Bettman *^%$#*^$*&$*^%#$(

Flex

Member
May 8, 2004
229
9
18
Rumor has it that Bettman gets a 1 million dollar bonus if he achieves the cost certainty he is so despretly seeking. If this is true.... could this be ruled conflict of interest, so his ass could be booted out of office?


Flex
 
Good for Betteman - it wouldn't be a conflict of interest. He doensn't work for the PA. Call in a bonus clause in his contract.
 
healer677 said:
Good for Betteman - it wouldn't be a conflict of interest. He doensn't work for the PA. Call in a bonus clause in his contract.
Same here. Nothing wrong with that. If he gets this for the owners, shouldn't he be rewarded by them?
 
nothing wrong with getting paid for doing your job...
 
The problem is that if you have a clause like that in your contract, don't dare walk around for a year saying that you and the owners only want what's "best for the game". What's wrong with that is that you better never imply that the players are in it only for the money when all evidence is that you yourself are interested in only the money.
 
It's a question of interpretation -

"what's good for the game" can translate to what's good for the ownership. Bettemans job, right now; is to ensure cost certainty before a new CBA is struck. If the owners feel that cost certainty will ensure a healthy market share and make the game more profitable (which is why anyone goes into business), then why not give the person given the charge of such a task, a healthy bonus.

Maybe the union reps and specially the union president (Goodenow) has something hiding in his contract as well.

To me - this was always a simple problem....

If I was an owner, and I had to front a couple of hundred million to - buy a franchise, build a stadium, develop a team, hire a management team, coaches, develop a farm team - I deserve to make money. Seeing that they're fronting ALL the cost including guaranteed contracts. Players contracts that aren't performance based and the owners are getting screwed on arbitration.

The players are EMPLOYEES not partners. They do not share any of the cost or risks in running / operating the team.

Try to go to you boss and demand a bigger share of the pie at work - wether or not the company is making money....see what happens.

If the players don't like the way it is - start your own league. Or go to Europe and make 1/3 of your regular wage. Besides, who's watching out for those poor European players who have lost their jobs cos NHLers are going over there?

Please.

I hope there isn't hockey here until cost certainty is established. The owners have waaaaaaaaay more money than the players and the union combined.
 
healer677 said:
The players are EMPLOYEES not partners. They do not share any of the cost or risks in running / operating the team.

You are right that they're not partners but you are absolutely wrong when you say they are employees - they're as far from it as possible. Sure, you can't go to your boss and demand huge pay increases but no one in your line of work pays to see you do they? Players are a product, people pay to go see them perform. People do not go to see employees perform.

I'm not saying I think the players are right here. I think they are greedy and overpaid, but don't equate them with what you or I do for a living because it's so far off reality it's like comparing apples to planets.
 
The way I see it though...as well as the current predicament the owners and players got themselves in....

I think both parties are somewhat diluted in their thinking.

I like hockey, grew up watching it and playing it, but;right now, its a fringe sport at best.
When Poker, Tennis and College basketball can draw more viewers in their (the league's) target market (the US) they need to reasess what they're paying the players. Nobody in the US cares about hockey - it barely gets any airplay down there. The NHL doesn't even have a tv contract.Arena football has a tv contract. Nobody that matters cares about the product.

It's a shame though, because a lot of people here care....but I sense not for long.
 
yychobbyist said:
You are right that they're not partners but you are absolutely wrong when you say they are employees - they're as far from it as possible.
They are employed by the people who sign their paycheques, the employers.

They are definitely not stereotypical employees, but employees nonetheless. Take actors as another example. An actor may decide which movie he'll do but once he signs that contract and is doing the movie, he's employed by whoever signs his cheques, the studio or executive producer or whoever. I guess it usually takes a few months to make a movie so then the actor gets himself another job and is employed by someone else.

A hockey player has several options as to who he wants to work for, but he can only work for one at a time. This makes him different than someone who makes a living by providing a service. Service providers, e.g. doctors, personal trainers, SP's, will have a number of clients. If he's only working for one person then that's his employer. In fact that's one of the tests the tax dep't will use to see if someone is an independant contractor or an employee (in which case the employer must withhold tax and pay unemployment and pension contributions). If they only work at one place the gov't says they're an employee.

As well, independant contractors do not have unions such as the NHLPA. Employees have unions to give them leverage against the employers.

