Clublink Charged

There's precedent law to support the idea of holding them responsible. That said, when a bunch of rich kids go drinking at a golf club in the Muskokas and get drunk and kill themselves, I don't have a lot of sympathy.

The kid driving his parents' Audi had either G1 or G2 (are you allowed to have ANY alcohol?) he was charged with public drunkenness just four days before his death, on Canada Day, and already had 6 points on his driving record.

And it's the bartender's fault? Bullshit.
 
Hangman said:
The kid driving his parents' Audi had either G1 or G2 (are you allowed to have ANY alcohol?) he was charged with public drunkenness just four days before his death, on Canada Day, and already had 6 points on his driving record.
And it's the bartender's fault? Bullshit.

Of course, it's the bartender's fault. Surely we are not going to blame the kid or his parents, are we?

The real tragedy here is that 16 people's lives could be ruined. It is no joke getting charged by the OPP for a crime that has jail time.
 
They're not Criminal Code charges.

The charges under the Liquor License Act carry fines on conviction of up to $250 000 for a corporation and up to $100 000 plus a year in jail for an individual.

No jail time, then, and 250k is nothing to Clublink, but the individual bartenders or waiters getting charged could be screwed. 100k? Because some little douche can't hold his liquor?
 
Hangman said:
They're not Criminal Code charges.
The charges under the Liquor License Act carry fines on conviction of up to $250 000 for a corporation and up to $100 000 plus a year in jail for an individual.

Did I read PLUS A YEAR IN JAIL for an individual?
 
Rockslinger said:
Did I read PLUS A YEAR IN JAIL for an individual?

Maybe I missed that. A year in fucking jail????

If I went to jail because the kids' Dad insisted that someone other than his precious snowflake be held responsible, I would seriously lose my shit.
 
Hangman said:
A year in jail????

I think a year in jail means a criminal record which means your career as a lawyer is dead in the water. Might as well drop out of law school now. Also, can't travel to the U.S. (Rock: Call that cute shooter girl now and ask her to really water down the drinks.)
 
massman said:
There's such a thing as personal responsibility
I agree. Those 3 people should be held responsible. The question is how do they pay anymore than they already have. They're dead. They were most responsible and paid the heaviest price.

Next up, Clublink staff. Less responsible...less of a payment/punishment.
 
What.....

"I cannot agree enough with you. When i worked the club scene here in Toronto, i worked my ass off making sure my customers got home in a cab; to the point of covering fares myself at times. Under the liquor licensing act, i could not serve a patron that was visibly intoxicated. The onus should not be put on the establishment whatsoever. People should conduct themselves accordingly and take a bloody cab if you plan on getting hammered."

"Good observation. I have to say, as an adult people should have enough sense to be responsible. If you can wake up everyday, get dressed and comprehend the world around you, there is no need for a waitress to babysit someone because they cannot act appropriately."
*****************

You're using logic and common sense. I agree with you but you can't sell that to spoiled little boys with access to exclusive clubs, with unlimited credit and driving the parents expensive car. It's obvious it's everyone elses' responsibility.

Taking responsibility for ones actions is not what this society does well....
 
Unfortunately we have reached a point where we are no longer responsible for our actions, it’s always someone else’s fault, and common sense is no longer used. Suing for spilling hot coffee on yourself, suing when someone slips and falls on ice due to wearing inappropriate footwear, the list goes on and on. Who benefits from all this nonsense? The damn lawyers who do the coaching.
 
Rockslinger said:
I think a year in jail means a criminal record which means your career as a lawyer is dead in the water. Might as well drop out of law school now. Also, can't travel to the U.S. (Rock: Call that cute shooter girl now and ask her to really water down the drinks.)

A year in jail does not mean a criminal record. A criminal record means a criminal conviction, which this would not be. As to the year in jail, that is the maximum sentence permissible under the Act. That covers ALL offences under the Act, and is not a specific sentencing provision for these two sections. The likelihood of any of them seeing any jail time or a fine anywhere near the maximum is virtually nil.

