Eight steps to immediately accelerate climate action

This is not true. Companies like GE and Philips make billions just from LED lighting.

LED lights are cheaper for people to run.
That's like complaining companies making windmills are getting rich.

None of those hold a candle to the oil industry.


I am not disputing research. I am expressing skepticism that it may be biased.

How can research in so many countries, through so many different governments by so many tens of thousands of scientist all be biased the same way to come up with the same results?
How can researchers hired by the oil companies to do their own internal research come up with the same results?

However, I don't believe in the kind of crisis that you are highlighting, and that it needs to be handled right now, while deprioritizing far greater issues. I think the impacts of warming will not be as severe. For instance, what does "more extreme weather" mean? Are you saying that our summer temps are going to go from 30C to 50C all of a sudden? Or are you saying the lowest temps in Feb is going to be -50C overnight? Or is it going to be a degree or two here and there over a period of many years? I can live with the latter.

The impacts are already severe. See the floods in Pakistan, extreme heat destroying crops in India, extreme drought in the SW of the US, forest fires in the Amazon and Siberia, constant polar vortexes from the shifting jet stream, floods in the EU....
Combine that with the changes we've already put in place, 96% of all mammals on earth are now humans, their pets and their livestock.

Then read about the massive tipping points we may trigger.
 
LED lights are cheaper for people to run.
That's like complaining companies making windmills are getting rich.

None of those hold a candle to the oil industry.

LED lighting in homes is not as profitable for these companies as the ones they sell to utility companies. Anyway there is nothing wrong in doing business, but the climate change, green energy space has lots of potential to be a booming business - that is my point. There is potential to earn billions. Oil and Gas maybe at the top now, but consider renewable sources of energy, lighting, electric vehicles and many others, and you'd see there are tons of markets untapped with billions, maybe even trillions in potential revenue. That is the major driver of climate change politics. The money. Not altruism.

How can research in so many countries, through so many different governments by so many tens of thousands of scientist all be biased the same way to come up with the same results?
How can researchers hired by the oil companies to do their own internal research come up with the same results?

For some reason you seem to think I am disputing research. I am not and am sure there are legitimate studies out there. I infact do believe in climate science but I am skeptical about alarmists. I mean GE makes aircraft engines which pollute. And they make LED lighting and sell it as a green energy solution. So you know entirely possible for oil and gas companies to play both sides.

The impacts are already severe. See the floods in Pakistan, extreme heat destroying crops in India, extreme drought in the SW of the US, forest fires in the Amazon and Siberia, constant polar vortexes from the shifting jet stream, floods in the EU....
Combine that with the changes we've already put in place, 96% of all mammals on earth are now humans, their pets and their livestock.

Then read about the massive tipping points we may trigger.

This I dont agree with. There may be some events that are triggered by climate change. But every weather related event is not due to climate change.

We've always had drought, forest fires and floods throughout history.
 
  • Like
Reactions: JohnLarue
LED lighting in homes is not as profitable for these companies as the ones they sell to utility companies. Anyway there is nothing wrong in doing business, but the climate change, green energy space has lots of potential to be a booming business - that is my point. There is potential to earn billions. Oil and Gas maybe at the top now, but consider renewable sources of energy, lighting, electric vehicles and many others, and you'd see there are tons of markets untapped with billions, maybe even trillions in potential revenue. That is the major driver of climate change politics. The money. Not altruism.

Except that if you are really claiming that LED lighting manufacturers have paid climatologists to fake the same results they've been getting for 40 years you'd be tarred a total wacko.
Sure there is money to be made, but unless you're arguing that Tesla secretly funded climate researchers in the 80's then you'd have to admit its way too late for them to have paid to have results changed.
Its a ridiculous claim with zero evidence to support it.

For some reason you seem to think I am disputing research. I am not and am sure there are legitimate studies out there. I infact do believe in climate science but I am skeptical about alarmists. I mean GE makes aircraft engines which pollute. And they make LED lighting and sell it as a green energy solution. So you know entirely possible for oil and gas companies to play both sides.

Of course businesses play both sides, same as the Saudi's just announced a giant solar plant. Exxon buys into some greenwashing to make themselves look good. Some companies hedge. But that has nothing to do with the research or influencing the research. Again, nearly 50 years ago Exxon and Shell both had their own internal scientists who came up with the same numbers. The science has always come up with the same warming, the changes now are in the details of how its effecting the planet and more accurate projections of how that change will happen.

