Captain Semaru trial

Mercy killing is illegal in Canada. Some people may think that isn't right, but that is the law as it stands. If you commit a mercy killing and there's proof of it then however good or honourable your intentions were, then like Robert Latimer, you will find yourself on the wrong side of a prison wall.
 
Mercy killing is illegal in Canada. Some people may think that isn't right, but that is the law as it stands. If you commit a mercy killing and there's proof of it then however good or honourable your intentions were, then like Robert Latimer, you will find yourself on the wrong side of a prison wall.

This was not done in Canada.....
 
Part one

The Toronto Star has been running articles on this matter over the past few days. Highlights added by me for emphasis, other posters are more than welcome to highlight anything they feel bolsters their opinion, or refutes mine:

Bruce Cheadle The Canadian Press


GATINEAU, QUE.—The first hint of a Canadian battlefield execution came from a stoned Afghan commander — near the end of a chaotic day-long offensive —and was dismissed, the commanding officer of Capt. Robert Semrau testified Thursday.
Semrau, 36, has pleaded not guilty to four charges, including second-degree murder, stemming from an October 2008 incident in Helmand Province when a badly wounded and disarmed insurgent was allegedly killed.
No body was ever recovered.
Maj. Steven Nolan, who was in charge of the Operation Mentor Liaison team assisting some 300 Afghan National Army soldiers that day, provided Semrau’s court martial with the first eyewitness account of the battle. The scene he painted was ugly.
Operating in close quarters between deep canals, with high foliage and cornfields limiting visibility, the offensive involved air strikes, repeated ambushes, an improvised explosive device (IED) strike that disabled an American unit and left a Canadian flank exposed, and Afghan army troops mistakenly firing on each other.
Nolan testified that Semrau radioed for instructions after reporting he had a severely wounded and disarmed insurgent, Nolan told the court at a Gatineau military complex.
Nolan said he instructed Semrau to “mentor the ANA (Afghan National Army) on providing first aid.”
Some five to seven minutes later, he said, he heard from the captain that the insurgent had died.
The prosecution alleges the ANA refused to treat the wounded insurgent and witnesses will say Semrau fired two shots from close range into his chest after telling a fellow soldier and interpreter to turn away so as not to witness the killing.
He was not charged until more than two months after the Oct. 19, 2008, battle.
Nolan testified that an Afghan lieutenant-colonel, for whom he had little respect and who had been chewing a “psycho-tropic” substance all day, made a strange sort of “comrade-in-arms comment” to him through an interpreter after the battle.
“My understanding of what he told me was ‘one of your guys killed a Taliban’,” said Nolan.
Nolan testified he was “dismissive” of the comment, and was later told by the Afghan interpreter that the lieutenant-colonel was “joking.”
Given the circumstances of the chaotic battle, it was not clear from Nolan’s testimony why he found it strange that a Canadian soldier had killed one of the enemy.
The case, thought to be the first of its kind in Canada, is casting a spotlight on the training and conduct of the military in Canada’s most deadly military conflict since the Korean War.
It is also highlighting the murky mandate of the Operation Mentor Liaison Teams, or OMLTs, of which Semrau was a part.
Nolan testified that he considers mentoring to be bringing out what is good about your counterpart and reshaping it in “a culturally sensitive” way.
The goal, said Nolan, is “not trying to westernize or turn (the ANA) into a NATO cookie-cutter operation.”
Earlier in court, Col. Joseph Shipley, the commander of the mentoring program in Afghanistan, described the OMLT as “a strange beast, it’s new.”
The mandate was evolving, Shipley testified, and senior commanders “tried desperately to put together the best training plan we could.”
Under cross-examination Thursday, Shipley noted that the military only had about 40 per cent of the training staff needed to complete the OMLT program, so some training scenarios had to be scaled back.
He also testified that the advanced first-aid training course required for all OMLT members was shortened to seven days from 10 days.
The OMLT is a “leadership figure” for the ANA to follow but cannot issue orders, said Shipley, and its overseers had envisioned mentoring teams that would be assisting Afghan commanders who already had some training.
“When we got on the ground, we found that was not the case,” he told Lt.-Col. Jean-Marie Dugas, one of Semrau’s defence lawyers.
Shipley told the court that medical training among Afghan soldiers was “non-existent” and that even Afghan company medics were “at best ... basic first-aiders.”
As for training in the laws of war or the Geneva Conventions, Shipley said ANA knowledge was “nil.”