I think people are over-reacting here. Responsibility cuts both ways. Yes, this kid should have had enough sense not to drink so much and drive. But, if this "rich punk" couldn't hold his liquor, then the bartender should have cut him off. Is it really the bartender's responsibility? Well, yes it is, and every person working in the beverage alcohol industry in Ontario has, or should have, received training in how to manage customers consumption within the confines of the law.

Now that sounds pretty straightforward, but in this case 16 people have been charged. There's obviously more to this than a bartender losing track of how many drinks somebody had. We lack specifics of the charges, so why don't we hold off on making martyrs of the bar staff until we hear the details of the allegations.
 
CTV just interviewed a lawyer and he said that this is "police overkill" and these charges will unlikely survive in court. Meanwhile, 16 human beings are twisting in the legislative wind.
 
Hangman said:
Maybe I missed that. A year in fucking jail????

If I went to jail because the kids' Dad insisted that someone other than his precious snowflake be held responsible, I would seriously lose my shit.

+1

So, the driver of the car gets plastered and offs himself. It is his fault - nobody poured those drinks down his throat with a funnel. When driving I always limit my drinking to be within reasonable bounds and have since I got my DL at 16. It is MY fault if I F*** up and off myself driving drunk, nobody else's. If this kid hit the bottle on a regular basis, had speeding tickets, etc and little parental supervison and keys to fast cars then maybe some degree of fault lies with his father for raising him to be a reckless fool. The father will have to live with any guilt he personally feels, but it isn't criminal. I'm sure the father will regret his parenting lapses until his dying day. However the parents who lobby for laws to be changed, wait staff to be charged, etc are just trying to push the blame off of themselves and their dead kids where it belongs on to someone else. It's the laws fault, the country club's fault, the car manufacturers fault, the road designer's fault, whine, whine. They are pushing for law changes and people to be charged - they can't just say "We went wrong raising little Johnny - he was a reckless drunken SOB and killed his friends, who also were reckless drunken SOBs". No, they want to think little Johnny is the victim in all this. Victim my ass. He made choices and they were bad ones and he paid the price. Anybody in this day and age who is of University age from a well off family knows full well that one doesn't throw back a dozen drinks then get behind the wheel of a fast vehicle and drive/speed around like a maniac. It's too bad the guys are dead, and it is too bad the families lost them. However, at least now he won't be crashing his drunk ass into my car in future.
 
alexmst said:
+1

So, the driver of the car gets plastered and offs himself. It is his fault - nobody poured those drinks down his throat with a funnel. When driving I always limit my drinking to be within reasonable bounds and have since I got my DL at 16. It is MY fault if I F*** up and off myself driving drunk, nobody else's. If this kid hit the bottle on a regular basis, had speeding tickets, etc and little parental supervison and keys to fast cars then maybe some degree of fault lies with his father for raising him to be a reckless fool. The father will have to live with any guilt he personally feels, but it isn't criminal. I'm sure the father will regret his parenting lapses until his dying day. However the parents who lobby for laws to be changed, wait staff to be charged, etc are just trying to push the blame off of themselves and their dead kids where it belongs on to someone else. It's the laws fault, the country club's fault, the car manufacturers fault, the road designer's fault, whine, whine. They are pushing for law changes and people to be charged - they can't just say "We went wrong raising little Johnny - he was a reckless drunken SOB and killed his friends, who also were reckless drunken SOBs". No, they want to think little Johnny is the victim in all this. Victim my ass. He made choices and they were bad ones and he paid the price. Anybody in this day and age who is of University age from a well off family knows full well that one doesn't throw back a dozen drinks then get behind the wheel of a fast vehicle and drive/speed around like a maniac. It's too bad the guys are dead, and it is too bad the families lost them. However, at least now he won't be crashing his drunk ass into my car in future.

Wicked post! The parents should not be blamed either. They were old enough, adult enough, and simply irresponsible. The choices one make are sadly the end result of one's actions. If they were any of my family members, i would be royally pissed.
 
I've been cottaging in that area for a hell of a long time. Drive the penn. road and know the bridge.


The area has become a playground for over indulged little twats with no sense at all of personal responsibilty.

The three that died, tough shit, at least no innocent driver going the other way was hit. Society has a net gain from their exit as they would likely have repeated in the future possibly with injury to others.

