Does Lacroix know something about Forsberg??

handsome sugardaddy

New member
Apr 16, 2005
486
0
0
The following up todate team salaries is from today. Look at the two comparing Colorado and Philadelphia.........Eliminate the Forsberg contract from Philly's list and the two teams were relatively the same in Cap space. For the two Philly contracts listed as undisclosed, insert $875,000 for each of them. That is what the two players in question signed for.

So the question is.........why did Lacroix not sign Forsberg for what Philly signed him for??

Player Contract Notes 2005-2006 Salary (US)
Joe Sakic $6,664,797
Rob Blake $6,364,111
Alex Tanguay Re-signed RFA (Colorado) $3.23 million
Pierre Turgeon UFA (Dallas) $2,533,333
Steve Konowalchuk $1.9 million
Patrice Brisebois UFA (Montreal) $1.5 million
Ian Laperriere $1.14 million
Bob Boughner $950,000
Ossi Vaananen $950,000
Kurt Sauer Re-signed RFA (Colorado) $718,200
Antti Laaksonen $646,000
Brett McLean $450,000
Cody McCormick $450,000
13 Players $27,446,241


Peter Forsberg UFA (Colorado) $5.75 million
Mike Rathje UFA (San Jose) $3.5 million
Derian Hatcher UFA (Detroit) $3.5 million
Keith Primeau $3.42 million
Eric Desjardins $2.28 million
Michal Handzus $2.128 million
Donald Brashear $1.748 million
Mike Knuble $1.52 million
Sami Kapanen $1.52 million
Turner Stevenson $1.254 million
Joni Pitkanen $900,600
Mattias Timander $608,000
Chris Therien UFA (Dallas) $500,000
Jon Sim UFA (,) $450,000
Jeff Carter Signed rookie deal Undisclosed
Mike Richards Signed rookie deal Undisclosed
14 Players 2 Salaries Undisclosed $29,078,600


Philly with the two undisclosed total, $30,750,000.00......minus, 5.75 for Forsberg, you get $25,00,000.00.

The difference between the two teams prior to Forsberg was 2.75 million. Wondering why Lacroix felt that 2.75 million was going to be too much for the best player in the world when healthy, and Clarke did not feel this way.


Interesting
 
he might

he has been injured alot maybe his team doctors feel a different way then phillys it possible
 
handsome sugardaddy said:
The following up todate team salaries is from today. Look at the two comparing Colorado and Philadelphia.........Eliminate the Forsberg contract from Philly's list and the two teams were relatively the same in Cap space. For the two Philly contracts listed as undisclosed, insert $875,000 for each of them. That is what the two players in question signed for.

So the question is.........why did Lacroix not sign Forsberg for what Philly signed him for??

Player Contract Notes 2005-2006 Salary (US)
Joe Sakic $6,664,797
Rob Blake $6,364,111
Alex Tanguay Re-signed RFA (Colorado) $3.23 million
Pierre Turgeon UFA (Dallas) $2,533,333
Steve Konowalchuk $1.9 million
Patrice Brisebois UFA (Montreal) $1.5 million
Ian Laperriere $1.14 million
Bob Boughner $950,000
Ossi Vaananen $950,000
Kurt Sauer Re-signed RFA (Colorado) $718,200
Antti Laaksonen $646,000
Brett McLean $450,000
Cody McCormick $450,000
13 Players $27,446,241

Milan Hejduk is missing from that list; I don`t know if he`s signed yet, but he`ll likely hit $5M when he does, leaving no room for Forsberg. Lacroix had to choose between a healthy 29 year-old and a brittle 32 year old. He made the right choice.

Wondering why Lacroix felt that 2.75 million was going to be too much for the best player in the world when healthy, and Clarke did not feel this way.

If you do the opposite of what Bobby Clarke does, you can`t go wrong. ;)
 
hammertm said:
That solves it right there, still needed cash for Hejduk. Still unsigned RFA, and i would take Hejduk over Foresberg at this exact point in their careers.

Yes, Hejduk isn't on the list, because he is a RFA. Yes, he does need the money for Hejduk as well, but, Clarke has his RFA's as well......Simon Gagne, Robert Esche, and three of his defensemen.