This I dont agree with. There may be some events that are triggered by climate change. But every weather related event is not due to climate change.

Clearly you don't understand the difference between weather and climate. Until you do, you don't know enough.

We've always had drought, forest fires and floods throughout history.

Sure, and the planet has always had ice ages, thermal maximums and mass extinction events.
Doesn't mean its ok to start another one.
That's a poor argument.
 
Except that if you are really claiming that LED lighting manufacturers have paid climatologists to fake the same results they've been getting for 40 years you'd be tarred a total wacko.
Sure there is money to be made, but unless you're arguing that Tesla secretly funded climate researchers in the 80's then you'd have to admit its way too late for them to have paid to have results changed.
Its a ridiculous claim with zero evidence to support it.

They may have paid off scientists. Or the hypothesis they were testing was inherently biased - kind of how there are numerous studies that publish harmful effects of marijuana - except they were looking for harmful effects in the first place. Of course they will find harmful effects and publish it but it also means the goals of the study were biased to begin with. Again it is not a claim, but I dont fully trust it especially when it is such a hot political topic, and when there are billions to be made in that industry.

Of course businesses play both sides, same as the Saudi's just announced a giant solar plant. Exxon buys into some greenwashing to make themselves look good. Some companies hedge. But that has nothing to do with the research or influencing the research. Again, nearly 50 years ago Exxon and Shell both had their own internal scientists who came up with the same numbers. The science has always come up with the same warming, the changes now are in the details of how its effecting the planet and more accurate projections of how that change will happen.

It most definitely has a lot to do with the research. You seem to be implying that all research is conducted honestly with integrity because scientists are involved. That is a naive assumption. If you trusted climate scientists so much, why not trust the ones who claim the opposite? When a profit making entity is involved in funding any research, regardless of what outcome they come up with you have to be skeptical.

Clearly you don't understand the difference between weather and climate. Until you do, you don't know enough.

I do. But the fact is that no actual causal relationship has been established between every one of these recent natural disasters and climate change.

Sure, and the planet has always had ice ages, thermal maximums and mass extinction events.
Doesn't mean its ok to start another one.
That's a poor argument.

I dont think anyone started it the first time around. And yet it happened. And if it happens again, the blame doesn't fall solely on humans. That is a ridiculous proposition.
 
  • Like
Reactions: JohnLarue
There are more important existential issues that we should be worried about, like poverty, hunger, accessibility to medicine and so on. Climate initiatives are necessary but a distant priority.

Well you nailed it here about existential issues, as poverty and hunger are being exacerbated by Climate Change. Hence, the real urgency for them to be addressed. Then the root cause is definitely and 100% Climate Change!!

Why Climate Change and Poverty Are Inextricably Linked
Fighting one problem helps mitigate the other.

 
  • Haha
Reactions: krealtarron
Well you nailed it here about existential issues, as poverty and hunger are being exacerbated by Climate Change. Hence, the real urgency for them to be addressed. Then the root cause is definitely and 100% Climate Change!!

Why Climate Change and Poverty Are Inextricably Linked
Fighting one problem helps mitigate the other.


So you mean climate change has always been THE reason for poverty!! OMG! If only we knew we wouldnt be blaming it on literacy, lack of investments, poor governance among other things!
 
  • Haha
Reactions: bver_hunter
So you mean climate change has always been THE reason for poverty!! OMG! If only we knew we wouldnt be blaming it on literacy, lack of investments, poor governance among other things!

Ohhh, so the evidence of Climate Change affecting more and more people's lives and pushing more nations into hunger, drought and poverty is supposed to be just due to literacy, lack of investments and poor governance? Those always existed but the effects of Climate Change have pushed more nations down there. That is why at the Climate Change Summit there were resolutions to provide more funding, but there are limits to how it can fully address the effects of Climate Change. Once again Climate Change is the ROOT CAUSE!!
 
