Clublink Charged

dcbogey said:
Interesting quote from the father of the driver of the car. Unlike many people in his situation, he seems to accept that his son bears responsibility for this accident.

"I haven't pushed for [charges] in any way, shape or form... I'm not looking for blood," he said. "I never really felt that anyone was responsible except Tyler."

Responsible man ... too bad his child hadn't learned from him.
 
jblplat said:
I can believe how bitter everyone in this post is - with negative slants to rich kids. Sounds like a bunch of sour grapes. People died. Lives and families have been ruined. I guess none of you never drank too much when you were kids and did something stupid. In their case it eneded tragically but for many others they simply got lucky.

As far as I know, the only thing that one of the Dads has done is push like hell to have the laws changed more to zero tolerance.

Yup .. they were rich kids.. Rest assured that these charges stem from lobbying by the parents, who by social stature have the "ear" of someone in the police department.. I highly doubt if these were average kids these charges would have come about.. I'm sure if the charges stick there will be very expensive civil suits to follow from this incident.. It's all about who you know and how good your lawyer is.. The squeeky wheel gets the grease and the more money you have makes the wheel squeal!! I hope these well heeled family's make a point to contact every parent who has lost a kid to excessive drinking and help them to get the "justice" they figure they deserve for belonging to the upper class.. The loss of any child is tragic but to make a case out of this and not others is just wrong.. You think any moneys they win in the civil suits will go to fund anti-drunk driving education ... I highly doubt it..

Av
 
They are...

themexi said:
Why sensible people haven't started lynching judges in this country is beyond me.

...just waiting for you to demonstrate some leadership and start the revolution!!

How many judges have you lynched yet?
 
Isn't the law that people should be cut off if they are visibly intoxicated or is it that people should be cut off if they might be close to failing a breath test?
I doubt it is the latter as the staff would have no way of knowing what was consumed previously or if anyone intends to drive.

Unless there is a bill showing that they had a ridiculous amount to drink, like 10+, I don't see how it might be proven that they may have appeared visibly intoxicated and continued to be served.

We don't know how much they drank, if they looked intoxicated, if the driver was impaired or if this was even a factor.
Maybe he was a bad inexperienced driver or he could have been simply showing off in his S4 and just fucked up, alcohol or not.

Who know?
Certainly not anybody here, that's for sure.:rolleyes:
 
Actually....

jblplat said:
I can believe how bitter everyone in this post is - with negative slants to rich kids. Sounds like a bunch of sour grapes. People died. Lives and families have been ruined. I guess none of you never drank too much when you were kids and did something stupid. In their case it eneded tragically but for many others they simply got lucky.

...I didn't.

When I was a kid, there was no money to bail me out of jail, so I stayed out of it. There was no time or tolerance for bullshit behavior, so I avoided it.


It is interesting to see how privilege brings assumed latitude.
 
What the hell do judges have to do with it? They don't press charges, the police do, and they didn't write the law or pass it.
 
Didn't you hear???

Hangman said:
What the hell do judges have to do with it? They don't press charges, the police do, and they didn't write the law or pass it.


Liberal judges are the cause for all that is wrong in society...
 
jblplat said:
I can believe how bitter everyone in this post is - with negative slants to rich kids. Sounds like a bunch of sour grapes. People died. Lives and families have been ruined. I guess none of you never drank too much when you were kids and did something stupid. In their case it eneded tragically but for many others they simply got lucky.

As far as I know, the only thing that one of the Dads has done is push like hell to have the laws changed more to zero tolerance.
.
I never KILLED anyone, no.

And my anger at this is not 'sour grapes'. It's a legitimate response to some Dad trying to further curtail mine and others freedoms because his kid died of extreme irresponsibility and stupidity. Zero tolerance means 100% intolerance, and I don't want my society to go that way. I prefer to make my own choices without others being held responsible. I also don't want to be held responsible for others' foolishness.
.
Remember the stink a couple months ago about increased restrictions for youth drivers? That's because of Tim Mulcahy complaining to the Ont government. Drunk driving is ALREADY ILLEGAL. Just because some kids broke the law doesn't mean we need to make more stuff illegal.
 