Lacroix was left with the choice.........either resign Forsberg, Hejduk, and Tanguay. He could only afford to sign 2 out of 3. Hejduk has been qualified at 4.3 and Tanguay at 3.25. Lacroix offered Forsberg a 4 year deal worth, 13.5 million. It appears to me, that he clearly had made up his mind that he was going to let Forsberg go. When questioned by the Colorado media, Lacroix was grilled as to why he would let Forsberg go as opposed to trading either Hejduk or Tanguay, he replied............."Not at their age".

Is that the right decision??..........Time will tell. In defense of Lacroix.........One should note that Forsberg signed for two years. I suspect that was his choice rather than Clarke's. Clarke gave both Rathje and Hatcher longer contracts, one would think that he would have offered a longer contract to Forsberg as well. Also, Lacroix, offered Forsberg a four year deal..........so it appears that Forsberg has decided that he only plans on playing two more years and thats it.

What does all this mean?? The NHL GM's are quickly discovering what the NBA and NFL GM's have to endure........a difficult balancing of trying to maintain your stars yet, to field the best overall team possible within the budget.

The new CBA will not allow a team the luxury of having two No. 1 centers. Hell it won't allow any team truly the luxury of having two Superstars. Tampa Bay is discovering this now. Their star goalie has gone, and soon they will be forced to decide between LeCavallier and St. Louis. I'm not sure the NHL and the NHLPA got this right. It appears that the max. allowed on one player is far too high. This sport requires you to ice a team of 22 players, to allow one player to receive 20% of the payroll isn't going to work. There are several flaws with this. First and foremost, it makes it virtually impossible to build a team and have any kind of continuity with the team. The NHL needs to understand that the Fans need this continuity in order to build the Fan base. Secondly, this is a team sport. Jealousy and greed will creep in. How is the dressing room atmosphere going to be, when Player A gets the Max allowed, and the guy next to him has to settle for One million because thats all that is left in the kitty?? I like the idea of the Salary Cap, but I think the Max. being allowed on one player is too great and I believe come the next CBA, it will be lowered.

This is the first year under this setup.........its going to take a couple of years at least for the GM's to figure out how to properly build a team under these conditions.

I believe each team will have their superstar.......what I think though is that the team that can get the best production from its 1-2 million dollar players is the team that will end up winning the Cup.
 
handsome sugardaddy said:
I believe each team will have their superstar.......what I think though is that the team that can get the best production from its 1-2 million dollar players is the team that will end up winning the Cup.

Excellent analysis....hockey the way it should be...a TEAM sport.

It seems to be that the superstars get the team into the playoffs, but with the checking and double teaming of the "superstar" player(s) in the playoffs, it's the role players and muckers and grinders that often come up big and win the games.

I sure would like to have Alyn McAuley(sp?) back with the Leafs instead of trying to pay off Nolan right now.
 
Colorado resigned Hejduk and brought in May. Still have Aebischer and Liles to deal with as restricted FAs. Philly's still got Gagne, Johnsson and Esche.
 
handsome sugardaddy said:
What does all this mean?? The NHL GM's are quickly discovering what the NBA and NFL GM's have to endure........a difficult balancing of trying to maintain your stars yet, to field the best overall team possible within the budget.

The new CBA will not allow a team the luxury of having two No. 1 centers. Hell it won't allow any team truly the luxury of having two Superstars. Tampa Bay is discovering this now. Their star goalie has gone, and soon they will be forced to decide between LeCavallier and St. Louis. I'm not sure the NHL and the NHLPA got this right. It appears that the max. allowed on one player is far too high. This sport requires you to ice a team of 22 players, to allow one player to receive 20% of the payroll isn't going to work. There are several flaws with this. First and foremost, it makes it virtually impossible to build a team and have any kind of continuity with the team. The NHL needs to understand that the Fans need this continuity in order to build the Fan base. Secondly, this is a team sport. Jealousy and greed will creep in. How is the dressing room atmosphere going to be, when Player A gets the Max allowed, and the guy next to him has to settle for One million because thats all that is left in the kitty?? I like the idea of the Salary Cap, but I think the Max. being allowed on one player is too great and I believe come the next CBA, it will be lowered.

This is the first year under this setup.........its going to take a couple of years at least for the GM's to figure out how to properly build a team under these conditions.

I believe each team will have their superstar.......what I think though is that the team that can get the best production from its 1-2 million dollar players is the team that will end up winning the Cup.

