Indian residential schools

On the other hand, Sitting Bull, the great Sioux chief, enjoyed his stay in Canada.
Although that might have had something to do with how American cavalry would have welcomed him back. But eventually he did return to the uS; Buffalo Bill's Wild West Show needed a star attraction.
 
The 'cultural genocide' aspect leaves them pretty messed up. The traditional way of life and the languages are seriously almost gone. So now they are left in really poor rez's without a way of living traditionally or the means to integrate into a system they rightfully don't trust. I don't know how you fix that.
I don't think anyone knows. But the first step is always to say, "We see the truth of the mess we made. We resolve to fix it".

Nothing like that from Our Dear Leader
 
Again with the WE bull shit,...,...so now you are apologising for electing a government that was in power when this shit was happening,...I had the feeling you were becoming senile,...now it makes sense.



So apologising for something I had absolutely nothing to do with,...doesn't magically make all the consequences and repercussions magically go away

Finally it gets through your thick scull,...!!!

FAST

It's about being able to take pride in our country's heritage. It's about helping mothers, fathers, children, and elderly. This is something our nation is responsible for and should do it's best to right it's wrong. Better than that feeble attempt.
 
I don't think anyone knows. But the first step is always to say, "We see the truth of the mess we made. We resolve to fix it".

Nothing like that from Our Dear Leader

And, even more sadly, not much of that from Canadians.

There was an article in the SUN of all places today, where the author asked: "What if it had happened to one of us?"
 
I would suggest that almost all Canadians alive to-day were only a glean in their parents eyes at the time of these schools.

And for that reason you think it is OK for native Canadians to be living in 3rd world conditions?
 
Absolutely not. Just don't blame the current generation of Canadians for those schools. No guilt trip here.

I am blaming the current generation of Canadians for letting native Canadians live in 3rd world conditions. In effect I am blaming current Canadians for having the same attitude as existed during the residential school.

PS: the last residential school was closed in 1996. Care to change your statement?
 
I am blaming the current generation of Canadians for letting native Canadians live in 3rd world conditions. In effect I am blaming current Canadians for having the same attitude as existed during the residential school.

PS: the last residential school was closed in 1996. Care to change your statement?

The majority of aboriginals do not live in 3rd world conditions. I live within a half hour of two reserve's that prosper quite well, not that there are not some problems but they are no different than any other neighbourhood. Yes, there are some that live in almost third world conditions and they are mainly up north, but obviously giving more money to the reserve is not the answer as we have seen many cases where the council or chief of a reserve squander's the money away - I am not responsible for that and I do not feel any responsibility, it is because I have worked for a living and paid taxes that the government has the money to spend on aboriginal affairs, and then it is a crooked chief or council that leaves their band to wallow in these conditions.

The majority of aboriginals now reside outside the reserve and those that stay on the reserve do so free of will. When they work they do not have to pay income taxes, they do not have to pay gst or hst on most if not all items they purchase. A lot of their post secondary education is fully funded or at the very least partially funded, however I have never spoken to an aboriginal student from community college or university that was not fully funded. When they purchase a new car even if they do not live on reserve they do not have to pay tax on it as long as they have their picture taken in front of a reserve sign by the car salesman who forwards it of to Ottawa.

The two bands from up North that were flooded out twice and rescued twice were offered a new community that they would not have to worry about flooding; no, they did not want to move, so the next time they are flooded out again they will be bailed out. The point I am trying to make is that some people can be their own worst enemies, it is hard to help people in some cases that do not want help, and it would be inaccurate to label every reserve as " those poor people" a lot are not that bad off and some others just don't want help - some not all would just rather complain.

The government's first step should be to abolish the Indian Act which many aboriginals agree with and others do not. We should be integrating people not segregating people it is the 21 st century, and their should be ONE law for everyone no matter origin or color of skin. When you start making exceptions for certain ethnicities or groups it is a recipe for a number of problems. After all the main difference between Aboriginals and Caucasians aside from skin color, is nothing. Biologically our bodies, emotions, wants and needs are all the same, so why not try and live in harmony!

As for survivors of the residential school's and family members of others that died (irregardless of how) what is the appropriate course of action needed. It has taken a very long time for this to be given national attention and for an apology to be offered, you cannot change the past, it happened, so for how long and to what end is action needed; when will the aboriginals be satisfied, when will the government be satisfied and when will everyone else be satisfied that Canada has made amends?
 
Alarming number of aboriginals in Canada's prisons: watchdog

Thu Mar 7, 2013 4:06pm EST


By David Ljunggren

OTTAWA (Reuters) - The number of aboriginals in Canadian prisons is rising at an alarming rate, and the prison service is not taking care of indigenous inmates properly, an official watchdog said on Thursday.