Ohhh, so the evidence of Climate Change affecting more and more people's lives and pushing more nations into hunger, drought and poverty is supposed to be just due to literacy, lack of investments and poor governance? Those always existed but the effects of Climate Change have pushed more nations down there. That is why at the Climate Change Summit there were resolutions to provide more funding, but there are limits to how it can fully address the effects of Climate Change. Once again Climate Change is the ROOT CAUSE!!

This is just ridiculous manipulation. More people have been lifted out of poverty by industries that are considered as contributing to climate change.

 
  • Like
Reactions: JohnLarue
Something related.

 
They may have paid off scientists. Or the hypothesis they were testing was inherently biased - kind of how there are numerous studies that publish harmful effects of marijuana - except they were looking for harmful effects in the first place. Of course they will find harmful effects and publish it but it also means the goals of the study were biased to begin with. Again it is not a claim, but I dont fully trust it especially when it is such a hot political topic, and when there are billions to be made in that industry.

They would have had to pay off the 99.9% of scientists who came to the same conclusions, along with paying off Exxon and Shell's scientists.
'Cuz they all say anthropogenic climate change is happening and its a big deal.
All of them.

Which makes this claim look really weak. You have zero evidence just a hunch that something bad could have happened.
This debate requires real evidence.

It most definitely has a lot to do with the research. You seem to be implying that all research is conducted honestly with integrity because scientists are involved. That is a naive assumption. If you trusted climate scientists so much, why not trust the ones who claim the opposite? When a profit making entity is involved in funding any research, regardless of what outcome they come up with you have to be skeptical.

Which ones claim the opposite?
Is their research solid?
How many of them are there?

Why is it that you think the 99.9% were paid off and not the 0.01% of contrarians (most of whom are actually accepting oil money)?


I do. But the fact is that no actual causal relationship has been established between every one of these recent natural disasters and climate change.

Start with the Polar Vortex. The change in the jet stream is directly related to warming. That's causing massive heat waves and cold waves with the new polar vortexes.
Direct causal relationship.


I dont think anyone started it the first time around. And yet it happened. And if it happens again, the blame doesn't fall solely on humans. That is a ridiculous proposition.

The blame falls solely on humans. Its not a ridiculous statement its fact and supported by the evidence.
That is exactly why climatologists call it 'anthropogenic', or 'human caused'.
Humans are putting greenhouse gases into the atmosphere, that's causing the planet to warm.
Anthropogenic.
 
This is just ridiculous manipulation. More people have been lifted out of poverty by industries that are considered as contributing to climate change.


This is not about an apocalyptical prediction by journalists or alternatively climate denials by skeptics!!
So rather than going with an opinion by a single person like Michael Shellenberger, let us examine the true Global Studies by several scientists and environmental agencies:



In other words Climate Change is currently affecting more and more nations around the world. Hunger and poverty are on the rise globally from both Climate Change and Non-Climate Change Factors such as The War in Ukraine, The Supply Chain Disruptions from the Pandemic and rising inflation. Pretending that Climate Change has no real impact is downright ridiculous:

 
This is just ridiculous manipulation. More people have been lifted out of poverty by industries that are considered as contributing to climate change.


You can't take that seriously, he starts off with multiple straw man claims and a couple of quotes out of context.
Did you check who pays him?
 
They would have had to pay off the 99.9% of scientists who came to the same conclusions, along with paying off Exxon and Shell's scientists.
'Cuz they all say anthropogenic climate change is happening and its a big deal.
All of them.

Which makes this claim look really weak. You have zero evidence just a hunch that something bad could have happened.
This debate requires real evidence.
No they dont have to pay them off. They just have to test a hypothesis that is biased.

Also if the argument is that climate change is happening then I dont have any disagreements with that conclusion, as I have said before. I just don't agree with the prioritizing climate change above all else. There are far greater issues to take care of before we get to climate change.

Which ones claim the opposite?
Is their research solid?
How many of them are there?

Why is it that you think the 99.9% were paid off and not the 0.01% of contrarians (most of whom are actually accepting oil money)?

I never said 99.9% of them were paid off. I said they could be testing a biased hypothesis. That said, if the contrarians are taking oil money, is it not entirely possible that atleast some of the ones agreeing are taking money from some other party that stands to financially gain from climate change initiatives ? Why is skepticism in this case unacceptable?

Start with the Polar Vortex. The change in the jet stream is directly related to warming. That's causing massive heat waves and cold waves with the new polar vortexes.
Direct causal relationship.