A couple of thoughts:
There has been a lot of comments about personal responsibility in this thread. Does anyone remember when one of the tag lines from the LCBO was "You are your own liquor control board"? Much has been lost since that time.

Maybe it's time to seriously consider raising the legal drinking age to 21.
 
I just read the latest story in the Star.

The charges are permitting drunken behaviour and serving liquor to people who were obviously intoxicated.

They had 31 drinks over 3 hours between the 4 of them.
That is quite a bit but not ridiculous in terms of assuming they must have been staggering and behaving obviously drunk and intoxicated.

I would think these charges will be very difficult to prove without witnesses and/or video evidence.
 
Malibook said:
I just read the latest story in the Star.

The charges are permitting drunken behaviour and serving liquor to people who were obviously intoxicated.

They had 31 drinks over 3 hours between the 4 of them.
That is quite a bit but not ridiculous in terms of assuming they must have been staggering and behaving obviously drunk and intoxicated.

I would think these charges will be very difficult to prove without witnesses and/or video evidence.

You are assuming a couple of things - all four of them were drinking equal amounts and that they hadn't been drinking before they showed up. Both equally hard to prove, yes, but I suspect it will all come out at the trial.
 
dcbogey said:
You are assuming a couple of things - all four of them were drinking equal amounts and that they hadn't been drinking before they showed up. Both equally hard to prove, yes, but I suspect it will all come out at the trial.
I am not assuming anything.
I simply stated the number of drinks that the group ordered.
I did not claim they all drank the same amount.
The driver may have drank more or less than the average.

I also did not assume they did not drink previously.
I am saying that simply looking at this receipt is not enough to assume that there must have been drunken behaviour and they must have been obviously intoxicated.

The point is was there drunken behaviour and were they obviously intoxicated.
Who knows how well they held their liquor that day?
The question is not whether or not they would have failed a breath test.
 
Last edited:
Hangman said:
And my anger at this is not 'sour grapes'. It's a legitimate response to some Dad trying to further curtail mine and others freedoms because his kid died of extreme irresponsibility and stupidity.
Well said.

If I was a new responsible driver, I'm sure I would be pissed off too.
Maybe I would have to sue Clublink.:p
 
Angela@Mirage said:
Wicked post! The parents should not be blamed either. They were old enough, adult enough, and simply irresponsible. The choices one make are sadly the end result of one's actions. If they were any of my family members, i would be royally pissed.

Sorry Angela but I have to mostly agree with the post.

Assuming the reported drinking is correct then these kids were irresponsible in their actions. Their deaths are sad and no right person is happy they are dead. Fortunately their reckless disregard for human life (including their own) ended with no loss of innocent lives. They could have just as easily hit someone causing the death of someone else who had the mis-fortune of being at the wrong place at the wrong time.

Society, and the law, acknowledge that parents bear some responsibility for their children's actions. This responsibility usually applies to minor children. Most people, even the parents themselves, feel that how a child turns out is a reflection on the quality of the parenting they received. Often this is true. Other times a bad child comes out of good parents.

Too many parents haven't the backbone for the job and want to always be adored by their children. As a result they spoil them trying to buy their love and affection. They teach their children the wrong lessons and ultimately the children lose respect for them and have no respect for the rest of society.

Parenting is about making choices, some of them very difficult. Your children will not always like you. Hopefully they will always love you and ultimately come to respect you.

