Captain Semaru trial

nottyboi

Well-known member
May 14, 2008
27,810
5,491
113
This is the officer being tried for murder for delivering a coup de grace to a fatally injured and suffering Taliban soldier... frankly this trial exemplifies many things wrong with our society. Millions will be spent TO WHAT END!!!! Personally I think Capt. Semaru acted honourably and in the finest traditions of the military. It was a difficult, but humanitarian act. What can possibly be accomplished by this trial? If the military wants to clarify the rules in this type of situation, why does it not just DO SO... why attack this man who was acting in good faith? I am sickened and appalled by this insanity. :mad:
 
There use to be a time when we prosecuted the enemy but now we prosecute our own. Welcome to the bizarre world of 21st century Canada. Oh yeah, the LLL will tell you that hanging Captain Semaru will win the hearts and minds of Afghans because they (the LLL) think you are I are totally stupid.
 
Release this guy immediately!
 
BTW I should make it clear I am 100% anti-afghan war... but this case is idiotic.. please end this madness and free Capt. Semaru immediately.
 
Having spoken to friends who have served in Afghanistan and had direct contact with both the Afghan National Army and the Afghan police, mercy killing may be too soft a description. The Afghans have a totally different concept of what is right and just. They would likely have continued to torture the wounded terrorists in ways that we can only imagine in our nightmares. I do not agree with the summary execution of a combatant, but someone did this guy a favour. Whether it was the Captain charged or was another individual, only time will tell.

BTW, unless Capt. Semaru is extremely lucky, the military chain of command has already decided that he is guilty. The courts martial is just going through the motions. My understanding is that were he to be charged with murder for this crime in Canada that he would not be found guilty. Even if he manages to beat this charge his career is over.
 
Cycleguy, you're hilarious, to call me a bleeding heart. That's rich. You have no idea what I do for a living, do you?

As for Capt Semrau, (please note the correct spelling) his court-martial will decide his fate. There are significant obstacles to prosecution, including a lack of a body and no ballistics report. Just because he has been charged does not mean he will be found guilty. However, shooting an unarmed and injured man, even a mortally wounded one, remains murder. There is no mythical code of honor among enemies. Canadian soldiers serving overseas remain subject to Canadian laws and regulations, including the Code of Service Discipline, QR&O's and a bunch of others. If he did it, even acting in 'good faith', he's a murderer. Pure and simple. The alleged act is NOT in "the finest traditions of the military." It is murder.

If he did do what is alleged, then he should go to jail. There was sufficient cause to lay the charge. You would all be twice as indignant if there were rumours of a murdering soldier running around, that was not brought to trial, wouldn't you?

If you actually want to understand military ethos, as opposed to schoolboy ideas of heroism and valour, I suggest you peruse this document.
http://www.cda.forces.gc.ca/cfli-ilfc/doc/dwhn-eng.pdf
 
Last edited:
Cycleguy, you're hilarious, to call me a bleeding heart. That's rich. You have no idea what I do for a living, do you?
No... why would I?

But for the same reason, why would you call me a redneck? Because I stand up for the rights of victims more than I would a self admitted, convicted serial child molester and murderer?

Just curious...
 
Although I no longer hold any credibility as a poster here, this is subject that I'm a bit compelled to respond to.

Except for one or two possible exceptions here on TERB, its likely none of us have all the facts on this situation. From what I have heard, Capt Semrau is accused of depriving a seriously wounded man (apparently not expected to survive) of the possibly final few & probably extremely painful moments on earth. The man received his wounds in a fight following a Taliban ambush on a ANA patrol. Semrau was there, along with a few other CF, as basically, instructors for the ANA, and the wounded man was part of the Taliban group. Apparently, the wounded Talib was disarmed & photographed, Semrau was alone with him, 2 shots were heard, and the Talib was dead. The ANA patrol continued, leaving the dead Talib behind and his body was never recovered.
As already pointed out, no body or ballistics. But apparently there is a witness affidavit, and a publication ban to protect the identity of the witness.

Under the Pashtunwali code of conduct, justice & revenge are basically the same thing. And that's a code that the Pashtun population of A-stan have practiced for the past 1000 or so years....it predates Islam in the area by quite some time. So that's what most of the ANA would likely instinctively revert to if left to their own resources, so in this situation, the wounded Talib would have definitely become a dead Talib in a reaaaal short time, probably under reaaaal primitive methods.

So, did Semrau kill this guy? If so, why - "mercy" killing, or execution, or he went native and applied Badal according to Pashtunwali? It's a tough situation in a tough location. Its pretty easy to comment on this here on TERB, but remember that he has a wife and a young kid. So, to paraphrase, show some respect towards those involved.

And although it might seem contradictory, BZ to Hangman and Aardvark.......good opinions from knowledgeable sources (IMO)
 
Canada has this ridiculous Court Martial and the U.S. has the Court Martial of the SEAL Team.

War use to be hell for the enemy. Now it is hell on our own troops. Who needs enemies when you got friends like the armchair generals in Ottawa and Washington?
 
Thanks Seth. We may hold different opinions, and have different understanding of the events in question, but I appreciate your input.
 
You're welcome, Hangman.
These types legal/political discussions are usually interesting to me.
So I try to stay the hell out of them.
Take ten competent biologists, show them an animal, and they'd probably all agree.
Take ten competent geologists, show them a rock, and they'd probably all agree.
But take ten competent lawyers (please, no jokes about finding that many), show them an issue, and............

PS. Whatever it is you do for a living, I'm sure you'll be recognized for your outstanding abilities, if you haven't very recently already been.:)
 
The Captain did the right and merciful thing, morally, but the wrong thing, legally. I would guess that his only hope is that with little or no evidence it comes down to a he-said/he-said argument. Probability of conviction would most likely depend on the accuser - his perceived credibility, motives for lying or telling the truth, etc.

How many of us have watched war movies where we saw one of the heroes kill a wounded comrade rather than leave him to the mercy of the enemy or to die a painful death? While watching did you ever think "oh my god that guy just committed a war crime - he should have left his buddy alive so the enemy could capture him"? Well, this is that in real life.
 
I think the one rule he broke was to talk about it after. When you do such things... you have to STFU. It is not talked about. That is why it is an unwritten code. Possibly some of the higher ups have it out for him as well (possibly for good reason we will never know)
 
This will probably put a bee is a few bonnets and get people citing GC paragraphs, and I'm not implying this is what Semrau did (I like CapitalGuys explanation - humane but not legal), but there is a process called a dead-check. Its as simple as it sounds - you check that the guy is dead, and if he isn't, he gets dead in the process. If you're moving fast through a closed area, to maintain your initiative and protect yourselves, a dead-check ensures that a wounded guy doesnt get the chance to kill you from behind. Poke him in the eye or throat, & if he flinches, he's not dead, so fire twice into the area you just poked with the dangerous end of your poking device.
US Marines have a saying - "if they're worth shooting, they're worth shooting twice".
Another Marine saying - "Yippey! Here comes the Army....we're saved!!" (just kidding, jarheads)
 
Last edited:
This is the officer being tried for murder for delivering a coup de grace to a fatally injured and suffering Taliban soldier... frankly this trial exemplifies many things wrong with our society. Millions will be spent TO WHAT END!!!! Personally I think Capt. Semaru acted honourably and in the finest traditions of the military. It was a difficult, but humanitarian act. What can possibly be accomplished by this trial? If the military wants to clarify the rules in this type of situation, why does it not just DO SO... why attack this man who was acting in good faith? I am sickened and appalled by this insanity. :mad:
It's a soldier's job to fight and kill, but even for them we have laws against cold-blooded murder of the helpless. You don't make laws just for the fun of it. Once you make them, then you have to keep them. For that you have police and prosecutors, who only enforce the law, but do not decide guilt. To determine innocence or guilt you have judges and juries who consider all the evidence and arguments brought by the prosecutors and by the defenders of the accused.

Only after all that can guilt or innocence be properly decided; that's what's going on now. You've read some stories, and seen some talking heads mouthing off in quick little quips on TV and sound like that's all you need to make up your mind, but fortunately you have nothing to do with our legal system.

If and when the court decides, then you might have a case to make about injustice, or disregard of military traditions. But I'm appalled by your assertion—on no real evidence, just media gossip—that due legal process is no more than an 'insane attack'.
 
Semrau was there as a mentor...maybe he should have let the ANA do it.