Allan Woods Ottawa Bureau


GATINEAU, QUE.–A Canadian soldier facing a murder charge lived by an unwritten "soldier's pact" in which enemy combatants put dying adversaries out of their misery on the battlefield, an historic court martial has been told.
Capt. Robert Semrau is alleged to have killed an unarmed Taliban fighter with two gunshots in October 2008, first telling a younger comrade to look away before he pulled the trigger, the prosecution said Wednesday.
Even after 36-year-old Semrau was charged with the murder of the wounded Afghan insurgent in January 2009, he allegedly confided to one of his superiors at CFB Petawawa about the pact, an agreement between enemy warriors that one would put the other out of his mortal pain.
"You do to the enemy what you would want or expect him to do to you," military prosecutor Capt. Thomas Fitzgerald recounted Semrau as saying. Fitzgerald was addressing a court-martial hearing on the second-degree murder charges against the soldier.
The high-profile case is the first instance of a Canadian soldier facing murder charges for causing death on the battlefield.
It is slated to run until June and could travel back to the Afghan crime scene to hear up to a dozen witnesses, including an Afghan interpreter nicknamed Max, who prosecutors said witnessed the second of two bullets hitting the disarmed fighter.

Semrau pleaded not guilty Wednesday to charges of second-degree murder, attempted murder, disgraceful conduct and negligent performance of duty.
A significant wrinkle in the prosecution's case, spelled out in its opening address Wednesday, is the absence of a body or any autopsy reports that would indicate who the dead man was and how he died independent of the various witnesses that will be called to testify in Semrau's court martial
"Some ill-informed, irresponsible individuals might say this poses an insurmountable obstacle to the prosecution," said Fitzgerald. "The absence of a body in a homicide is not a bar to prosecution. ... It is not an insurmountable obstacle."
What will be brought forward are the two 5.56-millimetre tracer bullets Semrau is alleged to have fired into the chest of his foe, one of a number of insurgents who ambushed a team of Afghan soldiers and their Canadian mentors in Helmand province shortly after 11 p.m. on Oct. 19, 2008.
The bullets were recovered by a team of Canadian soldiers and military investigators some three months after the incident, with the help of a young private, Steven Fournier, who was working under Semrau's command that night.
There are also photos of the injured fighter, taken at Fournier's urging, in case the man turned out to be a high-value Taliban commander.
Prosecutors also foretold of a nine-minute video recorded on the cellphone of an Afghan National Army soldier showing the wounded fighter removed of his rifle, vest and ammunition, being assaulted, spat upon and kicked with sand, all while Semrau, the senior Canadian officer on the scene, stood nearby.
On the video, an Afghan soldier decides against treating the insurgent, saying that his life or death is "in Allah's hands."
Then, prosecutors said, Semrau made a similar decision not to provide life-saving medical care, a violation of the rules instilled in Canadian soldiers to treat friend or foe alike wherever they're found on the battlefield.
Semrau's military defence team has yet to spell out its version of the facts, and won't get the chance to do so for several weeks.
But defence lawyer Maj. Steve Turner told reporters the prosecution has merely put its spin on an incident.
"They still have to prove all those things," Turner said.
But it seems the so-called soldier's pact will factor heavily in the case.
Lt.-Col. Joseph Shipley, the commander of Semrau's Afghan mentoring unit, testified he'd heard nothing of such an agreement before arriving in Afghanistan and even then considered it a matter of bravado rather than fact. He noted that a number of wounded insurgents received medical treatment by coalition forces while he was in Afghanistan.

On Wednesday, Turner wouldn't deny his client endorsed such a pact, nor refute the admission Semrau is alleged to have provided to a senior officer after the charges had been laid
.

CONTINUED........
 
