King street pilot project

Normally you are spot on. Not today
Since when is all electricity produced with Zero pollution .

Hydro, wind and solar.
Not zero, as you have to factor in construction and delivery, but very low.

Most of our electricity is still nuclear, which is also low carbon.
 
Besides San Fran and Mexico city I wouldn't consider those major cities.

The first sentence in this link reads: Electric streetcars or trolley(car)s (North American English for the European word tram) were once the chief mode of public transit in hundreds of North American cities and towns. Most of the original urban streetcar systems were either dismantled in the mid-20th century or converted to other modes of operation, such as light rail. Today, only Toronto still operates a streetcar network essentially unchanged in layout and mode of operation.

Besides San Fran, none of those would be considered first class. The ghettos of Detroit, Atlanta, Portland, DC would disqualify them instantly.



Lots of these appear to be upgraded to light rail trains.

The new and old TTC streetcars are all technically light rail vehicles. The old ones are even called Canadian Light Rail Vehicle and Articulated Light Rail Vehicle.
 
Wait a minute!!! I don't see the King streetcar carrying 65,000 people on saturdays or sundays. This pilot project should only be enforced during Mondays to Fridays - not the weekends. Downtown King St will look like a ghosttown on weekends. Retailers will suffer
 
The new and old TTC streetcars are all technically light rail vehicles. The old ones are even called Canadian Light Rail Vehicle and Articulated Light Rail Vehicle.

To add to this, this article tries to find factors to distinguish between streetcars and light rail. The classes of equipment overlap, (and sometimes the exact same cars are used), so it is more important to look at the overall system design to see where a specific situation lies on the continuum.

https://ggwash.org/view/36980/how-to-tell-the-difference-between-streetcars-and-light-rail

For King Street, the factors that would push it more 'light rail' would be whether they put in a more dedicated roadway and cutting out stops to make the trip faster. They are doing the former (ie the pilot), and the need for the latter will depend on what the typical trip time is once congestion is removed.

I've used the Spadina street car with the dedicated right of way and it is excellent.

They are looking at a waterfront LRT; that I think will have fewer stops compared to a downtown streetcar, but services a different need.
 
Normally you are spot on. Not today
Since when is all electricity produced with Zero pollution .

I should have been more careful with my wording.

The electric train does not pollute at the location of use.

Depending on how the electricity is generated, there may be pollution.

Toronto receives power from a few sources that I am aware of. One is the Hydro electric generating plants at Niagara falls. This is truly God's gift since there is absolutely no pollution created and nature has created the mighty Niagara River and the Niagara gorge. The volume of water in the river is massive like no other and the gorge allows a natural drop to the turbines that creates a natural situation where no flooding of land upstream to create a reservoir is required. If only every Hydro installation were so lucky.

The second is the nuclear installations at Pickering and Darlington and while these generate no carbon emissions, they do generate nuclear waste, which is hugely frightening to me I admit. I firmly believe that Ontario choosing to go nuclear was a massive mistake way back when. We should have done like Quebec and went all in on Hydro in James Bay. But we chose nukes in order to develop CANDU here in Ontario and because of the politics of flooding huge tracts of land, land claimed by aboriginal people.

It was the wrong choice.

But yes, realize that unlike God's gift of Niagara False, most Hydro dams have an environmental price tag associated with them.

Lastly I am aware that there is a natural gas generating plant off of Commissioners Street in Toronto. This would have carbon emissions, however, with the modern technology utilized this plant would produce the least amount of pollution per unit of energy. Hugely superior to the diesel engine in any bus.

So the benefit of the street car is is that it does not pollute where it is used. In the city where you have large built up areas with dense population and many sources of pollution already (cars, trucks, buildings, etc) adding thousands of diesel precipitate spewing buss to the equation would not be a good idea. The pollution generated at the source of generation is far less due to the way electricity can be generated as opposed to burning diesel.
 
What the city is doing is taking one major street and forcing all the non transit vehicles to use other routes- increasing the congestion there, without making any other changes. All vehicles will be required to make a right turn on the first intersection they encounter, thus clogging all the intersections North of King. This will not be a great issue outside the peak hours, but will be a nightmare during the busy times. Stupid idea.
It's already a nightmare, and not just during busy times. I regularly ride the standing room only King car into downtown, and fume while one guy at every intersection in a bloated 'luxury' SUV waits for the amber and holds up a hundred people so he can make a left turn, instead of efficiently going around the block to the right without waiting. That's what he'll have to do from now on.
 
Wait a minute!!! I don't see the King streetcar carrying 65,000 people on saturdays or sundays. This pilot project should only be enforced during Mondays to Fridays - not the weekends. Downtown King St will look like a ghosttown on weekends. Retailers will suffer
Don't be silly. The same folks who patronized those businesses the weekend before will need to buy the same goods and services there the week after. But the traffic will move better.
 
