King street pilot project

Good points — especially your first one — however they aren't the ones raised by folks that have moved me to respond.

Mostly they complain their car commutes are inconveniently long, and they blame non-car commuters on bikes, buses and streetcars for their slow progress, when that's the obvious and inevitable result of their choice to travel by road-space wasting car at the same time as most other commuters. It's a personal choice, not a necessity, and like every choice it comes with downsides (like time) that the chooser must accept and factor in.

Fair enough!
 
Seeing as that was written by Doug Ford, one might wonder if there may be a tad of bias in that article.

I don't normally do an attack the messenger approach, but I think it may be appropriate here.
 
Seeing as that was written by Doug Ford, one might wonder if there may be a tad of bias in that article.

I don't normally do an attack the messenger approach, but I think it may be appropriate here
No, it would not be appropriate. Attacking the messenger is just plain stupidity.

Is an article from the Red Star more to your liking?!

https://www.thestar.com/opinion/con...ing-st-pilot-project-is-killing-business.html


Toronto’s King St. pilot project is killing business

Let’s be clear. The merchants of King St – and me among them – are pro transit. Period. I live and work in the area, and have for more than 30 years.

Pro-transit opinion notwithstanding, the King St. pilot project is a disaster that is killing hundreds of businesses, adversely affecting King St., the Entertainment District and much of the downtown core. It can be fixed, quickly and quite easily, but the political will must collide with common sense.

Full credit to Toronto Mayor John Tory, who visited my restaurant and the adjoining establishments to hear from merchants on the impact of the study. We told him what I am saying here: it’s a disaster but can be fixed.

Toronto City Councillor Joe Cressy published an opinion piece in the Toronto Star this week. “King St. was broken,” he said, “it wasn’t working for anybody.”

“The pilot is working, as evidenced by early data showing improved streetcar reliability and travel times … as the local city councillor, I will not support going back to the past.”

King St. was not broken. It was a vibrant and important part of the residential and cultural fabric of our community. Go visit King St. today and it is a wasteland. No vibrancy, no pedestrians, no culture … and soon to be inhabited by “Closed” and “For Sale” signs.

“Commuters from east to west use King St. to get to and from work in the Financial District, or at the rapidly increasing number of tech startups in the Entertainment District — an area that also attracts thousands to its dynamic shops, theatres and restaurants,” Cressy wrote. Yet it is exactly these shops, theatres and restaurants that are being driven out of business by this short-sighted and poorly executed pilot project that turns King St. into an urban freeway for streetcars.

The improved streetcar reliability and travel times Cressy talks about are arguable. Data differs but even city reports show the most significant improvement is a 2.6-minute (approx. 140 seconds) improvement in average travel time through the pilot area. Barely long enough for Councillor Cressy to develop his flawed thesis.


Lastly, I was under the impression that the purpose of a pilot project is to determine if the plan was effective. Barely a month in, Cressy has already decided he is in favour. I guess there is no point in letting the facts get in the way of a good story.

Our proposal is quick, inexpensive and simple. We propose keeping the King St. traffic restrictions, but limiting them to rush hours. Cars could therefore return to King St. after 7 p.m. on weekdays, on weekends, and statutory holidays. Concerns expressed by city staffers that this would confuse drivers are spurious. It could be accomplished simply with lit street lights not unlike what currently exists on Jarvis, which allows traffic to flow into the core in the morning and out of the core in the afternoon rush hour.

The City of Toronto has chosen the worst time, in the worst way in the worst season to implement the pilot project. Their goal is clearly to move people through King St., not to King St. For years King St. was a destination, now it is a thoroughfare.

The goal of the King St. Pilot project was said to be to balance three important principles: to move people more effectively on transit, to support business and economic prosperity and to improve public space. In its current form, the competing principles seem to be decidedly tilted away from the economic well-being of merchants and biases efficiency over convenience. The casual stickiness of pedestrians walking and stopping at stores, restaurants and other merchants is lost.

Additionally, the TTC has eliminated a number of stops along King St., forcing passengers to walk further to enter and disembark streetcars, further reducing pedestrian traffic and affecting areas businesses. The TTC appears to believe that if they didn’t have to pick up and drop off people, they could run their system more effectively.

