Clublink Charged

mindingmyownbusiness said:
Yes those three individuals are mostly to blame but - the staff and management of the bar are profiting from their behaviour and therefore are not totally without fault.

I have a feeling that the reason that so many were charged, right up to the directors is that this was not a one-off incident. If the facts come out that Clublinks routinely served their patrons too much and allowed them to drive their cars or boats they should be penalized. That alleged behaviour would have put innocent others sharing the roads/water with their patrons at risk

I think this is total BS. They drank too much, they drove, they died. End of story and a good lesson to everyone else. Penalizing the servers is just as bad as Daddy crying for changes in the law. This all smells of Fantino - it's the sort of dickheaded thing he'd suggest.
 
Thhe AGCO are a law unto themselves and can prety well do what they want. Look for a long licencing problem for Clublink everywhere.
 
JohnC said:
Thhe AGCO are a law unto themselves and can prety well do what they want. Look for a long licencing problem for Clublink everywhere.

It's actually a bit more incestuous than that, I believe. The AGCO use the OPP on a contract basis to do their inspections. There have been incidents where the AGCO inspector essentially entrapped serving staff into breaking the rules and then brought down heavy fines. Some of these events were being run by volunteers. One involved an inspector sweet talking his way in through a back door, taking a glass of wine of the tray of a server and then demanding that the event be closed down.
 
1. No one is saying that the kids weren't responsible for their action. They were.

2. As for the liability of (at least some members and employees) Clublink, it is clearly spelled out in the Liquor Licence Act. If you disagree with the legislation, speak to your MPP or lobby Mr. McGuinty. However, you won't succeed.
 
vsailor said:
If the person doing the drinking (31 drinks between 4 people in a few hours) and then driving is not responsible and the bar is ...then shouldn't Smirnoff, Seagrams, Molsons, Labatts etc also be charged?QUOTE]

Under what section of the Liquor License Act?
 
There was a case a few years ago, north of TO, where at a staff party, a woman was cut off for being overserved. She was put IN A CAB, complete with a chit to pay for taking her home. She talked the driver into taking her to another bar instead, she (after continuing to drink at that bar) got a ride back to her car, drove home, got in an accident, and sued the first bar, and her employer... and won! Thankfully it was overturned on appeal - but the inmates have slowly been taking over the asylum, and it's only getting worse.

I've seen people mention personal ownership here... I went to the bar last night, drank too much, ended up at the SC, and handed over too much cash there, too... Guess who's at fault? ME! No one poured drinks down my throat.

Anyways - just a sore point with me... Carry on

Laz

PS: the bar / SC thing is true - there are some girls in North Bay that had a great night last night... ;) And a guy in north bay with empty pockets and a big head this morning!
 
blopar said:
1. No one is saying that the kids weren't responsible for their action. They were.

2. As for the liability of (at least some members and employees) Clublink, it is clearly spelled out in the Liquor Licence Act. If you disagree with the legislation, speak to your MPP or lobby Mr. McGuinty. However, you won't succeed.

This is absolutely correct correct. The charges the staff are facing are only peripherally related to the impaired driving. The staff have been charged with a failure to fulfill their obligations and responsibilities under the Liquor Licence Act. The impaired driving was an unfortunate consequence -- that according to the father of the driver will likely not see any civil action -- of the failure of the bar staff to fulfill their obligations under the Liquor Licence Act.
 
I think Clublink is lucky this has not happened before.....has anyone been to a member event or tournament at one of the courses before?
 
gardener_27 said:
They could have just as easily hit someone causing the death of someone else who had the mis-fortune of being at the wrong place at the wrong time.

Remember those two rich kids from Rosedale who killed the immigrant taxi driver? Think they got 2 years probation. The tax driver got life without parole.
 
Bounce said:
I think Clublink is lucky this has not happened before.....has anyone been to a member event or tournament at one of the courses before?
All golf clubs are at risk!!
 
Average Drinks ...

Hey according to the Math thats 2.5 drinks per hour per kid ... now im not that young anymore (31) and I cant drink like I could when I was say 19 or 20, but I can handle 2.5 drinks per hour and seem to be completely fine to others who arent drinking, im not an alcholic (i dont think I am yet:) ) but it would be hard to tell if these kids were drunk or not, especially if they werent exactly spring chickens to drinking, which many rich kids arent, trust me. It is unfortunate that people died, but thank god more that they didnt take anyone innocent with them.
 
I agree with LANCS LAD. The server ismore than likely some College kid making min wage and he is going to tell these spoiled rich kids you are cut off! They would complain etc get the kid fired and more than likely laugh about it.:mad:
 
emerging44 said:
My God - I don't believe it. I agree with every word you've written in this message. This has to be a first and a memorable one at that :)





There are other surprises out there.

At times danmand and I have agreed.


The Universe is in trouble.


.
 
Rockslinger said:
Remember those two rich kids from Rosedale who killed the immigrant taxi driver? Think they got 2 years probation. The tax driver got life without parole.



My thoughts exactly.

That poor bugger was just trying to earn a living and he looses his life to two snotty nosed SOB's carelessness. They get off lightly and he is gone forever.


.
 
Bounce said:
I think Clublink is lucky this has not happened before.....has anyone been to a member event or tournament at one of the courses before?

My point exactly.

I've attend many member events throughout the summer year after year and nothing changes.

Every night the staff pours certain members into their vehicles and off they go - either to home or the local poker game.

I'm amazed that this did not happen sooner.
 
waterloohobby said:
Hey according to the Math thats 2.5 drinks per hour per kid ... now im not that young anymore (31) and I cant drink like I could when I was say 19 or 20, but I can handle 2.5 drinks per hour and seem to be completely fine to others who arent drinking, im not an alcholic (i dont think I am yet:) ) but it would be hard to tell if these kids were drunk or not, especially if they werent exactly spring chickens to drinking, which many rich kids arent, trust me. It is unfortunate that people died, but thank god more that they didnt take anyone innocent with them.
it depends if it was beer or something stronger.
 
landscaper said:
I have a problem with this one, if they did feed them too much booze they should be charged with manslaughter, this charge reeks of well we have to do something. Proving that they fed them to much booze is going to be a big problem

Opens the door to a large civil suit, maybe (not sure how Canadian litigation law proceeds???).
 
vsailor said:
Yes, but according to some posters here on Terb, you are picking on them because (in the ClubLink case) they were "rich kids"......man, it's not easy being spoiled rich kids with an expense account at a $62,000 a year membership club and having daddy supply you with a high powered German sedan!!....shame on you!!!!!;)

Might be $62K to join but is probably only $5k-$9k annually.