Economics question

Look guy, the 13 posts before yours all were about money creation. The only contribution you made was some nonsense about banks lending out more than they had in deposits which you have now admitted was completely wrong. Now that you have admitted you were wrong, there is not much left to discuss.

Yeah right, the banks have nothing to do with money creation.

There you go again. I never admitted it was wrong, alhtough I suppose if you repeat that a thousand more times it might make you feel better. Do you realize how you carry on an argument? You simply ASSERT that 1) You know more 2) The other guy is a fool an idiot, then claim victory.

In the meantime, good night.


And actually, if you'd care to have a civil argument, there is a school of thought which believes loands come first, reserves later:

Quote:


Conventional wisdom regarding the money multiplier is wrong. Australian economist Steve Keen notes that in a debt based society, expansion of credit comes first and reserves come later.
 
Yeah right, the banks have nothing to do with money creation.
I don’t know if you believe this or if you are falsely claiming I do. Either way, it demonstrates your ignorance.
There you go again. I never admitted it was wrong, alhtough I suppose if you repeat that a thousand more times it might make you feel better. Do you realize how you carry on an argument? You simply ASSERT that 1) You know more 2) The other guy is a fool an idiot, then claim victory.
You either admitted you were wrong or suffer from some mental impairment that prevents you from knowing that you completely contradicted yourself.
Either way, by all means keep making a fool of yourself by posting nonsense.
 
That's one on the way to a thousand, keep going. I see your technique does not improve with time. You will probably keep on telling me how I supposedly admitted I was wrong forever, but who cares.

HEY! , let me try your method of argument! Here goes:

*******

OK, you have now admitted that you were either mistaken wrongly read my posts, or are just plain stupid, so...errrr.... that makes me right.

******

How'd I do?

My original point was that new deposits are multiplied by the banking system to create many more times that in new loans, and many times that original deposit. They are NOT equal to the new deposit, but many times it. That point of course as you know is perfectly valid, despite all your - forget it, lets just call it your childish way of dealing with discussions.
 
hey burt,

Go out, have a beer, get a massage, and forget about the subject. There's no way to dig yourself out of the hole you're in here - your best bet is to move on.
 
Why does it cause inflation when the government prints money to fund a project yet it does not when the government borrows the monies from a bank ??

WRONG....every SINGLE time money is Created out of nowhere, Inflation Follows! and pretty soon, there's gonna be a MASSIVE currency crisis with a SKY rocketing inflation !!!

to understand all that 1 must first understand the REAL purpose of money.....and as far as im concerned none of you here will ever understand that
so there's no point of even starting explainnig it LoL
 
Go out, have a beer, get a massage, and forget about the subject. There's no way to dig yourself out of the hole you're in here - your best bet is to move on.

Not in hole, not by a long shot!

I will always respond to nincompoops buffons and other assorted fools. He IS amusing, I must say.
 
The only contribution you made was some nonsense about banks lending out more than they had in deposits .

A quote:

"In a sense, banks do create money. Money is defined as anything that is generally accepted in exchange for goods and services. One common form of money is currency which only the mint (in the case of coins) and the Bank of Canada (in the case of bills) can create. However, another form of money is bank deposits. With a cheque, you can transfer part of your bank account to a landlord for housing. Now days, you can even use a debit account to transfer bank deposits to stores in exchange for goods. Thus, just about all economists would consider bank deposits to be a form of money as they are accepted in exchange for goods and services. Thus, when the bank of Canada puts lends the government $1000 they (and the banks) are creating far more than $1000 in new money. Suppose the B of C loans the GC $1000. The GC gives that $1000 in new money to you to work on the new subway you mentioned. You deposit the $1000 in your bank account. In the first round, $1000 in new money as been created. However, suppose your bank keeps 10% of all deposits in case some of their customers want to make withdraws but lends the rest. Thus, suppose they lend $900 of your $1000 deposit to me. I then spend it on something by writing a cheque and the person I give the money to deposits it in their bank account. The total increase in the money supply is now $1 000 (the amount you deposited) plus the $900 the person I gave the money to deposited. The process continues. As long as no one makes a cash withdraw, the money supply increases by 1000/r where r is the proportion of each deposit the bank keeps in case some of their customers want to make withdraws (i.e. r = 0.1 in our example so the money supply would increase by 10, 000). However, the process starts when the bank of Canada injects “new” money into the system. Without that “new” money in the form of lending the GC money (in our example), the chartered banks cannot create any money."

This is a quote from the great man , SOMEONE, himself, where he says exactly what I was saying - that banks create new money many multiples of what was initially deposited. This is from the "WTF solution to economic problems so simple thread.

https://terb.cc/vbulletin/showthrea...olution-to-economic-woes-this-simple-!!/page2

SO look has been the biggest self-contradictor here? It;s OK to be an arrogant ass, my friend, but it works better when you are also truthful, accurate, and consistent.

