Fat butts on planes

ReaganLevy said:
Where the heck did the word victim get thrown in??? True, in many cases it is a lack of discipline, being lazy, or plan old hating exercise. There are health issues like thyroid or hormone disorders that can cause rapid weight gain. These disorders are not victimizing disorder, however, they are real. Not to say they still shouldn't be charged for two seats...

To go with the other argument: There are many people out there a good 15 to 50 lbs overweight for their average height. An average bag weighs between 32 - 48lbs, so the weight limit is between 50 - 55lbs. If you are 6 ft and 220lbs should they charge you for each additional pound over the average weight of 192lbs even though you don't need an extra seat? Your using up extra fuel. The rest of us are paying for it in ticket cost even though we may be fit. What if I'm under weight do I get a credit?

Maybe girth would be a better way to determine when a person needs two seats. Like the carry-on basket. If it is bigger than this bin, it should be checked! If you are wider than this sign, you need two seats. If your legs are longer than this pole request a bulkhead or exit row. If your legs are longer than this pole, you're just SOL and going to be miserable, so sit down, shut up, and enjoy the ride. This guy's not a victim either...he's just drawn that way.

It is never fun to be in the middle of two large people or even to the side of one large person. There are times two seats should be purchased without the person taking offense or the airlines needing to defend themselves.

Bottom line, at the end of the day, we are all still human! Sometimes I forget my mints when I travel and am frightened I have bad breath...what if I do? Embarrassing, yes! The end of the world, no...
How about this? If you're black, you should be seated at the back? :rolleyes:

At what point does the airline accept responsibility for making their seats too small for people who are even slightly above average in height or body mass? People have turned this into a "fat" thread - that says more about the judgmental folks than it does about the obese ones. There are people who are just big, thick folks with a large frame and bones. There are tall people who cannot fold themselves into the tiny spaces allocated. There are people who have injuries or disabilities and need to fly, but cannot do so with any semblance of comfort.

So, going on the premise of many that large people should pay for two seats, then I posit that the airlines should be forced to make the double seats more comfortable - there are raised pads between the seats and the armrest doesn't go all the way up and out of the way, leaving lump in the middle of the two seats and an uncomfortable armrest in the middle of someone's back. Is it fair to pay double for that "privilege?"

I call bullshit on this and still go back to my premise that the airlines have done a terrible job of seat management planning. I'm not obese, but I am tall with broad shoulders and long limbs. Why should I just "suck it up" when I'm paying for a seat that is made for a relatively tiny person? The airlines have made this a one-size-fits-all situation - keep in mind that not all flights have multiple classes and when they do, the costs are disproportionate to what you need and are receiving - yet the majority here seem to agree. So I go back to my opening sentence: where do we draw the line? Weight, BMI, measurements, height, ethnicity, (dis)ability, gender?

If we go down this path, I foresee a number of class-action lawsuits that arise out of this. Especially as people start getting blood clots, deep vein thrombosis and other pressure-related issues. Medical evidence will probably show that small seats and a lack of room to stretch out are causes and that airlines knew this yet chose to go in the opposite direction. Reminds me of car companies that look at cost analyses of potentially fatally design flaws and compared that to what a recall would cost and chose to pay off death or injury lawsuits rather than fix the problem.

If someone is truly extra large and cannot fit in a regular seat without infringing on other paying passengers' space (and the reclining seat issue is a whole other can of worms), then an accommodation should be made. Whether it be a special row(s) of seats in coach or sitting in business class without the ancillary benefits, there should be some compromise that does not force the obese/large framed person to be humiliated and pay double the fare or more. Or cause a tall person to sit with his or her knees up to their chest for 5+ hours. Or... you know what I mean.

Otherwise, how far removed are we from, "Hey n!gger, get to the back of the bus!"?
 
tboy said:
The thing is, a tall person doesn't infringe on anyone else's space.....
Really? Where do they put their legs? They need to spread them out - infringing of another's leg room.
tboy said:
... and if a woman is that pregnant, she shouldn't be flying........
Really? And who should be the arbitrar of that? You? Are you now Dr. tboy? :rolleyes:
Flying is perfectly fine for pregnant women - perhaps you should do some reading or "talk to your physician" before you spout off.
 
Captain Fantastic said:
Really? Where do they put their legs? They need to spread them out - infringing of another's leg room.

Really? And who should be the arbitrar of that? You? Are you now Dr. tboy? :rolleyes:
Flying is perfectly fine for pregnant women - perhaps you should do some reading or "talk to your physician" before you spout off.

1) tall people might need to put their legs to the right or left or just not stretch them out. Plus size people ALWAYS encroach on the people next to them.

