Eight steps to immediately accelerate climate action

No they dont have to pay them off. They just have to test a hypothesis that is biased.

Also if the argument is that climate change is happening then I dont have any disagreements with that conclusion, as I have said before. I just don't agree with the prioritizing climate change above all else. There are far greater issues to take care of before we get to climate change.

I never said 99.9% of them were paid off. I said they could be testing a biased hypothesis. That said, if the contrarians are taking oil money, is it not entirely possible that atleast some of the ones agreeing are taking money from some other party that stands to financially gain from climate change initiatives ? Why is skepticism in this case unacceptable?

What do you mean a 'biased hypothesis'?
If you test a hypothesis that's wrong your results will show it to be wrong.

I see, so you think even making a hypothesis about anthropomorphic climate change is wrong because its 'biased'?
So even when Exxon paid scientists ran the numbers and came up withe result that burning Exxon products would cause the amount of warming we see today is somehow biased?

And as far as funding goes, if you pay someone to come up with wrong numbers their results will be different from the consensus.
Which is not the case with climatologists in general.
The only ones both getting paid by the oil industry and coming up with contrarian results are the 'contrarians'.
2 + 2, you know.


Warming and cooling of the earth, along with changes in global temperatures has occurred throughout history. Along with polar vortices and other climate/weather phenomenon. To suddenly blame it solely human actions is ridiculous. Again, yes there is an impact. But I think that impact is minimal, but is being overstated for financial gain. There are plenty of countries that are not even developed and do not actually have anything to do with out of control climate change because they aren't even industrialized enough.

Not on this time scale, except for a massive super volcano or asteroid.
and do some basic research, the polar vortexes are a new change with recent changes to the jet stream. Just denying it without checking doesn't wor
 
What does Putin's actions in Ukraine have anything to do with his response to Thunberg? I called her a little shit, cuz she is annoying as fuck. She is a privileged little white girl from fucking Sweden, who sits up there and goes "My childhood has been stolen! How dARe you!!!". Really? Your childhood was stolen cuz of climate change of all things? What a fucking joke!

Childhoods stolen because of climate change.

_126504403_gettyimages-1242726142_kids976.jpg
 
  • Like
Reactions: bver_hunter
What does Putin's actions in Ukraine have anything to do with his response to Thunberg? I called her a little shit, cuz she is annoying as fuck. She is a privileged little white girl from fucking Sweden, who sits up there and goes "My childhood has been stolen! How dARe you!!!". Really? Your childhood was stolen cuz of climate change of all things? What a fucking joke! Do you really want me to point you to actual children in 3rd world nations, whose childhood has been stolen because of grinding poverty? Heck, those children never had their childhood in the first place!!. It is a very arrogant, tone deaf, first world take.

Secondly, I responded to your data. In the past, manufacturing was done in the west. So emissions were high here. Now manufacturing is done in developing nations, BECAUSE western companies outsourced it there. The goods manufactured there are still being imported and consumed by people HERE. So for you to arrogantly state that developing nations should do something about their emissions, while simultaneously benefitting from it, is utter arrogance and ignorance.

This is exactly what Vijay Prashad talks about in the video. Not sure if you even cared to watch it.

Putin is a despicable character in what he has done in Ukraine. Cannot believe a single piece of crap that he spews from his nostrils. What Thunberg is saying about her generation and the impact this Climate Change will have on them is a cause for concern. Putin on the other hand is here for his own personal interests and that of his rich and corrupt oligarchs that he shares the spoils with on a regular basis. He does not give a rats ass about anything in the manner that he has destroyed the infrastructure and slaughtered the lives of several residents there. Then he cares about the environment in any way?? Really!!

Again you are not listening. Yes, as I posted those two images, in the past regarding Climate Change and Green House Gas Emissions were largely the responsibility of the Developed nations. So we are now continuing to see those emissions on a large scale emitted by the Developing Nations that is an impact on a more severe scale mainly the developing nations. Their crops failures due to severe droughts or inclement weather is causing them to undergo food shortages leading to hunger and poverty, as the real research indicates. No one is asking these nations to curtail their production and manufacturing factories, but to prepare to switch over to more renewable and greener energy sources. That is why targets are being set to be acceptable to all nations. If countries like China can invest in these greener resources, then why is it such an issue?