They've definitely got it a lot better than most employees, but that's what they are.
 
yychobbyist said:
You are right that they're not partners but you are absolutely wrong when you say they are employees - they're as far from it as possible. Sure, you can't go to your boss and demand huge pay increases but no one in your line of work pays to see you do they? Players are a product, people pay to go see them perform.

Not entirely true. The GAME is the product, and people go to see that. If players truly were "the product", we would see (or have seen) different behaviour when (1) players retire, or (2) when players are traded, or (3) when players - like Howe and Hull - went to play for different leagues (back then, it was the WHA). By and large, no one is watching the European leagues here (where a lot of the players went), and that is contrary to the "players are the product" theory.

The game is much bigger than any player. It's even bigger than ALL of the players.

yychobbyist said:
People do not go to see employees perform.

Not true. You may not know their names, but if your bank teller, or dentist's assistant, or anyone didn't do their job, you would change your consumption habits. The only real difference is what you are expecting from what you're "buying" - with banking, you want fast, accurate transaction execution... with dentists, you want comfortable, quick, painless dental attention... with hockey, you want to be visually entertained for a couple of hours. Yes, I don't expect the bank teller to amuse me, but they most certainly can be why I chose to use any particular bank. Likewise, the local watering hole I chose to repose in is DIRECTLY related to the employees (the beer is the same everywhere), but I wouldn't exactly consider them "the product" (if they left, I wouldn't necessarily stop drinking).... And, just like cheque cashers and bartenders can be replaced without affecting my business (IF the quality of my experience doesn't change), the current players are not the only ones who can "entertain".

If you like, consider the example of other entertainers... are singers "employees" of a record company, or are they "more" simply because they are "the ones the customers pay to see"? If Britney Spears "quit"... or was "fired"... would young girls (and boys?) stop listening to music or reading magazines? Nope. Does "boy band music" live and die on whether or not "The Backstreet Boys" perform? Considering they existed before (NKOTB) and after (N'Sync), you'd have to say not. Record companies will exist with or without any specific entertainer or groups of entertainers - because music (or whatever package of music and image they sell now) is the real product, and it survives any individual performer, or even group of performers.

yychobbyist said:
I'm not saying I think the players are right here. I think they are greedy and overpaid, but don't equate them with what you or I do for a living because it's so far off reality it's like comparing apples to planets.

If all of the current players went back to their farms to drive combines, no one would watch them either... and people WOULD watch replacement players - so long as the product (the GAME) was entertaining - with the only difference being new faces on the hockey cards....

The players are NOT the product... they ARE employees. And they most certainly need to be "straightened out" before the game can be properly fixed...

IMHO, of course.


Best regards,

F.
 
yychobbyist said:
What's wrong with that is that you better never imply that the players are in it only for the money when all evidence is that you yourself are interested in only the money.

They're ALL in it for the money. The players. The owners. The agents too. If they claim they're not, then they're bullshitting.
 
matrix2004 said:
They're ALL in it for the money. The players. The owners. The agents too. If they claim they're not, then they're bullshitting.
So you are not in your job because of the money?
 
n_v said:
So you are not in your job because of the money?

If I were working right now, money WOULD be the biggest factor- I have no problem saying that...as I'm pretty sure in most people's case. I say most because I can actually think of a few jobs that I'd work for free- the perks/fringe benefits would be the reward.

But back to this thread.....I think what pisses off alot of people in this whole lockout situation is when one of the sides accuses the other as being the greedy ones, while at the same time portraying their side as the one that's only 'concerned' about the 'game' and that it wasn't just about the money. My point was that they're ALL greedy. It's ALL about the money...I wish they would at least stop pretending that it wasn't.
 
Fortunato said:
Not entirely true. The GAME is the product, and people go to see that. If players truly were "the product", we would see (or have seen) different behaviour when (1) players retire, or (2) when players are traded, or (3) when players - like Howe and Hull - went to play for different leagues (back then, it was the WHA). By and large, no one is watching the European leagues here (where a lot of the players went), and that is contrary to the "players are the product" theory.

The game is much bigger than any player. It's even bigger than ALL of the players.



Not true. You may not know their names, but if your bank teller, or dentist's assistant, or anyone didn't do their job, you would change your consumption habits. The only real difference is what you are expecting from what you're "buying" - with banking, you want fast, accurate transaction execution... with dentists, you want comfortable, quick, painless dental attention... with hockey, you want to be visually entertained for a couple of hours. Yes, I don't expect the bank teller to amuse me, but they most certainly can be why I chose to use any particular bank. Likewise, the local watering hole I chose to repose in is DIRECTLY related to the employees (the beer is the same everywhere), but I wouldn't exactly consider them "the product" (if they left, I wouldn't necessarily stop drinking).... And, just like cheque cashers and bartenders can be replaced without affecting my business (IF the quality of my experience doesn't change), the current players are not the only ones who can "entertain".

