Eight steps to immediately accelerate climate action

I just started taking a look at it. But these are the kinds of figures below that I have a problem with. In the figure below, as you can see they say that the observed changes to ecosystem structure is globally "High or Very High". My question is, what is the baseline? What does high, very high, medium mean? Is this quantifiable or is it qualitative? What is the tolerance for calling something High vs Medium? Are the changes observed to the ecosystem solely due to human impact? If that was the case how was that observed/measured? I mean this seems very open to interpretation and consulting-y. The reason I ask is that according to NASA (and guaranteed they are not climate scientists), have said that the world is far greener today than it was 20 years ago. So if that is the case, how are ecosystems being destroyed? Maybe they have covered this in subsequent pages, which I havent read yet, but just throwing that out there off the top of my head.

View attachment 192709

That's the summary, so if you want the details of those numbers including confidence values and links to the research, you need to read the full IPCC reports.
The summary does give links to the reports where those findings are published.
If you want answers to your questions they are there, but you have to do a bit of work.
 
  • Like
Reactions: krealtarron
A biased hypothesis could be - "Is there a human impact to climate change"? Of course, there is. But that is just half the story imo. Question is how significant? I dont think it is significant enough to warrant immediate urgent action.

My point is, sure lets take steps to tackle climate change. But not with the urgency that this article advocates for. Gradually and incrementally is the way to go while prioritizing bigger issues like poverty, homelessness etc.,

how significant is the important question

absorption of infrared radiation by organic molecules has a logarithmic relationship to concentration
incremental additions to concentration result in diminishing returns of incremental absorption

it is call the Beer-Lambert Law -

1670131455939.png
there is no climate emergency

1670131309761.jpeg

a reasonable anology is painting a barn red
the first coat turns the barn red, after the second coat of paint, it appear to be more red, the third coat, a slightly deeper red. by the time you get to coat #7 or 8, you cannot perceive the different of the incremental coating of paint
 
Last edited:
how significant is the important question

absorption of infrared radiation by organic molecules has a logarithmic relationship to concentration
incremental additions to concentration result in diminishing returns of incremental absorption

it is call the Beer-Lambert Law -

View attachment 192726
there is no climate emergency

That's a two dimensional solution to a three dimensional problem.
You miss several important factors, though its likely you won't be able to understand them.
And don't pretend to ignore this post, it'll just prove I'm right.
 
How did a thread on climate action turn into another round of "Look, Russia had no choice but to invade Ukraine because the US wouldn't force NATO to change its charter and also agree to all of Russia's demands"?
 
How did a thread on climate action turn into another round of "Look, Russia had no choice but to invade Ukraine because the US wouldn't force NATO to change its charter and also agree to all of Russia's demands"?
Because of me. Shouldn't have brought up Putin's response to Thunberg :ROFLMAO:
 
Today's stat.

The G20 represents 80% of the fossil fuel market and together they subsidize the oil&gas industry by $190 billion USD a year.
 
What do you mean there were no clear cut choices? I cited a Pew Research poll that polled the locals for their opinion. 91% of them found the results of the referendum fair.

Despite Putin's view that Belarus and Ukraine, actually belong to Russia (aka the USSR), which is a debatable position, Putin's concern considering NATO are very real and legitimate. Just look at the way NATO has been expanding closer and closer to Russia over the last 30 years. Putin very aptly asked in a press conference recently, before the war started if Russia was the one with nuclear missiles near NATO countries. You cannot expect to put nuclear missiles near your rival and hide behind "Oh these are sovereign nations and they can do what they want" bit. You are forming a military alliance and threatening another sovereign nation and provoking them so they are going to react! It isn't any different from what the US did during the Cuban missile crisis.



Ukraine most definitely DID NOT have free and fair elections and is most definitely NOT a functioning democracy. It is infact a banana republic that is corrupt and divided internally with the east supporting Russia and the west supporting EU. That is reality. Yanukovych fled office after the Euromaidan protests that many in eastern Ukraine and Crimea consider a Coup D'eat. So opinions are divided even within Ukraine. Russia invaded for the simple reason that they weren't going to allow Ukraine to join NATO. If Ukraine and the west had given assurances to Russia that Ukraine will remain neutral, then there wouldn't be war. Putin has been sitting on Ukraine's borders for the last 8 years, he isn't going to back down without these assurances. These are practical geopolitical considerations that need practical and realistic solutions. You cannot argue this away with rhetoric. This is the same thing that happened with Georgia back in 2008, when Georgia tried to join NATO. Putin has always stood firm, that he wont let anyone else join NATO.

Does this seem like a fair Referendum to you? Especially when there was no choice on the ballot to remain as part of Ukraine!!

