Jays new/old manager

Toke

Just less active
Oct 14, 2002
2,724
132
63
Nope... Not Cito.

Reports surfacing that John Gibbons will be named the manager of the Jays on Tuesday.

I don't think best this is/was the best choice, but leave it to AA to do the unexpected.
 
I think it's a great choice. A lot of people only remember him for the incidents with Ted Lilly and Shea Hillenbrand, but they are remembering the bad and forgetting the good. He and Lilly got over their spat very quickly, and Hillenbrand is an asshole who deserved to get his clock cleaned, Gibby just managed to be the first one in the clubhouse to get his licks in before anyone else. Can't wait for spring training!
 
Once again AA proves his point that if there are rumours of a particular trade or signing by him, they are usually wrong. Gibbons name never showed up anywhere prior to today.
 
Yuck! This is almost as uninspired as Riggleman, Tracy or Acta. If the Jays win, it will be in spite of the manager...

It will be interesting to see who he brings onboard as hitting and pitching coaches, bench coach, etc., because on its own this is a terribly lame hire.

Here’s what the Baseball Prospectus 2008 annual had to say about Gibbons’ final full season:


John Gibbons is a terrible handler of starting pitchers. From what appear to be intentional attempts to break an already-fragile A.J. Burnett, to the way he contributed to Dustin McGowan’s trip through the wilderness, to riding Roy Halladay well past 120 pitches in four of five starts late last summer, Gibbons shows no recogniton for the fact that starting pitchers have limits. Keep in mind that Gibbons handled his starters this way in a season in which he had a deep, effective pool of relievers and nothing on the line. If either of those things change this year, we could see a science experiment in Toronto.

Indeed, the Jays were renowned for their slew of pitcher injuries during the Gibbons era, among both starters and relievers. Burnett, who already had a history of arm troubles, spent 135 days on the disabled list with elbow and shoulder injuries in 2006-2007. McGowan wound up needing the first of several shoulder surgeries in mid-2008, and has just 21 big league innings since. Gustavo Chacin spent over 300 days on the DL from 2006-2008 with elbow and shoulder woes and was never the same, though his 203-inning 2005 rookie season took place on Tosca’s watch. Closer B.J Ryan missed most of 2007 after undergoing Tommy John surgery. Reliever Casey Janssen missed all of 2008 after labrum surgery. Reliever Jeremy Accardo missed most of 2008 with a forearm strain. Starters Shaun Marcum and Jesse Litsch underwent Tommy John surgery after Gibbons’ departure, in late 2008 and early 2009, respectively.

It’s certainly not clear that Gibbons’ handling caused any or all of those problems, and even if it did, pitching coaches, medical staff and the since-departed Ricciardi share in the blame as well. But on the heels of a season where starters Kyle Drabek, Drew Hutchinson and McGowan, and relievers Litsch, Luis Perez and Sergio Santos all underwent season-ending shoulder or elbow surgeries — and Ricky Romero added a postseason elbow cleanup — the return of Gibbons raises an eyebrow if not a red flag. Particularly so, in light of the acquisition of the injury-prone Josh Johnson, a Tommy John surgery survivor who spent most of 2011 on the DL with shoulder inflammation. Toronto’s training staff will have to stay on its toes.

Source: http://mlb.si.com/2012/11/20/john-g...ger-rehired-red-flags/?sct=hp_t2_a7&eref=sihp
 
Terrible choice.
Fool me once, shame on you.
Fool me twice, shame on me.
Shame on AA. Gibbons is a terrible manager.
To go through that excellent trade and then top it off with a piece of shit is troubling.
 
Terrible choice.
Fool me once, shame on you.
Fool me twice, shame on me.
Shame on AA. Gibbons is a terrible manager.
To go through that excellent trade and then top it off with a piece of shit is troubling.
That might be a bit premature.

First of all, AA didn't hire him the first time, so he'd still be at "fool me once".

Secondly, most of us are happy with the roster moves he's made so does that mean he's smart with personnel but dumb with managers? As well, AA has seen him work up close and personal, not just via interviews. He knows the man a lot better than we do.

Johnny Mac, who is universally regarded as a classy guy, thought Gibbons was great to play for.

During Gibbons tenure the Jays pitching staff improved in ERA league ranking each year. Handling a pitching staff well is probably the toughest thing for a manager to do.

Gibbons was a raw rookie last time. He's had time to learn more since then.

AA seems pretty bright, has made lots of good moves (building the farm with prospects as well as the trades) so even though I'm not gonna say it's a great or even good move, I'm willing to give him the benefit of the doubt for now, hope he's right and root for our team to do well.
 