He needs a ladder to get himself out of his own hole. My point is valid: give the banking system $100 in new deposits, when the process is over they will have lent out MORE than the amount of those initial deposits. Subsequent `deposits" are not the same as the initial deposit, as he himself alluded to (New money vs just money). So whereas "new money" by his own words is not the same as money, "Original deposits" ( B of C) is decidedly not the same as deposits created as a result of credit extension. Thus my statment is 100% correct.

You know what this all is, right? He just doesnt want anyone else to `own` this economnic/financial/banking discussion space, so he goes ballistic whenever snyone impinges on his turf, making up mountains out of molehills on the basis of slight differences in definition/usage of terms.
 
burt-oh-my, are you ever going to get tired of making yourself look like a fool? Look, the only contribution you made to this thread was some nonsense about banks lending out more than they had on deposit. Your subsequent posts indicate that even you now realize that you were completely wrong. All you are doing now is making yourself look even stupider.
 
I assume they repay the loan with taxes not by printing money
Why don’t we try to get this thread back on track? Eventually, burt-oh-my will realize that he is just making himself look like an idiot.

Let me try to understand what you are saying and refresh my own memory. If I understand you right, you are suggesting that the government finance a deficit by selling its bonds directly to the Bank of Canada. As soon as the government spends this money, the money supply increases and normally the price level would rise. However, you are saying that the government could counter this by later paying off the bonds by raising taxes? This would end up reducing the money supply. Am I correct (this thread has gotten so off track that I may have lost your train of thought).

If I am correct when it comes to your argument, I have two responses. First, under current policies any profits the Bank of Canada makes go back to the government of Canada. Thus, the government would just be giving the money to the bank of Canada to give back to itself.

I was originally just going to limit my response to this when I latter started thinking that you might be on to something. Under current policies, the money would just go back to the bank of Canada but why could the Bank of Canada not just keep the funds? The Bank of Canada used to use something called “Drawdowns and redeposits” as a policy instrument. As you may know, the Bank of Canada is also the Banker for the federal government. They used to transfer money between the Government’s account with them and the Government’s accounts with private banks to influence the money supply. Basically, the idea was that by transferring the government’s funds to private banks, the money supply would increase (by the amount of the money multiplier times the amount transferred) due to the increase in reserves. By transfer money from the government’s accounts with private banks back to the bank of Canada, the money supply would decrease. It seems to me that what you are suggesting is not that much different if the tax dollars the government uses to pay back the B of C just stay in an account in the B of C. However, I think there may be two issues you have not considered:

1. The money supply would still increase until the government repaid the loan. Thus, it would still be inflationary. However, when the government repaid the money, the price level would go back to where it started. I am not sure this instability in the price level would be good.

2. After the government paid back the funds, I don’t think they would just let the money sit in the Bank of Canada account. It would be too tempting for them to spend it and thus, lead to the money supply going back up.

However, despite these points, I can see where you are coming from and that you may have a point.
 
burt-oh-my, are you ever going to get tired of making yourself look like a fool? Look, the only contribution you made to this thread was some nonsense about banks lending out more than they had on deposit. Your subsequent posts indicate that even you now realize that you were completely wrong. All you are doing now is making yourself look even stupider.

That;s repetition number two, just like I predicted.

You are actually becoming a great amusement to me. Keep it up!
 
That;s repetition number two, just like I predicted.

You are actually becoming a great amusement to me. Keep it up!
As long as we have established that you were completely wrong, that is fine with me. Now I suggest you stop hijacking Yoga’s thread. Eventually it will die and people will forget you made a fool of yourself.

Advice: Clearly, you are a young guy who thinks it is embarrassing to be caught out on such a mistake. However, in the greater scheme of things, your being wrong about the relationship between deposits and loans is not important. When you get older, you will learn that people don’t remember the unimportant mistakes you make in life but they do remember your reaction to them. They won’t remember your mistake but they will remember your going overboard in reaction to it being pointed out.
 
Anyways, back to my original point

When the government lends itself money it is inflationary


Why is it not inflationary when the banks create money ??

The answer is the banks do not loan money they do not have, and when their own money comes back to them and they re loan it this money has created goods in the meantime - IE you built a house with it etc - so the re loaned money has GDP attached to it hence no inflation as inflation equals money supply divided by goods

An exception is the housing bubble where people loaned money to bid up houses but generally speaking loaned money creates goods

That is my answer to my original question "Why does our government not borrow money from itself instead of banks and thus avoid paying interest ??
 
Anyways, back to my original point

When the government lends itself money it is inflationary


Why is it not inflationary when the banks create money ??

