I guess this thread can be re-labelled, given the Notice of Appeal filed (A-74-24-ID 1). Soon enough there will be a few Federal Court of Appeal Justices who will tell us who is right vs. who is wrong in this debate - or, perhaps more likely, they'll articulate where between the two positions 'right' exists.
And then, no matter what happens, there'll be a further appeal. At that point, team Wagner will likely expedite proceedings (only to be delayed by countless bodies seeking intervenor status), where we'll end up with a further group telling us where 'right' lies on the scale.
In sum: Soon enough our highest courts (FCA, then SCC) will tell us what 'right' is.
In even greater summation: "We'll see."