yychobbyist said:
You're so wrong it'd take a book to correct you. But, for a start, I'll offer this:
The game is the product? What's the game consist of? Players.
Players, marketing, even rules... but not necessarily any one group of players. Others will do.
yychobbyist said:
Do 18,000 people a night go and see women play the game? No.
Nor do 18,000 a night go to see peewee players. Some do, but it needs to be entertaining for a larger audience, when entertainment alternatives exist....
yychobbyist said:
Do people in Canada tune into Sportsnet to watch two unknown Swedish teams play? No. Why? because people here don't give a crap about Swedes playing the game.
But, by your argument, NHL players are over there now. If THEY were the product, people would watch, no? After all... they are "the best players", and they are playing the game, right?
And are the NHL players "the product" over there too? If not... why not? Why didn't THEIR leagues fold when they weren't able to sign "the best players in the world"? We MUST have "the best in the world", but Europeans don't need the same to be entertained? Without these specific players, Frankfurt will still watch hockey, but Montreal and Toronto won't? Or could that possibly mean... a professional hockey league can survive... possibly even thrive... without these particular players?
And what ever happened to this "All Star" league that was supposed to play? That really took off too... I guess seeing the "best players in the world" play shinny wasn't all that exciting after all....
yychobbyist said:
They care about Canadian players playing the game.
Only about half the league is Canadian players as it stands. And, considering that only 20% of the teams are Canadians... why do Americans (who host 80% of the league) watch the game? There are only a token number of Americans in the NHL on any given team.... is it REALLY a nationality thing? No. Is it a "home team" thing (i.e. I'll only watch our team)... possibly in some cases... but then it STILL isn't about just HAVING to see this one set of players, is it?
yychobbyist said:
Would we go watch replacement players play? Not likely?
Put a Maple Leafs jersey on them, and the house would be full. This city proved that through the Ballard years... and your city proved that for the last decade (last year excepted, of course).
yychobbyist said:
Why not? Because we want to see the best in the world play the game. The game does not exist in isolation.
The best players do make for the best entertainment, but do something first. If you have the capability, look at some of the old games they're playing on cable tv now... a bunch of networks are playing them... you'll notice that the talent level even so much as 20 years was so much lower then... Were the games less exciting? No. And did they have problems filling arenas? No.
Moreover - you seem to think that the talent level between the top 700 players in THE WORLD and the NEXT 700 players IN THE WORLD is such a "huge" chasm... truth is, half of the teams wouldn't even notice the difference (e.g. Pittsburgh, Columbus, etc.), aside from the fact that they might be more competitive on any given night.... and, better yet - it probably wouldn't be too long before they WERE the best 700 players in the world....
The game is more than any one group of players. It would survive losing every last one of them (the current ones) if it had to. Because, you know what? It always does. Did hockey survive the "loss" of Rocket Richard? Bobby Orr? Wayne Gretzky? It'll be just fine if we never see Chris Pronger again....
yychobbyist said:
And talk about "straightening out". Let's talk for a second about who should be straightened out here. If your theory is right and players are employees then Jaromir Jagr walked into his employers office as an employee and was, after what I presume were some offers and counter-offers, $11 million USD per year to play the game. Did Jagr, the employee put a gun to the head of his employer to get that much money? No. Did he threaten to go on strike? No. The employer gave him the money willingly. And if he didn't there was another overzealous owner out there somewhere who would have. So who exactly needs to be straightened out here?
The owners
have been stupid, to be sure, and horrible business managers. But they HAVE been straightened out - they ALL realise that sanity needs to be introduced to the economics of the game. THEY ALL WANT THE CAP. As of right now, it's only the players who are saying "you aren't allowed to have rules to make sure you're sensible".
That's what has to change. Fixing that will be critical to the league's survival... having THESE players back in uniform is not. They ARE employees... and they most certainly ARE replaceable.
Best regards,
F.