If you like, consider the example of other entertainers... are singers "employees" of a record company, or are they "more" simply because they are "the ones the customers pay to see"? If Britney Spears "quit"... or was "fired"... would young girls (and boys?) stop listening to music or reading magazines? Nope. Does "boy band music" live and die on whether or not "The Backstreet Boys" perform? Considering they existed before (NKOTB) and after (N'Sync), you'd have to say not. Record companies will exist with or without any specific entertainer or groups of entertainers - because music (or whatever package of music and image they sell now) is the real product, and it survives any individual performer, or even group of performers.



If all of the current players went back to their farms to drive combines, no one would watch them either... and people WOULD watch replacement players - so long as the product (the GAME) was entertaining - with the only difference being new faces on the hockey cards....

The players are NOT the product... they ARE employees. And they most certainly need to be "straightened out" before the game can be properly fixed...

IMHO, of course.


Best regards,

F.


You're so wrong it'd take a book to correct you. But, for a start, I'll offer this:

The game is the product? What's the game consist of? Players. Do 18,000 people a night go and see women play the game? No. Do people in Canada tune into Sportsnet to watch two unknown Swedish teams play? No. Why? because people here don't give a crap about Swedes playing the game. They care about Canadian players playing the game. Would we go watch replacement players play? Not likely? Why not? Because we want to see the best in the world play the game. The game does not exist in isolation.

And talk about "straightening out". Let's talk for a second about who should be straightened out here. If your theory is right and players are employees then Jaromir Jagr walked into his employers office as an employee and was, after what I presume were some offers and counter-offers, $11 million USD per year to play the game. Did Jagr, the employee put a gun to the head of his employer to get that much money? No. Did he threaten to go on strike? No. The employer gave him the money willingly. And if he didn't there was another overzealous owner out there somewhere who would have. So who exactly needs to be straightened out here?
 
yychobbyist said:
You're so wrong it'd take a book to correct you. But, for a start, I'll offer this:

The game is the product? What's the game consist of? Players.

Players, marketing, even rules... but not necessarily any one group of players. Others will do.

yychobbyist said:
Do 18,000 people a night go and see women play the game? No.

Nor do 18,000 a night go to see peewee players. Some do, but it needs to be entertaining for a larger audience, when entertainment alternatives exist....

yychobbyist said:
Do people in Canada tune into Sportsnet to watch two unknown Swedish teams play? No. Why? because people here don't give a crap about Swedes playing the game.

But, by your argument, NHL players are over there now. If THEY were the product, people would watch, no? After all... they are "the best players", and they are playing the game, right?

And are the NHL players "the product" over there too? If not... why not? Why didn't THEIR leagues fold when they weren't able to sign "the best players in the world"? We MUST have "the best in the world", but Europeans don't need the same to be entertained? Without these specific players, Frankfurt will still watch hockey, but Montreal and Toronto won't? Or could that possibly mean... a professional hockey league can survive... possibly even thrive... without these particular players?

And what ever happened to this "All Star" league that was supposed to play? That really took off too... I guess seeing the "best players in the world" play shinny wasn't all that exciting after all....

yychobbyist said:
They care about Canadian players playing the game.

Only about half the league is Canadian players as it stands. And, considering that only 20% of the teams are Canadians... why do Americans (who host 80% of the league) watch the game? There are only a token number of Americans in the NHL on any given team.... is it REALLY a nationality thing? No. Is it a "home team" thing (i.e. I'll only watch our team)... possibly in some cases... but then it STILL isn't about just HAVING to see this one set of players, is it?

yychobbyist said:
Would we go watch replacement players play? Not likely?

Put a Maple Leafs jersey on them, and the house would be full. This city proved that through the Ballard years... and your city proved that for the last decade (last year excepted, of course).

yychobbyist said:
Why not? Because we want to see the best in the world play the game. The game does not exist in isolation.

The best players do make for the best entertainment, but do something first. If you have the capability, look at some of the old games they're playing on cable tv now... a bunch of networks are playing them... you'll notice that the talent level even so much as 20 years was so much lower then... Were the games less exciting? No. And did they have problems filling arenas? No.

