Economics question

Yoga Face

New member
Jun 30, 2009
6,307
19
0
Why does it cause inflation when the government prints money to fund a project yet it does not when the government borrows the monies from a bank ?? as banks do not lend money they have so the banks are making money up like the government would have if it just printed more money


When the government sells bonds to the public that is a transfer of wealth. When they sell them to the banks no wealth is transferred wealth is just created out of thin air in the form of ledgers by the banks



Also, when the government borrows from a bank they now have to pay interest which they would not if they just borrowed the money from themselves (by making it up) then paying themselves back later through taxes to get the extra monies out of circulation
 
as banks do not lend money they have so the banks are making money up like the government would have if it just printed more money
Individual Banks lend money they have borrowed from someone else. That someone else might be depositors like you (when you make a deposit in your bank account, you are lending the bank money), firms, other banks or the central bank. Whoever it is, they have borrowed the money from someone else. Banks make their money on the difference between what they pay for their funds, (e.g. interest on your deposits) and what they get when they lend money. Whether the bank lends the money to government or someone else is the same from its point of view (other than loans to government usually having less risk). If they lend $1 to government, that is one less dollar they can lend to someone else.

As we discussed before, when the money banks have lent is deposit by someone else money is created. However, that money is only created when government starts the process by printing the original money injected into the system. Otherwise, banks have nothing to lend. Once the original money is injected into the system (e.g. the money is “printed), when it comes to inflation, it makes no difference whether private banks lend it to government or to someone else.

BTW, in modern economies governments/central banks almost never actually “print money” when they print money. Instead the central bank buys government bonds and pays for them by making accounting entries, crediting the accounts chartered banks keep with them. Usually, only countries with undeveloped bond markets (e.g. Zimbabwe) actually “print money” when they print money.
 
Individual Banks lend money they have borrowed from someone else. That someone else might be depositors like you (when you make a deposit in your bank account, you are lending the bank money), firms, other banks or the central bank. Whoever it is, they have borrowed the money from someone else. Banks make their money on the difference between what they pay for their funds, (e.g. interest on your deposits) and what they get when they lend money.

As we discussed before, when the money banks have lent is deposit by someone else money is created. However, that money is only created when government starts the process by printing the original money injected into the system. Otherwise, banks have nothing to lend.

BTW, modern economies almost never actually “print money” when they print money. Instead the central bank buys government bonds and pays for them by making accounting entries, crediting the accounts chartered banks keep with them. Usually, only countries with undeveloped bond markets (e.g. Zimbabwe) actually “print money” when they print money.


Old topic but it is not finished

Yes I understand governments do not print money but create ledgers the same way banks do

You are incorrect about the banks as banks only keep 7 % in reserve so they lend out far more money then they have borrowed from depositors so the banks are creating ledger money the same way a government would if it lent itself money are they not ???? What is the difference between a bank making up ledger money and the government making up ledger money ??? It is all made up as it did not come from the creation of goods therefore should be equally inflationary !
 
Old topic but it is not finished

Yes I understand governments do not print money but create ledgers the same way banks do

You are incorrect about the banks as banks only keep 7 % in reserve so they lend out far more money then they have borrowed from depositors so the banks are creating ledger money the same way a government would if it lent itself money are they not ???? What is the difference between a bank making up ledger money and the government making up ledger money ??? It is all made up as it did not come from the creation of goods therefore should be equally inflationary !
Only the central bank can start the process. A private bank cannot lend out money it does not have. If it has money to lend out (borrowed from someone else), if it lends it to government it cannot lend it to someone else. Whether it lends the money to government instead of someone else makes no difference from the prospective of inflation.
 
A private bank cannot lend out money it does not have. If it has money to lend out (borrowed from someone else), if it lends it to government it cannot lend it to someone else.