If I remember correctly, the weak performance of the Blue Jays during the latter part of Gibbons' first tenure was because they just weren't hitting, especially with runners in scoring position. This is based on memory, so may not be completely accurate, but there was criticism that management wanted batters to take pitches and work the count. This was to emulate the Yankees and Red Sox and, maybe, the Athletics where JP Ricciardi came from. The problem was that by taking a pitch or two the batters were in a 0-1 or 0-2 count. Again if I remember correctly, the turnaround when Cito came in and brought a more aggressive batting philosophy was pretty dramatic. Can this batting approach be pinned to Gibbons? Maybe not fully, but he was the manager at the time. I just hope he has learned from that.
 
My understanding was that Farrell left on his own accord. AA didn't "show Farrell the door".

Your not understanding gww post ... AA should have showed Farrell the door before Farrell requested it ... Listen to Farrell's press conference and it seems Farrell had checked out along time ago . His eye was on the Sox job ever since last summer .
 
At first I did not care for this re-hire, but the more I think about it Gibby may just be what this team needs.
 
At first I did not care for this re-hire, but the more I think about it Gibby may just be what this team needs.

I have to be honest and say it's hard to take Gibbie serious ( yes the fact media call him that ) when I listen to him talk . It's like listening to the Bills Coach and GM . Although we aren't talking about rocket science here and so it shouldn't matter how he speaks . I guesss we don't need a coach who sounds like a Harvard Graduate as long as he knows when to take a pitcher out .
 
I have to be honest and say it's hard to take Gibbie serious ( yes the fact media call him that ) when I listen to him talk . It's like listening to the Bills Coach and GM . Although we aren't talking about rocket science here and so it shouldn't matter how he speaks . I guess we don't need a coach who sounds like a Harvard Graduate as long as he knows when to take a picture out .

Yes, I agree. We need more baseball managers who are art enthusiasts. ;)
 
It would have been nice to see an Alomar name as a manager.
 
It would have been nice to see an Alomar name as a manager.
That's who I was pulling for initially, but what do we really know about his managerial abilities? I'm not sure a rookie manager would be best when AA has convinced to team to shoot the moon and spend, spend, spend. Too much at risk.
 
If he is such a good hire how come he never again managed in the bigs once he was showen the door in TO?
How come he only managed to get hired as a bench boss and why was he in the minors when he and AA were having dinner in TO?

He may know how to work the bullpen but he was notoriously bad for pulling his starters to quickly or leaveing them in to long when they should of been pulled.

Gibbons is not a good situational manager, he lacks creativity, when to put a hit and run on ( if he ever will ) when to steal or lay down a bunt.

I totaly agree with dj1470 it was a bad hire, one step forword, two steps back.

Art Howe, Tim Wallach, Terry Francona, and lets not forget old arrow head, Erine Whitt ( I call him arrow head because he always hit to right field...all the time, he should of put a arrow on his helmet to show everyone what field he would hit to) These managers would of been a better hire

I'm Just Saying.
 
Did anyone hear how much they're paying Gibbons ? and how long his contract is for ? It's gotta be cheap, cheap, as AA lost his wallet.

I think Gibby's hiring is all a setup. The Blue Jays will get off to a poor start in the first 3 months & then fire the discount manager. With no time to search for a bonafide replacement, the desperate phone call goes to Cito watching the Jays on tv at home. Get your ass up here!! And Cito rides the Jays into the playoffs
 
If he is such a good hire how come he never again managed in the bigs once he was showen the door in TO?
How come he only managed to get hired as a bench boss and why was he in the minors when he and AA were having dinner in TO?

He may know how to work the bullpen but he was notoriously bad for pulling his starters to quickly or leaveing them in to long when they should of been pulled.

Gibbons is not a good situational manager, he lacks creativity, when to put a hit and run on ( if he ever will ) when to steal or lay down a bunt.

I totaly agree with dj1470 it was a bad hire, one step forword, two steps back.

Art Howe, Tim Wallach, Terry Francona, and lets not forget old arrow head, Erine Whitt ( I call him arrow head because he always hit to right field...all the time, he should of put a arrow on his helmet to show everyone what field he would hit to) These managers would of been a better hire

I'm Just Saying.

Is Gibbons the best coach out there ? no ... But he has a working relationship with this GM and a affiliation to the city and this organization . He isn't just a hired gun Coach but somebody who loves this city and organization . AA after Farwell had to change his criteria for this hire cause the other coach had all the qualities which got him the job but the other guy always had a eye somewhere other then Toronto .