Great analysis Handsome.

20% of the cap for one player is too much given the number of players a team needs to sign. This isn't basketball.

The question GM's must confront is if three star type players with a bunch of lower paid players equals a well balanced payroll where the gap from most paid player to least paid player is small.

My suggestion is to see what Lou from the Devil's is doing and then just copy him. He knows what he's doing.

The word 'cap-enomics' has now entered the hockey lexicon.
 
handsome sugardaddy said:
The new CBA will not allow a team the luxury of having two No. 1 centers. Hell it won't allow any team truly the luxury of having two Superstars.
It depends on what your definition of superstar is.

If it means highest paid, you're correct. Teams will be resticted as to how many players can be paid the max.

If it means superstar in terms of talent, your statement is not necessarily correct. The overall talent level in the league will remain the same. There will still be the same number of players with superstar skills, just some of them won't be getting the superstar contracts. Some players will have superstar stats but will have to settle for 2nd line money.

I agree that the really big contracts will be more spread around the league more evenly but it will still be possible for a creative/intelligent GM to accumulate several players with exceptional/superstar talent. They just won't all get paid like a superstar.
 
shack said:
It depends on what your definition of superstar is.

If it means highest paid, you're correct. Teams will be resticted as to how many players can be paid the max.

If it means superstar in terms of talent, your statement is not necessarily correct. The overall talent level in the league will remain the same. There will still be the same number of players with superstar skills, just some of them won't be getting the superstar contracts. Some players will have superstar stats but will have to settle for 2nd line money.

I agree that the really big contracts will be more spread around the league more evenly but it will still be possible for a creative/intelligent GM to accumulate several players with exceptional/superstar talent. They just won't all get paid like a superstar.


Going to have to disagree with you........this past week is a perfect example. Colorado lost Foote and Forsberg because they wanted more......not 2nd line money.

Greed will always win out.
 
handsome sugardaddy said:
Hell it won't allow any team truly the luxury of having two Superstars.
Seeing as the term "superstar" is probably overused nowadays, how many true superstars do you feel are in the league at this time?

I'd say Colorado's Sakic and Blake are both superstars.
 
shack said:
Seeing as the term "superstar" is probably overused nowadays, how many true superstars do you feel are in the league at this time?

I'd say Colorado's Sakic and Blake are both superstars.

Jagr and Sakic.

Like you said, superstar is a term used way too often
 
How many of the unrestricted free agents signed last week are truly superstars?
Forsberg..........yes
Foote? no; Palffy?no, Leetch? Not anymore, Gonchar? no, Hatcher?no,
Kariya? not any more,

Can't think of any.
 
Coach said:
How many of the unrestricted free agents signed last week are truly superstars?
Forsberg..........yes
Foote? no; Palffy?no, Leetch? Not anymore, Gonchar? no, Hatcher?no,
Kariya? not any more,

Can't think of any.


True superstars.........your right, only Forsgberg would fall in that category.

But here is the whole point of all this........how riduculous it is to have a max limit of 20% on one player.

Colorado, kept Sakic and Blake.....total.....approx. 13 million for the two. If they were to keep what Forsberg and Foote signed for, then they would have had 4 players signed for a total of 23 million bucks. They then have to sign 18 players for under 16 million. And thats just for this year. Understand what i'm saying...........NO FRIGGEN WAY anybody will be able to keep a good team for any period of time. The max is going to have to be dropped to say around 10% of the Cap...........then you can keep your core of "Star" players together for long periods of time. And that is going to be the only way you will be able to do it.
 
handsome sugardaddy said:
Colorado, kept Sakic and Blake.....NO FRIGGEN WAY anybody will be able to keep a good team for any period of time.
Your previous comment was that NO team will be able to have more than 1 superstar. Now you're saying they can't keep a good team together. Very different. My point is that there are so few real superstars, it would be hard for a team to have more than one under almost any fee structure but we already have at least one team with two superstars.

A good team is made up of good players, not necessarily high paid players (see New York Rangers). The good players are not going to get as much as before even when they test the free agent market because the prospective new teams will be under the same financial restraints as their current teams. There may actually be less incentive for players to move around (once the dust settles) because teams like the Leafs and Rangers won't be able to overpay for good players (not necessarily superstars) and make it more expensive for all teams by raising the pay standards. It hasn't been easy to keep good teams together for a long time now (I'd say the Oilers were the last true dynasty over 20 years ago) and I don't think it will change much now.