But in essence banks do lend more money than deposited

I deposit money which I created GDP to obtain

You borrow that money

You buy something with that money

The seller deposits my original monies which is relent on and on and on

My original deposit expands many fold

You can argue (can you?) each deposit of my original deposit has created GDP somewhere

IE you bought a car with my original monies and now they have to build another car to replace it

If you cannot argue the above then there is no difference between the banks relending the same deposit and the government making money up
 
But in essence banks do lend more money than deposited
Not individual banks or even the system. Add up the sum total of deposits. Each loan becomes a new deposit. The fact is whether an individual bank uses its deposits to finance a loan to the government or a loan to someone else makes no difference when it comes to inflation. The only effect of the government borrowing from banks is to increase interest rates, reducing the demand for loans by other economic agents.
You can argue (can you?) each deposit of my original deposit has created GDP somewhere
I never said anything about it creating GDP. GDP is the total value of final goods and services produced domestically. In the long run, that is determined by real factors. In the long run, an increase in government consuption just reduces private consumption, regardless of how it is financed. In the long run, it is more a matter of how the pie (society's total production of goods and services) is divided. (OK, if the spending effects either the productivity of private production or incentives things could get more complicated but let's not go there right now as that depends on the specifics of the spending in question and not on how it is financed anyway).
 
Last edited:
Not individual banks or even the system. Add up the sum total of deposits. Each loan becomes a new deposit.

I deposit $100

You borrow $100

You buy $100 of services

The seller deposits $100

The bank re loans the $100 I originally deposited once again

$200 have been deposited and $200 loaned this is understand but

only $100 of that $200 loaned has been earned by the creation of GDP (which was my original deposit that you borrowed )
and inflation = money supply divided by GDP so we now have an additional $100 in the system with no equivalent addition of GDP hence inflation the same as if the government had expanded the money supply ?????????????

To counter this you have to argue that you bought someone's labour with your loan which in turn created $100 worth of GDP ( IE you bought a car with the $100 so they have to build another car ) so the growth of money supply created by banks (more accurately the growth of bank credit as the banks do not print money) is equalled by the growth of GDP so there is no inflation


So when the government borrows from the banks it is borrowing credit that has created GDP and can be safely respent knowing no inflation is being created

but when the government borrows from itself the borrowed credit is not backed by actual GDP so infaltion will result


I never said anything about it creating GDP. GDP is the total value of final goods and services produced domestically. In the long run, that is determined by real factors. In the long run, an increase in government consumption just reduces private consumption, regardless of how it is financed. In the long run, it is more a matter of how the pie (society's total production of goods and services) is divided. (OK, if the spending effects either the productivity of private production or incentives things could get more complicated but let's not go there right now as that depends on the specifics of the spending in question and not on how it is financed anyway).

This I understand (I think) If the government makes up monies to build a highway there is no more GNP then if they did not build the highway because an equivalent GDP was taken away from the private workforce which would have built something else ( assuming full employment) so we now have more monies ( in the form of government credits) in the system with no additional GDP which causes inflation
 
I deposit $100

You borrow $100
Change me to the Government borrows $100 in services and you will see that nothing really changes.
You buy $100 of services
This becomes, the government buys $100 in services instead. The rest is as you describe. The only real difference is that at this point the government has bought $100 in services instead of me.
The seller deposits $100

The bank re loans the $100 I originally deposited once again

$200 have been deposited and $200 loaned this is understand but

only $100 of that $200 loaned has been earned by the creation of GDP (which was my original deposit that you borrowed )
and inflation = money supply divided by GDP so we now have an additional $100 in the system with no equivalent addition of GDP hence inflation the same as if the government had expanded the money supply ?????????????
Actually, inflation is the change in the price level and not what you have described. However, the point is that the original $100 has to come from somewhere. E.g. the Central bank creates it when it buys government debt. If they don’t create the new $100 the process starts with, the rest never occurs.

Also, in your example when the banks keep nothing in reserves, the increase in the money supply form the original $100 deposit is infinite and there is a financial crisis if any depositor ever wants cash. However, I will assume that you were just trying to keep the example simple when you had them lend out the entire $100 you deposited.
 