China is leading in renewable energy investments


If Putin and Russia did the same instead of wasting Billions of dollars on a meaningless war that is destroying lives, causing more homelessness, hunger, poverty and destruction, the world would have been moving into a more positive direction!!
 
Putin is a despicable character in what he has done in Ukraine. Cannot believe a single piece of crap that he spews from his nostrils. What Thunberg is saying about her generation and the impact this Climate Change will have on them is a cause for concern. Putin on the other hand is here for his own personal interests and that of his rich and corrupt oligarchs that he shares the spoils with on a regular basis. He does not give a rats ass about anything in the manner that he has destroyed the infrastructure and slaughtered the lives of several residents there. Then he cares about the environment in any way?? Really!!

Firstly, the video I posted is a 2 minute response to what he thinks about Greta Thunberg. It has absolutely nothing to do with Ukraine.

That said, and I am digressing here, the crisis in Ukraine is not just because of Putin, it is also because of NATO and the west. Putin is legitimately worried that if Ukraine joins NATO, NATO will place nuclear tipped missiles at their borders. How did the US react during the Cuban Missile crisis? Did they not freak out and come close to war? Which country has nuclear missiles next to the other's border? Is it Russia? So although the current war in Ukraine is despicable, Russia had no choice. All the west had to do was to tell Putin that Ukraine wont join NATO. Did they do that? No.

Again you are not listening. Yes, as I posted those two images, in the past regarding Climate Change and Green House Gas Emissions were largely the responsibility of the Developed nations. So we are now continuing to see those emissions on a large scale emitted by the Developing Nations that is an impact on a more severe scale mainly the developing nations. Their crops failures due to severe droughts or inclement weather is causing them to undergo food shortages leading to hunger and poverty, as the real research indicates. No one is asking these nations to curtail their production and manufacturing factories, but to prepare to switch over to more renewable and greener energy sources. That is why targets are being set to be acceptable to all nations. If countries like China can invest in these greener resources, then why is it such an issue?

You are continuing to see increasing emissions from developing nations today BECAUSE of the manufacturing industries there. What part how of we have outsourced almost all manufacturing to the developing world do you not get? China literally manufactures even our buttons, nuts and bolts! Do you think manufacturing is possible without emissions? If those things were manufactured here then we would see similar emissions here. Doesn't mean we have done something great to reduce emissions. We have merely moved our share of emissions to the developing world, thats all and washed our hands of all responsibility, while blaming developing nations. AGAIN watch Vijay Prashad's answer in that video I posted.

I am not even talking about population here - the developing world hosts 80% of the worlds population. So surely there will be more emissions from there?

Also to say they have crop failures and therefore droughts and poverty is ridiculous. India and China actually have a food surplus. They are also are in the top 4 food producers in the world.

It is also a statement of fact that the world is today a greener place than 20 or 30 years ago. Look that up.

All of that said, sure invest in greener energy sources. But dont take rash decisions like prioritizing climate initiatives over more existential issues. Or shutting down fossil fuel plants effectively rendering thousands without jobs overnight.
 
Last edited:
What do you mean a 'biased hypothesis'?
If you test a hypothesis that's wrong your results will show it to be wrong.

I see, so you think even making a hypothesis about anthropomorphic climate change is wrong because its 'biased'?
So even when Exxon paid scientists ran the numbers and came up withe result that burning Exxon products would cause the amount of warming we see today is somehow biased?

And as far as funding goes, if you pay someone to come up with wrong numbers their results will be different from the consensus.
Which is not the case with climatologists in general.
The only ones both getting paid by the oil industry and coming up with contrarian results are the 'contrarians'.
2 + 2, you know.

Not on this time scale, except for a massive super volcano or asteroid.
and do some basic research, the polar vortexes are a new change with recent changes to the jet stream. Just denying it without checking doesn't wor

A biased hypothesis could be - "Is there a human impact to climate change"? Of course, there is. But that is just half the story imo. Question is how significant? I dont think it is significant enough to warrant immediate urgent action.