Normally you are spot on. Not today
Since when is all electricity produced with Zero pollution .
"All" is your word. You need to justify it. Compared to the pollution load of single occupant cars clogging our streets to a standstill many hours every day, Ontario's electricity is effectively zero pollution. Most of it is hydro, nuclear or wind generated, a small portion comes from burning natural gas in stand-by plants that cover peak demands, that burns far cleaners than the gasoline or diesel an idling suv/truck burns twice a day because its single occupant won't consider any of the better alternatives.
 
This should drive visitors to Toronto nuts!
Only the few who drove in. Seasoned tourists and business people know their limited time is best used letting local experts speed them to their planned destinations. While sharing transit, from moto-taxis through to double-deckers is how to collect experiences of travel and actually see the sights, instead of staring at a GPS.
 
Tory has proven himself to be an ineffectual mayor. He's just not a dreamer or a builder. He's a stuffed shirt. Good at talking in front of a TV camera, but that's about it.

Say what you want about Ford, he did manage to get the subway extended out to Scarborough some how. (Even if it was a silly move.)

Toronto needs a Queen Street line. Right from Sherway to Victoria Park .

We should be building it in phases just like they did when the Bloor Line was extended out to Kipling way back when.

And Bloor should be extended to Sherway also.
You left out the rapid transit line east of the Don, running south then west into downtown. The first serious study that said we needed it now, and that it would make the City grow in a healthier way was done over a century ago. Nothing's changed, except every year it's more needed. That 504 King car is overcrowded because it carries some of the load that DRL should.

On the transit file, the Big Strike against Tory and both Fords is their willingness to waste money on stuff almost no one needs and few will use when What Needs To Be Done is staring us all in the face.
 
If streetcars work so well, why are they not used in other major cities?
They are, all over Europe.

What makes buses look inexpensive is pricing out the cost of their road use at $0. Instead of factoring in the costs of periodic, frequent re-surfacing and the continual disruptions to service buried utilities that relocate whole routes, bus companie3s slough that to the Roads Dept.. Besides the cost to buy (and hire, train and pay drivers for) two or three times as many vehicles to carry the same loads, efficiently scheduling buses that must compete for space with cars, and cope with their erratic driving is an impossible task. Which is why cities that depend on them eventually build — or take over — entire roadways to be bus only.

But if you already covered the capital costs of the transit way and its trackage … That is the rationale for the useless ScarBurrow of today. Some day …
 
Hydro, wind and solar
And how many public transportation vehicles are powered with that??

Toronto receives power from a few sources that I am aware of. One is the Hydro electric generating plants at Niagara falls. This is truly God's gift since there is absolutely no pollution created and nature has created the mighty Niagara River and the Niagara gorge
Niagara Falls and Lewiston plants generate 2.4 million kilowatts per day, thats barely enough to power Toronto for 5 minutes. On a hot summer day Toronto can use up around 5,000 megawatts or so
 
And how many public transportation vehicles are powered with that??


Niagara Falls and Lewiston plants generate 2.4 million kilowatts per day, thats barely enough to power Toronto for 5 minutes. On a hot summer day Toronto can use up around 5,000 megawatts or so

All of Scotland was powered by wind in October.
https://www.juancole.com/2017/11/powered-scotland-renewable.html

Not that this is likely to happen here any time soon, but its possible.

The Subway, streetcars and trolleys here are all electric. Right now our electricity is still mostly nukes followed by hydro.
What its not going to be in the future is coal, and I expect that gas generation won't be the first choice for new generation any time soon either.

Regardless, King street and fewer people owning cars in a more dense downtown are the ways forward.
You need to get used to it.
 
65,000 people ride the 504 King streetcar daily and being packed in like lambs. Put more fuckin streetcars on the road

201192-double-decker-bus-1921.jpg


Double Decker bus, 1921

Got to get me one of those spindle wheels

200.webp
 
Will northbound/southbound traffic from streets between Jarvis and Bathurst be allowed to turn onto King (then I assume forced to turn right at the next intersection) or will they have to drive straight through?
I believe the idea is for people to be able to access business/restaurants all along King. You just have to make sure that you pick the right block to turn at or else you have to turn off and try again.
 
Toronto traffic is still miles better then most 3rd world cities
I don't think this will make people sitting on the 401 or DVP or Gardiner feel any better.

"It took me 2 hours to get home but at least I don't live in Karachi."
 
I believe the idea is for people to be able to access business/restaurants all along King. You just have to make sure that you pick the right block to turn at or else you have to turn off and try again.

Okay, so you can access King, but must turn right at the next major intersection. Got it!

Did they eliminate all street parking along that stretch?