PART TWO

John Ward The Canadian Press
GATINEAU—“Capt. Rob boom, boom Taliban.”
Those five words of broken English from an Afghan soldier led to murder charges against Capt. Robert Semrau, his court martial heard Friday.
Maj. Steve Nolan testified that a medic named Gulamjaan made the accusation about two months after Semrau allegedly executed a badly wounded and disarmed insurgent on a battlefield in Helmand province.
The man was complaining: “Helmand, no good. Mission, no good. Taliban, no good.”
Then he dropped the bombshell: “Capt. Rob, no good. Capt. Rob boom, boom Taliban.”
Nolan said the words, accompanied by a shooting gesture toward the ground, prompted him to start asking questions about the October 2008 incident
Nolan said he went first to his sergeant-major.
“We started to talk about the possibilities of what this meant,” he testified. “I came to the conclusion there was a very real possibility that a crime had been committed.”
Nolan had the sergeant-major speak to a private who was on the battlefield at the time of the incident. He then spoke to his commanding officer, Col. Joseph Shipley.
“I told him that there was an allegation, or the possibility of an allegation from the Afghans ... they should probably investigate it.”
Semrau was pulled out of the field shortly afterward by military police investigators.
The 36-year-old officer has pleaded not guilty to four charges, including second-degree murder.
Nolan was in charge of an Operation Mentor Liaison team assisting about 300 Afghan National Army soldiers on the day of the death. He was at headquarters, while Semrau was in the field with the Afghans.
The mission was a troubled one, with the Taliban launching a series of ambushes. An American unit hit a booby trap. Afghan army troops mistakenly fired on each other.
At one point, Nolan testified, Semrau radioed in to say he had a wounded Taliban and the Afghans were refusing to treat the victim.
Nolan acknowledged that the Afghans had little more than rudimentary first-aid training, but he told Semrau to “mentor” the Afghans to help the man.
The prosecution says Semrau fired two shots into the victims chest after telling a fellow Canadian and an interpreter to look away.
Nolan said he got another radio message from Semrau a few minutes later, saying the insurgent had died.
Later, he was told by an Afghan officer that a Canadian had killed a Taliban, but he ignored that comment because he considered the man unreliable and an interpreter had said it was a joke.
Nolan acknowledged to the court that he was investigated by military police on the suspicion that he tried to cover up the incident by not reporting it earlier. He was given a lie detector test as recently as last month.

I am not a lawyer and don't pretend to be one, but I do have some experience in some areas directly pertaining to this situation, so, IMO - although Semrau is a Canadian citizen and soldier, and as such subject to Canadian laws (and int'l law that Canada is treaty to), A-stan is not Canada. It is in so many way so alien to Canadian customs and values that it may as well be Mars. The ANA, which Semrau could not order, only "mentor", didn't have the ability to treat the wounded Talib, and if they did they wouldn't anyways. In a show of generosity, their idea of treatment was to leave it to Allah, which means this guy likely suffers incredibly before he dies, because normally, this guy would be beaten to death by riflebutts, stones, shoes, etc. That is the Afghan way of doing things, and it differs substantially from our way. If we have to force them to immediately adapt to doing things our way, we'd better have a few ANA observers learning from CF as we do things, and have them teach the others. Their concept of justice involves killings and beatings.
Semrau was faced with an incredibly difficult decision, that most of the rest of the world, never mind Terb, would never have to make. Be sensitive to "local custom" means leave the man to die in agony, or kill him. Following Canadian laws, if at all possible, would likely have meant that group of ANA would view him as having no honour, ending his & likely other Canadians value as a mentor.
From the comfort of your homes, you'll now make opinionated judgements on Semrau without ever being able to fathom the difficulty of his decision. Please, lets at least all try to show some respect towards his situation, his family, and each other when we debate this. If I were in Semrau shoes that day, I cannot say that I would have handled it differently (other than to use it as "mentoring" session on the process of dead-checking).

PS: it seems Gulamjaan is a fast learner, or a Taliban sympathizer. Either way, give that man a promotion!!
 
