I guess waiting for the facts and the court to do its job and then deciding whats right would be out of line?
Yeah, I'm trying to stick to the ethical issues, I don't think any of us have enough insight into the facts to comment on the actual case beyond the principles that should apply to it.
The principles:
1. Mercy killing is illegal under Canadian law, rightly or wrongly, you can't legally end a person's life in order to end their suffering. The justification for this is that it prevents actual murders from being passed off as mercy killings.
2. If it is safe to do so, our soldiers have a legal and a moral obligation to tend to the wounds of disarmed enemies, and if that is not feasible, at the very least not to make their wounds any worse.
Seth's trying to craft what I gather is a hypothetical case which attempts to slip through the cracks of these rules: What if you have a wounded enemy, who has information about you which would be dangerous to allow to fall into the hands of the enemy, who cannot be safely transported to a third location, and where it is not possible to stay and tend to him where he lies.
I don't know if (and I somewhat doubt) that is the situation Semrau found himself in. I guess, but don't know, that there were means available to transport the prisoner out of there. For example, if he had been an allied soldier or a Canadian, I am pretty sure they could have got him out of there safely--and if his information was that valuable to the enemy, seems sensible to do so. Moreover, presumably his information is not THAT valuable--if he had any comrades who escaped, they presumably already have information about force size and position (it was an ambush, after all).
However for the sake of argument I can imagine that soldiers might sometimes find themselves surrounded and cut off, with no way to transport even their own wounded out, in which case, what would you do with a prisoner who had highly dangerous information? I agree that's a hard question.
Short of such an extreme situation, though, it's pretty clear what is expected.