My point is, sure lets take steps to tackle climate change. But not with the urgency that this article advocates for. Gradually and incrementally is the way to go while prioritizing bigger issues like poverty, homelessness etc.,
 
  • Like
Reactions: JohnLarue
Firstly, the video I posted is a 2 minute response to what he thinks about Greta Thunberg. It has absolutely nothing to do with Ukraine.

That said, and I am digressing here, the crisis in Ukraine is not just because of Putin, it is also because of NATO and the west. Putin is legitimately worried that if Ukraine joins NATO, NATO will place nuclear tipped missiles at their borders. How did the US react during the Cuban Missile crisis? Did they not freak out and come close to war? Which country has nuclear missiles next to the other's border? Is it Russia? So although the current war in Ukraine is despicable, Russia had no choice. All the west had to do was to tell Putin that Ukraine wont join NATO. Did they do that? No.

First of all Thunberg and Putin had nothing to do with the emissions. You brought it on, with an individual who lied about his intentions with Ukraine. First of all denying that he would invade Ukraine and condemning the West and the US Intel Agencies for the advance warning of his eventual intentions. They were 100% correct and Putin is the liar!!
But you must be a correspondent for RT News. Blaming the West for Putin's invasion of Ukraine? First of all Russia has always threatened Ukraine, invaded Crimea and annexed it. They armed the Russian backed militias in Ukraine, and even now wanted to annex the Donbas region. So does Ukraine not have a concern about its own security? Is Russia's security more important to you? NATO has had no plans to place any Nuclear Tipped Missiles in Ukraine. Show us where you picked up that evidence. NATO would have admitted Ukraine into NATO a long time ago if they had wanted to. But they refrained from doing so as Ukraine had a border with Russia. Neither have they decided to let any other of Russia's immediate neighbours into NATO. But your comparison with the Soviet Union and Cuba is outrageous. The Soviet Union were on the verge of storing those Nuclear Weapons in Cuba. That is when they were warned against it. But was there a US invasion of Cuba since then??

You are continuing to see increasing emissions from developing nations today BECAUSE of the manufacturing industries there. What part how of we have outsourced almost all manufacturing to the developing world do you not get? China literally manufactures even our buttons, nuts and bolts! Do you think manufacturing is possible without emissions? If those things were manufactured here then we would see similar emissions here. Doesn't mean we have done something great to reduce climate change. We have merely moved our share of emissions to the developing world, thats all and washed our hands of all responsibility, while blaming developing nations. AGAIN watch Vijay Prashad's answer in that video I posted.

I am not even talking about population here - the developing world hosts 80% of the worlds population. So surely there will be more emissions from there?

Also to say they have crop failures and therefore droughts and poverty is ridiculous. India and China actually have a food surplus. They are also are in the top 4 food producers in the world.

It is also a statement of fact that the world is today a greener place than 20 or 30 years ago. Look that up.

All of that said, sure invest in greener energy sources. But dont take rash decisions like prioritizing climate initiatives over more existential issues. Or shutting down fossil fuel plants effectively rendering thousands without jobs overnight.

Once again if China who are manufacturing a lot of the items and are trying to do so in the future with also meeting their targets in CO2 Emissions, then does that not address everything that you are concerned about? What is your problem there? Again we are not discussing about shutting all fossil fuels production facilities overnight. This is about a gradual phasing out in an orderly manner when we have the greener facilities that would eventually take over the jobs of the fossil fuel sector. Do not know why you are repeating the whole population statistics. We are talking about all nations doing their part. We had an idiot of a previous POTUS who rashly pulled out of this Agreement.

African Nations are more severely affected by this crisis:


Yes, generally there are no food shortages in India and China, although their rice production has been hit with the flooding etc in some of the states. Rice is a stable food in both India and China. But again India has been quite a big emitter of green house gases, especially from coal powered factories etc. They have had the worst smog and air pollution that is exacerbated by their farmers burning stubble and adding to the the coal factories emissions. That is why there are also severe health issues in India!!
 