Moreover - you seem to think that the talent level between the top 700 players in THE WORLD and the NEXT 700 players IN THE WORLD is such a "huge" chasm... truth is, half of the teams wouldn't even notice the difference (e.g. Pittsburgh, Columbus, etc.), aside from the fact that they might be more competitive on any given night.... and, better yet - it probably wouldn't be too long before they WERE the best 700 players in the world....

The game is more than any one group of players. It would survive losing every last one of them (the current ones) if it had to. Because, you know what? It always does. Did hockey survive the "loss" of Rocket Richard? Bobby Orr? Wayne Gretzky? It'll be just fine if we never see Chris Pronger again....

yychobbyist said:
And talk about "straightening out". Let's talk for a second about who should be straightened out here. If your theory is right and players are employees then Jaromir Jagr walked into his employers office as an employee and was, after what I presume were some offers and counter-offers, $11 million USD per year to play the game. Did Jagr, the employee put a gun to the head of his employer to get that much money? No. Did he threaten to go on strike? No. The employer gave him the money willingly. And if he didn't there was another overzealous owner out there somewhere who would have. So who exactly needs to be straightened out here?

The owners have been stupid, to be sure, and horrible business managers. But they HAVE been straightened out - they ALL realise that sanity needs to be introduced to the economics of the game. THEY ALL WANT THE CAP. As of right now, it's only the players who are saying "you aren't allowed to have rules to make sure you're sensible".

That's what has to change. Fixing that will be critical to the league's survival... having THESE players back in uniform is not. They ARE employees... and they most certainly ARE replaceable.


Best regards,

F.
 
sigh. Ok, here's the deal. I've been accused of being in a pissy mood for the last few days and the guy who accused me of that is, I'm pained to say it, absolutely right. So, instead of a very lengthy reply I say this to you Fortunato - you raise well argued and valid points but I think we should agree to disagree on this one.

Eventhough I'm right.
 
did you see??

I just looked at the template for the offer made today by the NHL to the PA.....at this point, I'd say these guys are nuts not to take it......

www.nhlcba.com

Includes genuine partnership as well as mechanisms to accurtaely tabulate the revenues, audit from both sides. Apparently the PA rejected it as is, but they are still talking.....maybe we finally have something that the PA will negotiate from........
 
There is no chance the PA will take this offer and i cant even see hows it the basis for an agreement neither sides trust each other and with a weasel like Bettman running the show i dont blame the players one bit, its funny but when the players made there offer of 25% rollbacks he warned them not too release there offer to the public before they got a chance to look at it if and the players abided and look what Mr Bettman does today he releases there offer to all news agencys in an official release from the league before the players were even given the offer, imho this is a contract negotiation and the owners have yet to negotiate when they do this might be settled, players want to play hockey theres no doubt about that but this antagonistic approach that the NHL has taken will only give PA and there members more resolve
 
shack said:
They are employed by the people who sign their paycheques, the employers.

They are definitely not stereotypical employees, but employees nonetheless. Take actors as another example. An actor may decide which movie he'll do but once he signs that contract and is doing the movie, he's employed by whoever signs his cheques, the studio or executive producer or whoever. I guess it usually takes a few months to make a movie so then the actor gets himself another job and is employed by someone else.

A hockey player has several options as to who he wants to work for, but he can only work for one at a time. This makes him different than someone who makes a living by providing a service. Service providers, e.g. doctors, personal trainers, SP's, will have a number of clients. If he's only working for one person then that's his employer. In fact that's one of the tests the tax dep't will use to see if someone is an independant contractor or an employee (in which case the employer must withhold tax and pay unemployment and pension contributions). If they only work at one place the gov't says they're an employee.

As well, independant contractors do not have unions such as the NHLPA. Employees have unions to give them leverage against the employers.

They've definitely got it a lot better than most employees, but that's what they are.

You can not compare them in any way to regular employees. Many of their rights are taken away from them once the sign a contract. Most employees have the right to quit and go work with the competition if they chose. Not the players who don't even get to choose who they work for.

I don't feel sorry for the owners. Alot of the expansion owners don't have the resources to run a team and where given a promise by Bettman of cost certainty as a condition for the expansion fee. You can't trust the owners with the revenue they state either. Illich claims the Red Wings made $0 from either the advertising or in arena sales of Little Ceasers.
 
You know what though people, ever since Bettman has taken control of the NHL its gone downhill. American ratings have dropped, revenue overall has gone down and now this lock-out. I say get rid of Bettman and bring in a hockey guy instead of a lawyer (which is what Bettman is).

Does anyone else feel this way or is it just me??