To go after the large staff grouping is a tad excessive. It must be tough for those employees to deal with all the little preening prima donna rich kids that frequent the clubs up there. If they refuse little juniors request, snotty boy complains to Daddy and as a respected "member" of the club dDaddy's voice is heard. The employee can be out of a job. Nail Clublink ( under the umbrella of appearing to do something) and possibly a shift manager or two, but leave the rank and file employees out of it.

methinks the families of all those little twats had blinders on.

Lesson learned.


.
 
LancsLad said:
The area has become a playground for over indulged little twats with no sense at all of personal responsibilty.
...
To go after the large staff grouping is a tad excessive. It must be tough for those employees to deal with all the little preening prima donna rich kids that frequent the clubs up there. If they refuse little juniors request, snotty boy complains to Daddy and as a respected "member" of the club dDaddy's voice is heard.
Lesson learned.


.

This is the other half of the equation I was alluding to. Tough position for staff. One rich kid complains and you're out of a job?
 
I can believe how bitter everyone in this post is - with negative slants to rich kids. Sounds like a bunch of sour grapes. People died. Lives and families have been ruined. I guess none of you never drank too much when you were kids and did something stupid. In their case it eneded tragically but for many others they simply got lucky.

As far as I know, the only thing that one of the Dads has done is push like hell to have the laws changed more to zero tolerance.
 
The courts are going to have to decipher all this stuff and determine how much fault the various parties have. Obviously the kids, who are adults by law, have the majority of the responsibility to ensure they do not drink and drive, however the bartenders will have some fault, probably low, according to the law. The owners of Clublink, ie the executives, are charged presumely because they have some responsibility to ensure they have a training program in place to ensure the bartenders respect the law and don't over serve, if their training is weak, they might have some fault as a corporation.

If we are looking at Clublink and the bartenders as having some liability, so should the parents, hopefully they raised their kids to not drink and drive, if not, they should have some liability as well. There will fault all around, it's a matter of how much fault the courts allocate to the various parties.

The courts will have an interesting challenge in this and will set a precedent for future situations.
 
Going after the serving staff is not without precedent in Ontario. Serving staff have also lost civil actions for serving drunk patrons.

One of the problems with selling booze is that the staff have a vested interest in serving more booze to patrons. More booze sales means more profit, and more tips. And the more booze a person has in them, the more their capacity for reason diminishes.

So, the system has put in place legislation to try to prevent what happened. Simply, it is not legal to serve anyone who is, or who appears to be drunk.

Break the law, pay the consequences.

Should the kids that were killed accept some blame? Absolutely. But don't think that actions happen in a vacuum.
 
Interesting quote from the father of the driver of the car. Unlike many people in his situation, he seems to accept that his son bears responsibility for this accident.

http://www.theglobeandmail.com/servlet/story/RTGAM.20090112.wdrunkeness0112/BNStory/National/home


"After the crash, Tim Mulcahy, Tyler's father, campaigned to persuade the Ontario government to tighten laws for young people around speeding and drunk driving. He said publicly that he didn't know his son had previously received speeding tickets, and that had he been more severely punished for them, he wouldn't have been driving that July day.

Mr. Mulcahy set up a website in his son's name, and paid tens of thousands of dollars to take out advertisements.

Late last fall, Mr. McGuinty pointed to the crash in introducing the tougher legislation. Among other things, Ontario's proposed changes will impose zero-tolerance rules for alcohol on any driver aged 21 or under, and under a new graduated licensing scheme would also increase the time it would take to obtain a full licence.

Tim Mulcahy, reacting to the charges last night, said liquor license laws are just "asking other people to enforce laws… who are not police," and that "it looks like the OPP want to set a precedent."

He's hopeful the changes he fought for will save lives.

"I haven't pushed for [charges] in any way, shape or form... I'm not looking for blood," he said. "I never really felt that anyone was responsible except Tyler."
 
Charges like this are just a wake up call to the bars and clubs.The last one was the one in Barrie were the chick sued the company after leaving a x-mas party.Needs to be one every few years to tighten up regulations.In my opinion the old man is just trying to spreed the burden to others for when the other parents start to sue.