First of all Thunberg and Putin had nothing to do with the emissions. You brought it on, with an individual who lied about his intentions with Ukraine. First of all denying that he would invade Ukraine and condemning the West and the US Intel Agencies for the advance warning of his eventual intentions. They were 100% correct and Putin is the liar!!
But you must be a correspondent for RT News. Blaming the West for Putin's invasion of Ukraine? First of all Russia has always threatened Ukraine, invaded Crimea and annexed it. They armed the Russian backed militias in Ukraine, and even now wanted to annex the Donbas region. So does Ukraine not have a concern about its own security? Is Russia's security more important to you? NATO has had no plans to place any Nuclear Tipped Missiles in Ukraine. Show us where you picked up that evidence. NATO would have admitted Ukraine into NATO a long time ago if they had wanted to. But they refrained from doing so as Ukraine had a border with Russia. Neither have they decided to let any other of Russia's immediate neighbours into NATO. But your comparison with the Soviet Union and Cuba is outrageous. The Soviet Union were on the verge of storing those Nuclear Weapons in Cuba. That is when they were warned against it. But was there a US invasion of Cuba since then??

Crimea was leased to Russia by Ukraine. Russia just claimed it as its own with 99% approval from the citizens of Crimea. Similarly the people of Donbas and Luhansk are majority ethnic Russians who are pro-Russia. Ukraine itself is very divided. For instance in the 2010 elections, Tymoshenko was the pro-EU, pro-NATO candidate, and Yanukovych the pro-Russian candidate.

AE200521-A18B-45B6-95AA-3D38FFE7E653.jpeg

NATO had no plans to place nuclear missiles in Ukraine, because Ukraine was not yet a part of NATO. Had Russia allowed them to, the US would do what they have done with Turkey and other NATO nations - placed nuclear missiles there. Also check the expansion of NATO since 1990 and you'd see how they have been continuously moving east, which is very much a threat to Russia. Not saying Russia is right in this war, but the west left them no choice.

And my comparison with Cuba is exactly the same as this situation. US parking nuclear missiles in eastern EU is the same as Russia parking nukes in Cuba.

That said, we need to table this Ukraine-Russia stuff as it is digressing from what we were talking about in this thread.

0E9D4CE0-A2DC-43CD-BAFD-7118686BF833.jpeg

Once again if China who are manufacturing a lot of the items and are trying to do so in the future with also meeting their targets in CO2 Emissions, then does that not address everything that you are concerned about? What is your problem there? Again we are not discussing about shutting all fossil fuels production facilities overnight. This is about a gradual phasing out in an orderly manner when we have the greener facilities that would eventually take over the jobs of the fossil fuel sector. Do not know why you are repeating the whole population statistics. We are talking about all nations doing their part. We had an idiot of a previous POTUS who rashly pulled out of this Agreement.

I dont have disagreements here. Like I said many times before, incrementally and gradually while prioritizing more important issues such as poverty, illiteracy, infrastructure etc. I am only against alarmist climate politics like this article calls for - to use emergency powers to shut down fossil fuel industries.
 
Last edited:
A biased hypothesis could be - "Is there a human impact to climate change"? Of course, there is. But that is just half the story imo. Question is how significant? I dont think it is significant enough to warrant immediate urgent action.

My point is, sure lets take steps to tackle climate change. But not with the urgency that this article advocates for. Gradually and incrementally is the way to go while prioritizing bigger issues like poverty, homelessness etc.,

Humans are releasing greenhouse gases into the atmosphere.
So you think its biased to investigate whether that has an effect on the climate?

That's ridiculous.

The science is pretty basic, we've known about the greenhouse effect for a century. Its not biased to investigate how big an effect that has.
Ok, even if you step away from the science you could listen to the most conservative industry, insurance.
The insurance industry says there was $115 billion in extreme weather damage last year globally, an increase of 45%.

That's hitting people all over the world, in Australia, for instance, insurance for weather based events and fires are now too expensive or unavailable for large parts of the country.

Your arguments are weak.
 
Humans are releasing greenhouse gases into the atmosphere.
So you think its biased to investigate whether that has an effect on the climate?

