Captain Semaru trial

no hope of intervention or forestalling this and the wounded prisoner would himself have wished to be executed quickly.


Seems to me Semaru had the option of standing guard over the wounded prisoner until he died, to protect him from being tortured to death. That leaves the issue of his wounds in and of themselves being torturous to endure, but that seems to me to be in many ways similar to the case of Tracy Latimer: Our society, as you point out, has decided that a 3rd party cannot end an individuals suffering. That is true whether the individual is suffering as a result of a chronic illness, an automobile accident, or a shooting.
 
Semrau made a tactical decision.....not a moral or ethical or legal decision. Staying in that spot ("operating in close quarters between deep canals, with high foliage and cornfields limiting visibility, the offensive involved air strikes,repeated ambushes, an improvised explosive device (IED) strike that disabled an American unit and left a Canadian flank exposed) debating the ethics or legality of the issue would have been an EXTREMELY unwise thing to do and very well could have resulted in more deaths (this time for the good guys). Withdrawing from the area & leaving the wounded man alive - bad idea also. He might be 5 minutes away from getting his 72 virgins, or he might linger for an hour or two. What if another Taliban patrol finds him & hes able to provide info on the strength & movement of the ANA patrol? A few cellphone calls later & the Taliban could set up a bigger, better ambush and kill some CF or allied guys. Would that make you happy? And taking the wounded guy with you as you're trying to move on? Bad idea also, for reasons similar to the above.
Not all soldiers receive the same training. Semrau may not have been aware of the Dead-check process I mentioned earlier, but that's basically what he did, whether he understands why he did it or not. He had a resonsibility to get the CF OMLT under his command to safety, and to mentor the ANA on proper procedure. Under the conditions they were operating in, he seems to have done that. It simply is not worth risking your guys lives over this wounded man. I would have done the same.
Second-guess him all you want, but what would you have done?
 
There is a legal term for this power of a jury to decide, rather than simply let some inexorable automatic arithmetic of facts and law determine guilt, irrespective of the human factors. One of the lawyers might enlighten us.
Jury Nulification. Not really a legal right, but a de facto and traditional power. The hitch to this in Canada is that the Crown has the right to appeal the resulting acquittal (This is not the case in other Common Law countries)

The first known attempt to argue outright for jury nullification was the case of John Lilburne in 1649 (although there was perhaps an earlier instance in the case of the trial of Sir Nicholas Throckmorton in 1554). However, when it took hold was in 1670 with the "Hay-Market Case" the prosecution of William Penn and William Mead (Preaching by Friends) and the related Bushell's Case (22 Charles II., 1670) (the foreman of the Jury in the Hay-Market case).
 
I would recommend anyone so interested in the this topic to read the works of Dave Grossman. Here's a link with an excerpt from his book "On Combat: The Psychology and Physiology of Deadly Conflict in War and Peace"

http://www.killology.com/sheep_dog.htm

I read thru a couple of paragraphs of the link and was somewhat turned off. Essentially, a US naval officer giving his version of Jack Nicholson's "You can't handle the truth" speech.

Re SG's other post, I think no-one else in the thread - incuding Fuji and myself - realized that Semaru's situation was still tactical. I had the impression that he was making an ethical decision with no tactical imperatives. I'm now a little surprised he was charged. Everyone knows there are situations where you cannot take prisoners in war and this seems to have been one of them.
 
Same happened in 1800's England where 200 offences carried a death penalty. Decent human juries refused to convict.
Or in the 1700's as well, Judges frequently commuted the sentence to "transportation beyond the seas."

By the way one of the grievances which was dropped during the drafting of the U.S. Declaration of Independence (dumping your criminals [as Indentured Servants] on us).
 
I read thru a couple of paragraphs of the link and was somewhat turned off. Essentially, a US naval officer giving his version of Jack Nicholson's "You can't handle the truth" speech.
But for those who haven't looked not in the same Jackass manner. To my mind more Lieutenant Weinberg like.
 
I've never seen "A Few Good Men", so the references are a bit beyond me.
In retrospect it looks like the Grossman link was a little over-the-top. It wasn't meant to offend or upset, just to illustrate the difference between Semrau's job and most other jobs.
Taking no prisoners because of reprisal or revenge is a different matter (although I personally wouldn't fault the Canucks after Caen, or T.E. Lawrence after Tafas - its war, shit happens, sometimes you've got to make decisions most people won't ever imagine). The wounded man still posed a threat because of the location and situation. Semrau made a very difficult choice, but I think it was the right one under the circumstances. Our fellow posters can compare it to Latimer or Morgentaler all they wish if thats what they want to do, but its just not the same (IMO).