Actually, inflation is the change in the price level and not what you have described. However, the point is that the original $100 has to come from somewhere. E.g. the Central bank creates it when it buys government debt. If they don’t create the new $100 the process starts with, the rest never occurs..



Yes but more money without more GDP means higher prices as more money chases same amount of goods

I still think I am correct in stating when you borrow from a bank you are borrowing money that has produced GDP and when I spend it it will produce more GDP hence no inflation ( although the money supply has increased )

But when the government increases the money supply by borrowing from itself the money has not produced any GDP so is inflationary

Also, in your example when the banks keep nothing in reserves, the increase in the money supply form the original $100 deposit is infinite and there is a financial crisis if any depositor ever wants cash. However, I will assume that you were just trying to keep the example simple when you had them lend out the entire $100 you deposited.

Yes I was
 
Yes but more money without more GDP means higher prices as more money chases same amount of goods

I still think I am correct in stating when you borrow from a bank you are borrowing money that has produced GDP and when I spend it it will produce more GDP hence no inflation ( although the money supply has increased )
Money does not produce GDP. Factors of production like capital and labour when combined with technology produces GDP. Money is just something that is generally accepted in payments for goods and services that make up GDP.
 
Money does not produce GDP. Factors of production like capital and labour when combined with technology produces GDP. Money is just something that is generally accepted in payments for goods and services that make up GDP.


Understood that the dollar represents GDP and is not the GDP itself



My next question is meant to be serious


Do you think I am obtuse in that I am not grasping simple economic theories

Actually, I find the concept as to why the government should not borrow from its own made up ledgers instead of the banks ledgers in order to avoid interest payments (I know the simple answer is it would cause inflation ) intriguing and not as straight forward as one would assume
 
Understood that the dollar represents GDP and is not the GDP itself
I think that a better way of looking at it is that dollars are the unit of measurement of GDP (and a lot of other economic variables like savings, debt, etc.). Likewise, Celsius is the unit of measurement of temperature, kilograms for weight (whether the weight is your weight, a car’s weight, etc.), minutes are a unit of measure for time, etc.
My next question is meant to be serious


Do you think I am obtuse in that I am not grasping simple economic theories

Actually, I find the concept as to why the government should not borrow from its own made up ledgers instead of the banks ledgers in order to avoid interest payments (I know the simple answer is it would cause inflation ) intriguing and not as straight forward as one would assume
Perhaps you just need it explained in a different way by someone else. Remainder bins, places like Value Village and Goodwill (second hand bookstores don’t even accept them) often have old economics textbooks on sale for very little. Indeed, I will be moving soon and I’m trying to figure out how to get rid of a lot of old textbooks (It just feels wrong to me to put any books in the garbage but I realize that is not rational). Perhaps you should pick up one of those books the next time you pass a Goodwill, Value Village, etc. They might be dated but this stuff is not new and you might find their explanations better.
BTW, some time ago, you started a thread asking for information on creative writing courses. Did you find one you liked?
 
I think that a better way of looking at it is that dollars are the unit of measurement of GDP (and a lot of other economic variables like savings, debt, etc.). Likewise, Celsius is the unit of measurement of temperature, kilograms for weight (whether the weight is your weight, a car’s weight, etc.), minutes are a unit of measure for time, etc.

Perhaps you just need it explained in a different way by someone else. Remainder bins, places like Value Village and Goodwill (second hand bookstores don’t even accept them) often have old economics textbooks on sale for very little. Indeed, I will be moving soon and I’m trying to figure out how to get rid of a lot of old textbooks (It just feels wrong to me to put any books in the garbage but I realize that is not rational). Perhaps you should pick up one of those books the next time you pass a Goodwill, Value Village, etc. They might be dated but this stuff is not new and you might find their explanations better.
BTW, some time ago, you started a thread asking for information on creative writing courses. Did you find one you liked?

