Economics question

It is important ( and I assume you are asking this question in reference to our current situation) that an increase in the money supply from any source does not necessarily lead to inflation, and in fact can coexist with deflation. This is called the liquidity trap, and is basically where Japan finds itself today. I think there is a much larger chance of this happenning to us than most people realize.
 
OK but the banks create money in the form of credit but that does not cause inflation because the money it lends comes from us and we created goods with it ( not always but usually) and the money they lend in turn creates goods ( not always but usually)
Actually not. There is no reason to assume the money lent creates goods in the long run. Also, under a fait money system, the original reserves came from the central bank. See your previous thread for elaboration on this point. I think you have to get away from the idea that money creates goods. Goods are created with factors of production and technology, not money. In the long run, there is an almost 1-to-1 relationship between the growth the money supply (in excess of GDP growth) and inflation. It is one of the strongest economic relationships you can find. Also, you have to remember that it is the central bank that starts the process. When the government sells its bonds to the public, it has no real effect on the money supply, even if the bonds are bought by banks. When they sell bonds to the central bank, new reserves are created. We saw that in posts 5 and 6 and the previous thread. If no new reserves are created when they sell bonds to the public (whether bought by private banks or other investors) no reserves are created and hence no new money is created. If there is no new money, in the long run there is no new increase in prices. I think we have been through all of this before and are now just going in circles. Maybe someone like Fuji or OTB can explain this in a way that is more understandable.
 
Actually not. There is no reason to assume the money lent creates goods in the long run. Also, under a fait money system, the original reserves came from the central bank. See your previous thread for elaboration on this point. I think you have to get away from the idea that money creates goods. Goods are created with factors of production and technology, not money. In the long run, there is an almost 1-to-1 relationship between the growth the money supply (in excess of GDP growth) and inflation. It is one of the strongest economic relationships you can find. Also, you have to remember that it is the central bank that starts the process. When the government sells its bonds to the public, it has no real effect on the money supply, even if the bonds are bought by banks. When they sell bonds to the central bank, new reserves are created. We saw that in posts 5 and 6 and the previous thread. If no new reserves are created when they sell bonds to the public (whether bought by private banks or other investors) no reserves are created and hence no new money is created. If there is no new money, in the long run there is no new increase in prices. I think we have been through all of this before and are now just going in circles. Maybe someone like Fuji or OTB can explain this in a way that is more understandable.


Thanks someone

So you are saying when the banks relend the same money they have not created new money in the form of bank credit ???? If not then this is the fatal flaw of the film that started my original thread

I realize increase in money supply ( or bank credits which I am assuming is the same thing ) does not create goods because it depends how it is spent

Also, is burt correct when he states

"an increase in the money supply from any source does not necessarily lead to inflation, and in fact can coexist with deflation. This is called the liquidity trap, and is basically where Japan finds itself today. I think there is a much larger chance of this happenning to us than most people realize."

I find his statement puzzling
 
Thanks someone

So you are saying when the banks relend the same money they have not created new money in the form of bank credit ???? If not then this is the fatal flaw of the film that started my original thread
Banks are in the business of borrowing from one party and lending to another. If they were not lending to the government by buying government bonds, they would lend it to someone else. The point is they can only create money when the central bank increases the reserves of the banking system. Remember the story of the last thread (I forget the exact numbers). The Bank of Canada buys $1000 worth of government of Canada bonds from you. You take that $1000 and deposit it in your bank and they lend out part of it. If banks keep 10% of deposits as reserves and the Bank of Canada increases reserves by buying government bonds worth $1000, private banks can then “create” an additional $10 000 (assuming no one holds cash, etc.). Some of the $10000 might be in the form of loans to government but it could also all be loans to individuals. However, if the Central bank does not increase the reserves, the private banks cannot “create” money (unless they decide to reduce the reserves they keep. Unlike the U.S., in Canada there is no legal minimum they have to keep).
Don’t worry about possible liquidity traps as they have nothing to do with your question. Your question deals with the long run relationship between inflation and the money supply. Liquidity traps are a theoretical possibility (many argue it is not even a theoretical possibility) when monetary policy may be ineffective and fiscal policy may be very effective. Basically , Keynesians argue that in the short run, prices may be “sticky”. That is they do not change quickly. If so, then fiscal and monetary policy may increase GDP in the short run. Expansionary monetary policy (increasing the money supply) would reduce interest rates (and if prices are fixed or at least sticky in the short run, otherwise nominal interest rates would increase and real interest rates would remain fixed). If so, investment will increase and GDP will increase. However, this is all in the short run when prices are fixed. In the long run, when prices are flexible, GDP returns to full employment. Keynes hypothesized that if income was really low (e.g. the great depression) and nominal interest rates are already near zero, businessmen might not want to invest if they did not think customers would have money to buy their goods anyway, regardless of how low interest rates were. Think of the liquidity trap in terms of the old saying, “you can lead an horse to water but you can’t make him drink”. Thus, Keynes argued that expansionary monetary policy might not even have a short run effect on GDP. The main argument against the liquidity trap is that even if nominal interest rates are near zero, the inflation you eventually get from increasing the money supply should still be able to push real interest rates below zero (real interest rates are approximately equal to the nominal rate of interest you pay minus the rate of inflation) If you are interested in that stuff, I suggest taking a night course or a correspondence course in first and second year macroeconomics as you don’t really get to that until you learn something called the ISLM model. At one time, first year macroeconomics courses finished with ISLM but now that is usually left until second year. Anyway, I would prefer not to get into it right now. It really has nothing to do with your question with is really about the long run relationship between the money supply and inflation.
 
