Blue Jays 2022 Thread

If Shohei Ohtani was the starting pitcher, but a different player was the DH, I wonder if he would be eligible to pinch hit later in the game, for any player in the lineup, or possibly just for the DH? A canny Manager could think up multiple ways to exploit a scenario like that, while following the letter of the Rule, rather than its intent.

I grew up watching National League games, so I'm not happy with the DH being adopted by the Senior Circuit. The pitcher batting was more important when starting pitches went deeper into the game on a regular basis. Teams needed deeper benches for pinch hitting and double replacements, and the bench players needed to be good fielders, as they often came into games in the late innings with the score close. Everybody has to be able to bat in Cricket. If a batsman is injured in a match to the degree that he can't continue, he's listed as Retired(hurt) in the scorecard, but the batting side can't replace him; if he can't return later, his wicket is lost for the team, but not in his personal stats.
 
Manoah and Gausman Cy Young candidates!, Berrios could be there also.
That's a pretty solid top 3 that not many teams can match. I suspect that every single team has weak links in their starting rotation. Jays are not the only one.
 
I grew up watching National League games, so I'm not happy with the DH being adopted by the Senior Circuit. The pitcher batting was more important when starting pitches went deeper into the game on a regular basis. Teams needed deeper benches for pinch hitting and double replacements, and the bench players needed to be good fielders, as they often came into games in the late innings with the score close.
I understand your point, but none of those things translates into more excitement on the field. Pitchers batting are pretty much an automatic out and rally killer. Dull, boring. A double switch is not exciting. Even the puritans in the NL agreed that the game is better with the DH.

And there are times where we get to see a pitcher pitching a gem go longer instead of being pulled for a pinch hitter. IMHO, all better and more exciting than watching a manager think.
 
@shack:

In 1972, when neither League had the DH, Most games were completed in 2 1/2 hours, and games completed in less than two hours were common, particularly in April, when it was cold, or September, when neither team playing was going to be in the post season.

The average game time today is at least 40 minutes longer, sub 2 hour games are non existent, and nine inning games lasting more than four hours occur at least once a week. This is a big reason why the average age of Major League Baseball fans is well over 50. At about 2 hours, 15 minutes, an NBA game is comparable in length to a fairly long movie, and close to the attention span limit of a younger audience.

Maybe you and I define the word 'exciting' differently....
 
From your above post it sounds like your only argument regarding excitement is game length.

I define exciting by what happens on the field and how it impacts the final outcome. Length of game may be irritating but to me it is a non-factor in my assessment of excitement. Excitement is hitting and scoring and spectacular defensive plays. DH enhances all 3 of those. The defence has to make more plays with a DH as opposed to when a pitcher lamely strikes out or makes contact and doesn't even leg it out. And when they get a hit 1/10th of the time they don't steal bases. The pitcher hitting is a black hole for excitement.

Regarding length, which I repeat, to me does not affect the excitement on the field.

The game is played much differently now. There are way more pitching changes nowadays, which uses up more time. Use of relievers is much more prevalent and undeniably increases the length of the game to a significant degree.

In 2014 the typical AL/DH game was 2 minutes longer than the average NL game. IMO, that is insignificant.

Did length of games in the AL get longer when the rule changed in '73? By how much?

Anyways, everybody is entitled to their preferences and I prefer the DH. It does not mean that others have to agree with me or that I am trying to convince anybody to change their mind. Just giving my reasons for my preference.
 
If Shohei Ohtani was the starting pitcher, but a different player was the DH, I wonder if he would be eligible to pinch hit later in the game, for any player in the lineup, or possibly just for the DH? A canny Manager could think up multiple ways to exploit a scenario like that, while following the letter of the Rule, rather than its intent.

I grew up watching National League games, so I'm not happy with the DH being adopted by the Senior Circuit. The pitcher batting was more important when starting pitches went deeper into the game on a regular basis. Teams needed deeper benches for pinch hitting and double replacements, and the bench players needed to be good fielders, as they often came into games in the late innings with the score close. Everybody has to be able to bat in Cricket. If a batsman is injured in a match to the degree that he can't continue, he's listed as Retired(hurt) in the scorecard, but the batting side can't replace him; if he can't return later, his wicket is lost for the team, but not in his personal stats.
I don't know the rule re your scenario with Ohtani.
However, if he's pitching I think it's almost 100% he's gonna be the DH?
 
Another poor outing by Kikuchi, he's got a great fastball, sometimes reaching 97mph. He should be throwing it 95% of the time like Robbie Ray, with the occasional slider. He should drop the change up and curve,
 
Another poor outing by Kikuchi, he's got a great fastball, sometimes reaching 97mph. He should be throwing it 95% of the time like Robbie Ray, with the occasional slider. He should drop the change up and curve,
I think that the team overall is playing mediocre ball. I'm glad that they've got a decent record but it seems to be smoke and mirrors for the time being.

Bichette looks totally lost at the plate. No discipline. Can't read a pitch and has no concept of the strike zone. Even Vlad is taking a tonne of really bad swings. And they can't hit for shit with runners in scoring position. Last I saw, they were 2nd worst in the AL.
 
Agree about Bichette, Vlad needs Teo back in line up for his protection ASAP.
Bottom 3rd of order is doing good, Tapia gets on base a lot as well as Espinal, but Bichette and Vlad need to get going to plate them.
 
Jays players imitate Bo's hair flip.

 
Great pitching, great bullpen, great third basing, great center fielding, great Springer.......and the rest dreadful. They couldn't even get a hit off a kid making his debut (8th inning) with a mediocre Triple A record. I really wonder about our hitting coaches
 
Their bats better come alive tonight, the Bronx Bombers are in town for a 3 game series, they are hot right now!
They will not face Garett Cole in the series.
 
These guys are rolling - finally we got pitching where we can also win those low scoring games. Lets Go ! How about that Markham local JR68.
 
The Jays deserved to lose yesterday's game. Defensive bobbles and the lack of hitting (especially with runners in scoring position) is catching up with them. However, MLB umpiring continues to be bad. While ball/strike calling is often awful, last night's call on the basepaths (Vlady's run down tag) was frustrating and the league should be embarrassed. I've said it before, bad umpiring sucks the joy out of watching.
 
They'll be swept tonight, Cortes pitches for Yanks, he owned the Jays last time he faced them.
 
As a Yankee fan I'm loving the roll they are on at present.

Cortes has been our best starter from about the middle of last year until now.

He's a late bloomer who comes at the hitter from different angles and speeds. Great control and always around the plate

He's hard on younger impatient power hitters especially. Our relievers have been lights out as well.

Advantage Yankees today but we'll see...........
 
I'm glad I was wrong about tonight's game. Kikuchi had his best start of the season and Cortes only lasted 4 innings in 2-1 win. Kikuchi still needs to throw more fastballs. He got away with some cutters that didn't move very much. Umpiring still not very good but the Yankees were burned more often tonight.
 
  • Like
Reactions: tml