I found one that has students write on a spontaneous topic and people are not allowed only to say what they like about what you wrote

The idea is to take the intimidation out of writing

I was in a group but thought they were not very good and not capable of appreciating my stuff but that could just be my ego although I believe I have genuine abilities that are somewhat of a gift but I could be wrong as it is too subjective to analyze your own stuff

Some people say writing cannot be judged as good or bad as it is art

I disagree

I became intersersted in economics while in NYC

I saw some brokers `Limo surfing` so I wrote a piece on it

That is where brokers rent limos and drive down wall street toasting each other through the sun roofs with champagne after having made a fortune going short or whatever

While writing I started to wonder if betting on such things screws up economies without adding to the point of the market which is to put money into the hands of entrepeneurs

I see Germany wants to stop short selling the Euro
 
Not individual banks or even the system. Add up the sum total of deposits. Each loan becomes a new deposit.

Dead wrong.

Banks lend out many TIMES what they have in deposits. It is called credit. Much of the 'money' out there is actually credit. Which is why a credit contration is so dangerous, and why the money supply can be contracting even as the government is doing everything in its power to prime the pump. If banks gets scared and overly cautious it can create a deflationary spiral.

From Wikipedia:

Fractional-reserve banking is the banking practice in which banks keep only a fraction of their deposits in reserve (as cash and other highly liquid assets) and lend out the remainder, while maintaining the simultaneous obligation to redeem all these deposits upon demand.[1][2] Fractional reserve banking necessarily occurs when banks lend out any fraction of the funds received from deposit accounts, and is practiced by all modern commercial banks.

By its nature, the practice of fractional reserve banking expands the money supply (cash and demand deposits) beyond what it would otherwise be. Because of the prevalence of fractional reserve banking, the broad money supply of most countries is a multiple larger than the amount of base money created by the country's central bank. That multiple (called the money multiplier) is determined by the reserve requirement or other financial ratio requirements imposed by financial regulators, and by the excess reserves kept by commercial banks.

Another factor affecting inflation sis the velocity of money - i.e. how quickly it is 'turned around' and moves through the system.
 
Dead wrong.

Banks lend out many TIMES what they have in deposits. It is called credit. Much of the 'money' out there is actually credit. Which is why a credit contration is so dangerous, and why the money supply can be contracting even as the government is doing everything in its power to prime the pump. If banks gets scared and overly cautious it can create a deflationary spiral.

From Wikipedia:

Fractional-reserve banking is the banking practice in which banks keep only a fraction of their deposits in reserve (as cash and other highly liquid assets) and lend out the remainder, while maintaining the simultaneous obligation to redeem all these deposits upon demand.[1][2] Fractional reserve banking necessarily occurs when banks lend out any fraction of the funds received from deposit accounts, and is practiced by all modern commercial banks.

By its nature, the practice of fractional reserve banking expands the money supply (cash and demand deposits) beyond what it would otherwise be. Because of the prevalence of fractional reserve banking, the broad money supply of most countries is a multiple larger than the amount of base money created by the country's central bank. That multiple (called the money multiplier) is determined by the reserve requirement or other financial ratio requirements imposed by financial regulators, and by the excess reserves kept by commercial banks.

Another factor affecting inflation sis the velocity of money - i.e. how quickly it is 'turned around' and moves through the system.

Someone is correct in stating banks do not loan out more than they have

Fractional reserve is the lending out of most of what you have not more than you have

What I wonder is why this does not cause the same inflation as the printing of money as any deposit is continually lent out “deposit creation multiplier" as it is redeposited by someone else therefore are not the banks increasing the money supply as if they actually printed money ???

I assert they are but the money supply they create also produces goods or GDP which balances the money supply so there is no inflation
 
Dead wrong.
Look guy, I know far more about thus stuff then you do. I am the one who to gets paid to teach people like you this stuff.
Banks lend out many TIMES what they have in deposits. It is called credit. Much of the 'money' out there is actually credit.
You are simply wrong here. I think your confusion is that you think the only deposit in the system is the original deposit. I would suggest you google the term “deposit creation multiplier” before you make a complete fool of yourself. The fact is that a bank’s liabilities (e.g. deposits people hold with it) must equal its assets (loans it has made plus reserves it keeps) plus equity (a small term). If you ever take a first-year course, this will be explained to you with what are called T accounts. The left side of which must always equal the right side.