2) As for Dr Tboy, read the airline sites and the OMA: many doctors tell pregnant women not to travel in their third trimester and many airlines WON'T let a pregnant woman fly (I believe it is) a month before her due date.

Sorry, I've read up on it after a co-worker couldn't fly to a meeting due to her advanced pregnancy....something about the pressure.......

" Some airlines won’t allow you to travel for 30 days before your due date,"

"Pregnancy can cause circulation problems in any women. It is also well known that when you are flying, you have an increased chance of developing a blood clot. Put the two together and there could be some problems."

read up captain:

http://www.pregnancy-info.net/wellbeing_flying.html
 
I have researched this extensively in the past, which is why I called you on your nonsense. The majority of pregnant women can fly with little or no risk. Read your own link:
Generally, women who are having a healthy, normal pregnancy are free to come and go as they please. However, the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists (ACOG) recommends women don’t fly after their 36th week of pregnancy.
So that allows for most pregnant women up to about 8-8.5 months to be able to fly. The only ones who should not are those with complications.

As for the blood clot/circulation point, re-read the website. It can happen to anyone, based on being sedentary for prolonged periods of time. Yes, pregnant women have more circulatory issues, but for the most part, they are NOT severe, can be alleviated with stretching and should not get in the way of their ability to fly. However, small seats with no space between them make this more difficult. Next.

You really hate to admit or even acknowledge that you're wrong, don't you?
 
I believe the whole issue was settled in Canada by the Supreme Court last year...where have you people been?

http://abcnews.go.com/Travel/wireStory?id=6322184

"Under the ruling, airlines cannot charge extra for an obese person who needs an additional seat or a disabled person who needs space for a wheelchair or stretcher or who must be accompanied by an attendant."
 
OddSox said:
I believe the whole issue was settled in Canada by the Supreme Court last year...where have you people been?

http://abcnews.go.com/Travel/wireStory?id=6322184

"Under the ruling, airlines cannot charge extra for an obese person who needs an additional seat or a disabled person who needs space for a wheelchair or stretcher or who must be accompanied by an attendant."
Right, this decision took place in November, if I recall correctly. That is why I was making a human rights (and airline responsibility) argument. "One-person, one fare" is something that exists in most forms of public transport in this country.

However, that doesn't apply to all countries and airlines flying IN to Canada (I believe it's only Air Canada and WestJet), nor does it cover international airlines flying out of the country. For now.
 
Captain Fantastic said:
I have researched this extensively in the past, which is why I called you on your nonsense. The majority of pregnant women can fly with little or no risk. Read your own link:

So that allows for most pregnant women up to about 8-8.5 months to be able to fly. The only ones who should not are those with complications.

As for the blood clot/circulation point, re-read the website. It can happen to anyone, based on being sedentary for prolonged periods of time. Yes, pregnant women have more circulatory issues, but for the most part, they are NOT severe, can be alleviated with stretching and should not get in the way of their ability to fly. However, small seats with no space between them make this more difficult. Next.

You really hate to admit or even acknowledge that you're wrong, don't you?


This is the captain putting his hands over his eyes and ears and going "lalallalalalalalla i can't hear you....."

I am taking the assumption that the captain is of the plus sized population or is related to one......

BTW: nice try at the "dr tboy barb" but that obviously hit you in the face like a pie......that site specifically reiterated what I posted. EOS.
 
tboy said:
This is the captain putting his hands over his eyes and ears and going "lalallalalalalalla i can't hear you....."

I am taking the assumption that the captain is of the plus sized population or is related to one......
That's why you're an ass. I'm just tall(ish.)

You took "pregnant" and went all tboy-the-pedant, based on your very limited and obviously unworldly "knowledge", claiming that pregnant women should not fly, when the fact is that the vast majority of pregnant women can fly with no problems or issues. You made the minority into the case for all. You might want to edumacate yerself and get some of that book learnin'.

Typical example of tboy "logic." There's a new thread on bad cops that you should go and hijack. ;)
 
ReaganLevy said:
...Maybe girth would be a better way to determine when a person needs two seats...
Raising once again the age-old question: length, or girth?
 
Captain Fantastic said:
That's why you're an ass. I'm just tall(ish.)

You took "pregnant" and went all tboy-the-pedant, based on your very limited and obviously unworldly "knowledge", claiming that pregnant women should not fly, when the fact is that the vast majority of pregnant women can fly with no problems or issues. You made the minority into the case for all. You might want to edumacate yerself and get some of that book learnin'.

Typical example of tboy "logic." There's a new thread on bad cops that you should go and hijack. ;)

and your posts are indicative of how you should really take reading comp.

I did NOT say "pregnant women should not fly".

Inmy post you quoted, you obviously failed to read the entire post. I specifically said:

... and if a woman is that pregnant, she shouldn't be flying........