The max is going to have to be dropped to say around 10% of the Cap...........then you can keep your core of "Star" players together for long periods of time. And that is going to be the only way you will be able to do it.
The concept of dropping the max to 10% to have more to spend on other players is sound in principle. However I don't think it would fly with the players, not when they were previously making over $10 million. The higher paid players already took the biggest hit with the 24% rollback. Having a max of $3.9 million is a 2/3 reduction. Again, once the big boys have been paid then the pay scale for the second and third liners will be determined and I don't think it will vary much from team to team. Management will have to decide whether they want to put all their eggs in a few baskets or spread it out more throughout the lineup.
 
shack said:
Your previous comment was that NO team will be able to have more than 1 superstar. Now you're saying they can't keep a good team together. Very different. My point is that there are so few real superstars, it would be hard for a team to have more than one under almost any fee structure but we already have at least one team with two superstars.

A good team is made up of good players, not necessarily high paid players (see New York Rangers). The good players are not going to get as much as before even when they test the free agent market because the prospective new teams will be under the same financial restraints as their current teams. There may actually be less incentive for players to move around (once the dust settles) because teams like the Leafs and Rangers won't be able to overpay for good players (not necessarily superstars) and make it more expensive for all teams by raising the pay standards. It hasn't been easy to keep good teams together for a long time now (I'd say the Oilers were the last true dynasty over 20 years ago) and I don't think it will change much now.


The concept of dropping the max to 10% to have more to spend on other players is sound in principle. However I don't think it would fly with the players, not when they were previously making over $10 million. The higher paid players already took the biggest hit with the 24% rollback. Having a max of $3.9 million is a 2/3 reduction. Again, once the big boys have been paid then the pay scale for the second and third liners will be determined and I don't think it will vary much from team to team. Management will have to decide whether they want to put all their eggs in a few baskets or spread it out more throughout the lineup.


Actually, I think it is the players that will intiate this kind of change to the current CBA.

No question, the high salary players will never agree to it.........but......the middle of the road and lower end players would go for it. If you limit the superstars or high priced help to 10%.......that leave more of the Cap to be distributed to the other players.

The greed of the high end salary players will in fact be their own downfall.

Why is Pronger in Edmonton.......by his choice??..........Nope.

Why is Adam Foote in Columbus......not by his choice. The only reason Columbus has him, is because Columbus was one of the few teams that could afford to pay him that much.

Columbus now has committed itself to two players totalling 10 million. If in the next year, another "superstar, or High end player" develops, and wants over 4 million a year........can they afford to pay it, and still put out the same type of team??.........Yes and no..........yes, they can, only if they have a bunch of players, that are very good, that are on entry level contracts. No, if they have to try and sign decent players in the two million range.

The Cap Max is flawed by sheer numbers. This years Cap, is at 39 million. If you were to divide that by 22 players, that comes out to 1.77 million.

For every player you sign for a million dollars over that average, you need to sign a scrub for the bare minimum. You sign somebody for 4.7 million, then you need to sign three scrubs.

You have 3 players at 4.7 million, then you need 9 players at the league minimum.

It is Flawed!!!!!!!!
 
I wouldn't consider it a downfall if I chose to take a job that paid me an extra 500,000 bucks per year over what anyone else would pay for the next few years... especially if I am close to retirement!
 
The above scenario can also work in a grand sinister scheme.

Now my conspiracy theory mind is at work here.........lol.

What if it was the owner's intention all along to create this lack of harmony within the player's union.

Remember......if your paying 2 players on your team over 4.5 million each. Then there is only 30 million for 20 players. That equates to 1.5 million average. But if you limit those 2 players to 3 million each, now you have the other 20 to divide 33 million. Thats an extra 3 million to be divided out........which in quick numbers, comes out to another $150,000.00 per player.

If the Players were to vote on the Current CBA vs. a revamped one that only allows a max of 10% per any one player..........guess which one would win.
 
I think one thing we'll find is that players will want to sign sooner rather than later, before a team (or teams) have a chance to get too close to their max. If a high-priced player waits too long he may find himself in a position where nobody will be able to meet his demands even if they wanted to. Previously, teams could go over their budget to pay a star but not anymore.