Ok. Jays are approx. 25% through this shortened season. They are 6-8, .429%. Last year year they played .414 over a full season.
They added pitching and did some tinkering with the infield and outfield. Aside from that the basic strategy is "we have lots of good young talent that we are confident in. Let them mature."
From what you have seen so far, should this roster be more improved from last year than we have currently seen? The only negative occurrence that is not talent based is Giles' injury.
If you feel that they are doing commensurate with what you feel this roster is capable of, fine. Compared to last year that would be about 2 or 3 more wins than last year over a full season.
Some questions if you feel they should be doing better:
Are the players underperforming based on their talent even though so many are still very young?
Is Montoyo a problem?
Has upper management over-estimated their talent?
Has upper management done too little/not spent enough to augment the youngsters?
Has upper management sold us a bill of goods?
Do we need to keep showing patience? If so, how long? This is the prez' 5th year.
Personally, I probably expected them to play a bit better, but not by an awful lot. Without injecting a significant amount of proven talent, I wouldn't expect this team to go from .414 to much over .460 ball this year.
I know that I have been bashed for being overly critical of upper management. For the record, I never said that they could not assess and develop talent. My criticism is in the time frame that they are operating at to build a winner, especially since they inherited a playoff worthy team and even if they did not have a good farm, they had assets at the major league level that did not seem to garner a lot in return for the team.
Based on the start so far, this baby steps improvement seems to be continuing. People say "when the time is right, they will spend". My concern is that in the meantime they could be becoming accustomed to a losing culture instead of learning by example of what it takes to win.
Increasing their winning percentage by 20 or 30 points per year will keep us waiting another 5 or so years. I will say that I respect the talent of the youngsters, they seem like fine young men, I cheer for them with each at bat, but my one question continues...how long?
So based on what you've seen so far, what are your expectations and is the team living up to them. If not, why not. How many years are you willing to give upper management to give us a competitive team?