Last edited:
A significant wrinkle in the prosecution's case, spelled out in its opening address Wednesday, is the absence of a body or any autopsy reports that would indicate who the dead man was and how he died independent of the various witnesses that will be called to testify in Semrau's court martial
"Some ill-informed, irresponsible individuals might say this poses an insurmountable obstacle to the prosecution," said Fitzgerald. "The absence of a body in a homicide is not a bar to prosecution. ... It is not an insurmountable obstacle."
What will be brought forward are the two 5.56-millimetre tracer bullets Semrau is alleged to have fired into the chest of his foe
, one of a number of insurgents who ambushed a team of Afghan soldiers and their Canadian mentors in Helmand province shortly after 11 p.m. on Oct. 19, 2008.
The bullets were recovered by a team of Canadian soldiers and military investigators some three months after the incident, with the help of a young private, Steven Fournier, who was working under Semrau's command that night.
It isn’t insurmountable but it certainly isn’t a walk in the park, particularly with a decent defence team. So they recovered two slugs what forensic evidence is the prosecution going to bring forward to link them with someone being murdered?

Maj. Steve Nolan testified that a medic named Gulamjaan made the accusation about two months after Semrau allegedly executed a badly wounded and disarmed insurgent on a battlefield in Helmand province.
The man was complaining: “Helmand, no good. Mission, no good. Taliban, no good.”
Then he dropped the bombshell: “Capt. Rob, no good. Capt. Rob boom, boom Taliban.”

Nolan said the words, accompanied by a shooting gesture toward the ground, prompted him to start asking questions about the October 2008 incident
Nolan said he went first to his sergeant-major.
“We started to talk about the possibilities of what this meant,” he testified. “I came to the conclusion there was a very real possibility that a crime had been committed.”
Nolan had the sergeant-major speak to a private who was on the battlefield at the time of the incident. He then spoke to his commanding officer, Col. Joseph Shipley.
“I told him that there was an allegation, or the possibility of an allegation from the Afghans ... they should probably investigate it.”
I have to agree with you as to Gulamjaan. And as much as I hate saying it, I wonder what reputation Major Nolan has.
 
I am not a lawyer and don't pretend to be one, but I do have some experience in some areas directly pertaining to this situation, so, IMO - although Semrau is a Canadian citizen and soldier, and as such subject to Canadian laws (and int'l law that Canada is treaty to), A-stan is not Canada. It is in so many way so alien to Canadian customs and values that it may as well be Mars. The ANA, which Semrau could not order, only "mentor", didn't have the ability to treat the wounded Talib, and if they did they wouldn't anyways. In a show of generosity, their idea of treatment was to leave it to Allah, which means this guy likely suffers incredibly before he dies, because normally, this guy would be beaten to death by riflebutts, stones, shoes, etc. That is the Afghan way of doing things, and it differs substantially from our way. If we have to force them to immediately adapt to doing things our way, we'd better have a few ANA observers learning from CF as we do things, and have them teach the others. Their concept of justice involves killings and beatings.
Semrau was faced with an incredibly difficult decision, that most of the rest of the world, never mind Terb, would never have to make. Be sensitive to "local custom" means leave the man to die in agony, or kill him. Following Canadian laws, if at all possible, would likely have meant that group of ANA would view him as having no honour, ending his & likely other Canadians value as a mentor.
From the comfort of your homes, you'll now make opinionated judgements on Semrau without ever being able to fathom the difficulty of his decision. Please, lets at least all try to show some respect towards his situation, his family, and each other when we debate this. If I were in Semrau shoes that day, I cannot say that I would have handled it differently (other than to use it as "mentoring" session on the process of dead-checking).

PS: it seems Gulamjaan is a fast learner, or a Taliban sympathizer. Either way, give that man a promotion!!
Excellent points Seth.
 
I agree that those are interesting points that SG made. Unfortunately, western criminal law was not constructed with A-stan in mind. What Semrau did is clearly murder under any Western criminal justice system.

"I shot the guy to avoid him being tortured to death by my allies" is a brand new legal defence, although manifestly one worth arguing and taking - if necessary - to the Supreme Court of Canada.

What is he charged with exactly anyway and why does a Canadian court have jurisdiction? If it is a military court martial, then the charge would be "conduct unbecoming" or something like that. The defences to this sort of a charge might be far wider than the standard common law defences to a murder charge.
 
That is the Afghan way of doing things, and it differs substantially from our way. If we have to force them to immediately adapt to doing things our way, we'd better have a few ANA observers learning from CF as we do things, and have them teach the others.

