http://www.torontosun.com/Entertainment/Television/2007/03/27/3844413-sun.html
Survivor: Sanjaya
Tone-deaf singer sparks Idol brouhaha
By TARA MERRIN, SUN MEDIA
Sanjaya Malakar is officially a star. Why, however, remains a baffling mystery.
The puffy-haired, 17-year-old American Idol contestant is, arguably, the least talented of this year's popstar wannabes -- some have gone so far to say he's the worst singer to ever make the Top 10 in the reality series' six seasons.
But is he really bad enough to warrant all the attention he's been getting?
Every season, one unlucky -- or tone-deaf -- Idoler is singled out by the judges and, more importantly, bloggers online. There, they are ridiculed, insulted and even hailed as a god by anti-reality TV fanatics, who encourage their followers to vote the worst through in order to prove Idol is a joke.
While it's not a new trend, Malakar's situation is a little different -- he has surpassed all his predecessors in terms of his popularity and, in turn, attracted the attention of some very famous and outspoken people.
The women of The View, aka Rosie O'Donnell and friends, have certainly taken notice of Malakar's lack of talent, constantly questioning America's intellect when it comes to who they vote for. O'Donnell, who now appears to be backing down -- but only a little -- says while she thinks the shy singer needs to be sent packing, people should cut him a little slack because of his age.
Even Saturday Night Live took a shot at Malakar, a sure sign you have made it.
UNDERDOG
On the other side of the Malakar battle sits Sirius Satellite Radio shockjocker Howard Stern, who has made it his personal mission to keep the underdog on Idol. The popular radio host has publicly thrown his support behind votefortheworst.com, a website dedicated to keeping the least deserving contestants on the show, by encouraging his own listeners to vote as many times as humanly possible for Malakar.
While it's impossible to prove, many people are crediting Stern and votefortheworst.com, which gets about one million hits a day and up to three million on show nights, with altering the outcome of last week's Idol show.
(Powerhouse singer Stephanie Edwards was booted off, while Malakar completely avoided the bottom two.)
Another theory surrounding Malakar's survival?
That because he is the first contestant of Indian descent to make it to the finals, members of the Indian-American community are voting for him in droves.
Others believe his boyish good looks and long locks have rendered millions of teenage girls, who are supporting him, deaf.
In response to the controversy, judge Simon Cowell, who recently said Malakar has very little singing talent, has threatened to quit the show if he wins. And, taking even more extreme measures, a fan of Idol has gone on a hunger strike in the hope he will be voted off. The 23-year-old New Yorker, who calls herself "J", announced on a YouTube video dated March 16, she will not eat until Malakar is gone.
"I have no problems with Sanjaya personally, he seems like a very charming young man. However, he does not belong on American Idol," she says on the tape.
Meanwhile, a source close to Malakar's family tells the website TMZ that Sanjaya is devastated by the bad press he's received.
"He's so young and so sensitive, it's hard for him to go out on that stage and not have that devastation affect his performance," the source said.