Prior to tonight I was going to say I was fairly indifferent about who won AI this year, given the final 3. I have a ton of respect for Melinda's talent and professionalism, give props to Blake for having some charisma and being the sole dude left, and think Jordin is a marvelous blossoming talent at 17. I thought each one could conceivably win, and I didn't think any of them sang their way out of the competition last night.
With that, I was not too surprised Melinda got the boot tonight. I had long thought that while she was definitely the most proficient singer, she was not going to win. We all know this is not a singing contest. Maybe it was back when Kelly Clarkson won, but now it is a vote-getting contest. Blake gets a ton of chick votes, and Jordin gets votes because she is younger and cuter than Melinda, and who can resist a perky 17 year old with that kind of potential? Sorry, but that's just the way it works.
This finale is somewhat reminiscent of last year's matchup of Taylor Hicks vs. Katharine McPhee. Kat was a hottie, for sure, and she sang pretty well, better than Taylor, I thought. But she was a little boring, maybe even a bit icy, and Taylor just charisma'ed (yes, I just made up that word) his way to victory. This year, Jordin is the cute girl, and she is a pretty good singer. She is more likeable than Katharine, in my view. But Blake has a certain x-factor, and I have no doubt he'll get the votes from the ladies. I think Blake wins.