No it is perfectly legitimate to investigate that. My disagreement is with climate alarmists. If someone says, there is a human impact on the climate, I agree. How could there not be with 8 billion people, all the factories and industries and what not?

However, if someone says, we have to make changes NOW. Shut down fossil fuel industries NOW etc, then that I do not agree with. I don't think the situation is that dire. Thats hyperbole.

Slow, incremental and steady changes while focusing on more existential issues such as poverty, illiteracy, access to healthcare, homelessness, infrastructure etc, should be top priority. Climate change initiatives can take a back seat for the time being.

What is disagreeable to you with this position?
 
No it is perfectly legitimate to investigate that. My disagreement is with climate alarmists. If someone says, there is a human impact on the climate, I agree. How could there not be with 8 billion people, all the factories and industries and what not?

However, if someone says, we have to make changes NOW. Shut down fossil fuel industries NOW etc, then that I do not agree with. I don't think the situation is that dire. Thats hyperbole.

Slow, incremental and steady changes while focusing on more existential issues such as poverty, illiteracy, access to healthcare, homelessness, infrastructure etc, should be top priority. Climate change initiatives can take a back seat for the time being.

What is disagreeable to you with this position?

Tipping points.

If we move slow, which means essentially doing nothing, we'll hit major tipping points that will start larger feedbacks.
AMOC, polar vortex, permafrost melt, polar melts....

We could have moved slowly had we actually listened to the scientists 3 or 4 decades ago.
Now we are close to 1.5ºC, if we hit much past 2ºC we run the risk of thermal maximums in 100 years.

Essentially, if we don't do massive changes in the next 3-5 years we'll be on a path for massive change in the climate.
You just want to save the oil industry over saving the climate, which will hit those that live in poverty and global infrastructure the hardest.
 
Tipping points.

If we move slow, which means essentially doing nothing, we'll hit major tipping points that will start larger feedbacks.
AMOC, polar vortex, permafrost melt, polar melts....

We could have moved slowly had we actually listened to the scientists 3 or 4 decades ago.
Now we are close to 1.5ºC, if we hit much past 2ºC we run the risk of thermal maximums in 100 years.

Essentially, if we don't do massive changes in the next 3-5 years we'll be on a path for massive change in the climate.
You just want to save the oil industry over saving the climate, which will hit those that live in poverty and global infrastructure the hardest.

I think that is massive overreaction. What is the actual impact of the tipping point? What happens when we hit 2C? Like actual every day impact? I am sure if you actually see the impact, it will be manageable. Plus with incremental changes, (and moving slow isn't equal to doing nothing), means we will slow the effect of climate change.
 
Crimea was leased to Russia by Ukraine. Russia just claimed it as its own with 99% approval from the citizens of Crimea. Similarly the people of Donbas and Luhansk are majority ethnic Russians who are pro-Russia. Ukraine itself is very divided. For instance in the 2010 elections, Tymoshenko was the pro-EU, pro-NATO candidate, and Yanukovych the pro-Russian candidate.

View attachment 192608

NATO had no plans to place nuclear missiles in Ukraine, because Ukraine was not yet a part of NATO. Had Russia allowed them to, the US would do what they have done with Turkey and other NATO nations - placed nuclear missiles there. Also check the expansion of NATO since 1990 and you'd see how they have been continuously moving east, which is very much a threat to Russia. Not saying Russia is right in this war, but the west left them no choice.

And my comparison with Cuba is exactly the same as this situation. US parking nuclear missiles in eastern EU is the same as Russia parking nukes in Cuba.

That said, we need to table this Ukraine-Russia stuff as it is digressing from what we were talking about in this thread.
Let's get the basic fact straight. Crimea was not leased to Russia. It was just the naval facilities that was on lease for 20years until 1997 for 97 million dollars. Now the Russians would offset this payment with the supply of oil etc. However, the Russians invaded the whole of Crimea and annexed it eventually after Yanukovych left office at the behest of the majority of Ukrainians. The elections in Crimea was a clear sham, just like the recent ones in the Donbas region. Most of the Ukrainians were uprooted from their homes in Crimea and fled to the main Ukrainian region. The fact is that Russia wanted to takeover Kyiv and install their own puppet leader. Yanukovych is a perfect fit for Putin:


Every nation has the divine right to join an International Treaty and Ukraine should not be an exception. If NATO wanted to "plant" those Nuclear Weapons they would have admitted Ukraine several years ago. The majority of Ukraine citizens want to be a part of NATO as they feel that their security is threatened by Putin and they are justified in their beliefs. The Soviet Union were planting Nuclear Weapons in Cuba, but had reverse that decision when threatened by the USA!!

