Are Baseball Players Soft?

No, it's about baseball players that are SOFT. Prince Fielder should be the poster boy for soft.
He's so soft that he's missed 13 games in the last 8 years. That means he's averaged over 160 out of 162 per year for 8 years.

Do you know what "soft" means? It doesn't appear so. Soft means a player who gets injured frequently and cannot play through them. From that aspect, though he has a far from athletic body, no one could ever call him soft.

And the other matter that makes it seem you are in over your head in this discussion, and to which you still have not explained, is how can anyone say that tennis is not an actual sport?

Cricket? Badminton? Tennis?

I don't even consider any of those actual 'sports'.

I apologize for my previous response in which I sarcastically said your post was "brilliant".

Actually, it was ignorant. Do you prefer that? I'll humbly retract both of those comments if you have a valid explanation of why tennis is not an actual sport.
 
Could an NBA, NFL or NHL player endure a 162 baseball season?
Yes
Could a baseball player last more than a month in the NFL, NHL or NBA ?
No
Prince Fielder could not finish a full game in any of the three leagues.

Relative to the other three team sports baseball is defiantly not a tough mans sport
Someone earlier in this thread placed both the NHL & NFL well a head of the NBA in terms of toughness.
That is debateable
There is a lot of contact in basketball and the men are huge & heavy. 6'6' is a small dude in this league & most of them are well north of 225 lbs and in incredible physical shape.

It takes some skill to be a baseball player & trying to hit a 95 mph fastball is next to impossible, harder still if there is movement on the ball
It also takes a lot of skill to throw 95 with precision

However relative to the other sports "soft" is appropriate
 
Could an NBA, NFL or NHL player endure a 162 baseball season?
Yes

Tell me John, which one of these guys could endure/perform at a reasonable level over a 162 game baseball season?

Mackenzy Bernadeau
Shaun Rogers
Clifton Geathers
Chris Baker
Cordy Glenn
Bryant Mckinnie
Marcus Cannon
Damon Harrison

Shall I go on?

I would wager not one of those players, all on active NFL rosters, would be able to play at an acceptable level for even 'A' level baseball.
 
Wow ... really ? lol
You are such an idiot.

Hee Hee, just love this.

A comment from a guy who who thinks Don Cherry is an actual person.

Can't wait to hear the reply.
 
Prince Fielder an athlete?????
A 260 lb pile of goo who can hit a ball with a stick (except in the playoffs)

A 90-mph fastball with a stick?
I would love to see you try to make contact with a ball at 90 Mph, much less hit 50 home runs in a regular season like Prince did
And I'm not defending his performance in the playoffs, which was terrible, merely your asinine assertation that a slump means he isn't an athlete
You are aware that he played first base for the Brewers before he was with the Tigers?
 
No, it's about baseball players that are SOFT. Prince Fielder should be the poster boy for soft.

Here's a good example...when was the last time you saw a baseball player put on a performance of sheer toughness like RGIII last year before his knee finally blew? How bout never!? There are examples of this type of thing every week during each and every NFL season, so try not to sound so foolish when you talk comparatively about baseball players with boo-boos on their pinky fingers that prevent them from playing, or a sore ankle that keeps them from flopping around the bases like cows.

How about Kirk Gibson hitting a game-winning home run with a knee injury?
How about Curt Schilling tearing his ankle tendon and yet pitching well enough to have his bloody sock introduced into the Hall of Fame?
 
Could an NBA, NFL or NHL player endure a 162 baseball season?
Yes
Could a baseball player last more than a month in the NFL, NHL or NBA ?
No
Can't prove those. Pure speculation completely arrived at by your personal perception.

Oh wait there is some evidence. Danny Ainge. (Do you know who he is and why I'm using him as an example?)

15 full seasons in the NBA. 6 seasons with over 80 games played and another 6 with over 70 games played. Only 2 consecutive seasons in the middle of his career where he had some chronic lingering injuries, but recovered and got back to his consistent form, which means your hypothesis is bullshit.

You don't know what you're talking about. I suggest that you stick with your pro-trickle down economics posts instead.
 
He's so soft that he's missed 13 games in the last 8 years. That means he's averaged over 160 out of 162 per year for 8 years.

Yeah, must have been tough for his fat ass to stand motionless in the field for 90% of every 3 hour game over 8 years. Wow. The sheer determination he must have exerted to overcome such intense physically challenging adversity. That fat fucker couldn't run around the bases twice at any reasonable speed without keeling over sideways from a near heart attack, and asking the manager to swap him out for a young skinny guy who only plays one inning a month as a bench spare. There are hotdog vendors at ballgames who are more physically taxed over the course of a game that Prince Fielder is. It is what it is shack. Just admit it - you're a big fanboy for soft, prima donna pussies. It's ok. We won't judge you.
 
While there are many tough past and present players in sports, IMHO, I think the majority of them would be in football and hockey. One of the toughest has to be Walt Garrison.