I find it disgusting that Western nations, egged on by the Bob Raes and Jack Laytons, are always practicing "CULTURAL IMPERIALISM". Forcing our values (e.g. democracy, women's rights, turning the other cheek, etc.) on alien peoples and nations. We evolved the way we did and they evolved the way they did. Who are we to tell them that they are all fucked up and should adopt our values?
 
I agree that those are interesting points that SG made. Unfortunately, western criminal law was not constructed with A-stan in mind. What Semrau did is clearly murder under any Western criminal justice system.

"I shot the guy to avoid him being tortured to death by my allies" is a brand new legal defence, although manifestly one worth arguing and taking - if necessary - to the Supreme Court of Canada.

What is he charged with exactly anyway and why does a Canadian court have jurisdiction? If it is a military court martial, then the charge would be "conduct unbecoming" or something like that. The defences to this sort of a charge might be far wider than the standard common law defences to a murder charge.

What do you mean, why does a Canadian court have jurisdiction? He is a Canadian soldier. All soldiers are subject to the laws of Canada, no matter where they are serving.

As for Section 129 of the National Defence Act (An act to the prejudice of good order and discipline ), that is used for minor misbehaviour, such as negligent discharge of a weapon, not murder. Semrau is charged with murder.
 
I find it disgusting that Western nations, egged on by the Bob Raes and Jack Laytons, are always practicing "CULTURAL IMPERIALISM". Forcing our values (e.g. democracy, women's rights, turning the other cheek, etc.) on alien peoples and nations. We evolved the way we did and they evolved the way they did. Who are we to tell them that they are all fucked up and should adopt our values?

You're a terrible troll.
 
This was not done in Canada.....

The forces are still subject to Canadian law, though the military version.

Robert Latimer was convicted of a mercy killing in the case of his daughter, who he plainly loved, and who was suffering tremendously without hope of recovery. Many people thought those sorts of extenuating circumstances should have been given consideration, but the courts did not agree--they sent him to prison.

In many ways Semaru's case is similar. Seth has done a good job of listing all the extenuating circumstances, which includes a similar story about how the alleged killing was done to end another person's needless suffering. My guess is that, as with Latimer, the courts aren't going to buy that, and if they find that he did it, they are going to send him to prison.

The general argument for leaving the laws the way they are is that once you open up to door to mercy killings in "clear cut" cases you wind up allowing actual murders to take place under the veil of a mercy killing. In Latimer's case, if he'd been acquitted the the worry is that less honourable parents with unwanted disabled children would engage in "mercy killings" to rid themselves of the trouble. In this Semaru case, even if we assume only the best of intentions for Semaru, letting him go without punishment, assuming he did it, opens the door for pretty much any soldier to kill any wounded enemy and call it a "mercy killing". Pretty soon we'll have lots of "mercy killings", carried out in anger by the soldiers who just moments ago were being shot at by the now wounded and disarmed enemy.

Whether Semaru really did it or not I'll leave to the courts to sort out.
 
In this Semaru case, even if we assume only the best of intentions for Semaru, letting him go without punishment, assuming he did it, opens the door for pretty much any soldier to kill any wounded enemy and call it a "mercy killing". Pretty soon we'll have lots of "mercy killings", carried out in anger by the soldiers who just moments ago were being shot at by the now wounded and disarmed enemy.
Which assumes a very by rote legal system in which Court Martial Boards or Juries are incapable of making basic determinations as to motive.

However, it is also true that Court Martial Boards don't have the option whether it is technically legal or not of nullification.
 
Which assumes a very by rote legal system in which Court Martial Boards or Juries are incapable of making basic determinations as to motive.

Sure, they would try, but it would be hard to establish motive in many cases, and the presumption of innocence would mean that the "it was a mercy killing" motive would stand in many cases simply because the contrary couldn't be proved beyond a reasonable doubt.

If you wanted to permit mercy killings on the battlefield I would say that the decision should be taken by an ad hoc tribunal of at least three officers and never something done independently by a single soldier acting alone. Even that might not be enough to safeguard the rights of POW's but it would at least be similar to the GC rules on when someone can be executed as a murderer (unlawful combatant) rather than detained as a POW.
 
