Are Baseball Players Soft?

BANG!!

That was the sound of your credibility exploding.
Actually, as lame as his response was, I'm impressed that he was actually able to come up with anything at all.

Tennis players are Olympic worthy athletes and have to train incredibly hard on and off the court. Strength, agility, stamina, speed, reflexes, eye/hand co-ordination are all required.

They are probably among the fittest athletes on the planet. They have to be to compete in this grueling SPORT.

Even though your response is an epic fail, I sincerely respect the fact you posted a reply as opposed to saying nothing.

BTW, world class ping pong is an amazing sport.
 
Tell me John, which one of these guys could endure/perform at a reasonable level over a 162 game baseball season?

Mackenzy Bernadeau
Shaun Rogers
Clifton Geathers
Chris Baker
Cordy Glenn
Bryant Mckinnie
Marcus Cannon
Damon Harrison

Shall I go on?

I would wager not one of those players, all on active NFL rosters, would be able to play at an acceptable level for even 'A' level baseball.

Oh sure, pick all the fatties
If Prince can do it, I am sure at least one of your cubby football payers could manage
 
Oh sure, pick all the fatties
If Prince can do it, I am sure at least one of your cubby football payers could manage

You're sure are you? No documented evidence to show that your claim is true?

That's what I thought.
 
Can't prove those. Pure speculation completely arrived at by your personal perception.

Oh wait there is some evidence. Danny Ainge. (Do you know who he is and why I'm using him as an example?)

15 full seasons in the NBA. 6 seasons with over 80 games played and another 6 with over 70 games played. Only 2 consecutive seasons in the middle of his career where he had some chronic lingering injuries, but recovered and got back to his consistent form, which means your hypothesis is bullshit.

You don't know what you're talking about. I suggest that you stick with your pro-trickle down economics posts instead.

So Danny Angie Bo Jackson and Dion Sanders define without question that baseball players are not soft
There will always be exceptions , however take your average MBL player and put him on the ice, court or gridiron and you have a train wreak in the making
These guys go on the DL with a blister or a hangnail for Christ sake!
Bobby Baun played an overtime period with a broken ankle. That is tough (Do you know who he is and why I am using him as an example?)
NHL goalies use to stop pucks with their face. That's tough

Tough for the average base ballplayer is the walk back to the dugout after striking out

Perhaps it is you who does not what you are talking about and are allowing your admiration for your idols interfere with sound judgement
I suggest you find something you do understand and converse about that

I had wanted to stick to facts and avoid insults, however, went insulted I return the gesture
 
Last edited:
Tennis players are Olympic worthy athletes and have to train incredibly hard on and off the court. Strength, agility, stamina, speed, reflexes, eye/hand co-ordination are all required.

They are probably among the fittest athletes on the planet. They have to be to compete in this grueling SPORT.


Even though your response is an epic fail, I sincerely respect the fact you posted a reply as opposed to saying nothing.

BTW, world class ping pong is an amazing sport.


While I do agree with entirety of your post.

I do notice that some of the female players seem to be carrying some excess weight at times.

One of the male players on the tour about 10 years ago even came out and said the same thing.

Maybe it's an issue of not wanting to carry too much muscle and it's possibility of it affecting their endurance during the match. I'm not sure.

Anyways having given tennis a try in my youth I found and extremely difficult sport to play and was impressed by the fitness level required to play quality opposition.

They have my respect as athletes for sure.
 
Oh sure, pick all the fatties
If Prince can do it, I am sure at least one of your cubby football payers could manage

The above is a brain dead response.

What's a 'cubby football payer'? :confused:

A Chicago Bears wannabe? :confused:
 
Actually, as lame as his response was, I'm impressed that he was actually able to come up with anything at all.

Tennis players are Olympic worthy athletes and have to train incredibly hard on and off the court. Strength, agility, stamina, speed, reflexes, eye/hand co-ordination are all required.

They are probably among the fittest athletes on the planet. They have to be to compete in this grueling SPORT.

Even though your response is an epic fail, I sincerely respect the fact you posted a reply as opposed to saying nothing.

BTW, world class ping pong is an amazing sport.

Your response above has done nothing but out you as the pandering sissy boy you are if you believe that drivel. We're talking SPORTS here, not sports. At what age did your mommy finally let you wear big boy pants shack? You really sound like one of those little four-eyed twerps whose answer to sucking at everything 'sports' was that geometry club was cool too.
 
BANG!!

That was the sound of your credibility exploding.