I dont have disagreements here. Like I said many times before, incrementally and gradually while prioritizing more important issues such as poverty, illiteracy, infrastructure etc. I am only against alarmist climate politics like this article calls for - to use emergency powers to shut down fossil fuel industries.

The Emergency policies are just for Ireland, but it is not to just shut down the fossil fuel industries. More like accelerating the Renewable Energy so that they can slash the amount of energy obtained from the Fossil Fuel Industry. After all Ireland has to import the vast majority of the Fossil Fuel Energy that it is dependant on. So not sure why it is a problem to accelerate its move to the Renewables as a viable alternative?
 
Let's get the basic fact straight. Crimea was not leased to Russia. It was just the naval facilities that was on lease for 20years until 1997 for 97 million dollars. Now the Russians would offset this payment with the supply of oil etc. However, the Russians invaded the whole of Crimea and annexed it eventually after Yanukovych left office at the behest of the majority of Ukrainians. The elections in Crimea was a clear sham, just like the recent ones in the Donbas region. Most of the Ukrainians were uprooted from their homes in Crimea and fled to the main Ukrainian region. The fact is that Russia wanted to takeover Kyiv and install their own puppet leader. Yanukovych is a perfect fit for Putin:

This is not true. There was a referendum and citizens of Crimea overwhelmingly voted in favor of Russia. To call it a sham because it doesn't suit your narrative is dishonest. Infact the Pew Research Center polled local residents back in 2014 and found that the majority found the results of the referendum fair.

Every nation has the divine right to join an International Treaty and Ukraine should not be an exception. If NATO wanted to "plant" those Nuclear Weapons they would have admitted Ukraine several years ago. The majority of Ukraine citizens want to be a part of NATO as they feel that their security is threatened by Putin and they are justified in their beliefs. The Soviet Union were planting Nuclear Weapons in Cuba, but had reverse that decision when threatened by the USA!!

True, every nation has a right to join a group or sign a treaty. NATO was in the process of admitting Ukraine, but dont forget Ukraine is a banana republic. Its own leaders have been pro-Russian in the past, so what NATO wanted to do wouldn't have mattered.

Also it may or may not be true that the majority of Ukrainians are pro-EU (because of regional population differences). But eastern Ukraine is very pro Russia and infact the majority there feel Russia is right to send its army to protect Ukraines Russian speaking population. So before Ukraine signs with NATO they need to have internal consensus, which they dont have.

Lastly, yes the US threatened and the USSR reversed course. In this case, Russia is trying to preemptively resolve this issue, and unfortunately they have no other choice than war. Which is a terrible position to be put in.

The Emergency policies are just for Ireland, but it is not to just shut down the fossil fuel industries. More like accelerating the Renewable Energy so that they can slash the amount of energy obtained from the Fossil Fuel Industry. After all Ireland has to import the vast majority of the Fossil Fuel Energy that it is dependant on. So not sure why it is a problem to accelerate its move to the Renewables as a viable alternative?

I am speaking from a Canadian standpoint, for Canada, should we decide to do something like this. I dont care what Ireland does. So if we have to make such a decision, I'd question the planning and what "accelerating" means for local economies and industries currently employing thousands, and also the subsequent investments needed. I suppose those are valid questions for Ireland as well.
 
This is not true. There was a referendum and citizens of Crimea overwhelmingly voted in favor of Russia. To call it a sham because it doesn't suit your narrative is dishonest. Infact the Pew Research Center polled local residents back in 2014 and found that the majority found the results of the referendum fair.