That indicating that she is well along in her pregnancy and as supported by the site I provided, I was correct in my original post. TYVM.
 
You're just obfuscating now - making up b.s. excuses for your constant need to argue

tboy said:
and your posts are indicative of how you should really take reading comp.

I did NOT say "pregnant women should not fly".

Inmy post you quoted, you obviously failed to read the entire post. I specifically said:

That indicating that she is well along in her pregnancy and as supported by the site I provided, I was correct in my original post. TYVM.
:confused:

Because we're all supposed to know what "that" pregnant means? I suppose you have never seen women at five or six months that are as big as a house? Again, thanks "doctor" tboy, web M.D. Next time try and be clear about what "that" means then, ok? Just so I don't waste my time and this site's bandwidth.

My mistake was thinking you would actually try and have an intelligent discussion instead of just watching you show off "tboy logic" and the need to be right, even if you're talking out your ass... umptions.

"That" pregnant. (shaking head)
 
I'll say it again.
I'm 6'3" and currently 237 lbs.
I am in decent shape.
I am not obese.
Could I lose a few lbs? Sure.
I am just a big guy - always have been.
Even in highschool and university I was between 6'1" and 6'3" and between about 210-220.
I was a linebacker in football and an 8-man in rugby.
Why should I be charged extra because I'm over 200 just so the airlines can jam extra seats on a plane and ram people in like sardines?
Are they going to start charging the Buffalo Bills team members extra, for example, for being large men? Don't think so.
 
Captain Fantastic said:
How about this? If you're black, you should be seated at the back? Otherwise, how far removed are we from, "Hey n!gger, get to the back of the bus!"?

The racism analogy does not work here. And you know that. The use of that argument does not advance this discussion. I am afraid that it actually detracts from everything else you are saying, by bringing your emotional objectivity into question.

A person's skin colour does not cause physical intrusion into another person's paid-for space. This is not about fat-bashing or a person's right to be overweight. It is about where that right ends (ie. when it encroaches on someone else's physical space, in this example).
 
CapitalGuy said:
The racism analogy does not work here. And you know that. The use of that argument does not advance this discussion. I am afraid that it actually detracts from everything else you are saying, by bringing your emotional objectivity into question.

A person's skin colour does not cause physical intrusion into another person's paid-for space. This is not about fat-bashing or a person's right to be overweight. It is about where that right ends (ie. when it encroaches on someone else's physical space, in this example).
I can see what you're saying, but it really isn't that far removed from saying "I don't want some n@#$%r sitting next to me!"

Someone used the example of a person smelling terribly, another, a baby crying, etc. These are all intrusions to someone's sensibilities (and to a lesser extent, rights), just as skin colour unfortunately is to others.

It was exaggeration to make a point. Like I said, I understand your concern with it, but c'est la vie. The anti-fat brigade ruined the thread long ago.

To me, the space encroachment issue is more a product of the airlines reducing seat size and cramming the seats too close together. It should be up to the airlines to find a solution.
 
CapitalGuy said:
The racism analogy does not work here. And you know that. The use of that argument does not advance this discussion. I am afraid that it actually detracts from everything else you are saying, by bringing your emotional objectivity into question.

A person's skin colour does not cause physical intrusion into another person's paid-for space. This is not about fat-bashing or a person's right to be overweight. It is about where that right ends (ie. when it encroaches on someone else's physical space, in this example).

Then why the comments on buffets, flatbed trucks, etc.?

Say this were a debate on affirmative action. And the people against AA are using racial slurs and epithets.

And then ... It's not about race; it's about merit. There is no racism; so we don't need AA.
 
Bale said:
2) Don't charge big people more, charge people under 200 lbs less - like half price. It will give bigger people incentive to lose weight! :D

Good idea!

Also, If flight attendants see a skinny person SQUiSHED by an obese person, they should move the skinny guy/girl up into business class if there is a seat open up there!
 
dj1470 said:
Would the airlines consider me obese because I barely fit in the seat due to my body size?
I wouldn't, nor would the airline. I didn't start this thread to cause grief for large but height/weight proportional people. Clearly there's nothing they can do about that.

I'm talking about the guy I sat beside flying to Calgary recently, who was perhaps 5'8" and weighed in at about 320 to 350 pounds. He was just plain fat. It wasn't genetics, because he ate non stop for the entire flight. He probably gained 15 pounds en route!

To make matters worse, he was in the centre seat and got up to pee (or something) about 6 times. I suspect that this was partly because he was very uncomfortable in his seat. I usually take the aisle seat, so had to move every time. After the third time, I suggested changing seats, but he was enjoying talking to the woman in the window seat.
 
Stoo - sounds like your seatmate was a real asshole. No concern for his actions' impact on those around him. How un-Canadian, eh?