By early March, the Russian military had control of Crimea. Crimean authorities then proposed a referendum, which was held on March 16. It proved an illegitimate sham. To begin with, the referendum was illegal under Ukrainian law. Moreover, it offered voters two choices: to join Russia, or to restore Crimea’s 1992 constitution, which would have entailed significantly greater autonomy from Kyiv. Those on the peninsula who favored Crimea remaining a part of Ukraine under the current constitutional arrangements found no box to check.

The referendum unsurprisingly produced a Soviet-style result: 97 percent allegedly voted to join Russia with a turnout of 83 percent. A true referendum, fairly conducted, might have shown a significant number of Crimean voters in favor of joining Russia. Some 60 percent were ethnic Russians, and many might have concluded their economic situation would be better as a part Russia.

It was not, however, a fair referendum. It was conducted in polling places under armed guard, with no credible international observers, and with Russian journalists reporting that they had been allowed to vote. Two months later, a member of Putin’s Human Rights Council let slip that turnout had been more like 30 percent, with only half voting to join Russia.

Maybe the majority would have voted to be part of Russia, but that whole referendum was illegal. But it is hilarious when you are denouncing Ukraine's Elections that observers from all around the globe were given access to, as compared to Russia that is the most corrupt nation where the resources go just to Putin and his crooked Oligarchs. ROTFLMAO!!

Again there was zero evidence that NATO intended to station nuclear missiles and 100% unlike The Soviets intention in Cuba. Of course Putin hates democracy and will continue to poison his dissenters!! Again any neighbours sharing a border with Russia have not been admitted to NATO. So if Putin does not continue his ridiculous Lous aggression against his neighbours then he has nothing to worry about. The excuse about joining NATO and persecution by the Nazis in the Donbas region is beyond redemption.

I am generally talking about climate change alarmists. My comments were not specifically about Ireland.

Well your comments about emergency measures to shut down the oil refineries etc, is alarmist itself as Canada and nations around the Globe will phase them out when the alternative green resources can fully replace them. Nothing alarmist about addressing Climate Change when Nations around the Globe are feeling the full impact of it!!
 
How did a thread on climate action turn into another round of "Look, Russia had no choice but to invade Ukraine because the US wouldn't force NATO to change its charter and also agree to all of Russia's demands"?

Well I am being told that Putin is justified in his actions, and Ukraine along with Climate Change Activists such as Greta Thunberg are the bad guys!! :rolleyes:
 
Does this seem like a fair Referendum to you? Especially when there was no choice on the ballot to remain as part of Ukraine!!
Well the people of Crimea found the referendum to be fair. It doesn't matter what you think. 91% of them found it to be fair, so I think it is good.

Maybe the majority would have voted to be part of Russia, but that whole referendum was illegal. But it is hilarious when you are denouncing Ukraine's Elections that observers from all around the globe were given access to, as compared to Russia that is the most corrupt nation where the resources go just to Putin and his crooked Oligarchs. ROTFLMAO!!
Because it doesn't matter if Russian elections are corrupt or not. What matters is Ukraine and its internal divide.

Again there was zero evidence that NATO intended to station nuclear missiles and 100% unlike The Soviets intention in Cuba. Of course Putin hates democracy and will continue to poison his dissenters!! Again any neighbours sharing a border with Russia have not been admitted to NATO. So if Putin does not continue his ridiculous Lous aggression against his neighbours then he has nothing to worry about. The excuse about joining NATO and persecution by the Nazis in the Donbas region is beyond redemption.
If you think NATO wouldn't place nuclear missiles in Ukraine if it joined NATO, then you are naive. And no country bordering Russia has joined NATO you say? Here is NATO expansion since 1990. As you can clearly see NATO is right on the border of Russia. How close would they be if Ukraine joined NATO? Can you not see NATO encircling Russia?

Also you are sitting here defending the biggest terrorist organization in the world - NATO, who illegally invade countries in the name of war on terror and institute regime change in countries they dont like.

0E9D4CE0-A2DC-43CD-BAFD-7118686BF833.jpeg

Well your comments about emergency measures to shut down the oil refineries etc, is alarmist itself as Canada and nations around the Globe will phase them out when the alternative green resources can fully replace them. Nothing alarmist about addressing Climate Change when Nations around the Globe are feeling the full impact of it!!
As I mentioned before, I have nothing against renewable sources of energy. However, gradually transitioning over a period is what is needed, not the next 5 years. That would devastate families and local economies.
 
Well the people of Crimea found the referendum to be fair. It doesn't matter what you think. 91% of them found it to be fair, so I think it is good.


Because it doesn't matter if Russian elections are corrupt or not. What matters is Ukraine and its internal divide.