The Referendum was definitely a sham. There were no clear cut choices on the ballot.:


No doubt that most in Crimea may have the opinion to be part of Russia. But the manner in which Russia just invaded and took it over is definitely non--constitutional. There should have been proper dialogues etc. Can you imagine if countries around the globe adopted the same strategy how many wars etc there would be. Just like the India - China, India - Pakistani, Israel - Palestine Conflicts. But Russia is the real culprit in the manner in which they also wanted to topple the Zelensky Government and install a puppet!!

True, every nation has a right to join a group or sign a treaty. NATO was in the process of admitting Ukraine, but dont forget Ukraine is a banana republic. Its own leaders have been pro-Russian in the past, so what NATO wanted to do wouldn't have mattered.

Also it may or may not be true that the majority of Ukrainians are pro-EU (because of regional population differences). But eastern Ukraine is very pro Russia and infact the majority there feel Russia is right to send its army to protect Ukraines Russian speaking population. So before Ukraine signs with NATO they need to have internal consensus, which they dont have.

Lastly, yes the US threatened and the USSR reversed course. In this case, Russia is trying to preemptively resolve this issue, and unfortunately they have no other choice than war. Which is a terrible position to be put in.

Ukraine had a legitimate elections unlike Russia that is not democracy. A sizeable number of Russians oppose this ghastly war in Ukraine. But are not allowed to express their opinions. Russia always had that influence over Ukraine in the past and that is why the Ukrainians wanted Yanukovych removed from office. A vast majority of Ukrainians want to be a part of NATO. In fact only democracies are admitted into NATO. Russia has not invaded Ukraine just to "protect" the Russian speaking residents of Donbas. They are destroying the infrastructure of Ukraine, taking out the power grids especially during this winter season, bombing hospitals, schools, residences and creating a devastating crisis in Ukraine. But that is a very sad opinion of yours regarding "Russia's only choice is a war". Putin is doing what autocrats and dictators in the past have accomplished just to boost their own ego. They do not care for the lives lost. NATO's only choice is to stand behind Ukraine. No wonder that countries.like Montenegro, North Macedonia, Finland and Sweden have opted to sign up with them. Russia dare not touch these nations including Poland with a barge pole or else they will pay the price!!

I am speaking from a Canadian standpoint, for Canada, should we decide to do something like this. I dont care what Ireland does. So if we have to make such a decision, I'd question the planning and what "accelerating" means for local economies and industries currently employing thousands, and also the subsequent investments needed. I suppose those are valid questions for Ireland as well.

Canada has not intentions to shut the fossil fuel power plants. Otherwise, show us where they stated that they would? That link posted by OP was all about Ireland. Remember that we are still dependant on Fossil Fuels for now. So, nothing to get that concerned about the Emergency Act from across the Pond!!
 
I think that is massive overreaction. What is the actual impact of the tipping point? What happens when we hit 2C? Like actual every day impact? I am sure if you actually see the impact, it will be manageable. Plus with incremental changes, (and moving slow isn't equal to doing nothing), means we will slow the effect of climate change.

The CO2 that we're putting in the air will likely stay there for thousands of years.
You can enter different global temps here and see what will likely happen.

Its not pretty.

The worry is if it doesn't max at around 1.5ºC then it hits 2ºC by the end of the century and keeps going up, possibly as high as 1 IAU.
 
The Referendum was definitely a sham. There were no clear cut choices on the ballot.:


No doubt that most in Crimea may have the opinion to be part of Russia. But the manner in which Russia just invaded and took it over is definitely non--constitutional. There should have been proper dialogues etc. Can you imagine if countries around the globe adopted the same strategy how many wars etc there would be. Just like the India - China, India - Pakistani, Israel - Palestine Conflicts. But Russia is the real culprit in the manner in which they also wanted to topple the Zelensky Government and install a puppet!!

What do you mean there were no clear cut choices? I cited a Pew Research poll that polled the locals for their opinion. 91% of them found the results of the referendum fair.