The fact is each loan a bank makes creates new deposits of an equal amount (minus whatever proportion people decide to hold in cash).

Which is why a credit contration is so dangerous, and why the money supply can be contracting even as the government is doing everything in its power to prime the pump. If banks gets scared and overly cautious it can create a deflationary spiral.

From Wikipedia:

Fractional-reserve banking is the banking practice in which banks keep only a fraction of their deposits in reserve (as cash and other highly liquid assets) and lend out the remainder, while maintaining the simultaneous obligation to redeem all these deposits upon demand.[1][2] Fractional reserve banking necessarily occurs when banks lend out any fraction of the funds received from deposit accounts, and is practiced by all modern commercial banks.

By its nature, the practice of fractional reserve banking expands the money supply (cash and demand deposits) beyond what it would otherwise be. Because of the prevalence of fractional reserve banking, the broad money supply of most countries is a multiple larger than the amount of base money created by the country's central bank. That multiple (called the money multiplier) is determined by the reserve requirement or other financial ratio requirements imposed by financial regulators, and by the excess reserves kept by commercial banks.

Another factor affecting inflation sis the velocity of money - i.e. how quickly it is 'turned around' and moves through the system.
You clearly do not understand what the Wikipedia passage says or you would know that nothing in it disagrees with anything I have said.
 
Last edited:
Look guy, I know far more about thus stuff then you do. I am the only to gets paid to teach people like you this stuff.

You are simply wrong here. I think your confusion is that you think the only deposit in the system is the original deposit. I would suggest you google the term “deposit creation multiplier” before you make a complete fool of yourself. The fact is that a bank’s liabilities (e.g. deposits people hold with it) must equal its assets (loans it has made plus reserves it keeps) plus equity (a small term). If you ever take a first-year course, this will be explained to you with what are called T accounts. The left side of which must always equal the right side.

The fact is each loan a bank makes creates new deposits of an equal amount (minus whatever proportion people decide to hold in cash).


You clearly do not understand what the Wikipedia passage says or you would know that nothing in it disagrees with anything I have said.

Listen, I wish people who have little differences of opinion could refrain from tossing about words like 'fool' etc, and saying "hey, I win the argument because... I know more than you do!" lol. Just shows you have to ameliorate your argument with vindictive comments in a rather pathetic attampt to somehow bolster your facts. Of course it does nothing of the kind. It's about as childish as me saying you are wrong because your first sentence has a spelling/grammar error. Grow up.

Look, banks ON AGGREGATE lend out more than they take in in the form of deposts - agreed? Lets deal with one simple fact at a time. It's called credit creation, and it's why if everyone at a bank demanded their deposits back almost no banks in the world could do so.

see below

Reserve Requirements and Money Creation
Reserve requirements affect the potential of the banking system to create transaction deposits. If the reserve requirement is 10%, for example, a bank that receives a $100 deposit may lend out $90 of that deposit. If the borrower then writes a check to someone who deposits the $90, the bank receiving that deposit can lend out $81. As the process continues, the banking system can expand the initial deposit of $100 into a maximum of $1,000 of money ($100+$90+81+$72.90+...=$1,000). In contrast, with a 20% reserve requirement, the banking system would be able to expand the initial $100 deposit into a maximum of $500 ($100+$80+$64+$51.20+...=$500). Thus, higher reserve requirements should result in reduced money creation and, in turn, in reduced economic activity.

Please explain to me: 1) what about the above paragraph you disagree with, and 2) tell me, has a $100 deposit indeed been expanded VIA THE BANKING SYSTEM into $1,000?
 