Sorry if I offended anyone & thanks for reading
 
One more thing from me on this.......
In other posts, I've previously made reference to a SEAL capture/kill job that went terribly awry after they voted to release a sheperd who stumbled across them.
Look up either "Operation Red Wing" or "Lone Survivor".
I'd wager that deep down, privately, he wishes he had voted to kill the guy.
 
Or in the 1700's as well, Judges frequently commuted the sentence to "transportation beyond the seas."

By the way one of the grievances which was dropped during the drafting of the U.S. Declaration of Independence (dumping your criminals [as Indentured Servants] on us).

Many of those so convicted were shipped off to Australia. Many of those "criminals" were not criminal in the true sense of the word, they merely did or said something that displeased the king or queen.
 
IThe wounded man still posed a threat because of the location and situation.

In that case why didn't they take the wounded man with them? Don't tell me it wasn't possible--if he was a wounded Canadian they would have.

If you come back with some sort of "maybe this, maybe that" answer, then I'll reiterate the point I'm about to make next: You don't have enough information about what happened, you don't know what options he had, you don't know what the situation was like, so you aren't really in a position to make any claims. Neither do I, neither does anyone else here. The court will certainly hear those details, let's wait and let them do their job.

My only comment on this thread is that if it boils down to "mercy killing" then my full expectation is that Semrau is going to go to jail, like Latimer went to jail.
 
Last edited:
Jury Nulification. Not really a legal right, but a de facto and traditional power. The hitch to this in Canada is that the Crown has the right to appeal the resulting acquittal (This is not the case in other Common Law countries)

The first known attempt to argue outright for jury nullification was the case of John Lilburne in 1649 (although there was perhaps an earlier instance in the case of the trial of Sir Nicholas Throckmorton in 1554). However, when it took hold was in 1670 with the "Hay-Market Case" the prosecution of William Penn and William Mead (Preaching by Friends) and the related Bushell's Case (22 Charles II., 1670) (the foreman of the Jury in the Hay-Market case).

Thanks Aardvark, do you know if such a case has ever occurred in courts martial? To me it seems a sensible and pragmatic way of dealing with moral, ethical issues that would be impossible to parse into statute law. Best to have a blanket prohibition against shooting or abusing wounded and other helpless prisoners (See also: Afghan detainee threads) but use the human interpretive power of the jury process to see that right as well as justice prevails in exceptinal circumstances.

The peril of double jeopardy at least helps to ensure this doesn't become a wide open escape-hatch from the law's intent.
 
Last edited:
Semrau made a tactical decision.....not a moral or ethical or legal decision. Staying in that spot ("operating in close quarters between deep canals, with high foliage and cornfields limiting visibility, the offensive involved air strikes,repeated ambushes, an improvised explosive device (IED) strike that disabled an American unit and left a Canadian flank exposed) debating the ethics or legality of the issue would have been an EXTREMELY unwise thing to do and very well could have resulted in more deaths (this time for the good guys). Withdrawing from the area & leaving the wounded man alive - bad idea also. He might be 5 minutes away from getting his 72 virgins, or he might linger for an hour or two. What if another Taliban patrol finds him & hes able to provide info on the strength & movement of the ANA patrol? A few cellphone calls later & the Taliban could set up a bigger, better ambush and kill some CF or allied guys. Would that make you happy? And taking the wounded guy with you as you're trying to move on? Bad idea also, for reasons similar to the above.

Canadians are there in a large part to fight this guy and his buddies.
A wounded Canadian would likely be an acceptable risk. A wounded ally would probably be an acceptable risk. A wounded enemy would not be an acceptable risk. Someone had to make a decision on it, there and then. Easy solution to prevent a situation like this from happening again - a CF JAG officer accompanies all patrols CF participates in or conducts. Let someone else make an extremely difficult decision, under imperfect conditions with imperfect information, and be held accountable for it.

If you wish to call it a mercy killing, go right ahead.

But, Sgt Hulka here as a few words he'd like to say to a few obstinate individuals here:
hulkavl3.jpg


Have a good day, everybody!
 
Many of those "criminals" were not criminal in the true sense of the word, they merely did or said something that displeased the king or queen.
Not really. More that almost all felonies were capital offenses. Further for theft the amount need for it to be a felony was quite small even by the prices of the time.
 
Thanks Aardvark, do you know if such a case has ever occurred in courts martial.
Not that I am aware of.

