Israel at war

sseth

Active member
Nov 23, 2022
112
199
43
Watching the video of the female soldier with bloodied pants and cuts on her toes (on Reddit) made me lose all sympathy for Palestinians.
I hope Israel does the right thing here, clear out the strip of all civilians (like a 24 hrs warning) and flatten the fuck out of it. Targeting known Hamas targets is not good enough. Do it like Sri Lanka did with the LTTE.
 

mandrill

monkey
Aug 23, 2001
79,084
100,088
113
Bear in mind that all this is designed to trigger a massive, angry, emotional response from Israel and the West, which can then be exploited for propaganda and diplomatic purposes in the Middle East.

My first reaction as well was to say "Nuke 'em! They don't deserve to live!"

But I suspect that is what Hamas is trying to achieve.

Israel needs to permanently remove Hamas from Gaza while attempting to minimize civilian casualties. But easier said than done.

Hamas survives by continuing the hostility and tension between Israel and the Palestinians.

Israel is faced with a number of difficult choices. If they invade, they subject their forces to endless intifada from Hamas, which will then dissolve again into the general population. If they just bomb, they will have no way of identifying Hamas personnel and will simply inflict indiscriminate casualties.

OTOH, the situation demands massive and effective retaliation.
 

shack

Nitpicker Extraordinaire
Oct 2, 2001
53,953
11,795
113
Toronto
Does Israel have a "no negotiations" policy?

I'm guessing it does. Otherwise, hostage fees would eat up a chunk of the Israeli state budget.
Not sure, but I believe that they have had hostage/prisoner exchanges in the past.
 

mandrill

monkey
Aug 23, 2001
79,084
100,088
113
Hmmm.........it doesn't sound like a lot in Western budget terms, but it is almost 2% of Iranian GDP. The mullahs haven't exactly ushered in an era of prosperity.

So that's about $40 billion in relative Canadian terms for reference.

I'm not blaming the Biden Administration for Gaza, but I don't think there is any hope for rapprochement with Iran. I just don't buy Blinken's explanation of how the money is for this and not for that.
Hard to believe an oil producing country has a GDP of only $300B. It must be quite fucked up.
 

Insidious Von

My head is my home
Sep 12, 2007
40,802
7,948
113
Hard to believe an oil producing country has a GDP of only $300B. It must be quite fucked up.
Not really, the Americans and the British decided that Iran didn't deserve democracy. In 1953 the Iranians were still loyal to the Americans for getting the Soviets out of Tabriz at the Yalta Accord.

 
  • Like
Reactions: Frankfooter

Not getting younger

Well-known member
Jun 29, 2022
4,537
2,449
113
Bear in mind that all this is designed to trigger a massive, angry, emotional response from Israel and the West, which can then be exploited for propaganda and diplomatic purposes in the Middle East.

My first reaction as well was to say "Nuke 'em! They don't deserve to live!"

But I suspect that is what Hamas is trying to achieve.

Israel needs to permanently remove Hamas from Gaza while attempting to minimize civilian casualties. But easier said than done.

Hamas survives by continuing the hostility and tension between Israel and the Palestinians.

Israel is faced with a number of difficult choices. If they invade, they subject their forces to endless intifada from Hamas, which will then dissolve again into the general population. If they just bomb, they will have no way of identifying Hamas personnel and will simply inflict indiscriminate casualties.

OTOH, the situation demands massive and effective retaliation.
Which is exactly why Trump should never be allowed near the White House. Days like this. Arguably ours too.

What happens tomorrow and this week?
Tuesday could potentially suck.
See also Black Monday.



 

mandrill

monkey
Aug 23, 2001
79,084
100,088
113
Not really, the Americans and the British decided that Iran didn't deserve democracy. In 1953 the Iranians were still loyal to the Americans for getting the Soviets out of Tabriz at the Yalta Accord.

Great point. Except the Iranians ditched the Shah and picked Khomeini, who was even worse.
 

Frankfooter

dangling member
Apr 10, 2015
95,246
24,179
113
Bear in mind that all this is designed to trigger a massive, angry, emotional response from Israel and the West, which can then be exploited for propaganda and diplomatic purposes in the Middle East.

My first reaction as well was to say "Nuke 'em! They don't deserve to live!"

But I suspect that is what Hamas is trying to achieve.

Israel needs to permanently remove Hamas from Gaza while attempting to minimize civilian casualties. But easier said than done.

Hamas survives by continuing the hostility and tension between Israel and the Palestinians.

Israel is faced with a number of difficult choices. If they invade, they subject their forces to endless intifada from Hamas, which will then dissolve again into the general population. If they just bomb, they will have no way of identifying Hamas personnel and will simply inflict indiscriminate casualties.

OTOH, the situation demands massive and effective retaliation.
More violence won't help.
There were attacks by Israel in 2015, 2018 and 2021 on Gaza and more before then and none created peace.

You can't kill the entire democratically elected Hamas government and police force.
Even if Israel did kill the tens of thousands in Hamas there are still 2 million people living in Gaza who wouldn't just bow their heads and live under an apartheid blockade.

If you want peace Israel needs to deescalate for a change, not kill more people.
End the occupation or end apartheid.
 

Conil

Well-known member
Apr 12, 2013
4,306
1,225
113
The Palestinian terrorists shot themselves in the foot this time. Most countries have raised the Israeli flag and support Israel. The Brandenburg gate has a huge Israeli flag on it. The Palestinians took pictures of themselves with Israeli hostages, 80 year old Granmas, mothers holding babies and small children, girls, women. Sorry that's uncivilized.

 
  • Like
Reactions: xmontrealer

Insidious Von

My head is my home
Sep 12, 2007
40,802
7,948
113
According to La Corriere and the BBC, Israel's Good Cop/Bad Cop strategy has failed miserably.

The hardline parties that support Likud, want the restoration of Biblical Israel, the West Bank is part of the restoration, Gaza is not. The Israelis allowed freedom for Gaza's inhabitant to earn a living in Israel, figuring this would mollify Hamas. At the same time the Netanyahu coalition ramped up settlements in the West Bank, then conducted unprovoked raids on West Bank cities. The expeditions were intended to cull terrorists, the bloodiest was in Jenin. In response to the raids, Hamas organized a major attack on Israeli territory. Israel is lucky not to be fighting on two fronts, Hezbollah is pre-occupied guarding Bashar al Assad's worthless ass.

 

Frankfooter

dangling member
Apr 10, 2015
95,246
24,179
113
The Palestinian terrorists shot themselves in the foot this time. Most countries have raised the Israeli flag and support Israel. The Brandenburg gate has a huge Israeli flag on it. The Palestinians took pictures of themselves with Israeli hostages, 80 year old Granmas, mothers holding babies and small children, girls, women. Sorry that's uncivilized.

Is that better than this?
warning: video of Israelis pissing on Palestinian corpses
 
  • Angry
Reactions: Kautilya

Conil

Well-known member
Apr 12, 2013
4,306
1,225
113
Toronto Escorts