathurst streetcar tracks and foundation get ripped up every 5-10 years. They are doing the same with the dedicated Spadina tracks and bed now too. Once you get salty water creeping under the tracks and into the concrete, it causes heaving and cracking.
 
it seems to me they pay for themselves


partialy with fares because there are more riders and by increased productivity in the economy because everything moves faster and increased land value which increases taxes


so borrow the money
So I'm sure you'll have no trouble quoting the TTC profits for the years since they opened the subway. Even Rob Ford would say you are right about 'paying for themselves' in economic productivity, but no one has yet figured out how to tax that money after fact, or even more importantly before when we need it to build the things. If he had, Rob would be Our Hero, and our financially sound subways would be a-diggin' now, all over the place. But he couldn't find anyone to lend him a half-dozen billion dollars for Sheppard, or for his Underground Trollies on Eg. And of course he'd have to tax us to pay it back wouldn't he?

Not to put you on the spot, but how would you turn all that downstream benefit for tomorrow's Toronto into tunnel-building money today?
 
Not a chance in Canada. Bathurst streetcar tracks and foundation get ripped up every 5-10 years. They are doing the same with the dedicated Spadina tracks and bed now too. Once you get salty water creeping under the tracks and into the concrete, it causes heaving and cracking.

Yep, a good portion of the Spadina streetcar track only lasted 15 years.
 
So I'm sure you'll have no trouble quoting the TTC profits for the years since they opened the subway. Even Rob Ford would say you are right about 'paying for themselves' in economic productivity, but no one has yet figured out how to tax that money after fact, or even more importantly before when we need it to build the things. If he had, Rob would be Our Hero, and our financially sound subways would be a-diggin' now, all over the place. But he couldn't find anyone to lend him a half-dozen billion dollars for Sheppard, or for his Underground Trollies on Eg. And of course he'd have to tax us to pay it back wouldn't he?

Not to put you on the spot, but how would you turn all that downstream benefit for tomorrow's Toronto into tunnel-building money today?

that is what prudent borrowing is for


i oppose debt unless it can be proven a sound financial play

in the case of public transit it can


better yet the government prints the money in the form of credit (as this is what banks do anyways) then take the monies back out of society through increased taxes from the additional revenue created by public transit that way they pay no interest and prevent inflation from the printed monies



just a idea from someone who does not know WTF he is talking about
 
Whats hilarious aboot all this is Toronto's traffic problems are peanuts compared to Latin America and some Asian cities. I heard in Bangladesh you're lucky if you move 10 feet in one hour during rush hour. Imagine that in Toronto, they would have Rob Ford's head on a platter

So you consider the worst cities in Latin America and Asia to be bench marks to compare our transit system with?

Listen, they (whoever you are referring to there, evil left wingers conspiring against Ford I suppose) would have anyone's head on a platter if he got elected saying "Subways, subways, subways," and two years later still didn't have a clue how to finance it.
 
So you consider the worst cities in Latin America and Asia to be bench marks to compare our transit system with?
No, I dont. It was just an observation in general, stop being so defensive

Listen, they (whoever you are referring to there, evil left wingers conspiring against Ford I suppose) would have anyone's head on a platter if he got elected saying "Subways, subways, subways," and two years later still didn't have a clue how to finance it
I fully support improving our transit system
 
Deciphering Butler's poor writing, I think he is actually proposing running a subway line alongside the DVP, not an express way for cars, as he mentioned a "station".

Basically he's suggesting we build the downtown relief line. It does make more sense than putting a subway into scarborough. LRT's out into the 'burbs and more subways into downtown--that would actually be economically viable.

I read one critique that pointed out that the population of Scarborough would have to *double* to make a subway there economic. On the other hand the lines into the downtown core are just rammed and having a 3rd way to get from the core to the bloor line would take a lot of the load off yonge and university.

I thought when I used the wording Express LINE and the topic was subways people would understand. My bad. That being said the purpose is solely to move people directly to the core. Heck even place three sets of tracks on the ground so you can run two sets of trains one way depending on time of day. This would also help in case of a breakdown.
I do like this though. It could probably be built quickly. A station already exists at yonge under the present station as well. Anyone have an idea what it costs per km to lay track? And for a simple concrete shell over top?
The idea is a direct run from Sheppard line(say leslie station) straight down the Don Valley along side the highway as far a possible(bloor?) Then underground to Queen. Turn to west straight to University. This places most of the core within about 10 min walking distance and direct access to the PATH.
 
They should be building subways costantly in city like ours should be no need to take cars to work anywhere

Not a fan of Ford but he's right on this. The above statement is bang on. I'd say a specific transit tax on property owners for any year that subway construction is happening, tax parking lots downtown and hotel rooms, road tolls on the Gardener and DVP and make the TTC free.
 
I thought when I used the wording Express LINE and the topic was subways people would understand. My bad. That being said the purpose is solely to move people directly to the core. Heck even place three sets of tracks on the ground so you can run two sets of trains one way depending on time of day. This would also help in case of a breakdown.
I do like this though. It could probably be built quickly. A station already exists at yonge under the present station as well. Anyone have an idea what it costs per km to lay track? And for a simple concrete shell over top?
The idea is a direct run from Sheppard line(say leslie station) straight down the Don Valley along side the highway as far a possible(bloor?) Then underground to Queen. Turn to west straight to University. This places most of the core within about 10 min walking distance and direct access to the PATH.

The usual proposal is to run it south from danforth along the river and then cut west along queen to connect up with the yonge line at Queen Station, giving people on the danforth a quicker route downtown and relieving the congestion at union station.

It would be great to have a third track for express running from King or from St. Andrew up to the bloor line with no stop, but the original planners did not have the foresight to build a wide enough tunnel unfortunately.