Captain Semaru trial

I guess waiting for the facts and the court to do its job and then deciding whats right would be out of line?

The sensible approach. But a calm discussion of the difficult issues and possibilities involved is useful for concerned citizens in all sorts of unpredictable ways and in all sorts of unknown areas of life and laew. However the usual name calling hysterics (that come only from people who disagree with me. My side simply calls a spade an agricultural implement) certainly are a waste of bandwidth here.
 
The sensible approach. But a calm discussion of the difficult issues and possibilities involved is useful for concerned citizens in all sorts of unpredictable ways and in all sorts of unknown areas of life and laew. However the usual name calling hysterics (that come only from people who disagree with me. My side simply calls a spade an agricultural implement) certainly are a waste of bandwidth here.

I love it. The OP's original bleat was that Semrau should not have been charged, and that he should be set free. 3 pages later the reasonable people all seem to agree that a court martial proceeding should be conducted to determine the facts of the matter and pass judgement. Huh! Imagine that - letting the system do its job!
 
Canadians are there in a large part to fight this guy and his buddies.
A wounded Canadian would likely be an acceptable risk. A wounded ally would probably be an acceptable risk. A wounded enemy would not be an acceptable risk.

Is it true they teach you in Canadian military college that if you have a wounded Canadian and a wounded Taliban and can only evacuate one, the politically correct decision is to save the Taliban?
 
. . . I stand up for the rights of victims more than I would a self admitted, convicted serial child molester and murderer . . .

Well, shame on you.

Victims dont have rights because they are victims. Victims have rights because they are citizens -- just like child molesters.

There are goivernment programs that are intended to offer some succour to victimns, and of course, thr sympathy of people like you (and me). But these are not rights.

Your rights are expressed in the laws that limit the things the government can do to you. The self-admitted serial child molester and murderer is the very person for whom rights are most important. They are cut off from sympathy and understanding, unlike victims. Rights are the only thing they have.

Rights are not something we give only to those people for whom we have sympathy. Our rights apply not only to me and the people I agree with; they apply to all, including you, no matter how despicable you might be.

Please, by all means do what you can to support programs that assist victims. But please, at the same time, defend to the death the rights of the perverts and child molesters. You don't support anyone's rights at all, if you dont support the rights of perverts and child molesters.

Be Canadian!
 
I love it. The OP's original bleat was that Semrau should not have been charged, and that he should be set free. 3 pages later the reasonable people all seem to agree that a court martial proceeding should be conducted to determine the facts of the matter and pass judgement. Huh! Imagine that - letting the system do its job!
Charging everyone for every criminal offense with which they could possibly be charged is not really "letting the system do its job" it is abdication of responsibility. Likewise letting charges go forward for trial which should have been dealt with outside of trial.
 
Charging everyone for every criminal offense with which they could possibly be charged is not really "letting the system do its job" it is abdication of responsibility. Likewise letting charges go forward for trial which should have been dealt with outside of trial.

Do you know how communist countries maintained the illusion of the rule of law? They would run "fair" trials for the most part. They would only arrest people for crimes they actually committed. They imposed state control by making pretty much anything you could possibly do a crime, so that *everybody* was guilty of something, and then only prosecuting those who were seen as enemies of the party. Wasn't hard to get a "legitimate" conviction--the accused really was guilty as charged. So was everyone who wasn't charged.

Prosecutorial discretion undermines the rule of law, it's a much better idea to strike down and repeal laws that you don't really want to enforce most of the time.

The risk in having charges "dealt with outside of trial" is that they may be dealt with via a little quid pro quo: Stop publishing those critical articles in your newspaper and we'll make those irritating charges go away.
 
I love it. The OP's original bleat was that Semrau should not have been charged, and that he should be set free. 3 pages later the reasonable people all seem to agree that a court martial proceeding should be conducted to determine the facts of the matter and pass judgement. Huh! Imagine that - letting the system do its job!
Are you surprised there are 'bleaters' who rush to post half-thought-out propostions on TERB? Or that there are "reasonable people"?
 
Prosecutorial discretion undermines the rule of law, it's a much better idea to strike down and repeal laws that you don't really want to enforce most of the time.

No, it does not. It allows wise human judgment to decide when it is or isn't appropriate to prosecute. If we always act according to the letter of the law, we might as well turn our justice system over to computers.

When the Tamils broke a 1,000 laws by blocking the Gardiner last year, Chief Bill Blair wisely decided NOT to enforce the letter of the law. His first, second and third priority was public safety. Yes, people were inconvenienced but nobody git hurt.
 
Don't engage fuji in "conversation". He is a troll, full stop. The worst type of internet weirdo out there. Let him say what he wants.....and just ignore him. Thank you.
 
I am naive about the legality of killing enemies in the battlefield and this
a question by virtue of my ignorance.

Had we policed and investigated our soldiers in WWI and WWII
the way we do now applying similar morals and ethics how many
of them would have been charged like captain Semrau?
 