That particular type of verdict is not available in a court martial, either he is guilty or he is not. If found guilt he gets sentenced there is no guilty but......
That type of verdict [a Morganthaler verdict] was not a guilty but…, as you decribe. There is no such possibility in our civilian courts either. In Morganthaler, the evidence was everything needed for a verdict of guilty, and the case was appealled on that basis, because, in spite of that evidence the jury returned (more than once) verdict of Not Guilty. The Supremes uheld the verdict. There is a legal term for this power of a jury to decide, rather than simply let some inexorable automatic arithmetic of facts and law determine guilt, irrespective of the human factors. One of the lawyers might enlighten us.

From what I know of the Semrau case, I think that would be the ideal way to reach a verdict.
 
That type of verdict [a Morganthaler verdict] was not a guilty but…, as you decribe. There is no such possibility in our civilian courts either. In Morganthaler, the evidence was everything needed for a verdict of guilty, and the case was appealled on that basis, because, in spite of that evidence the jury returned (more than once) verdict of Not Guilty. The Supremes uheld the verdict. There is a legal term for this power of a jury to decide, rather than simply let some inexorable automatic arithmetic of facts and law determine guilt, irrespective of the human factors. One of the lawyers might enlighten us.

From what I know of the Semrau case, I think that would be the ideal way to reach a verdict.

Yes, but Diana Ross came to a different verdict!

Thank you, you've been a great audience! Try the veal!!
 
Which assumes a very by rote legal system in which Court Martial Boards or Juries are incapable of making basic determinations as to motive.

However, it is also true that Court Martial Boards don't have the option whether it is technically legal or not of nullification.

I agree with this post. Judges and juries sometimes have to render very difficult decisions. There's no reason to let the "floodgates" argument prevail in this type of case.

I'm still confused about jurisdiction. A court martial in Canada has no jurisdiction over serious criminal offences and these have to be turned over to the civil courts where Semaru would have a jury trial. A trial by jury might be crucially important in this type of situation where the traditional law does not afford a defence, but a reasonable jury might find convicting Semrau repugnant and choose to render a not guilty verdict.
 
That type of verdict [a Morganthaler verdict] was not a guilty but…, as you describe. There is no such possibility in our civilian courts either. In Morganthaler, the evidence was everything needed for a verdict of guilty, and the case was appealed on that basis, because, in spite of that evidence the jury returned (more than once) verdict of Not Guilty. The Supremes upheld the verdict. There is a legal term for this power of a jury to decide, rather than simply let some inexorable automatic arithmetic of facts and law determine guilt, irrespective of the human factors. One of the lawyers might enlighten us.

From what I know of the Semrau case, I think that would be the ideal way to reach a verdict.

Actually Morgentaler was repeatedly acquitted by juries in Montreal for no good legal reason except the juries were absolutely determined not to convict. Morgentaler really had no defence until after 1982 when the Charter of Rights was proclaimed. At that point, it was argued that the state had no business telling women what they could do with their bodies and the underlying charge was found unconstitutional and void. Hence, the only and final acquittal and end to years of endless litigation.

There is no "guilty, but... " in Canadian law. And no "defence of necessity" for the crime of murder.
 
This case is actually a little different to the Robert Latimer case. In the RL case, the suffering was chronic and had been ongoing for some time. The situation was known to the medical authorities and - rightly or wrongly - our society has presently adopted a policy that a 3rd party cannot end the suffering in this type of situation.

In Semrau, the suffering - in the form of torture to death by the ANA - was not chronic, but would have certainly begun very soon and was inevitable. There was - it will be argued - no hope of intervention or forestalling this and the wounded prisoner would himself have wished to be executed quickly.

There is no societal policy about this in Canada because this situation simply does not happen in Canada where 911 is just a few seconds away. The type of situation described has not been present in Western society since the 17th or 18th Century, before the Law was developed or law enforcement reliable and effective.
 
Actually Morgentaler was repeatedly acquitted by juries in Montreal for no good legal reason except the juries were absolutely determined not to convict.


Same happened in 1800's England where 200 offences carried a death penalty. Decent human juries refused to convict.