Then again the procedures and even the legal basis for Courts Martial have changed in a good many countries in the last 60 or so years (presumably this is true of Canada) so a nineteenth century case may currently have no precedent at all.
 
A wounded enemy would not be an acceptable risk.

I disagree. Your two assertions are contradictory: You are asserting that (a) leaving the prisoner behind alive would compromise the safety of Canadians or their allies, and that (b) it is not worth the risk of removing him from the area. If leaving him behind alive really is a serious threat to the safety of Canadians then it would seem to be very worthwhile to transport him out of there.

I do not think those two statements can be reconciled. I think you have to pick one or the other.
 
This whole discussion reminds me of the situation in Saving Private Ryan... The company comes across a radar installation and a gun fight ensues, the Navis end up critically wounding Giovanni Ribisi's character and he dies a short time later. There is one german survivor and the rest of the guys want to shoot the guy but the bleeding heart rookie in the group objects and there's a big argument amongst the other 6-7 guys on the rescue mission to save Private Ryan... well the long and short of it is, they end up letting the guy go thinking they are on a critical mission and can't take the guy prisoner, and he will get picked up by another allied company... problem is, the would be POW finds his way back to his own army first, joins them and eventually kills the captain- the guy who was responsible for letting him go in the first place! The bleeding heart rookie then promptly shoots him in revenge... thereby coming full circle in his moral dilemma.

Yes, its a Hollywood movie... done for effect etc. but at the end of the day war is an ugly business... it really is a "kill or be killed" dilemma, isn't it.
 
I guess waiting for the facts and the court to do its job and then deciding whats right would be out of line?
 
This whole discussion reminds me of the situation in Saving Private Ryan... The company comes across a radar installation and a gun fight ensues, the Navis end up critically wounding Giavani Rabissi's character and he dies a short time later. There is one german survivor and the rest of the guys want to shoot the guy but the bleeding heart rookie in the group objects and there's a big arrangement amongst the other 6-7 guys on the rescue mission to save Private Ryan... well the long and short of it is, they end up letting the guy go thinking they are on a critical mission and can't take the guy prisoner, and he will get picked up by another allied company... problem is, the would be POW finds his way back to his own army first, joins them and eventually kills the captain- the guy who was responsible for letting him go in the first place! The bleeding heart rookie then promptly shoots him in revenge... thereby coming full circle in his moral dilemma.

Yes, its a Hollywood movie... done for effect etc. but at the end of the day war is an ugly business... it really is a "kill or be killed" dilemma, isn't it.
However, I believe it is accurate to its time in that everyone didn't promptly report the interpreter up the chain of command or run to the nearest JAG they could find.

I think that at that time there was perhaps a bit more clarity about what was a serious or blatant enough violation of the Laws of War and what was not.

Criticize that as situational ethics if you wish, the fact remains that to my mind there are different varieties of oranges and they are not the same.
 
I guess waiting for the facts and the court to do its job and then deciding whats right would be out of line?

Yeah, I'm trying to stick to the ethical issues, I don't think any of us have enough insight into the facts to comment on the actual case beyond the principles that should apply to it.

The principles:

1. Mercy killing is illegal under Canadian law, rightly or wrongly, you can't legally end a person's life in order to end their suffering. The justification for this is that it prevents actual murders from being passed off as mercy killings.

2. If it is safe to do so, our soldiers have a legal and a moral obligation to tend to the wounds of disarmed enemies, and if that is not feasible, at the very least not to make their wounds any worse.

Seth's trying to craft what I gather is a hypothetical case which attempts to slip through the cracks of these rules: What if you have a wounded enemy, who has information about you which would be dangerous to allow to fall into the hands of the enemy, who cannot be safely transported to a third location, and where it is not possible to stay and tend to him where he lies.

I don't know if (and I somewhat doubt) that is the situation Semrau found himself in. I guess, but don't know, that there were means available to transport the prisoner out of there. For example, if he had been an allied soldier or a Canadian, I am pretty sure they could have got him out of there safely--and if his information was that valuable to the enemy, seems sensible to do so. Moreover, presumably his information is not THAT valuable--if he had any comrades who escaped, they presumably already have information about force size and position (it was an ambush, after all).

However for the sake of argument I can imagine that soldiers might sometimes find themselves surrounded and cut off, with no way to transport even their own wounded out, in which case, what would you do with a prisoner who had highly dangerous information? I agree that's a hard question.

Short of such an extreme situation, though, it's pretty clear what is expected.