The dubious benefits of faster street car traffic on King St. notwithstanding, the collateral damage of the increased traffic of the more than 20,000 cars the TTC alleges are displaced from King St to adjoining streets has turned Adelaide, Queen, Wellington and Front Sts. into a gridlock standstill. Anyone who has tried to navigate the area can attest that much of the time, no matter how close you are you can’t get there from here.

Along with the other merchants of King St. and the Toronto Entertainment District we ask that Mayor Tory and Toronto council to consider a simple, reasonable and cost-effective alternative.

Put lights on King St. that restricts vehicle traffic during rush hours, but return King St. to its former vibrant self after 7 p.m., on weekends and statutory holidays. It’s smart, fair, reasonable and helps meet the goals of the King St. pilot project
 
No, it would not be appropriate. Attacking the messenger is just plain stupidity.

Is an article from the Red Star more to your liking?!

https://www.thestar.com/opinion/con...ing-st-pilot-project-is-killing-business.html


Toronto’s King St. pilot project is killing business

Let’s be clear. The merchants of King St – and me among them – are pro transit. Period. I live and work in the area, and have for more than 30 years.

Pro-transit opinion notwithstanding, the King St. pilot project is a disaster that is killing hundreds of businesses, adversely affecting King St., the Entertainment District and much of the downtown core. It can be fixed, quickly and quite easily, but the political will must collide with common sense.

Full credit to Toronto Mayor John Tory, who visited my restaurant and the adjoining establishments to hear from merchants on the impact of the study. We told him what I am saying here: it’s a disaster but can be fixed.

Toronto City Councillor Joe Cressy published an opinion piece in the Toronto Star this week. “King St. was broken,” he said, “it wasn’t working for anybody.”

“The pilot is working, as evidenced by early data showing improved streetcar reliability and travel times … as the local city councillor, I will not support going back to the past.”

King St. was not broken. It was a vibrant and important part of the residential and cultural fabric of our community. Go visit King St. today and it is a wasteland. No vibrancy, no pedestrians, no culture … and soon to be inhabited by “Closed” and “For Sale” signs.

“Commuters from east to west use King St. to get to and from work in the Financial District, or at the rapidly increasing number of tech startups in the Entertainment District — an area that also attracts thousands to its dynamic shops, theatres and restaurants,” Cressy wrote. Yet it is exactly these shops, theatres and restaurants that are being driven out of business by this short-sighted and poorly executed pilot project that turns King St. into an urban freeway for streetcars.

The improved streetcar reliability and travel times Cressy talks about are arguable. Data differs but even city reports show the most significant improvement is a 2.6-minute (approx. 140 seconds) improvement in average travel time through the pilot area. Barely long enough for Councillor Cressy to develop his flawed thesis.


Lastly, I was under the impression that the purpose of a pilot project is to determine if the plan was effective. Barely a month in, Cressy has already decided he is in favour. I guess there is no point in letting the facts get in the way of a good story.

Our proposal is quick, inexpensive and simple. We propose keeping the King St. traffic restrictions, but limiting them to rush hours. Cars could therefore return to King St. after 7 p.m. on weekdays, on weekends, and statutory holidays. Concerns expressed by city staffers that this would confuse drivers are spurious. It could be accomplished simply with lit street lights not unlike what currently exists on Jarvis, which allows traffic to flow into the core in the morning and out of the core in the afternoon rush hour.

The City of Toronto has chosen the worst time, in the worst way in the worst season to implement the pilot project. Their goal is clearly to move people through King St., not to King St. For years King St. was a destination, now it is a thoroughfare.

The goal of the King St. Pilot project was said to be to balance three important principles: to move people more effectively on transit, to support business and economic prosperity and to improve public space. In its current form, the competing principles seem to be decidedly tilted away from the economic well-being of merchants and biases efficiency over convenience. The casual stickiness of pedestrians walking and stopping at stores, restaurants and other merchants is lost.

Additionally, the TTC has eliminated a number of stops along King St., forcing passengers to walk further to enter and disembark streetcars, further reducing pedestrian traffic and affecting areas businesses. The TTC appears to believe that if they didn’t have to pick up and drop off people, they could run their system more effectively.

The dubious benefits of faster street car traffic on King St. notwithstanding, the collateral damage of the increased traffic of the more than 20,000 cars the TTC alleges are displaced from King St to adjoining streets has turned Adelaide, Queen, Wellington and Front Sts. into a gridlock standstill. Anyone who has tried to navigate the area can attest that much of the time, no matter how close you are you can’t get there from here.