It does matter.
If the referendum was as corrupt as Russian elections than your claim of 91% agreeing is total Russian propaganda.
 
It does matter.
If the referendum was as corrupt as Russian elections than your claim of 91% agreeing is total Russian propaganda.

That wasn't from Russia. That was from a Pew Research Poll, so it was neutral.
 
That wasn't from Russia. That was from a Pew Research Poll, so it was neutral.

Ah, but you assume that polls are trustworthy about an occupying force and under an occupying force?
Do you also think polls on Putin's popularity in Russia are accurate?
 
Well the people of Crimea found the referendum to be fair. It doesn't matter what you think. 91% of them found it to be fair, so I think it is good.

That is total BS, and as I posted the elections were about just 30% who cast their ballots, that were totally rigged!!

Because it doesn't matter if Russian elections are corrupt or not. What matters is Ukraine and its internal divide.

It does not matter if Russian Elections are corrupt? Really
So Russia is allowed to dictate how Nations conduct themselves? WOW!!

If you think NATO wouldn't place nuclear missiles in Ukraine if it joined NATO, then you are naive. And no country bordering Russia has joined NATO you say? Here is NATO expansion since 1990. As you can clearly see NATO is right on the border of Russia. How close would they be if Ukraine joined NATO? Can you not see NATO encircling Russia?

Also you are sitting here defending the biggest terrorist organization in the world - NATO, who illegally invade countries in the name of war on terror and institute regime change in countries they dont like.

View attachment 193192

Blame Russia for its actions and how repressive the Soviet Union used to be. That is why all the neighbours WANT TO JOIN NATO. One reason that you can add Finland and Sweden to the mix. But calling NATO the "Biggest Terrorist" organization is downright pathetic. Look at the damage that Russia has inflicted on Ukraine and how it has upended Millions and Millions from their homes and disrupted their lives, as well as killing thousands of civilians. This was supposed to be the "Peacekeeping Mission" to you!!

Well read what NATO is really about, while the actual terrorist is Putin and Russia:


As I mentioned before, I have nothing against renewable sources of energy. However, gradually transitioning over a period is what is needed, not the next 5 years. That would devastate families and local economies.

We have to go towards renewable energy and nothing alarmist about it. Again, Canada seems to be conducting it in a more pragmatic manner!!
 
Ah, but you assume that polls are trustworthy about an occupying force and under an occupying force?
Do you also think polls on Putin's popularity in Russia are accurate?
The poll was conducted amongst the locals of Crimea who are majority ethnic Russians and support Russia. Probably why they voted in favor or Russia in the first place. His annexation was really bloodless. He just stationed troops in key areas and called it his, which the people there supported. Infact 71% of them say their life is better after Russia took over
 
That is total BS, and as I posted the elections were about just 30% who cast their ballots, that were totally rigged!!

In any election, even here in Canada voter turnout isn't 100%. That is nobody's fault. Of the people who voted the majority voted in favor or Russia and in subsequent polls the majority found the referendum fair.

It does not matter if Russian Elections are corrupt? Really
So Russia is allowed to dictate how Nations conduct themselves? WOW!!

Russia is allowed to say that we dont want an enemy military alliance expanding towards our borders. That is what they are doing.

Blame Russia for its actions and how repressive the Soviet Union used to be. That is why all the neighbours WANT TO JOIN NATO. One reason that you can add Finland and Sweden to the mix. But calling NATO the "Biggest Terrorist" organization is downright pathetic. Look at the damage that Russia has inflicted on Ukraine and how it has upended Millions and Millions from their homes and disrupted their lives, as well as killing thousands of civilians. This was supposed to be the "Peacekeeping Mission" to you!!

Well read what NATO is really about, while the actual terrorist is Putin and Russia:


Finland and Sweden are neutral and not a part of NATO.

Oh really Russia is worse than NATO? Guess you forgot the Vietnam war, the Korean war, Gulf war, intervention in Libya, invasion of Afghanistan, invasion of Iraq - just to name a few. How many millions were killed/displaced because of NATO actions? PS: Dont tell me those were US wars - US undoubtedly leads NATO.

Also giving me a NATO link to defend NATO actions, is like showing me the bible when I ask you to prove god exists. Do better.

We have to go towards renewable energy and nothing alarmist about it. Again, Canada seems to be conducting it in a more pragmatic manner!!

If it is a pragmatic approach its all good.
 
We have to go towards renewable energy and nothing alarmist about it. Again, Canada seems to be conducting it in a more pragmatic manner!!

I too agree Canada is being pragmatic in conducting the transition
to renewable energy given our government's support of stepping
up oil drilling in deep water into the future even when we are already
producing more oil than we need.