Listen, I wish people who have little differences of opinion could refrain from tossing about words like 'fool' etc, and saying "hey, I win the argument because... I know more than you do!" lol. Just shows you have to ameliorate your argument with vindictive comments in a rather pathetic attampt to somehow bolster your facts. Of course it does nothing of the kind.
The fact remains that I know far more than you do. If you were smart you would use my posts to correct your misunderstandings.
Look, banks ON AGGREGATE lend out more than they take in in the form of deposts - agreed?
I have already explained to you that this is incorrect. If you were smart, you would use my posts to try to understand why you are wrong here.
Lets deal with one simple fact at a time. It's called credit creation,
Actually, it is normally referred to as deposit creation. That is why the terms deposit multiplier and money multiplier are used. The main difference between the two is the one allows for the possibility that there might be a cash drain.
and it's why if everyone at a bank demanded their deposits back almost no banks in the world could do so.

see below

Reserve Requirements and Money Creation
Reserve requirements affect the potential of the banking system to create transaction deposits. If the reserve requirement is 10%, for example, a bank that receives a $100 deposit may lend out $90 of that deposit. If the borrower then writes a check to someone who deposits the $90, the bank receiving that deposit can lend out $81. As the process continues, the banking system can expand the initial deposit of $100 into a maximum of $1,000 of money ($100+$90+81+$72.90+...=$1,000). In contrast, with a 20% reserve requirement, the banking system would be able to expand the initial $100 deposit into a maximum of $500 ($100+$80+$64+$51.20+...=$500). Thus, higher reserve requirements should result in reduced money creation and, in turn, in reduced economic activity.

Please explain to me: 1) what about the above paragraph you disagree with, and 2) tell me, has a $100 deposit indeed been expanded VIA THE BANKING SYSTEM into $1,000?
It is not the above that is wrong but you inability to understand it. $100 is the initial deposit. In the process $1 000 in new deposits have been created in the second case $500 in new deposits have been created. In the first case, you end up with a total of $1100 in deposits (the original $100 plus the $1000 in new deposits) and $1000 in loans. The total assets of the banking system ($100 in reserves plus $1000 in loans) is equal to the total liabilities of the banking system ($1100 in deposits).

Edit: Try this link. It will take you through the process step by step: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Money_creation#Money_creation_through_the_fractional_reserve_system

I would rather not spend a lot of my leisure time trying to explain this to you. However, if you indicate you have made a real attempt to try to understand it and still have a question, let me know.
 
Last edited:
LOL, you fail to admit that you know liittle on the subject, by refusing to accept that what I wrote is correct. After all, I am me, therefore you must be wrong! Naw naw naw naw naw, I know more than you do (adopting your infantile tactics).

Oh yes, if you were smart you would see how wrong you are because I know more blah blah blah. Gee , arguing 'someone-style' is actually boring. How can you stand it?

Anyone who knows anything about banks knows that they are very leveraged entities PRECISELY because of thi. You must be a young whipper snapper - dont worry, given enough time you will learn.



What is it about this: As the process continues, the banking system can expand the initial deposit of $100 into a maximum of $1,000 of money -- that you dont understand? I will try to walk you through it.
 
And:
from
Money multiplier
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to:navigation, search

In monetary economics, a money multiplier is one of various closely related ratios of commercial bank money to central bank money under a fractional-reserve banking system.[1] Most often, it measures the maximum amount of commercial bank money that can be created by a given unit of central bank money. That is, in a fractional-reserve banking system, the total amount of loans that commercial banks are allowed to extend (the commercial bank money that they can legally create) is a multiple of reserves; this multiple is the reciprocal of the reserve ratio, and it is an economic multiplier.[2]

If banks lend out close to the maximum allowed by their reserves, then the inequality becomes an approximate equality, and commercial bank money is central bank money times the multiplier. If banks instead lend less than the maximum, accumulating excess reserves, then commercial bank money will be less than central bank money times the multiplier.

In the United States since 1959, banks lent out close to the maximum allowed for the 49-year period from 1959 until August 2008, maintaining a low level of excess reserves, then accumulated significant excess reserves over the period September 2008 through the present (November 2009). Thus, in the first period, commercial bank money was almost exactly central bank money times the multiplier, but this relationship broke down from September 2008.