Trying to find the legal link but one website I came across for Formula Honda indicated that in the GTA if the damage to the vehicles involved is less than $1000 total and the services of a tow truck are not required you do not have to report to the police.
From the website:
"Accident Reporting Responsibilities
In the Greater Toronto Area (GTA), motor vehicle accidents that do not require a tow truck and appear to have less than $1000 total damage do not require reporting to the police. Exceptions include accidents involving injury, death, a bicycle or public vehicle or where the driver appears impaired or is especially uncooperative or argumentative.
A police officer must attend under any of the following circumstances:
* collisions involving death
* criminal activity involved in a collision (eg. impaired driving, stolen vehicle, assault, etc.)
* collisions involving Federal, Provincial, or Municipal vehicles
* collisions involving vehicles transporting dangerous goods
* collisions involving a person who is uninsured or is a suspended driver
* collisions involving damage to private, municipal, or highway property
* collisions involving bicycles or pedestrians
* involved party refuses to provide required information
* when in doubt, call police who will attend the accident scene or advise accordingly"