Right. Now give me shack-like response heralding the toughness of hunters (also sportsmen apparently, in the same vein as baseball player I daresay) who sit up at the top of trees all week hoping to shoot a bear in the back of the head while it stoops to eat the apples you were baiting him with. They'd tell you they have all the same stamina, hand eye coordination, agility and endurance of baseball players when stalking they oh-so-cunning prey....Baseball players are SOFT. Tennis players too. Only difference between tennis and ping pong is the size of the court and the weight of the ball. Both are still played by the elderly as a recreational activity when they are no longer tough enough to play real sports.
 
Ping Pong and Tennis are exactly the same game, simply played on different sized courts. Tennis no more a 'sport' than Ping Pong is. They are both, IMO, nothing more than recreational pastimes. If some dumb-asses want to pay good money to watch them spend 2-3 hours mostly hitting the ball directly back to their opponent, or alternately into the net, so be it. Doesn't make it competitive enough to qualify as a real sport. Feels more like a simple game of chance.

Coming from a person who's never played either at a completive level, no doubt. By the way it's called Table Tennis. Ping pong is what you play at cottage on a rainy day with the kids. You couldn't hit a fastball pitched at you from 40 feet away at 70 mph, they each ~120mph+ at the world league level, let along a TT ball hit a you from 10 feet away. Now a tennis ball can approach you at 140+ mph.
 
Could a baseball player last more than a month in the NFL or NBA ?
No
This was your assertion. Nobody put the words in your mouth. There were no qualifiers to your statement.
So Danny Angie Bo Jackson and Dion Sanders define without question that baseball players are not soft

You were undeniably wrong. You did not ask which players define softness/toughness. Your grand assertion was "no player could last a month".

Sorry if I demonstrated you're full of bluster. Your opinion has no merit.

By the way, because of the nature of the sport, i.e. more skill, less contact it is next to impossible for a baseball player to prove he's as tough as a football player. Many of these players could show their toughness if they were put in the appropriate position.
 
Baseball players are soft?

Lets see any of you clowns that think that, say that face to face to Frank Thomas (he's a retired baseball player, probably super soft).
 
“I wish,” said Jays shortstop Jose Reyes, a man whose devastating ankle injury on April 12 in Kansas City helped destroy any chances for the club to compete in 2013. “That would be better for everybody. There’s probably players who don’t want to come here (because of the turf). It’s tough to play here on that turf every day. It’s a little different (on the injured ankle) when I play here than when I play on regular grass.”

BTW: Reyes hurt his ankle in Kansas City where they do have natural grass.

Are you truly this clueless?

Reyes injured his ankle jamming it into the side of the 2nd base bag, sliding on dirt.
What's wrong with you? I quoted Reyes saying he (and other players) prefers to play on natural grass and yet IRONICALLY he got hurt playing in a natural grass stadium. Of course, we all know he hurt himself sliding into 2nd base, which has been replayed 19,000 times.
 
Bo Jackson should have stuck with baseball. He hurt his hip playing football which effectively ended both his football and baseball careers.
 
This was your assertion. Nobody put the words in your mouth. There were no qualifiers to your statement.


You were undeniably wrong. You did not ask which players define softness/toughness. Your grand assertion was "no player could last a month".

Sorry if I demonstrated you're full of bluster. Your opinion has no merit.

By the way, because of the nature of the sport, i.e. more skill, less contact it is next to impossible for a baseball player to prove he's as tough as a football player. Many of these players could show their toughness if they were put in the appropriate position.

Oh Boy !
I hope you are able to get paid for nitpicking, because you have a skill there

The general question is are baseball players soft
I give them credit for having the skills to either hit a 95 mph fastball or throw one with accuracy
I also will give them some credit for some mental toughness as even the best of them fail 2 out of three times. That must be tough to deal with day after day

However, relative to hockey, football, rugby, boxing, basketball or lacrosse there is no question in terms of toughness, they are soft like the grandpa who lost his Viagra

As far you demonstrating I am full of bluster.... Sorry all you did was demonstrate an anal retentaive black and white approach to viewing a question

Many of these players could show their toughness if they were put in the appropriate position.
That's an opinion, not a fact.
It is tough to buy into this opinion when one hears about MLB players who are on the DL because of blisters or a hang nail
Yeah, tough as butter on a summer day
 
It should have read chubby
I guess you are a little short on intelligent arguments when you need to make a big deal about a typo
If you are going to go down that road, be sure you are letter perfect in all your posts going forward

You still haven't explained the 'payer' part of that, as in 'cubby football payer'?

Feel free to point out all spelling and other errors in my posts.
 
However, relative to hockey, football, rugby, boxing, basketball or lacrosse there is no question in terms of toughness, they are soft like the grandpa who lost his Viagra
Many of these players could show their toughness if they were put in the appropriate position.
That's an opinion, not a fact.
And your assertion that baseball players are soft is also just an just opinion. Neither one can be properly measured.