The blame falls solely on humans. Its not a ridiculous statement its fact and supported by the evidence.
That is exactly why climatologists call it 'anthropogenic', or 'human caused'.
Humans are putting greenhouse gases into the atmosphere, that's causing the planet to warm.
Anthropogenic.

Warming and cooling of the earth, along with changes in global temperatures has occurred throughout history. Along with polar vortices and other climate/weather phenomenon. To suddenly blame it solely human actions is ridiculous. Again, yes there is an impact. But I think that impact is minimal, but is being overstated for financial gain. There are plenty of countries that are not even developed and do not actually have anything to do with out of control climate change because they aren't even industrialized enough.
 
  • Like
Reactions: JohnLarue
You can't take that seriously, he starts off with multiple straw man claims and a couple of quotes out of context.
Did you check who pays him?
What straw man claims has he made? He is simply quoting people who have made alarmist claims about the effects of climate change and then goes on to argue that isn't necessary.
 
This is not about an apocalyptical prediction by journalists or alternatively climate denials by skeptics!!
So rather than going with an opinion by a single person like Michael Shellenberger, let us examine the true Global Studies by several scientists and environmental agencies:



In other words Climate Change is currently affecting more and more nations around the world. Hunger and poverty are on the rise globally from both Climate Change and Non-Climate Change Factors such as The War in Ukraine, The Supply Chain Disruptions from the Pandemic and rising inflation. Pretending that Climate Change has no real impact is downright ridiculous:


This is exactly what I was talking about earlier. That first document for example is prepared by government agencies and a few corporates and financial institutions.

These are the kinds of studies and documents that I am skeptical about. I do not trust their intentions. This is also the sort of colonial mentality that Vijay Prashad was talking about in the video I posted, where these developed OECD nations seem to blame developing nations, while the more industrialized ones are the ones responsible for the most emissions.
 
This is exactly what I was talking about earlier. That first document for example is prepared by government agencies and a few corporates and financial institutions.

These are the kinds of studies and documents that I am skeptical about. I do not trust their intentions. This is also the sort of colonial mentality that Vijay Prashad was talking about in the video I posted, where these developed OECD nations seem to blame developing nations, while the more industrialized ones are the ones responsible for the most emissions.

I go by the actual Scientists and the Research that they have conducted. My skepticism is more towards the big Corporations like the Oil Companies and how they hid their own research when there was evidence that their emissions were a cause for Global Warming. I am not doubting that the biggest polluters were the developed nations and that is why they have to undertake serious steps in reducing these green gas emissions. At the recent Climate Change Conference there was more aid pledged for addressing the fight against Climate Change and also to aid these developing nations.

Historically, yes developed nations caused 79% of the Climate Change Emissions

who-caused-climate-change-1.png


But currently this is the Carbon Emissions Map:

who-is-causing-climate-change-now.png


Yes 63% of current emissions is by the developing nations!!
 
I go by the actual Scientists and the Research that they have conducted. My skepticism is more towards the big Corporations like the Oil Companies and how they hid their own research when there was evidence that their emissions were a cause for Global Warming. I am not doubting that the biggest polluters were the developed nations and that is why they have to undertake serious steps in reducing these green gas emissions. At the recent Climate Change Conference there was more aid pledged for addressing the fight against Climate Change and also to aid these developing nations.

Historically, yes developed nations caused 79% of the Climate Change Emissions

who-caused-climate-change-1.png


But currently this is the Carbon Emissions Map:

who-is-causing-climate-change-now.png


Yes 63% of current emissions is by the developing nations!!

By all means take steps to address climate change. But don't argue that we need to prioritize climate above all else. Thats ridiculous. Here is Putin's perfect response to annoying little shit Greta. This is exactly what I feel:


Also, on your second pie chart

- What % of the worlds population lives in the developing world vs the developed world? India and China account for 40%.
- What about the fact that manufacturing has almost completely moved to the developing world. They are manufacturing stuff for us, for our corporations to profit from it and we are blaming them? Vijay Prashad addresses this in his speech in the video I posted. If we were to continue manufacturing here, our emissions would go back up to what it was in your first chart as the majority of consumers live in the developed world (even though they make up a minority of world population).