These children seemed to have little respect for much other than their own pleasure.

g_27
 
avguy said:
Yup .. they were rich kids.. Rest assured that these charges stem from lobbying by the parents, who by social stature have the "ear" of someone in the police department.. I highly doubt if these were average kids these charges would have come about.. I'm sure if the charges stick there will be very expensive civil suits to follow from this incident.. It's all about who you know and how good your lawyer is.. The squeeky wheel gets the grease and the more money you have makes the wheel squeal!! I hope these well heeled family's make a point to contact every parent who has lost a kid to excessive drinking and help them to get the "justice" they figure they deserve for belonging to the upper class.. The loss of any child is tragic but to make a case out of this and not others is just wrong.. You think any moneys they win in the civil suits will go to fund anti-drunk driving education ... I highly doubt it..

Av

It's sad if you are right that charges result only from lobbying. If any laws exist they should be enforced. If we as society say that we don't want to prosecute certain acts then we should change the law, not just ignore it.

In this case laws exist and if the behaviour goes against the law then charges should be laid.

Unfortunately money does seem to have obtained a strange power in our society. Do something wrong, pay a fine and start over. Have you suffered a wrong, then sue and money will make it right. Have money then hire a good lawyer and do as you damn well please. Money won't bring back a dead person, it won't heal organs and make you new again and it won't make you a better person.

g_27

I'll surrender the soapbox now!
 
thompo69 said:
There is also such a thing as the Liquor Licence Act, which makes it an offence to serve a patron who appears intoxicated, or for a licencee to permit drunkenness on the premises. All serving staff are supposed to be trained in SmartServe to recognize when someone has had too much and cut them off, and they are also supposed to take steps to insure that people aren't driving home.

Personal responsibility cuts both ways. Yes, the kids shouldn't have had so much to drink, but the server should have cut them off before they got to that point. And who do you think was in a better position to make a judgment call? My money's on the sober server.

I could be way over .08 and you would NEVER be able to tell.
 
avguy said:
Yup .. they were rich kids.. Rest assured that these charges stem from lobbying by the parents, who by social stature have the "ear" of someone in the police department..
Av

Did you even read the Globe article? It's posted in this thread.

The parent of at least of the deceased kids explicitly stated he didn't lobby and that he thought no one except his dead son was to blame.
 
Agree

Compromised said:
Going after the serving staff is not without precedent in Ontario. Serving staff have also lost civil actions for serving drunk patrons.

One of the problems with selling booze is that the staff have a vested interest in serving more booze to patrons. More booze sales means more profit, and more tips. And the more booze a person has in them, the more their capacity for reason diminishes.

So, the system has put in place legislation to try to prevent what happened. Simply, it is not legal to serve anyone who is, or who appears to be drunk.

Break the law, pay the consequences.

Should the kids that were killed accept some blame? Absolutely. But don't think that actions happen in a vacuum.


Yes those three individuals are mostly to blame but - the staff and management of the bar are profiting from their behaviour and therefore are not totally without fault.

I have a feeling that the reason that so many were charged, right up to the directors is that this was not a one-off incident. If the facts come out that Clublinks routinely served their patrons too much and allowed them to drive their cars or boats they should be penalized. That alleged behaviour would have put innocent others sharing the roads/water with their patrons at risk
 
LancsLad said:
I've been cottaging in that area for a hell of a long time. Drive the penn. road and know the bridge.


The area has become a playground for over indulged little twats with no sense at all of personal responsibilty.

The three that died, tough shit, at least no innocent driver going the other way was hit. Society has a net gain from their exit as they would likely have repeated in the future possibly with injury to others.

To go after the large staff grouping is a tad excessive. It must be tough for those employees to deal with all the little preening prima donna rich kids that frequent the clubs up there. If they refuse little juniors request, snotty boy complains to Daddy and as a respected "member" of the club dDaddy's voice is heard. The employee can be out of a job. Nail Clublink ( under the umbrella of appearing to do something) and possibly a shift manager or two, but leave the rank and file employees out of it.

methinks the families of all those little twats had blinders on.

Lesson learned.


.

My God - I don't believe it. I agree with every word you've written in this message. This has to be a first and a memorable one at that :)