Along with the other merchants of King St. and the Toronto Entertainment District we ask that Mayor Tory and Toronto council to consider a simple, reasonable and cost-effective alternative.

Put lights on King St. that restricts vehicle traffic during rush hours, but return King St. to its former vibrant self after 7 p.m., on weekends and statutory holidays. It’s smart, fair, reasonable and helps meet the goals of the King St. pilot project

The same argument for time to see if it works works both ways.

And considering the weather Id say walking traffic on king would be down anyway.

As for times. I take it everyday. And saving 15 minutes on average. And that's only travelling half the distance of the restrictions.

People will adjust. Remember when the smoking ban would kill bars? Didn't happen. It's the same with this.
 
The same argument for time to see if it works works both ways.

And considering the weather Id say walking traffic on king would be down anyway.

As for times. I take it everyday. And saving 15 minutes on average. And that's only travelling half the distance of the restrictions.

People will adjust. Remember when the smoking ban would kill bars? Didn't happen. It's the same with this
Why not just do it during rush hours??
 
The problem is John Tory can do no wrong according to the media narrative. He is not a "hands on mayor" though and in his first term it is clear he does not have a backbone.

The City lost $10 million dollars in back rents from Union Station tenancies because City staffers were not doing their job. It was swiflty covered up with a bullshit explanation.

Do an FOI request on the St. Lawrence Market and you will find the same thing IMHO. You will also find a salary that makes no sense as the manager made $150,000 in 2015 which is well outside the pay grade for that position. Yet no one questions this despite it being public information on the Sunshine List.

There is way too much mismanagement in the City of Toronto. I am holding out hope that Richard Peddie considers entering the race because he would bring accountability to city staffers and a clearly defined strategy.

Even Doug Ford would do a better job than Tory but Rob's demons may have done irreparable harm to the Ford name in politics.

If there is a new mayor the first order of business should be to conduct an external audit of the existing make up organization wide. There are too many redundancies in the City of Toronto's organizational makeup.

In fact, they have supervisor/management positons that exist with one or two direct reports. Does this sound like value-for-money??? More like positions created for friends and family. In fact, some City staffers have told me that there are many conflict of interest hirings because human resources does not participate in the interview process.

Toronto will be stronger if it gets it's finances in order. The current City Manager suggests the only solution is raising our friggin taxes. He's got to go...
 
Those who oppose cars have a fundamental misunderstanding of why commuters use them. And it is because cars are the fastest and most convenient way to get around. For those of us living not on a subway line or within a quick walk to it, car is the only alternative. There's a lot of infrastructure we need to build before majority of the commuters will leave their personal vehicles behind. As it is, even with the heavy congestion and the ever increasing parking fees, people still prefer sitting on the Gardiner. Not because they enjoy the view, but because it is still a better way. In the North American economy and culture time is still the most valuable commodity. As soon as the public transportation can tip that advantage away from the car, the commuters will exit them. The idiotic ideas like the King St or St
Claire or bike lanes n major roads are just feel good projects only designed to piss people off.
 
Why not just do it during rush hours??

I'm actually travelling to work off peak. King is a nightmare at night as well. Especially in the theatre area. I've taken twenty plus minutes in a streetcar from Spadina to University before. Not any more.

What needs to happen is all new construction have a public parking element. Retail/restaurant ground level and mix commercial residential above.

Then there would be space for people to park.

But allowing parking anywhere on king on the street at anytime is insane.

Sorry but the streetcar can move a crapliad more people faster. Park you car at the subway and travel in. Or uber in.

But the downtown is not built or laid out for the mass of cars we have now. People have to change their travelling means.
 
Those who oppose cars have a fundamental misunderstanding of why commuters use them. And it is because cars are the fastest and most convenient way to get around. For those of us living not on a subway line or within a quick walk to it, car is the only alternative. There's a lot of infrastructure we need to build before majority of the commuters will leave their personal vehicles behind. As it is, even with the heavy congestion and the ever increasing parking fees, people still prefer sitting on the Gardiner. Not because they enjoy the view, but because it is still a better way. In the North American economy and culture time is still the most valuable commodity. As soon as the public transportation can tip that advantage away from the car, the commuters will exit them. The idiotic ideas like the King St or St
Claire or bike lanes n major roads are just feel good projects only designed to piss people off.