Howard Sapers, in charge of monitoring the Correctional Service of Canada, said in a special report that aboriginals made up 4 percent of Canada's population but 23 percent of inmates in federal jails.

The aboriginal population of Canada's prisons has grown by 43 percent in the last five years alone.

"Given these alarming and growing numbers, programs and options for the care, custody and treatment of aboriginal inmates must become a significant priority for the Correctional Service of Canada," Sapers said during a news conference.

"Despite years of efforts, things are not getting better," he added, noting there were "serious gaps between the law and practice" when it came to dealing with aboriginal inmates.

Many of Canada's 1.2 million aboriginals have to deal with high rates of unemployment, poor healthcare and substandard schools. In January, militant chiefs threatened to bring the economy to a halt unless the government did more to help.

Prison officials regularly failed to follow rules that require the social histories of indigenous prisoners to be taken into account when dealing with security and discipline.

Sapers said aboriginal offenders served disproportionately more of their sentence behind bars before first release, were more likely to return to prison on revocation of parole and were disproportionately involved in security incidents inside jails. Continued...
 
Alarming number of aboriginals in Canada's prisons. . .
You always have to ask the question is this because somehow people from a certain group are being prosecuted while others who engage in exactly the same behavior are not, OR do people from a certain group commit criminal offenses more frequently than those from other groups.
 
The majority of aboriginals do not live in 3rd world conditions. I live within a half hour of two reserve's that prosper quite well, not that there are not some problems but they are no different than any other neighbourhood.
Also, many aboriginal bands receive 100's of millions of dollars for their mineral rights on their treaty land.
 
This residential school thing is immoral and illegal, 1990 was not so long ago, many of those responsible are still alive. If these kids were white we would have dug up corpses and put them on trial, but since these are natives kids; even those still alive get no punishment. I want to see a bunch of old motherfuckers crying in front of a court for mercy while a jury of natives decides their fate, that would be justice, that would be reconciliation.
 
You always have to ask the question is this because somehow people from a certain group are being prosecuted while others who engage in exactly the same behavior are not, OR do people from a certain group commit criminal offenses more frequently than those from other groups.

It's all too easy to make a certain "group" of people commit criminal offences more frequently. Take away everything they have and treat them like shit for a few generations. Take the children away from their parents to be beaten and abused. Throw those broken people back into the community. Pretend there is no ripple effect and that merely stopping residential schools makes it all instantly better. Don't forget to make sure that there is substandard healthcare, education and infrastructure in those places.Then be sure to make condescending little "tut-tut" noises at your newspaper when you read about recidivism, alcoholism and unemployment rates. Remember that you're not a racist, but....
 
This was tragic. But honestly, how many generations have to pay for this? Why should my children or grandchildren be on the hook for something that happened so long ago to a group that can never seem to help themselves no matter how much money they are given. As well, things have to be judged within their time. I had an uncle who grew up in Ontario at the turn of the 1900's as an orphan. He was basically traded around as farm labor, made to sleep in barns, and treated no better than cattle. Those were brutal times all around and children were treated awfully and regarded as burdens especially orphans. Who is telling that story? Where was his compensation? Ah, but alas, orphans do not have their own Federal minister.
 
Wasn't that long ago, the victims are still around and still suffering the effects.

I would agree if we were talking about slavery in the US where the crime occurred many generations ago, but like interment you can still talk to survivors, and see the damage that was done to their lives.

... once I am finished laughing ....
Let me get this straight, you think the residential school system affected more people than slavery? And think all slavery ended generations before these schools stopped operating?

The biggest problem the natives have these days is government killing off door to door postal (now they need to put down the alcohol and go outside to get welfare cheques)
 
The last residential school was closed in 1996, it was not a lifetime ago. The residential schools were an institution funded by tax dollars, yes we were paying taxes to tear apart families, kill and rape children. I am sorry for what happened to your uncle, but bringing your uncle into the story is like saying someone you know got raped and the rapist got away, so no one else deserve protection from rape and all rapists should not be prosecuted. We all have moments where feel violated, some lesser people see that as a free pass to violate others in the same way, some better people try to stop it happening again to others.
 
I am blaming the current generation of Canadians for letting native Canadians live in 3rd world conditions. In effect I am blaming current Canadians for having the same attitude as existed during the residential school.

PS: the last residential school was closed in 1996. Care to change your statement?

How about if natives paid taxes then maybe they would be entitled to some better infrastructure? Why exactly should we be on the hook for a generation of deadbeats?

PS and is there any documented cases of abuse in 1996? You do realize the actual abuse took place years ago, hence why they dig up corpses?
But then again, back in those days Indians raided British settlements and scalped people. So cry me a river.