American Idol odds

Back Burner said:
I will cry for Sanjaya on my tear proof pillow tonight.
He got dumped???????

Aye......he was only 16, I think some of the criticism was a bit harsh!!


But...........where the hell is my beer??????!!!!!!! :mad:
 
What's the f'n little fag crying for tonight, he should have been gone in the first week. Others that were MUCH better went before him. He was a farce.

Sanjaya...gone

and Howard Stern's campaign.....over.
HE'S GONE, ABOUT TIME!
 
Sangaya's reign of mediocrity finally came to an end last night. Finally! When I saw Lakisha and he were in the bottom two, I thought it might be Lakisha, because America has never allowed three sistas to be in the top 6 before.

But I am glad America has finally regained its senses (hearing primarily).
 
Thank goodness he's gone. I'd imagine even his hardcore supporters couldn't vote for him after Wednesday's performance.

I miss Hailey!!!!!!!
 
Oh fuck it!!!!!

I'm half drunk!!!!


I would slightly appreciate it if everyone would kinda......chill....away from.....me.......a..while....cheers.......!!!!!!!!!!

Boo!!!!!!!!!!!!! :cool:
 
lookingforitallthetime said:
I agree. She may be the best they've ever had on the show. Whether she wins or not, I think she will be a big star.
Agreed. She is by far the best singer on the show...it's just too bad (and of course, not her fault) that she has no neck, and looks a bit like "Francine' from the "Arthur" kids cartoon show...
 
Toroz said:
LOL @ Esco....still going 4:30 in the morning on a Wed./Thurs....and I thought I was a lush....how's your head this morning?
I had a major family feud yesterday and my way of dealing with those things is to get drunk.

Head doesnt hurt too much thanx to codeine :)
 
When a guy didn't belong there in the first place, and better singers were gone before him....yes.
 
The Bandit said:
When a guy didn't belong there in the first place, and better singers were gone before him....yes.

I take the American Idol thing a bit seriously too, in that it is a highly entertaining show, and real careers have gotten made out of it. I just don't get trying to get votes for someone who is clearly undeserving, when there are more deserving, more talented people who get tossed by the wayside because you think it's all a big joke. I do think the vast majority of kids who try out for this show are sincere, and really do want to be "discovered", and I think it is a shame that some people think that's something to belittle. People like Howard Stern don't care about Sangaya, they are just making fun of the whole hulabaloo that seems to surround this show. I do grant that there are a lot of things to mock about the show, but letting someone like Sangaya think they have a chance to win, while dashing the hopes of someone who is actually better, I think that's just mean-spirited. I think we've taken the joke (which I did think was funny at the time) of William Hung too far.
 
The Bandit said:
the f'n little fag
I agree he's fun, but good grief, man - get a grip.

I can understand Homonger's perspective, but there's something just a little disturbing about grown men resorting to school yard name calling over a singing contest. For the love of Fred, it's not as if it's the fuckin' Pussycat Doll's search. If Melissa R doesn't win, I, for one, will be one foot stamping mofo.


I'm still rooting for Blake as he has an odd "star quality", w/ Jordin being my personal favorite overall. Melinda is the obvious choice as most complete performer, but a little too "safe".

FWIW I thought Haley's farewell performance was a good few notches above any other I've witnessed.



PS A little part of me died with the rejection of Sunjaya and somehow humanity became just a little less human. My heart goes out to his sister and all his fans.
 
Prior to tonight I was going to say I was fairly indifferent about who won AI this year, given the final 3. I have a ton of respect for Melinda's talent and professionalism, give props to Blake for having some charisma and being the sole dude left, and think Jordin is a marvelous blossoming talent at 17. I thought each one could conceivably win, and I didn't think any of them sang their way out of the competition last night.

With that, I was not too surprised Melinda got the boot tonight. I had long thought that while she was definitely the most proficient singer, she was not going to win. We all know this is not a singing contest. Maybe it was back when Kelly Clarkson won, but now it is a vote-getting contest. Blake gets a ton of chick votes, and Jordin gets votes because she is younger and cuter than Melinda, and who can resist a perky 17 year old with that kind of potential? Sorry, but that's just the way it works.

This finale is somewhat reminiscent of last year's matchup of Taylor Hicks vs. Katharine McPhee. Kat was a hottie, for sure, and she sang pretty well, better than Taylor, I thought. But she was a little boring, maybe even a bit icy, and Taylor just charisma'ed (yes, I just made up that word) his way to victory. This year, Jordin is the cute girl, and she is a pretty good singer. She is more likeable than Katharine, in my view. But Blake has a certain x-factor, and I have no doubt he'll get the votes from the ladies. I think Blake wins.
 
I am absolutely shocked that Melinda didn't make the final. However, the song choices last night may have turned viewers off for her. Personally, I thought Jordin should have been the one leaving. I am cheering for Blake, I don't think he's the best singer but he is definitely the most unique, modern, hip and risk-taking contestant on the show. He deserves to win.