It allows wise human judgment to decide when it is or isn't appropriate to prosecute.

Which is the problem. "Human judgment" may have nothing whatsoever to do with justice. It may have to do with punishing political opponents, or something equally nefarious.

Justice should be blind. Everyone should be equal before the law.
 
Well, shame on you.

Victims dont have rights because they are victims. Victims have rights because they are citizens -- just like child molesters.

There are goivernment programs that are intended to offer some succour to victimns, and of course, thr sympathy of people like you (and me). But these are not rights.

Your rights are expressed in the laws that limit the things the government can do to you. The self-admitted serial child molester and murderer is the very person for whom rights are most important. They are cut off from sympathy and understanding, unlike victims. Rights are the only thing they have.

Rights are not something we give only to those people for whom we have sympathy. Our rights apply not only to me and the people I agree with; they apply to all, including you, no matter how despicable you might be.

Please, by all means do what you can to support programs that assist victims. But please, at the same time, defend to the death the rights of the perverts and child molesters. You don't support anyone's rights at all, if you dont support the rights of perverts and child molesters.

Be Canadian!

Well... there ya have it then buttercup... This is a nut shell is my whole problem with the "rights vs responsibilities" argument. I believe in taking responsibility for ones own actions OVER an individuals rights. You do the crime... you do the time.
 
Had we policed and investigated our soldiers in WWI and WWII
the way we do now applying similar morals and ethics how many of them would have been charged like captain Semrau?

The answer is simple, we would have lost WW I and WW II and you and I would be conversing in German or Japanese behind barbed wires on a ration of one cup of rice a day.
 
The answer is simple, we would have lost WW I and WW II and you and I would be conversing in German or Japanese behind barbed wires on a ration of one cup of rice a day.

Bull.

There were cases of outright violations of the GC in WW2 in Europe but they were not commonplace, they were the exception, rather than the rule. I'm aware of only one case where the Princess Patricia's are alleged to have executed prisoners, for example, out of the entire war--one case. Had they not executed those prisoners in that one case (assuming they even did--never proven) the outcome of the war would not have been any different.

The German side also generally respected the Geneva Convention as well, with some notable exceptions, e.g., they ignored it with respect to saboteurs dropped behind their lines, even when in uniform, and in an infamous case at the battle of the bulge. However, generally, other than these exceptions, both sides respected the GC throughout the entire war.

In the Pacific theatre the GC was ignored by both sides as the Japanese were not signatories to the convention and did not abide by its terms, the Americans then took the view that the GC in its entirety did not apply in the Pacific and so the GC was essentially ignored in that theatre. In Europe, however, it was for the most part well respected, to the extent that violations of it did not impact the war outcome.
 
Good news! Minister Lawrence Cannon said we are departing Afghany no later than June 30, 2011, No ifs, ands or buts.

I will never ever again support sending our brave men and women into a war zone with both their hands tied behind their backs. I support our troops 100% but not the stupid rules, politicians and upper military brass who tie their hands. What they did to Aaron Perry and what they are doing now to Captain Semrau is criminal.
 
There were cases of outright violations of the GC in WW2 but they were not commonplace, they were the exception, rather than the rule.

We covered this ground before and Sheik even told you real life stories from his relatives of maltreatment of allied POW's in German prison camps. Old Irish proverb: "There is no one so blind as those we do not want to see."
 
We covered this ground before and Sheik even told you real life stories from his relatives of maltreatment of allied POW's in German prison camps. Old Irish proverb: "There is no one so blind as those we do not want to see."

He got his ass handed to him in that debate. At the end he relied on confusing the Eastern front (where the GC was not followed) with the Western front (where it was).

The ONLY criticism that was EVER substantiated was that POW's were malnourished, but only at a time when the entire German army was malnourished, as their food distribution was collapsing along with the rest of their regime. That is not a violation of the GC, as they gave the POW's equal treatment to their own.

Try again.
 
At the end he relied on confusing the Eastern front (where the GC was not followed) with the Western front (where it was).

The Battle of the Bulge and the "Great Escape" happened on the Western Front and defenseless allied POW's were murdered in cold blood by German soldiers. There was also an incident where Canadian POW's were murdered in cold blood as well. You don't have to answer because we know you will say these were anomalies and the Nazis were really nice guys.
 
The Battle of the Bulge and the "Great Escape" happened on the Western Front and defenseless allied POW's were murdered in cold blood by German soldiers.

So you are essentially agreeing with me that these things wer exceptional cases. Exceptional cases do not change war outcomes.

Out of all the battles fought over the many years long war there were only a few cases of individual units violating the GC, on either side.

At any rate you've already painted yourself into a corner on THIS thread: Your line now is that the allies followed the GC but the germans didn't, yet the allies won the war. This is inconsistent with your view that if we followed the GC we'd have lost WW2.

The fact is the GC was mostly followed in WW2 on the Western front, to the point where the violations were inconsequential to the war outcome.