I don't live near a subway. I do just fine.

As more enter the city(100,000+ per year) it will only get worse.

I call it the Manhattenization of Toronto. And while i agree about more transit the car sutuation eobt get better but worse.

Density is going to increase. So really it's either this or complete gridlock.
 
Car is more convenient and cleaner (for the driver) than public transportation. I won't be trading in my car for public transit any time soon.

It's akin to your smartphone which is a mobile computer. Your car is a mobile office/home complete with temperature control, music, adjustable relaxation, and more.

I look at the poor saps waiting for streetcars in the freeze of winter or oppressive heat of summer and wonder WTF are they thinking.

I look at the poor saps in their cars stuck in oppressive rush hour traffic while their gas is wasting away and wonder WTF are they thinking. BTW I walk to work, save so much money and stress free.
 
I look at the poor saps in their cars stuck in oppressive rush hour traffic while their gas is wasting away and wonder WTF are they thinking. BTW I walk to work, save so much money and stress free.

How far is the walk?
 
Do you think Doug Ford has no bias on this issue as it relates to Tory?

C'mon Lol. Would like to hear what you think? I thought for sure you'd respond.

Let's do this. If you don't respond, I will assume you agree that Dougie has a bias and Tory is a factor in that bias.
 
I look at the poor saps in their cars stuck in oppressive rush hour traffic while their gas is wasting away and wonder WTF are they thinking. BTW I walk to work, save so much money and stress free.

What are they thinking? The alternative to being stuck by themselves in a cozy, climate controlled environment is having to walk to the bus stop, wait, (sometimes for more than one as they're often full during rush hour) get on with standing room only next to coughing, sneezing or smelly people. Transfer to another bus or subway, wait, get on with standing room only then walk the balance of their trip.

So if transit takes longer than driving, that's what their thinking!
 
Last edited:
Doug Ford will be your new mayor. First order of business will be to hire someone like Harry Schlange as City manager and cut all the management fat at City Hall. They have supervisors, managers and even directors managing less than 5 staff under them. Plus, managers and directors make anywhere between $100,000 to $200,000. Does this sound right to you?
No.... but Doug Ford sounds horrendously wrong!
 
Killing business?

But, don't all the downtown walkers claim they can get everywhere by foot or transit. So with better streetcar times, it should make every person living in the core want to check out King St even more. Business should be better than ever.....

..... oh wait. Some of the revenue comes from suburban people who drive downtown to have fun and spend money. And that's why on weekends and any night with a sporting event, parking lots and GO Train are jammed. Where do you think all these cars come from? 3 blocks down the street? It suburb people trekking downtown.

Sorry King St businesses. But just like any neighbourhood getting public works construction for months, business will drop no matter how much you think it comes from locals.
 
and I hope all the cyclists are enjoying all the bike paths that they have had built for them this winter. The bike paths are plowed faster than the roads, yet hardly anybody is using them. But everytime I suggest that having a transportation strategy based on a mode of travel that is impractical for half the year is absurd, it falls on deaf ears. Well........ enjoy !
 
and I hope all the cyclists are enjoying all the bike paths that they have had built for them this winter. The bike paths are plowed faster than the roads, yet hardly anybody is using them. But everytime I suggest that having a transportation strategy based on a mode of travel that is impractical for half the year is absurd, it falls on deaf ears. Well........ enjoy !

Cyclists are the biggest whiners.

I moved not long ago, but used to live in an area that got new bike lanes. So our nice 4 lane street got converted to 2 car lanes and 2 bike lanes. There were numerous town hall meetings, and the bike lanes passed. It was a decent stretch too that was probably a good 5km stretch.

I'm not joking when I say this, but since I'd use that street for work, I've driven on that street enough on workdays and the weekend to notice this net effect:

1. Car traffic increased

2. In the two years it was up (until I moved), I saw probably 10 people ride bikes on it. Don't get me wrong, I'm only driving on that stretch for a bit, so there are surely other bike riders, but you'd think there would be way more

3. In winter, I saw ZERO people attempting to ride their bikes. Not one person. Maybe a better thing would be bikes lanes during the spring/summer, and make it car lanes in winter, but nope. 100% bike lanes. Totally retarded during the winter months when it's cars trying to get home with lane restrictions