Well, I was reading your question Yoga, and thinking how so many people fear inflation is an inevitable result of recent policies, that i thought I would point out that increases in the money supply do not necessarily lead to inflation. So yes, it actually does have SOMETHING to do with your question, in that it is an interesting offshoot to what you are talking about, namely MONEY SUPPLY and INFLATION. I guess however we are no longer allowed to take threads off in interesting directions?

Now, by the way, with regard to a liquidity trap, SOMEONE said"

The main argument against the liquidity trap is that even if nominal interest rates are near zero, the inflation you eventually get from increasing the money supply should still be able to push real interest rates below zero (real interest rates are approximately equal to the nominal rate of interest you pay minus the rate of inflation).

He is right, but the key word is EVENTUALLY. Just because a problem is EVENTUALLY solved does not mean it doesn't exist in the first place. If that were the case, recessions wouldn't exist because they EVENTUALLY end. For that matter, I wouldn't exist either, because EVENTUALLY I won;'t be here either. Japan's problems are now going on 20 years.

You might want to read these fascinating articles, by Paul Krugman: ( brief description below)

"Who is Paul Krugman and why do people say such nasty things about him? And why is a mere economist drawing the kind of fire usually reserved for real celebrities--say, Rush Limbaugh? Simple. The Stanford University scholar has been puncturing the reputations of policy wonks all over Washington. In a prodigious spate of essays and books--the latest, Pop Internationalism (221 pages. MIT Press), hits the stores next week--Krugman has launched a one-man crusade to shatter the era's most cherished economic myths. Among the most pernicious: the very C[onventional] W[isdom] idea that in our dog-eat-dog, post-cold-war world, America must viciously compete for jobs and markets against other nations.

But more on that in a moment. What most riles the wonks is that Krugman is impossible to ignore. Born on New York's Long Island, educated at MIT, he's one of the world's most eminent trade theorists--a future Nobel Prize winner, in the view of his peers. He's not just some ivory-tower type, either; he writes eloquently and simply for the public. "A lot of dumb stuff passes for sophistication out there," says the frenetic, gnomishly handsome Krugman, his brown eyes darting to and fro as a cascade of ideas tumbles from his mouth. "What amazes me is that people will have a vast thesis of the world economy and what it's doing to us--and not check their facts."

http://web.mit.edu/krugman/www/japtrap.html

http://web.mit.edu/krugman/www/jpage.html

Yoga, am I right that you have some interest in this as an investor?
 
Now, by the way, with regard to a liquidity trap, SOMEONE said"
Look guy, you already know that I think you are an idiot (as you said yourself). It would be best if you did not comment on my posts and continue to hi-Jack Yoga's thread. I only responed to your nonsense becuase Yoga Face asked me to. As I say, your post has nothing to do with his question, but you would have to understand his question to realize this.

Yoga Face, why don’t we leave our exchange for some other time when we have more mature co-posters? I think we are just repeating our past posts in this and other threads anyway.
 
I am not hijacking any thread, I just took it in another interesting direction that Yoga was curious about. Who are you to say where a thread can and cannot go? What is "nonsensical' about discussing the possibility of us entereing into a 'lost decade' similar to what japan has experienced?

And Pu Lease- lol, his original post concerned money supply, inflation, amongst other things, so my reference to the liquidity trap is painfully obviously relevant. No, not an EXACT involvement in his origiinal question, but of enough interest to pique his interest. Besides, I suspect in fact his original question STEMS from the concern which many have nowadays of the effect of current loose monetary policy on eventual inflation.

Please refer to my many other posts for my opinion of yourself.
 
Banks are in the business of borrowing from one party and lending to another. If they were not lending to the government by buying government bonds, they would lend it to someone else. The point is they can only create money when the central bank increases the reserves of the banking system. Remember the story of the last thread (I forget the exact numbers). The Bank of Canada buys $1000 worth of government of Canada bonds from you. You take that $1000 and deposit it in your bank and they lend out part of it. If banks keep 10% of deposits as reserves and the Bank of Canada increases reserves by buying government bonds worth $1000, private banks can then “create” an additional $10 000 (assuming no one holds cash, etc.). Some of the $10000 might be in the form of loans to government but it could also all be loans to individuals. However, if the Central bank does not increase the reserves, the private banks cannot “create” money (unless they decide to reduce the reserves they keep. Unlike the U.S., in Canada there is no legal minimum they have to keep).


I realize we are going full circle here but I now got you to agree that banks create money by re lending the same monies (regardless of where the original deposits came from)

So if every dollar they have is relent into nine dollars then why no hyper inflation ????? Has always been my question (in one form or another)

My argument is this lent money creates goods and services (USUALLY) that expands the economy so no inflation even though there is more money in the form of bank credits

When the government borrows from itself instead of the banks it does not expand the economy just makes more money

Even if they build a bridge with that money that is just labor taken from the manufacter of private goods so no more goods have been created just different goods

The made up bank money has GNP attached to it (but government made up money does not) but if the government increases reserves by buying back bonds is this money made up ?? I would think not as it came from taxes

When the goverment makes up money there is inflation but not when the banks do so my question has always been why
 
Last edited: