Captain Semaru trial

Stupid, this case should never have been prosecuted in the first place.

Why not? Are battlefield killings of prisoners and wounded enemies suddenly an acceptable way for Canadian soldiers to conduct themselves? Seems there had been a reasonable suspicion that he had killed a prisoner. As it stands now it sounds like all anybody can conclude is he fired a bullet at a dead body--which is still not the sort of conduct we want from our soldiers.
 
Why not? Are battlefield killings of prisoners and wounded enemies suddenly an acceptable way for Canadian soldiers to conduct themselves? Seems there had been a reasonable suspicion that he had killed a prisoner. As it stands now it sounds like all anybody can conclude is he fired a bullet at a dead body--which is still not the sort of conduct we want from our soldiers.

Fuji, stuff happens on a battlefield which doesn't happen at the local supermarket or in your living room. Usually, people are smart enough not to complain about it and usually the people complained to are smart enough to lose the file. And usually, the Crown is smart enough to avoid the prosecution or to proceed on a much reduced technicality.

Confused about this whole thing.
 
Fuji, stuff happens on a battlefield which doesn't happen at the local supermarket or in your living room. Usually, people are smart enough not to complain about it and usually the people complained to are smart enough to lose the file. And usually, the Crown is smart enough to avoid the prosecution or to proceed on a much reduced technicality.

Confused about this whole thing.

In a counter insurgency that sort of conduct is exactly why we are losing the war. Prosecuting him was the right thing. A jury found him not guilty, fine. But if we abstract to a hypothetical--a Canadian soldier knowingly shoots and kills an unarmed, wounded insurgent--that's GOT to be punished.

Otherwise we lose.

In fact, because of our abusive practices in Afghanistan, with respect to prisoner transfers and so on, we ARE losing. The population is turning against us. We SHOULD have prosecuted a hell of a lot more people than we did. As a foreign army carrying out counter-insurgency operations in a hostile country you HAVE to hold yourself to the highest standard of conduct. The enemy can get away with shit you can't. Anything you do, like shoot an injured soldier, becomes "proof" that you're a brutal invader that everybody should resist, even if the locals are doing worse.

Or to put it another way, if you can't bring yourself to fight a war in a way that wins the war, then stop fighting and go home. It's pointless to fight to lose.
 
Okay, first of all I would suggest that everyone ignore post #146, because it has soooo many incorrect assumptions and conclusions in it, that reading it may actually make you a little bit stupider than before. In case you already did read it , go get EXTRA drunk and hopefully the short-term memory impairment with erase that foolishness from your mind.

On to the important stuff..... I'm with Oagre on this, in that the sentence added some degree of confusion. Reducion of rank and booted out, but not booted out in disgrace. That means he can try to rejoin the CF, and since he already was a para with the Brits, he'd likely be welcome there again. So the door may still be open to him. And then there's always the possibility of an appeal. His career in the military may not be over at all.....unlike the corporal who testified against him and the major who started the investigation. Not many guys are going to put much trust in either of those two (IMO).
 
His career in the military may not be over at all.....unlike the corporal who testified against him and the major who started the investigation.

I sure wouldn't want those two guys watching my back when I go into combat or a hockey game for that matter.
 
Okay, first of all I would suggest that everyone ignore post #146, because it has soooo many incorrect assumptions and conclusions in it, that reading it may actually make you a little bit stupider than before. In case you already did read it , go get EXTRA drunk and hopefully the short-term memory impairment with erase that foolishness from your mind.

Pouring some Jim Beam as we speak.

On to the important stuff..... I'm with Oagre on this, in that the sentence added some degree of confusion. Reducion of rank and booted out, but not booted out in disgrace. That means he can try to rejoin the CF, and since he already was a para with the Brits, he'd likely be welcome there again. So the door may still be open to him. And then there's always the possibility of an appeal. His career in the military may not be over at all.....unlike the corporal who testified against him and the major who started the investigation. Not many guys are going to put much trust in either of those two (IMO).

After the way he has been treated, I would not blame the Captain if he wanted nothing whatsoever to do with our military ever again.
 
Maybe I've had couple to many Tag#5s tonight and/or the conspiracy theories are working overtime. The jaded part of me thinks that the PTB in DND don't allow anything to happen with out a reason. Hence the "message" being sent with this ruling - "How can we expect our soldiers to follow the laws of war if their officers do not? How can we expect the Afghan National Army to follow the laws of war if the officers mentoring them do not.”
Could it be that DND is laying the groundwork for a much larger and potentially embarrassing situation that's been brewing for a while now?
 
Okay, first of all I would suggest that everyone ignore post #146, because it has soooo many incorrect assumptions and conclusions in it, that reading it may actually make you a little bit stupider than before.

Of course you're unable to say what. You don't LIKE my points, but you've never been able to find flaws in my arguments. Funny that.

You don't win a counter-insurgency by building up a reputation for brutality. Sorry. And yes, the locals can get away with shit that you can't, and then blame you for it. It's not fair--but then it's a war, they're not usually fair.
 
It's not fair--but then it's a war, they're not usually fair.

I refuse to send our brave troops into an unfair war.

Old Irish proverb: "All is fair in love and war and our first target is Fuji's ivory tower." Hee, hee, hee.
 
Of course you're unable to say what. You don't LIKE my points, but you've never been able to find flaws in my arguments. Funny that.

You don't win a counter-insurgency by building up a reputation for brutality. Sorry. And yes, the locals can get away with shit that you can't, and then blame you for it. It's not fair--but then it's a war, they're not usually fair.

LOL! Double LOL!!
Au contaire, my pointy-headed little amigo. I LOVE your points, because they are usually so comically hysterical. And generally, I find HUGE flaws in your arguments....I just choose not to engage you, because I just don't have the free time that you have to argue on the Internet. Seriously, how does a guy with a wife AND a girlfriend have so much free time to fritter away online??
Anyhooo, why don't you revive that doozy over in the P&I forum...you know, your "plan" for "fixing" the UN HCR and ICC.....read up a little on the Bashir/Kenya/ICC brouhaha first, lest you embarass yourself again. Jeez, I've got the giggles just thinking about that!
Anyhow, thanks for providing the laughs, its much appreciated.
Keep up the good work!
 
LAnd generally, I find HUGE flaws in your arguments....I just choose not to engage you, because I just don't have the free time that you have to argue on the Internet.

You're right, the correct way to fight a counter-insurgency is to terrify the population and persuade them that you're evil. They'll join your side because they're so afraid of you, and none of them would ever think to try and kick you out.

Seriously, how does a guy with a wife AND a girlfriend have so much free time to fritter away online??

By getting rid of the mistress!

Serious answer I have the sort of job that allows me a lot of 5 min here and there to surf the web, between fires I have to fight. Some days there are no fires.
 
You're right, the correct way to fight a counter-insurgency is to terrify the population and persuade them that you're evil. They'll join your side because they're so afraid of you, and none of them would ever think to try and kick you out.

No Fuj, your assumption that the Toronto Star is read widely throughout A-stan and is fueling the "insurgency" is laughable. The detainee issue is only an issue here - its a none starter in A-stan. You are projecting your values on the situation, and your values are different from Pashtun values. And don't even begin with the "moral superiority" bullshit......superiority implies a counterpart to be inferior, and A-stan is not inferior. It is different. End of story. Unless you also consider them to be inferior in other ways (genetically? Intellectually?) So, unless your a racist with a grudge against Afghans, you should change that tune tout suite. One cornerstone of counterinsurgency is the legitimacy of the gov't - that is something that the Karzai gov't just does not have. The gov't is widely (and rightly) perceived as corrupt and ineffective, it is also viewed a a puppet gov't of the west (if only that were true, at least there would be some ability to rein them in). Most states have organized crime, in A-stan under Karzai, organized crime has a state. NATO and the ANA are viewed as ineffective and weak, because we cannot stop the violence and intimidation coming from the Taliban......if the combined powers of the western world can't beat the Taliban after 10 years, the local attitude is "if you can't beat 'em, we'll join 'em." The locals are terrified by the Taliban, not by us. They neither fear us, love us or even respect us, because we haven't delivered what we've promised. They're looking to the future, and from wherre they're standing the future is the Taliban, so they go along to get along. Its not up tho NATO and ISAF to "win the hearts & minds", unless we plan on staying there for a long, long time. And western politicians are looking no further than the next election cycle. Its the Karzai gov't & its agencies that need to win over the populace, but they are failing miserably because they treat the populace as their own private ATM machines (through shakedowns, not legitimate taxation). That is what drives this situation much, much more than anything you have alluded to.

But nice try anyways.
 
Gee, I guess those Afghan nationals protesting against coalition brutality must be thinking of something else then. Give your head a shake.

Many of the factors you cited are true, but also this is true: We're vilified in Afghanistan for what is perceived as our callous disregard for the lives of Afghan civilians.

Fair or unfair we're painted as a foreign oppressor by our enemies, and when we're complicit in torture, when we shoot wounded prisoners, when we recklessly fire off missiles and kill people who are only maybe the enemy, that criticism of us rings true, and harms our interests.

We should get the hell out of there because it's plain as day the Canadian and American armed forces have no idea how to win and don't even really understand why we're losing.
 
Last edited:
The trial was properly constituted and carried out. The court found him guilt of disgacefull conduct, that charge by the way can carry upto 10 years in confinment at hard labour. The penalty was fair. Shooting a mortally wounded combatant has been going on forever and will go on for ever, the person in question had been stopped by a 30mm canon and apparantly half of him was not there anymore. In theory he had a "positve responsibility" to stop the partol and call for medical asistance, which would not have gotten there in time. The question of whether or not it was a body or a person is irrelavent in this case as shooting a body carries he same charge. His big problem was as Lee MArvin put it in the Dirty Dozen He let somebody see him do it. For that lapse he has correctly been reduced in rank and ordered removed from the forces. He may appeal but it is unlikely he will win.