I assume they repay the loan with taxes not by printing money
Why don’t we try to get this thread back on track? Eventually, burt-oh-my will realize that he is just making himself look like an idiot.
Let me try to understand what you are saying and refresh my own memory. If I understand you right, you are suggesting that the government finance a deficit by selling its bonds directly to the Bank of Canada. As soon as the government spends this money, the money supply increases and normally the price level would rise. However, you are saying that the government could counter this by later paying off the bonds by raising taxes? This would end up reducing the money supply. Am I correct (this thread has gotten so off track that I may have lost your train of thought).
If I am correct when it comes to your argument, I have two responses. First, under current policies any profits the Bank of Canada makes go back to the government of Canada. Thus, the government would just be giving the money to the bank of Canada to give back to itself.
I was originally just going to limit my response to this when I latter started thinking that you might be on to something. Under current policies, the money would just go back to the bank of Canada but why could the Bank of Canada not just keep the funds? The Bank of Canada used to use something called “Drawdowns and redeposits” as a policy instrument. As you may know, the Bank of Canada is also the Banker for the federal government. They used to transfer money between the Government’s account with them and the Government’s accounts with private banks to influence the money supply. Basically, the idea was that by transferring the government’s funds to private banks, the money supply would increase (by the amount of the money multiplier times the amount transferred) due to the increase in reserves. By transfer money from the government’s accounts with private banks back to the bank of Canada, the money supply would decrease. It seems to me that what you are suggesting is not that much different if the tax dollars the government uses to pay back the B of C just stay in an account in the B of C. However, I think there may be two issues you have not considered:
1. The money supply would still increase until the government repaid the loan. Thus, it would still be inflationary. However, when the government repaid the money, the price level would go back to where it started. I am not sure this instability in the price level would be good.
2. After the government paid back the funds, I don’t think they would just let the money sit in the Bank of Canada account. It would be too tempting for them to spend it and thus, lead to the money supply going back up.
However, despite these points, I can see where you are coming from and that you may have a point.