As I said, which you have failed to address, is that a minor injury that does not significantly affect a hockey player, such as a broken finger, renders a baseball player useless. That is a big reason why, using your example, a pitcher can't pitch with a blister. He has to have a feel for and manipulate the ball with finesse. So the same injury in two different sports results in two different outcomes. Two broken fingers are not equal.

As to my bolded statement above I can demonstrate how BB players don't have to play tough because of the nature of the sport but they can be tough if they need to be. One word:

CATCHERS

Anybody who says that catchers are not tough, demonstrates that they don't understand baseball. In fact, almost every one is tough as nails for all the abuse they put up with and play through. No one has ever said that the term "the tools of ignorance" (catcher's equipment) is anything but appropriate. So catcher's are shown to be tough more readily than other players because they are put in a position where anyone can clearly see that they have to be tough to play their position the same as football players have to be tough to play their sport. Perfect analogy.

That means that at any one time there are over 60 such tough players in the league. Not a huge amount, but clearly not insignificant in terms of our debate.

Next. Would anybody assert that out of all the players that make it through all the trials and tribulations required to make it to the majors, and who come up playing with and against each other, in the same competitive culture, proving to each other who is more macho and more worthy of making it (it happens in all sports) competing for big paying jobs, the only guys who are tough all end out being catchers? It would obviously be a ridiculous assertion. There are lots of other guys who are equally as tough but because of the position they play they don't need to nor have the opportunity to demonstrate that toughness on as consistent a basis as catchers or players of other sports. Sure some are soft, but a lot less than you are giving them credit for.

My first point of all catchers being tough is clearly true. My second statement, is admittedly conjecture, but not a huge stretch given the undeniability of the catchers being tough.

As well, my point about injuries not being equivalent for different sports must be acknowledged.
 
I bet you were the snotty know-it-all in school everyone could not stand.

Again, pointing out typos is hardly a convincing argument
It is more of an annoying habit often exhibited by weak and insecure minds.

Please provide some intelligent arguments or confine yourself to worrying about your own spelling and grammatical perfection

Or you could simply have said, oops typo, my bad, and moved on.
 
And your assertion that baseball players are soft is also just an just opinion. Neither one can be properly measured.
No argument there

As I said, which you have failed to address, is that a minor injury that does not significantly affect a hockey player, such as a broken finger, renders a baseball player useless. That is a big reason why, using your example, a pitcher can't pitch with a blister. He has to have a feel for and manipulate the ball with finesse. So the same injury in two different sports results in two different outcomes. Two broken fingers are not equal.
excuses, excuses excuses
A hockey player will not allow blisters to prevent him from playing
Basketball players have worn a face masks and played with a broken nose
Football players will tape up injuries and still trot out onto the field
All of these sports require finesse and the ability to apply precision to a shot or throw. Yet baseball stands alone in excusing their players from participating for minor injuries


As to my bolded statement above I can demonstrate how BB players don't have to play tough because of the nature of the sport but they can be tough if they need to be. One word:

CATCHERS

Anybody who says that catchers are not tough, demonstrates that they don't understand baseball. In fact, almost every one is tough as nails for all the abuse they put up with and play through. No one has ever said that the term "the tools of ignorance" (catcher's equipment) is anything but appropriate. So catcher's are shown to be tough more readily than other players because they are put in a position where anyone can clearly see that they have to be tough to play their position the same as football players have to be tough to play their sport. Perfect analogy

That means that at any one time there are over 60 such tough players in the league. Not a huge amount, but clearly not insignificant in terms of our debate.

I would grant catchers are generally tougher than the rest of the baseball world, however that position is no where near as physically demanding as a NHL goalie or a NFL lineman's job

Next. Would anybody assert that out of all the players that make it through all the trials and tribulations required to make it to the majors, and who come up playing with and against each other, in the same competitive culture, proving to each other who is more macho and more worthy of making it (it happens in all sports) competing for big paying jobs, the only guys who are tough all end out being catchers? It would obviously be a ridiculous assertion. There are lots of other guys who are equally as tough but because of the position they play they don't need to nor have the opportunity to demonstrate that toughness on as consistent a basis as catchers or players of other sports. Sure some are soft, but a lot less than you are giving them credit for.

I read this three time and still do not understand what you are trying to communicate
The objective of communication is provide a clear and concise message which is understood by the reader
English please

My first point of all catchers being tough is clearly true. My second statement, is admittedly conjecture, but not a huge stretch given the undeniability of the catchers being tough.

It sounds like your are saying "Catchers are tough therefore all baseball players are tough"
That is not a logical conclusion

As well, my point about injuries not being equivalent for different sports must be acknowledged
.

Why ? Because you say so?
A blister will hurt a basketball player just as much as a baseball player and it will impact both of them when it comes down to throwing a ball
One is soft , the other is not