When you look at data you have to interpret them appropriately while considering nuances.
 
By all means take steps to address climate change. But don't argue that we need to prioritize climate above all else. Thats ridiculous. Here is Putin's perfect response to annoying little shit Greta. This is exactly what I feel:


Also, on your second pie chart

- What % of the worlds population lives in the developing world vs the developed world? India and China account for 40%.
- What about the fact that manufacturing has almost completely moved to the developing world. They are manufacturing stuff for us, for our corporations to profit from it and we are blaming them? Vijay Prashad addresses this in his speech in the video I posted. If we were to continue manufacturing here, our emissions would go back up to what it was in your first chart as the majority of consumers live in the developed world (even though they make up a minority of world population).

When you look at data you have to interpret them appropriately while considering nuances.

OIC you prefer a despicable killer like Putin over Thunberg. Not worth my bandwidth to listen to his lies, especially when he was sending "Peace Keeping" forces to Ukraine!!
See your true colours are being revealed when you throw insults against Thunberg calling her a "shit"!! How many people has she killed? She has every right to demonstrate in favour of the 90% + of Environmental Scientists who agree about the dangers of Climate Change if not addressed in a timely manner. Only Climate Change Deniers throw those type of hate lingo at her!!

Again we are not talking about the past, when once again the Developed Nations were responsible for the emissions.
But go by the real data for once where the Developed nations are right about the current emissions and the root cause of them as stated in that second graph that I posted!!
Everyone has to fight against these emissions and no one is saying that it has to be implemented overnight. But if a higher impact of this Climate Change is occurring in these developing nations then they have to take heed of it, and that is what is the whole point of the Summit!!
 
This is not true. Companies like GE and Philips make billions just from LED lighting.



I am not disputing research. I am expressing skepticism that it may be biased.

I can write a Monte Carlo simulation code to predict
change of thermodynamic properties of air upon addition
of carbon dioxide. I cannot dispute output from running
the code. What is important to do is to understand the
results are only as good as the model the algorithm of
the code based on.

Likewise I would not dispute a computer modelling study
of the melting of Antarctic glaciers so long as the inventor
of the model agrees results of this study are only as good
as the model.

With regard to modelling of global climate change I did
look into refereed papers of climate science in an attempt
to uncover any definitive prediction of the tipping point of
climate change. I came up empty-handed. My search wasn't
very thorough though.
 
  • Like
Reactions: krealtarron
OIC you prefer a despicable killer like Putin over Thunberg. Not worth my bandwidth to listen to his lies, especially when he was sending "Peace Keeping" forces to Ukraine!!
See your true colours are being revealed when you throw insults against Thunberg calling her a "shit"!! How many people has she killed? She has every right to demonstrate in favour of the 90% + of Environmental Scientists who agree about the dangers of Climate Change if not addressed in a timely manner. Only Climate Change Deniers throw those type of hate lingo at her!!

Again we are not talking about the past, when once again the Developed Nations were responsible for the emissions.
But go by the real data for once where the Developed nations are right about the current emissions and the root cause of them as stated in that second graph that I posted!!
Everyone has to fight against these emissions and no one is saying that it has to be implemented overnight. But if a higher impact of this Climate Change is occurring in these developing nations then they have to take heed of it, and that is what is the whole point of the Summit!!

What does Putin's actions in Ukraine have anything to do with his response to Thunberg? I called her a little shit, cuz she is annoying as fuck. She is a privileged little white girl from fucking Sweden, who sits up there and goes "My childhood has been stolen! How dARe you!!!". Really? Your childhood was stolen cuz of climate change of all things? What a fucking joke! Do you really want me to point you to actual children in 3rd world nations, whose childhood has been stolen because of grinding poverty? Heck, those children never had their childhood in the first place!!. It is a very arrogant, tone deaf, first world take.

Secondly, I responded to your data. In the past, manufacturing was done in the west. So emissions were high here. Now manufacturing is done in developing nations, BECAUSE western companies outsourced it there. The goods manufactured there are still being imported and consumed by people HERE. So for you to arrogantly state that developing nations should do something about their emissions, while simultaneously benefitting from it, is utter arrogance and ignorance.

This is exactly what Vijay Prashad talks about in the video. Not sure if you even cared to watch it.