----------------------------------------------
Offshore auction draws $238 million in Eastern Newfoundland Region bids

November 03, 2022


https://www.worldoil.com/news/2022/...-million-in-eastern-newfoundland-region-bids/
 
In any election, even here in Canada voter turnout isn't 100%. That is nobody's fault. Of the people who voted the majority voted in favor or Russia and in subsequent polls the majority found the referendum fair.

Nobody is saying that the elections have to be 100% turnout. Those referendums were conducted without UN Observers to monitor it. It is considered to be illegal by the UN.
There were no negotiations or agreement with Ukraine. It was a sham elections conducted by a despotic state such as Russia!!

Russia is allowed to say that we dont want an enemy military alliance expanding towards our borders. That is what they are doing.

Russia itself has been a threat to their neighbours. They are the rogue state with a despicable dictator called Putin!!

Finland and Sweden are neutral and not a part of NATO.

They both applied to join NATO and were waiting approval from two of the members such as Turkey and Hungary. The approval process has gone through for Finland and they have a date to be an official member. Sweden are awaiting their Turkey's approval. In that sense they support NATO and are not "Neutral".

Oh really Russia is worse than NATO? Guess you forgot the Vietnam war, the Korean war, Gulf war, intervention in Libya, invasion of Afghanistan, invasion of Iraq - just to name a few. How many millions were killed/displaced because of NATO actions? PS: Dont tell me those were US wars - US undoubtedly leads NATO.

Also giving me a NATO link to defend NATO actions, is like showing me the bible when I ask you to prove god exists. Do better.

If it is a pragmatic approach its all good.

You think that The Soviet Union were a Peaceful entity? Stalin butchered over millions of his own people. He created some of the biggest genocides since the World War II. No wonder that many Russians and other Soviet Union residents fled to the West. Did not come across that many want to go in the opposite direction. The Russians have to this day continued their bombings in Syria. They did so in Afghanistan and other former EU nations. Their own people have no right to even mention the war in Ukraine without compromising their own safety!!

But if you are living in a "Terrorist Nation" like Canada as we are part of NATO, then Russia will welcome you with open arms. So move there!!
 
I too agree Canada is being pragmatic in conducting the transition
to renewable energy given our government's support of stepping
up oil drilling in deep water into the future even when we are already
producing more oil than we need.

----------------------------------------------
Offshore auction draws $238 million in Eastern Newfoundland Region bids

November 03, 2022


https://www.worldoil.com/news/2022/...-million-in-eastern-newfoundland-region-bids/

There is a crisis in Europe and other nations, thanks to krealtarron's heroes such as Russia's Putin conducting a "Peacekeeping Operation" in the Ukraine. That is why in the short term globally there is a need for Canada's Oil and other Energy resources. Yes, that is why it is a pragmatic approach for now!!
 
Nobody is saying that the elections have to be 100% turnout. Those referendums were conducted without UN Observers to monitor it. It is considered to be illegal by the UN.
There were no negotiations or agreement with Ukraine. It was a sham elections conducted by a despotic state such as Russia!!

The UN is one of the most useless organizations ever. That said as I mentioned before, independent polls such as the one conducted by the Pew Research Center have revealed that the locals of Crimea consider the referendum free and fair.

Russia itself has been a threat to their neighbours. They are the rogue state with a despicable dictator called Putin!!

The US is the definition of a rogue state. Russia only meddles in its borders because of NATO. The US has over 750 foreign military bases which they use to bully other nations.

They both applied to join NATO and were waiting approval from two of the members such as Turkey and Hungary. The approval process has gone through for Finland and they have a date to be an official member. Sweden are awaiting their Turkey's approval. In that sense they support NATO and are not "Neutral".

Sure, they are formally not members yet. Time will tell what role they will play. But Finland joining NATO is indeed a checkmate to Russia.

You think that The Soviet Union were a Peaceful entity? Stalin butchered over millions of his own people. He created some of the biggest genocides since the World War II. No wonder that many Russians and other Soviet Union residents fled to the West. Did not come across that many want to go in the opposite direction. The Russians have to this day continued their bombings in Syria. They did so in Afghanistan and other former EU nations. Their own people have no right to even mention the war in Ukraine without compromising their own safety!!

But if you are living in a "Terrorist Nation" like Canada as we are part of NATO, then Russia will welcome you with open arms. So move there!!

So all that means is no one is innocent. You were arguing earlier as if NATO has moral high ground. They dont. They are just as much responsible for this war as Russia is. They dont give a fuck about Ukraine. The only thing they are interested in is checkmating Russia and you have blinders on to be parroting their rhetoric.