Although I no longer hold any credibility as a poster here, this is subject that I'm a bit compelled to respond to.
Except for one or two possible exceptions here on TERB, its likely none of us have all the facts on this situation. From what I have heard, Capt Semrau is accused of depriving a seriously wounded man (apparently not expected to survive) of the possibly final few & probably extremely painful moments on earth. The man received his wounds in a fight following a Taliban ambush on a ANA patrol. Semrau was there, along with a few other CF, as basically, instructors for the ANA, and the wounded man was part of the Taliban group. Apparently, the wounded Talib was disarmed & photographed, Semrau was alone with him, 2 shots were heard, and the Talib was dead. The ANA patrol continued, leaving the dead Talib behind and his body was never recovered.
As already pointed out, no body or ballistics. But apparently there is a witness affidavit, and a publication ban to protect the identity of the witness.
Under the Pashtunwali code of conduct, justice & revenge are basically the same thing. And that's a code that the Pashtun population of A-stan have practiced for the past 1000 or so years....it predates Islam in the area by quite some time. So that's what most of the ANA would likely instinctively revert to if left to their own resources, so in this situation, the wounded Talib would have definitely become a dead Talib in a reaaaal short time, probably under reaaaal primitive methods.
So, did Semrau kill this guy? If so, why - "mercy" killing, or execution, or he went native and applied Badal according to Pashtunwali? It's a tough situation in a tough location. Its pretty easy to comment on this here on TERB, but remember that he has a wife and a young kid. So, to paraphrase, show some respect towards those involved.
And although it might seem contradictory, BZ to Hangman and Aardvark.......good opinions from knowledgeable sources (IMO)