Walt Garrison
His style of play and perceived ability to play hurt brought him recognition in Cowboys lore, which included playing the 1970 NFC Championship Game against the San Francisco 49ers with a cracked collarbone and a serious ankle injury.[SUP][1]

Bo Jackson and Deion Sanders played both pro baseball and football, wonder what they would say on this subject?[/SUP]
 
Yeah, must have been tough for his fat ass to stand motionless in the field for 90% of every 3 hour game over 8 years. Wow. The sheer determination he must have exerted to overcome such intense physically challenging adversity.
Good use of sarcasm. I like it. Does that mean you are becoming a bitter old man?

That fat fucker couldn't run around the bases twice at any reasonable speed without keeling over sideways from a near heart attack, and asking the manager to swap him out for a young skinny guy who only plays one inning a month as a bench spare. There are hotdog vendors at ballgames who are more physically taxed over the course of a game that Prince Fielder is. It is what it is shack. Just admit it - you're a big fanboy for soft, prima donna pussies. It's ok. We won't judge you.
Seeing as you don't have any idea of what you're talking about, no need to reply.

Maybe I'm wrong and you do understand sports. This will be the third or fourth time I've asked you to explain why tennis is not an actual sport. If you don't have anything of substance to reply with, I completely understand because it was a really uninformed comment. Another refusal to defend your clear statement would seem to indicate that you agree there is absolutely no basis for your comment. You were just spewing off whatever came into your head which further implies that anything else you post about sports is equally useless and intended to be ignored.

Admission of ignorance accepted (unless you can back up your tennis statement.)
 
Stand in the outfield for a few innings with nothing coming your way. Then a line drive screams out of the infield. Without benefit of a stretch beforehand, you break into an Olympic quality 50 yard dash, while concentrating on a moving ball instead of a stationary tape. At the last second you leap for it and land flat out, smashing your body into the ground and sliding for a few yards. Then you have to jump to your feet, find out exactly what's going on, who is where, and attempt to get the ball to a base that a runner is trying to get to.

Yeah, pussies. :rolleyes:

Here is a video on how to catch fly balls. Although I don't have hard statistics, I suspect most fly ball are rather routine and not where the outfielder has to run 50 feet at full speed and dive to get to the ball.

[video=youtube;d2RIQkmy9cE]http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_detailpage&v=d2RIQkmy9cE[/video]


BTW: Is it true they will start growing real grass at the Rogers Centre because baseball players can't handle artificial turf:)?
 
BTW: Is it true they will start growing real grass at the Rogers Centre because baseball players can't handle artificial turf:)?
They gotta wait until the Argos are out. I think the latest is 2018 (yikes) when their lease expires. If they find someplace sooner then they can get the grass in sooner. Hoping the Jays can provide some motivation for the Argos to speed it up.
 
BTW: Is it true they will start growing real grass at the Rogers Centre because baseball players can't handle artificial turf:)?

“I wish,” said Jays shortstop Jose Reyes, a man whose devastating ankle injury on April 12 in Kansas City helped destroy any chances for the club to compete in 2013. “That would be better for everybody. There’s probably players who don’t want to come here (because of the turf). It’s tough to play here on that turf every day. It’s a little different (on the injured ankle) when I play here than when I play on regular grass.”

BTW: Reyes hurt his ankle in Kansas City where they do have natural grass.
 
“I wish,” said Jays shortstop Jose Reyes, a man whose devastating ankle injury on April 12 in Kansas City helped destroy any chances for the club to compete in 2013. “That would be better for everybody. There’s probably players who don’t want to come here (because of the turf). It’s tough to play here on that turf every day. It’s a little different (on the injured ankle) when I play here than when I play on regular grass.”

BTW: Reyes hurt his ankle in Kansas City where they do have natural grass.

Are you truly this clueless?

Reyes injured his ankle jamming it into the side of the 2nd base bag, sliding on dirt.

The fact that he plays 90 games on artificial turf (a harder surface, less forgiving) instead of grass affects the pounding the ankle takes as he plays, after the injury.
 
Good use of sarcasm. I like it. Does that mean you are becoming a bitter old man?


Seeing as you don't have any idea of what you're talking about, no need to reply.

Maybe I'm wrong and you do understand sports. This will be the third or fourth time I've asked you to explain why tennis is not an actual sport. If you don't have anything of substance to reply with, I completely understand because it was a really uninformed comment. Another refusal to defend your clear statement would seem to indicate that you agree there is absolutely no basis for your comment. You were just spewing off whatever came into your head which further implies that anything else you post about sports is equally useless and intended to be ignored.

Admission of ignorance accepted (unless you can back up your tennis statement.)

Ping Pong and Tennis are exactly the same game, simply played on different sized courts. Tennis no more a 'sport' than Ping Pong is. They are both, IMO, nothing more than recreational pastimes. If some dumb-asses want to pay good money to watch them spend 2-3 hours mostly hitting the ball directly back to their opponent, or alternately into the net, so be it. Doesn't make it competitive enough to qualify as a real sport. Feels more like a simple game of chance.