The answer is the banks do not loan money they do not have, and when their own money comes back to them and they re loan it this money has created goods in the meantime - IE you built a house with it etc - so the re loaned money has GDP attached to it hence no inflation as inflation equals money supply divided by goods
I don’t think you need to assume it created any goods. I think a better way of looking at it is that if the banks did not lend to government, they would just lend to someone else. Think back to our posts #5 and #6. All government is doing in that example is crowding out private borrowing (You could make things more complicated and get some goods created in the short run but if you limited things to the long run you don’t need that complication.). However, when government lends money to itself it is creating money that would not otherwise have been created. E.g. it is the central bank that changes the size of the money supply from an existing equilibrium. Otherwise, the money supply would remain fairly constant with banks more or less creating however much money they have always created. It is when central banks change the reserves of the banking system that private banks start creating more or less money than they had been creating and the price level changes.
 
As long as we have established that you were completely wrong, that is fine with me. Now I suggest you stop hijacking Yoga’s thread. Eventually it will die and people will forget you made a fool of yourself.

Advice: Clearly, you are a young guy who thinks it is embarrassing to be caught out on such a mistake. However, in the greater scheme of things, your being wrong about the relationship between deposits and loans is not important. When you get older, you will learn that people don’t remember the unimportant mistakes you make in life but they do remember your reaction to them. They won’t remember your mistake but they will remember your going overboard in reaction to it being pointed out.

You are the one hijacking the thread. You keep repeating the same thing, hinking that somehow it constitutes an argument. You "you are young" etc comments are hilarious.

As for you, I have no idea how old you are, but I fear you will NEVER learn the essentials of critical thinking and logical argumentation. And my REASON ( yes - sometimes people DO have reasons in an argument) is that you are becoming increasingly illogical with every post, now making completely baseless comments about my age etc.
You can't let it be and are now making all kinds of illogical assertions.

Now, I am not STATING FOR A FACT (unlike you) that you are unbalbnced, but you do seem to have very deep psycholigical issues that I hope you can deal with eventually. I am not a psycjologist, but I do see a bit of histronic disorder "is defined by the American Psychiatric Association as a personality disorder characterized by a pattern of excessive emotionality and attention-seeking, including an excessive need for approval "
 
Burt, don’t you ever get tired of making a fool of yourself. So you were wrong about something. Big deal. The best thing to do now is to just move on and not keep reminding everyone you were wrong by continually making these posts.
 
Well, to me you are exhibiting the classic symptoms of a histronic disorder. Maybe not. But if you insist on doing your own hijacking (see your post # 52, which had nothing to do with the original post, but was simply another of your baseless attacks on me), then of bloody course I will respond. Just don't pepper every response with an insult, get back on topic, and we're good to go. But I've always insisted on returning fire when fired upon. It's up to you.
 
Well, to me you are exhibiting the classic symptoms of a histronic disorder. Maybe not. But if you insist on doing your own hijacking (see your post # 52, which had nothing to do with the original post, but was simply another of your baseless attacks on me), then of bloody course I will respond. Just don't pepper every response with an insult, get back on topic, and we're good to go. But I've always insisted on returning fire when fired upon. It's up to you.
If you had any brains at all, you would have taken my advice in post 52. You have a serious insecurity problem if you call helpful advice an attack. Look, you made yourself look foolish by not only making a stupid post but insisting on arguing about if long after it was clear you were wrong and that I knew far more than you did. If you have any brains at all, you will take the advice I gave you in post 52. It was meant to be helpful.
 
You are a hopeless egomaniac. I asked you to stop PMing me and yet you continue. You repeatedly spout the same nonesnse over and over , failing to see how clear it is that you are obsessed with anyone upstaging you. You fail to use the slightest hint ot logic in any of your comments about me. You are obsessed with me! lol

You see, I tried to end it somewhat amicably in post 57. I attempeted to show you my side of things, yet , ONCE AGAIN (in a tired voice!) lol you must once again bandy about terms like "any brains at all", "look foolosih", "stupid post". So you are the insecure one, you are obviously enjopying this cause you can't leave it be.


Now, once again i will try to help you. I will reiterate YOUR position, so that you don't have to, then THIS very post can be the last unless you insist on prolonging it.

You think I am stupid, have no brains, umm lets see, oh well, I can't remember them all, wrong about my posts, know nothing about banks or the banking system, have no clue where money supply growth comes from - hopefully that pretty well sums up YOUR position.
 
I don’t think you need to assume it created any goods. I think a better way of looking at it is that if the banks did not lend to government, they would just lend to someone else. Think back to our posts #5 and #6. All government is doing in that example is crowding out private borrowing (You could make things more complicated and get some goods created in the short run but if you limited things to the long run you don’t need that complication.). However, when government lends money to itself it is creating money that would not otherwise have been created. E.g. it is the central bank that changes the size of the money supply from an existing equilibrium. Otherwise, the money supply would remain fairly constant with banks more or less creating however much money they have always created. It is when central banks change the reserves of the banking system that private banks start creating more or less money than they had been creating and the price level changes.

OK but the banks create money in the form of credit but that does not cause inflation because the money it lends comes from us and we created goods with it ( not always but usually) and the money they lend in turn creates goods ( not always but usually)