Despite Putin's view that Belarus and Ukraine, actually belong to Russia (aka the USSR), which is a debatable position, Putin's concern considering NATO are very real and legitimate. Just look at the way NATO has been expanding closer and closer to Russia over the last 30 years. Putin very aptly asked in a press conference recently, before the war started if Russia was the one with nuclear missiles near NATO countries. You cannot expect to put nuclear missiles near your rival and hide behind "Oh these are sovereign nations and they can do what they want" bit. You are forming a military alliance and threatening another sovereign nation and provoking them so they are going to react! It isn't any different from what the US did during the Cuban missile crisis.

Ukraine had a legitimate elections unlike Russia that is not democracy. A sizeable number of Russians oppose this ghastly war in Ukraine. But are not allowed to express their opinions. Russia always had that influence over Ukraine in the past and that is why the Ukrainians wanted Yanukovych removed from office. A vast majority of Ukrainians want to be a part of NATO. In fact only democracies are admitted into NATO. Russia has not invaded Ukraine just to "protect" the Russian speaking residents of Donbas. They are destroying the infrastructure of Ukraine, taking out the power grids especially during this winter season, bombing hospitals, schools, residences and creating a devastating crisis in Ukraine. But that is a very sad opinion of yours regarding "Russia's only choice is a war". Putin is doing what autocrats and dictators in the past have accomplished just to boost their own ego. They do not care for the lives lost. NATO's only choice is to stand behind Ukraine. No wonder that countries.like Montenegro, North Macedonia, Finland and Sweden have opted to sign up with them. Russia dare not touch these nations including Poland with a barge pole or else they will pay the price!!

Ukraine most definitely DID NOT have free and fair elections and is most definitely NOT a functioning democracy. It is infact a banana republic that is corrupt and divided internally with the east supporting Russia and the west supporting EU. That is reality. Yanukovych fled office after the Euromaidan protests that many in eastern Ukraine and Crimea consider a Coup D'eat. So opinions are divided even within Ukraine. Russia invaded for the simple reason that they weren't going to allow Ukraine to join NATO. If Ukraine and the west had given assurances to Russia that Ukraine will remain neutral, then there wouldn't be war. Putin has been sitting on Ukraine's borders for the last 8 years, he isn't going to back down without these assurances. These are practical geopolitical considerations that need practical and realistic solutions. You cannot argue this away with rhetoric. This is the same thing that happened with Georgia back in 2008, when Georgia tried to join NATO. Putin has always stood firm, that he wont let anyone else join NATO.

Canada has not intentions to shut the fossil fuel power plants. Otherwise, show us where they stated that they would? That link posted by OP was all about Ireland. Remember that we are still dependant on Fossil Fuels for now. So, nothing to get that concerned about the Emergency Act from across the Pond!!
I am generally talking about climate change alarmists. My comments were not specifically about Ireland.
 
The people who use the term 'alarmists' generally are 'science deniers'.
Just saying.

I doubt the science (in that specific instance) if someone is trying to create panic. In those cases I would need a more detailed explanation and actual examples of effects that have a causal relationship with climate change. If they are reasonable in their conclusions, no issues. I dont think I am being unreasonable.
 
I doubt the science (in that specific instance) if someone is trying to create panic. In those cases I would need a more detailed explanation and actual examples of effects that have a causal relationship with climate change. If they are reasonable in their conclusions, no issues. I dont think I am being unreasonable.

You should read the latest summary.
But will you?

 
You should read the latest summary.
But will you?


I just started taking a look at it. But these are the kinds of figures below that I have a problem with. In the figure below, as you can see they say that the observed changes to ecosystem structure is globally "High or Very High". My question is, what is the baseline? What does high, very high, medium mean? Is this quantifiable or is it qualitative? What is the tolerance for calling something High vs Medium? Are the changes observed to the ecosystem solely due to human impact? If that was the case how was that observed/measured? I mean this seems very open to interpretation and consulting-y. The reason I ask is that according to NASA (and guaranteed they are not climate scientists), have said that the world is far greener today than it was 20 years ago. So if that is the case, how are ecosystems being destroyed? Maybe they have covered this in subsequent pages, which I havent read yet, but just throwing that out there off the top of my head.

Screenshot at Dec 03 21-56-18.png